After Xu Shu was invited by Cao Cao, why was he unwilling to contribute to Cao Cao?

Because he was forced, Cao Cao used a trick to deceive Xu Shu's mother to Xuchang, or directly arrested Xu Shu's mother to Xuchang, forcing Xu Shu to leave Liu Bei and join himself. Xu Shu expressed helplessness at Cao Cao's approach, and at the same time, he looked down on Cao Cao from the bottom of his heart.

The first possibility is that Xu Shu's entry into Cao Ying was before the Battle of Chibi, when Cao Cao was not a traitor, he was not so ruthless, and when Cao Cao became an out-and-out traitor in his later years, he really didn't blink an eye when he killed people, including killing Cui Yan with first-class character and Xun Yu with first-class wisdom.

The second possibility is that Cao Cao still has to be a person at this time, when Cheng Yu suggested that Cao Cao kill Liu Bei, Cao Cao's answer was like this, saying: "When Fang Jin collects the heroes of the world, it is not okay to kill one person and lose the heart of the world." ”

Now is the time to buy people's hearts, Liu Bei and his grandson pretend to be very good, right, you can't find any fault with him, everyone thinks he is a hero, you kill him, you lose the heart of the world, this is not good.

Cao Cao Qingmei boiled wine and talked about heroes, saying, "Today's heroes, only the king and Cao Er", already knew that Liu Bei was a threat to himself, but he still didn't kill him. Why? Buying people's hearts. The hearts of the people are scattered, how can the team be led?

Xu Shu is also a celebrity, do you want to kill it? If you want to kill, what is the difference between it and Dong Zhuo, Li Dao, Guo Yan and the like? Besides, even an unscrupulous tyrant like Dong Zhuo knows that he wants to win people's hearts and win over Cai Yong and other celebrities, how can a big politician like Cao Cao not understand?

You Heng "beat the drum and scolded Cao", Cao Cao did not kill anyone, but just sent him to Liu Biao to "watch the after-effects"; Later, if Kong Rong had not opposed Cao Cao on the political line and proposed that "no marquis will be sealed within a thousand miles", Cao Cao would have been driven thousands of miles away, and it is estimated that Cao Cao would not have been killed.

Because you can't just kill people......

Isn't Dong Zhuo just killing people casually, isn't Yuan Shu just appointing ** casually, if the monarch rewards and punishes according to personal preferences, then his ending can be imagined, Cao Cao is because he doesn't do this kind of thing, so he can develop to that position.

Xu Shu did not cooperate, and he did not offend Cao Cao, so Cao Cao had no reason to kill him. A monarch like Dong Zhuo and Yuan Shu is just a tragedy ...... the end

Cao Cao loves talent and can't bear to kill him.

Xu Shu did not give Cao Cao.

There was a stratagem. Xu Shu entered Cao Ying without saying a word", the allusion comes from the literary work "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

Xu Shu became Liu Bei through self-recommendation.

, but was deceived to Cao Ying's camp by Cao Cao's strategist Cheng Yu. Later, Cao Cao's troops attacked Fancheng where Liu Bei was stationed in eight ways, and at Liu Ye's suggestion, Cao Cao sent Xu Shu to Fancheng to persuade Liu Bei to surrender, but after Xu Shu arrived in Fancheng, he told Liu Bei that the army was coming, and asked Liu Bei to prepare early. Liu Bei wanted to keep Xu Shu, but Xu Shu was afraid that the world would laugh at him, and he thought that Liu Bei had Zhuge Liang.

The assistant refused on the ground, and told Liu Bei that although he was in Cao Cao's camp, he swore not to sacrifice anything for Cao Cao.

Xu Shu (year of birth and death unknown), the character Yuan Zhi, was a native of Changshe County, Yingchuan County (now Changgedong, Xuchang, Henan). At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, Liu Bei's account was a figure, and later returned to Cao Cao, and served in Cao Wei.

After Xu Shu surrendered to Cao Cao, he has been defending the north for Cao Cao and resisting the attack of the northern forces.

After Xu Shu arrived in Cao Ying, he was reluctant to give Cao Cao a plan, but Cao Cao did not punish Xu Shu for this, and Cao Cao did this mainly for the following three reasonsClause.

3. Cao Cao hopes to stabilize people's hearts by treating Xu Shu well.

1. Cao Cao killed Xu Shu's mother Xu Shu at that time, and Xu Shu was actually Liu Bei's advisor at the earliest, because his ability was really good, so Cao Cao wanted to dig the foot of the wall. At that time, Liu Bei was defeated in the Battle of Changbanpo, and Cao Cao used Xu Shu's mother to blackmail Xu Shu to join Cao Ying, but Xu Shu learned that his mother committed suicide in order to prevent himself from being coerced by Cao Cao. Because Cao Cao killed Xu Shu's mother, it was normal for Xu Shu not to give Cao Cao advice, and Xu Shu didn't want to live in the world at that time, so he was not afraid of Cao Cao killing himself at all.

Cao Cao also knew that he was sorry for Xu Shu, so he would treat Xu Shu well.

Second, Cao Cao hoped to influence Xu Shu by treating Xu Shu well After Xu Shu arrived in Cao Ying, although Cao Cao treated Xu Shu well, he also supervised Xu Shu all the time, that is, he did not let Xu Shu leave Cao Ying. The reason why Cao Cao did this was actually to hope that Xu Shu would be soft-hearted as soon as possible, and then assist himself as he had assisted Liu Bei. Because Xu Shu's mother had just died, Cao Cao couldn't force Xu Shu too hard, lest Xu Shu commit suicide because he couldn't stand the coercion.

3. Cao Cao hopes to stabilize people's hearts by treating Xu Shu well Finally, after Xu Shu stayed in Cao Ying for a long time, he was still unwilling to give Cao Cao a plan, but Cao Cao still couldn't punish Xu Shu, because if Cao Cao killed Xu Shu at this time, it meant that he had treated Xu Shu well before. If Cao Cao continues to treat Xu Shu well, it will make the world feel that Cao Cao is a person who truly cherishes talents, and Cao Cao's subordinates will be more loyal to Cao Cao.

Because Cao Cao is a person who attaches great importance to talents, and Xu Shu is a talented person, Cao Cao would rather keep Xu Shu than let him go to others, thus posing a threat to himself.

Cao Cao's intention was just to pull Xu Shu away from Liu Bei, so that Liu Bei would have no capable people to help, and he would go through hardships on the road of struggle, and he would not do anything big in the future.

Because Cao Cao valued him too much, he thought that as long as he was not used by Liu Bei, he would be a credit, so he was willing to raise him for nothing.

Because Xu Shu did not give him advice under Cao Cao's account, he was not at fault, if he killed him, it would affect Cao Cao's reputation as a talent, and the number of people who defected to him would be greatly reduced.

Because he respects Xu Shu very much and admires his filial piety and ability very much, he would rather raise him for nothing than kill him.

Because Cao Cao wants to be famous, if he kills Xu Shu at that time, he will let the world know that he can't tolerate people, and in the end, there won't be so many people who come to him.

After Xu Shu surrendered to Cao Cao, he really didn't sacrifice any relics, because Xu Shu himself was a person from Liu Bei's side, and he was particularly loyal to Liu Bei, only because of his mother, so he took refuge in Cao Cao, he didn't want to take refuge in Cao Cao at all, and he was just helpless, so he didn't plan to serve Cao Cao at all.

After Xu Shu surrendered to Cao Cao, he really didn't offer a plan, so Xu Shu entered Cao Ying's camp without saying a word to commemorate his loyalty.

It's really like this, Xu Shu didn't do anything after he went in, and he didn't make any contributions.

。It should be okay to contribute, otherwise there will be a record There is still a difference in historical romance Do you think Xu Shu can be promoted a few times if you don't do anything.

Xu Shu did not offer a single plan in Cao Ying, but he was never punished by Cao Cao, and the reasons can be attributed to the following:(1) Xu Shu has both talent and integrity, which Cao Cao appreciates very much; (2) Cao Cao's way of bringing Xu Shu was not legitimate, and he felt sorry in his heart; (3) Even if you don't offer a plan or strategy, keeping Xu Shu is a way to weaken the opponent's strength; (4) Cao Cao established an image of being eager to seek talents, and he could use Xu Shu to strengthen and consolidate this image.

Cao Cao admired Xu Shu very much

Cao Cao is a traitor in troubled times, and his character is very complex, with a treacherous side, as well as a side of affection and love for talents. Xu Shu was a down-to-earth strategist who despised Cao Cao very much, and after being forced to come to Cao Ying, he kept his promise not to offer a single plan. Such a person who has both strategy and integrity, Cao Cao appreciates it very much, and naturally he will not be punished.

Cao Cao's way of getting Xu Shu was improper

Xu Shu was dedicated to Han and wanted to assist Liu Bei to achieve a great causeIn order to get him, Cao Cao arrested Xu Shu's mother, and he had no choice but to leave Liu Bei and go to Cao Ying. Xu Shu didn't really return to Cao, and Cao Cao also knew that he was rude firstWith this, it is not good to say anything about Xu Shu's behavior of not offering a plan.

Weaken your opponents

In the Three Kingdoms era, all forces wanted to strengthen themselves and weaken the opponent's strength as much as possibleEven if he doesn't make a plan to stay in Cao Ying, he is weakening the strength of the Shuhan GroupTherefore, Cao Cao was also very relieved to leave Xu Shu.

Establish an image externally

The rapid growth of Cao Wei Group is directly related to Cao Cao's thirst for talentCao Cao himself also deliberately established a public image of loving talents, and his attitude towards Xu Shu just reflects Cao Cao's consistent attitude towards talentsIf Xu Shu is punished, Cao Cao's image of Aicai will inevitably be damaged. Xu Shu was a brilliant strategist, but throughout his life he was unknown, failed to realize his ambitions, and became a victim of Cao Cao's efforts to establish an image of the outside world.

Xu Shu did not offer a plan when he entered Cao Ying, but Cao Cao did not punish him, this is because Cao Cao wants to use Xu Shu to show others, so that others can see Cao Cao's love for talent.

In addition to Xu Shu, Cao Cao also has Chen Yu, Xun Yu, Xun You, Jia Xu, etc.

Clause.

1. Cao Cao's guilt towards Xu Shu. Cao Cao's love is something that everyone knows.

Clause. Second, if you can't get it, you can't get it cheap, Liu Bei.

Clause. Third, it is conducive to building Cao Cao's reputation.

Looking at Xu Shu's later experience, he served as the county Taishou Chong Xun, the captain of the agricultural school and other positions, if he was judged to really not contribute, he would definitely not be able to get such a position, so he still contributed to Cao Cao.

Xu Shu did it, Xu Shu did not participate in all of Cao Cao's decisions, and he did not give Cao Cao any opinions.