Why didn t Xu Shu give Cao Cao advice?

Xu Shu did not give advice to Cao Cao because he had advised under Liu Bei's account, and he himself was also a backbone and loyal person. He thought that since he was already loyal to Shu, he couldn't do things for Cao Cao without forgetting his righteousness. And he was forced into Cao Cao's camp because Cao Cao captured his mother, and as a son, Xu Shu had to go to Cao Ying.

It can be said that Xu Shu does not like Cao Cao's approach. chose to rather bury himself than be loyal to the lord he didn't want to see. It was precisely because of Xu Shu's obvious character role and Cao Cao's disrespectful approach to himself that Xu Shu did not want to give advice.

When Xu Shu left Shu, he not only promoted the famous Wolong, but also swore never to give Cao Cao a plan when he entered Cao's camp. Of course, he did not go against his will when he entered the Cao camp. Xu Shu's mother was imprisoned in Cao Ying, and she did not resent Cao Cao for treating her like this.

In the face of Xu Shu, he did not give Cao Cao advice, so he gave Xu Shu a strict education. When Zhuge Liang burned Chibi, he made some suggestions to Cao Cao on the side.

Xu Shu was deceived to Xuchang by Cao Cao, and was forced to leave Liu Bei, and promised not to give Cao Cao a plan when bidding farewell to Liu Bei.

First of all, Xu Shu followed Liu Bei, and in a short period of time, Cao Cao deceived Xu Shu's mother to Xuchang, or directly arrested Xu Shu's mother to Xuchang, and forced Xu Shu to leave Liu Bei and join himself. Xu Shu expressed helplessness at Cao Cao's approach, and at the same time, he looked down on Cao Cao from the bottom of his heart.

Secondly, Liu Bei attaches great importance to Xu Shu and is courteous, Xu Shu has a great future in Liu Bei's camp, and Cao Cao's troubles are equivalent to cutting off Xu Shu's future. If Xu Shu doesn't leave, it is estimated that there will be nothing to do with Zhuge Liang.

In the end, Liu Bei could have killed Xu Shu, using Cao Cao's style, people who are not used for themselves, let alone left to be hostile, but Liu Bei did not do this, and Xu Shu knew it in his heart. And according to Xu Shu's personality and prestige, since he promised that Liu Bei would not make a plan for Cao Cao, he would do what he said.

Therefore, Xu Shu did not give Cao Cao advice for these reasons.

Because Xu Shu did not take the initiative to defect to Cao Cao, but was forced to come to Cao Ying.

We all know that Xu Shu was originally under Liu Bei's command, and later Cao Cao hijacked Xu Shu's mother to make Xu Shu become Cao Cao's subordinate.

The ancient Chinese strategists were very virtuous, and they would not be held hostage easily, but Xu Shu was a well-known filial son, and in order to save his mother, Xu Shu came to Cao Cao's side.

Since it was helpless to leave Liu Bei, how could Xu Shu work for Cao Cao?

The ancients were very particular about the concept of "loyalty to the monarch", once the strategists identified their lords, they were bound to live and die, and in Xu Shu's heart, Liu Bei was undoubtedly such a monarch worthy of loyalty.

Liu Bei has the grace of knowing Xu Shu, and at the same time, during the time of serving Liu Bei, Xu Shu also deeply felt Liu Bei's personality charm. For this reason, Xu Shu would not offer Cao Cao any strategy.

At the same time, Xu Shu left Liu Bei because of his own family affairs, and did not help Liu Bei realize his political ideas, Xu Shu will definitely have a lot of guilt in his heart, and in order to make up for Liu Bei, Xu Shu will also remain silent in Cao Ying.

Xu Shu didn't know how to contribute ideas to solve the problem, and Xu Shu couldn't think of a way to solve some things, which stumped Xu Shu.

In fact, Xu Shu's role in Cao Ying is not very big, and there are many strategists in Cao Ying.

forced Xu's mother to death, this revenge is not shared.

Xu ShuForced to follow Cao, he did not offer a single policy for life:

Xu Shu became Liu Bei through self-recommendation.

of the military division, but was Cao Cao.

's strategist Cheng Yu designed to deceive Cao Ying. Later, Cao Cao's troops attacked Fancheng where Liu Bei was stationed in eight ways, and at Liu Ye's suggestion, Cao Cao sent Xu Shu to Fancheng to persuade Liu Bei to surrender, but after Xu Shu arrived in Fancheng, he told Liu Bei that the army was coming, so that Liu Bei could prepare early. Liu Bei wanted to keep Xu Shu, but Xu Shu was afraid that the world would laugh at him, so he assured Liu Bei that although he was in Cao Cao's camp, he swore not to sacrifice anything for Cao Cao.

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms".Literary achievements:

The artistic achievements of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" are more important in the military and political depiction and character building. ** is best at describing wars and can write about the characteristics of each war. Attention should be paid to describing the application of different strategies and tactics under specific conditions and guiding the development of subjective initiative in operations, rather than spending the main pen and ink on a simple contest of strength and martial arts.

Such as the battle of Guandu.

The Battle of Chibi, the Battle of Yuyiling, etc., the writing style of each war also changes with the characteristics of the war, and at the same time as writing about the war, other activities are also written, as the prelude to the war, the aftermath, or the auxiliary means of the war, so that the tense and thrilling war is expressed with tension and relaxation, and the slowness is slow.

For example, before the Battle of Chibi, the cooperation between Sun and Liu and Zhuge Liang was described.

The contradictions between Zhou Yu, Cao Cao's temptation, Sun and Liu's preparations to lure the enemy into depth, etc., in terms of character building, special attention is paid to the sharp contradictions of the real struggle, and through their words and deeds or the surrounding environment, they express their thoughts and characters.

A word is empty.

Xu Shu, a figure in the Three Kingdoms period at the end of the Han Dynasty, visited famous teachers all over the world, and became friends with Sima Hui, Zhuge Liang and others. Liu Bei, who was an official in Xinye, had to abandon his preparation because Cao Cao imprisoned his mother, and recommended Zhuge Liang's talent to Liu Bei before leaving.

After Xu Shu returned to Cao in the north, he was still very attached to his late master Liu Bei and his friend Zhuge Liang. Although he had outstanding strategy and talent, he was unwilling to give advice to Cao Cao and became enemies of Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang. Therefore, Xu Shu was in Cao Wei for decades, but he never made a difference in politics and military affairs, and almost disappeared into oblivion.

Therefore, in later generations, there is a proverb that "Xu Shu entered Cao Ying without saying a word".

There is a saying that it is difficult for a clean official to decide family affairs, who dares to guarantee that he will be able to do better than Xu Shu in this situation.

Again, under what circumstances did Xu Shu go to Cao Ying, he was forced to go after Cao Cao caught his mother, and he was unwilling. And Xu Shu's mother died because of this. In this case, you still expect Xu Shu to help you come up with ideas, you can dream about it, it would be good if you didn't hit you with a rake.

On the third floor, you are embarrassed to say that Xu Shu is a traitor, if your mother is killed by someone else, will you go to do something for your mother-killing enemy? What is a reputation for fame, that's nonsense.

In the end, Xu Shu himself said that his mother died because of himself, and if he returned to Liu Bei, he would inevitably lose his trust in the world and become an unfaithful and capricious person. Let me ask you, are you willing to be disloyal and untrustworthy?

Xu Shu was forced by Cao Cao to threaten his old mother to Cao Ying, and had to leave Liu Bei. But he never plotted for Cao Cao, Xu Shu spent decades in Cao Wei, but he never made a difference in politics and military. Therefore, in later generations, there are proverbs such as "Xu Shu enters Cao Ying - without saying a word" and "he is in Cao Ying, and his heart is in Han".

has come out, that is, he has given Cao Cao a series of schemes to harm Cao Cao.

No. He didn't come up with a plan in his life.

There are two plans, the first is when Zhao Zilong is seven in and seven out of Changbanpo, Cao Cao wants to get Zhao Zilong, Xu Shu said that if Zilong is captured alive, he can persuade him to surrender, and as a result, Cao Cao asked the military academy to catch Zhao Zilong alive so that Zhao Zilong can get out of trouble, although Xu Shu is to protect Zilong, but it is also a plan that Xu Shu offered for Cao Cao. The second time was before the Battle of Chibi, when Cao Cao's arrival reported that Ma Teng was going to fight Xuchang, Xu Shu heard Pang Tong tell Cao Cao that he would go home to guard Xuchang, but in fact, he ran away first. Both of these tactics were tricked by Cao Cao.