Should tragedy be joyful or sad, and the relationship between tragedy and comedy?

Personally, I think it's better to be miserable, otherwise how can it be a tragedy? Impressive, what is remembered is usually tragedy, such as Liang Zhu. What makes people feel a lot of sadness is the one that makes people think better, rather than forgetting after seeing it.

However, if you write, it depends on your skills and level, like Zhang Ailing's some **, the ending seems to be complete, but it is an out-and-out tragedy.

But Eileen Chang's masterpiece The Golden Lock is a complete tragedy. It's wonderful.

I think a truly wonderful tragedy should be filled with a faint sadness from beginning to end and until the end of the story, which makes people's hearts ache, not great sorrow and joy, or the kind that you call devastating and unbearable.

All comedy tragedies are evaluated by the audience, like Shanghai Fortress, the text message in the ending is shocking, but it gives people a feeling of nostalgia, rather than deliberately asking for sadness and joy.

Therefore, it is still required to resonate, rather than being created by the author himself. It is the result of the interaction between the two parties.

Lu Xun said: Tragedy is the destruction of valuable things in life for others to see.

The so-called tragedies mostly end in tragedy, otherwise how to reflect their sorrow? If the drama is a happy one, it is often difficult to highlight its most lamentable value, and it cannot achieve the effect of touching people's hearts. It's just that sometimes it is appropriate to coordinate joy and sorrow with each other, but it is still mainly sad. The above is a personal opinion.

Those are all artistic techniques, don't fall into them, we have to look at things from an outsider's perspective

Don't be sad or happy, leave a tail, let the reader think for himself, think about the good and think the bad for the bad.

1. From the perspective of literary theory:

Comedy is generally interpreted as a comedy or a comedy, using exaggerated techniques, witty lines and portrayal of comedy character, so as to arouse people's ridicule of ugliness and funny, and affirm normal life and beautiful ideals. Such as "Chaplin Series", "Bean Series" and so on.

Tragedy, the development of a conflict between the protagonist and a dominant force (e.g., fate, circumstance, society) that culminates in a tragic or catastrophic ending. It is characterized by the irreconcilable conflict between the protagonist and reality and its tragic ending. Such as "Dou E's Injustice" and "Hamlet".

Wait. 2. From the general public.

Perspective: Comedy is a drama that makes people laugh. Such as "The Richest Man in Xihong City.

Spring Splendid Pig Bajie".

On the wrong sedan chair to marry the right man", etc., the audience can harvest joy from their senses.

Tragedy is a drama that makes people cry. Such as "Qiong Yao Drama" and "Thunderstorm".

Qu Yuan", "Young You", "Dream of Red Mansions".

Mirror Flowers" and so on, the audience can feel the power of tragedy from the depths of their hearts.

3. From the perspective of the main creators:

Comedy and tragedy are part of the home.

The creators of every comedy and tragedy will never define their creations from a one-dimensional perspective.

Comedians hope to achieve "laughter with tears". Such as Stephen Chow's "Journey to the West".

The series, which was originally defined as a nonsensical comedy, has grown in experience, and now looking back, it is a complete tragedy.

Tragedy plus hope can expose the root cause of the problem from the tragedy, so as to trigger people to live a better life.

yearning, but also tending to joy.

To sum up, Mr. Lu Xun famously said: Tragedy is to break beautiful things for others to see.

So: comedy should be to package bleak things to make people worthy.

Comedy is about having a happy, perfect ending; And tragedy is a sad and sad ending. And my favorite thing to watch is comedy, especially when I'm not happy, I will watch several comedies in a row to make myself happy.

Comedy makes people happy, tragedy makes people sad, but in fact, the core of comedy is tragedy. Because after all, there is joy when there is sorrow.

Take you to understand what tragedy is.

Personally, I think that tragedy generally refers to a tragic ending, such as "The Love of the Hawthorn Tree" and "Fanghua". Comedy generally refers to a good ending, such as "Three Lives, Three Worlds, Ten Miles of Peach Blossoms".

Comedy is to make people laugh when they watch it, and tragedy is to make people very sad and sad after watching it, and often the ending is very bad.

The two upstairs are pure plagiarism.,At least write some of your own opinions.,The link below has the original text.,I know that someone asked this question.。

There is a hidden meaning in this sentence: tragedy is based on the premise of "life" and "worthlessness", and comedy is based on the premise of "life" and "worthlessness". Further, sadness is the embodiment of the human perspective, because it is valuable, there is a sense of sadness; Comedy, on the other hand, is the embodiment of an unhuman point of view, seeing its ridiculousness and its worthlessness.

The key to tragedy and comedy is not how it ends, or not just how it ends, but how you see it, and you look at it from two completely different perspectives.

I think this explanation is already very good, if you say some of your own opinions, I don't think comedy is premised on "worthlessness", but because of the happy ending, the meaning of the object itself is not obvious, as if there is a saying that only after losing is to cherish, destruction just profoundly highlights the value of things, so there is a sense of sadness.

Hey, it seems to be in conflict with the above, which is roughly what it means, because the problem in the original text is different from yours. Pi Hong's self-support for tragedy and comedy is not just about how it ends, but it has a lot to do with the ending.

Mr. Zhu Guangqian once said in a letter to young people, "Life is valuable precisely because it has tragedy."

In "The Beauty of Speechless", Mr. Zhu Guangqian further said: "The world is flawed, and the possibility is great. As a master of aesthetics, Mr. Zhu Guangqian's views on the tragedy of life can be described as novel and profound, and thought-provoking.

Tragedy is a defect in life, a dilemma faced by people. In Mr. Zhu Guangqian's view, tragedy is not sad, and it is precisely because of the existence of tragedy that people have "opportunities for hope" and "fields of imagination" in life!

If the world is imperfect, there are flaws everywhere, and everything that people want must be achieved through their own efforts, and even if they cannot be obtained through hard work, then life will be full of "opportunities for hope" and "fields of imagination", and the value of human beings as subjects will be revealed.

It can be seen that although tragedy makes life flawed and the world full of imperfections, at the same time, Li Haohua also gives people a "possibility": the "possibility" of giving full play to subjectivity!

With this "subjectivity", people will "know what they can't do", try their best to make up for the tragedy of life, and bloom the brilliance of life.

You don't see, Zhang Guimei, the principal of Huaping Girls' Senior High School, "is not afraid of crushing dust, has no intention of fighting for spring, and expresses stubbornness to the world with a blooming life" With this "subjectivity", people will "know that they can't do it", try their best to improve the world's defects, and show the beauty of the world.

Standing at the crossroads of life, we are in the prime of our youth, we should give full play to our subjectivity and devote ourselves to the torrent of the times, "Even if life is a tragedy, we must act out this tragedy vividly, and do not lose the magnificence and joy of the tragedy."

Although there are tragedies in life, although the world is flawed, it is because of people's "subjectivity" - life is beautiful because of tragedy, and the world is perfect because of defects!

Tragedy and comedy will eventually be intertwined.