Guan Sheng and Zhu Tong in Water Margin , who is closest to Guan Yunchang?

Zhu Tong is the closest to Guan Yunchang, although Guan Sheng is Guan Yu's descendant, but whether it is in appearance or as a person, he is more like Guan Yu. In terms of force value, Zhu Tong is a little weaker, not as good as Guan Sheng. At this point, it is still Guan Sheng's demeanor.

Guan Yu is quite a prominent figure in the Three Kingdoms, and in the Water Margin, Guan Sheng is his descendant. It stands to reason that his own family should be more like himself, but many people think that Zhu Tong, who is not his descendant, is more like Guan Yu. First of all, let's take a look at Zhu Tong's appearance, there is a description of Zhu Tong's appearance in the book, saying that he is dignified, and he has a particularly good-looking beard, which is called "beautiful beard".

This is very similar to Guan Yu, so from the perspective of appearance, it is more similar to Zhu Tong.

Let's take a look at Zhu Tong's personality, Zhu Tong actually doesn't appear many times, and he is not a popular figure at all. But his deeds are impressive. He is very righteous towards the people he identifies, such as Chao Gai, Song Jiang, and Lei Heng, and he released them under great pressure.

And he is still a person who understands righteousness, he didn't want to go to Liangshan, but later, under the design of Liangshan, he was forced to have no way out, so he went to Liangshan. But he has always been at odds with Li Kui, because Li Kui killed Xiao Yanei in front of him in order to force him to go to Liangshan, and these qualities are very similar to Guan Yu.

Although Zhu Tong does not appear many times, he is the one who drives the plot. And he released all the big shots, Chao Gai and Song Jiang are the key characters in the whole book, so it can be seen from the side that Zhu Tong is also a very important character. Since I said Zhu Tong, I have to talk about Guan Sheng.

Although Guan Sheng said that he is also very similar to Guan Yu in appearance, and his martial arts are also very strong, his characteristics are said to be often imitating Guan Yu, not from the inside out, so many people say that he is not like Guan Yu.

Closer to Guan Yunchang is Zhu Tong.

1. Judging from his appearance, Zhu Tong's appearance is very close to Guan Gong, and he is even given the well-known nickname "Beautiful Bearded Gong".

Second, from the perspective of righteousness, Zhu Tong's meticulous thoughts, righteous personality and steadfast sentiments are very similar to Guan Yu.

3. Judging from the ending, after the fall of the Northern Song Dynasty, Zhu Tong followed the famous anti-Jin general Liu Guangshi to fight against the Jin soldiers, repeatedly defeated strong enemies, and made great achievements until he was promoted to the envoy of the Taiping Army. Zhu Tong can be said to be full of merit, and he really responds to the fate of Tianmanxing.

I think Guan Sheng is the closest to Guan Yunchang, first of all, Guan Sheng looks like Guan Yunchang in appearance, and the weapon he uses is also the Qinglong Yanyue Knife, and the book also says that he is a descendant of Guan Yunchang.

Guan Sheng is closer to Guan Yunchang, because they are all surnamed Guan, and Guan Sheng's martial arts are stronger than Zhu Tong.

Liangshan heroes Zhu Tong and Guan Sheng, compared to the two of them, Guan Sheng is more like the incarnation of the martial saint Guan Yu. As a martial saint, the force value must be high. Moreover, the character must be loyal and courageous, the weapon held must be the Qinglong Yanyue Knife, and the mount must be a red rabbit horse.

The martial saint, Guan Yunchang Guan Yu, is one of the heroes of the Three Kingdoms that we are more familiar with. Guan Yunchang and Liu Bei Zhang Feibai became three brothers, supporting half of the sky of Shu together, and Guan Yunchang was also the earliest one to die among the three of them. Next, let's talk about the reason why compared to Zhu Tong and Guan Sheng, Guan Sheng is more like the incarnation of the martial saint Guan Yu.

1. Although Zhu Tong's face is also red, and he is also very loyal and courageous, he has no sense of existence When everyone reads the book "Water Margin", the 108 heroes in Liangshan may not be able to recognize all of them, especially those who have no sense of existence, such as Zhu Tong. Zhu Tong's appearance is very similar to Guan Yu, and he also has this long beard. However, Zhu Tong does not have a big official position on Liangshan, nor does he have any big role, and he can only be mixed with the uneducated Jiulong Shijin, and his reputation is not as loud as others.

Second, Guan Sheng's appearance and ** and mount, and even his surname are very similar to Guan Yu Guan Sheng's appearance and personality are very similar to Guan Yu, especially, he is also surnamed Guan, and he is a descendant of Guan Yu, which makes it easier for people to think that he is the incarnation of the martial saint Guan Yu. Guan Sheng held the Qinglong Yanyue Knife, a red rabbit horse in his crotch, a red face and a long beard, loyal to the liver and courage, like Guan Yu, the martial saint who dominated the Three Kingdoms back then.

Third, compared with Guan Sheng, Zhu Tong is far less powerful than Guan Sheng Since we are talking about the martial saint Guan Yu, then whether the martial arts are powerful or not is an important factor that can judge whether he is the incarnation of the martial saint. Judging from the ranking of the 108 heroes in Shuipo Liangshan, Guan Sheng is much higher than Zhu Tong. From Liang Shan's position, Guan Sheng is the general of the army, and Zhu Tong is just a squad leader.

This shows which is better and which is inferior.

Guan Sheng is the incarnation of Guan Yu, because although Zhu Tong's face is red like Guan Yu, he does not have Guan Yu's arrogance and chivalrous courage. And Guan Sheng is a descendant of Guan Yu, he is also a big sword, and his martial arts are strong, so he is the incarnation of Guan Yu.

Guan Sheng is, because he is a descendant of Guan Yu, and he is very strong with a big sword.

In the Water Margin, Zhu Tong and Guan Sheng are relatively similar in appearance and appearance, they are more like Guan Yu, but in terms of real force value, Guan Sheng is closer to Guan Yu or more powerful, because he also uses the Blue Dragon Glaive, so he should be Guan Yu's peanut.

Guan Sheng. Because Guan Sheng is a descendant of Guan Yu, he looks very much like Guan Yu, which makes people feel that he is the incarnation of Guan Yu at first glance.

Because his personality and behavior in Water Margin are very similar to Guan Gong, the author's purpose is to create a second Guan Gong and make readers look happier.

The purpose is to better portray his character, and also hint at his tragic fate, although he is brave and resourceful like Guan Gong, he will not have a good result.

The purpose is to imply that his ending and the ending of the entire Liangshan heroes are like Shu, and the final ending is lost.

Personally, I think that the person mentioned in this topic is Zhu Tong in the Water Margin, because his appearance and other aspects are similar to Guan Yu, so some people call him the "Guan Yu" in the Water Margin, but in fact, he has nothing to do with Guan Yu, and if he is better than Guan Sheng, I personally think that Guan Sheng is more powerful. Because Guan Sheng's force value can be in the top three among the heroes of Liangshan, but Zhu Tong is not good at all.

In fact, to be honest, Zhu Tong is only somewhat similar to Guan Yu in appearance, but he is much inferior to Guan Yu in terms of martial arts, how can Guan Yu be the top three in the Three Kingdoms, and Zhu Tong should not be ranked in the top ten in Liangshan, how can such a level be compared with Guan Yu. Of course, this question is not about him and Guan Yu, but about him and Guan Sheng, so we can take a look at the comparison between him and Guan Sheng.

Zhu Tong's original position in the Water Margin should be equivalent to the current director of a police station, he has a certain force value, but he is definitely not strong, otherwise it is impossible to beat Li Kui. And that Guan Sheng, who was born as a military general, is able to go to the battlefield to kill the enemy, his big knife is also very powerful, his force value is not Li Kui, even Lin Chong may not be able to defeat him, so such a comparison can be known, Zhu Tong is far inferior to Guan Sheng.

But to be honest, it is a bit unfair to let Zhu Tong compare with Guan Sheng, because a discerning person can see at a glance that there is no comparison between the two, and I personally think that Zhu Tong is not good to be called Guan Yu in the Water Margin, but it is more appropriate for Guan Sheng to be called Guan Yu in the Water Margin, because Guan Sheng is the hero who can be compared with Guan Yu.

This person is Guan Sheng, so if Guan Sheng and Guan Yu are compared together, Guan Yu must be powerful, and Guan Yu's martial arts are higher than him.

The "Guan Yu" in the Water Margin is Guan Sheng, if these two people are compared, it must be Guan Yu who is more powerful, and Guan Yu's martial arts are high.

Guan Yu and Guan Sheng are heroes of two periods, one is a hero of the Three Kingdoms in troubled times, and the other is a hero of Shuibo Liangshan. But Guan Yu is a martial saint, and this realm is not comparable to ordinary people.

The "Guan Yu" of the Water Margin is Guan Sheng, he is more modest and not so conceited. Guan Yu is too light on the enemy, but his martial arts should be higher than Guan Sheng's.

Guan Sheng's only merit is that he is relatively humble and not as proud as his ancestors. The only possibility of Guan Yu's defeat is to be careless and underestimate the enemy. But as long as Guan Yu is on guard against one or two, it should be fine.

The "Guan Yu" in the Water Margin is Guan Sheng, Guan Yu and Guan Sheng are naturally more powerful than Guan Yu, but Guan Sheng is more modest than Guan Yu.

This person is Guan Sheng, on the whole, Guan Sheng must be more powerful, because Guan Sheng is not only powerful in martial arts, but also relatively modest, Guan Yu was defeated because he underestimated the enemy.

"Guan Yu" in "Water Margin" should be Guan Sheng! Guan Yu and Guan Sheng are of course more powerful than Guan Yu. After all, Guan Yu's martial arts are higher and stronger, and his ranking is also above Guan Sheng.

This person should be Guan Sheng, looking at the two of them on the whole, I personally think that Guan Yu's Wen Taowu strategy is above Guan Sheng.

Guan Sheng is powerful, Guan Sheng uses the Qinglong Yanyue Knife, and he uses Guan Yu's knife technique, just like Guan Yu, Guan Yu is a martial saint.

In "Water Margin", Song Jiang, Guan Sheng, and Zhu Tong all hope to be recruited by the imperial court, and Liangshan is just their pedal to the ladder of success。Song Jiang, Guan Sheng, and Zhu Tong fully supported the acceptance of the imperial court recruitment, they had worked in the Song Dynasty court system, but they went to Liangshan because of some unexpected events, their hearts were always in the Song Dynasty court, and they were always thinking about returning to the arms of the court.

The heroes of Liangshan had only three attitudes towards the Song Dynasty's Zhao'an policy, one was resolute support, one was neutral, and the other was resolutely opposed。The low-level social green forest heroes led by Wu Song and Lu Zhishen resolutely opposed the imperial court recruitment, because they were not originally people in the imperial court system, and they also knew that they could not integrate into this circle. As long as the Liangshan group accepted the Song Dynasty's Chao'an, their fate was already in the hands of others, and they could not live the life they wanted, and their lives were also in the hands of the Song Dynasty's court, and they had to be restrained and controlled by the court at all times.

Guan Sheng and Zhu Tong resolutely supported the Song Dynasty's Zhao'an policy。They have a deep relationship with people in the court, and with their years of credit, they can regain a foothold in the court, and the court of the Song Dynasty also needs talents like Guan Sheng to help them protect their families and defend the country.

Song Jiang is indeed wholeheartedly thinking about the future of the Liangshan Group。The Liangshan group could not always rely on robbing homes to make a living, this was not a solution to the problem, and there were only two ways in front of the Liangshan group, the first was to continue to expand their territory and form a rival force against the Song Dynasty court. The second is to accept the recruitment of the Song Dynasty court, of course, Song Jiang wants to seek a path of peaceful development for all his brothers, and does not want them to live every day licking blood on the knife with their heads.

However, under the command of the imperial court, it was finally gradually eliminated by the imperial court.

The reason why Song Jiang, Guan Sheng, and Zhu Tong are one in "Water Margin" is mainly because the three of them worked together in a yamen before going to Liangshan. And they still went up to Liangshan together.

Because the three of them all support Zhao'an, needless to say, Song Jiang is the most supportive of Zhao'an, Guan Sheng and Zhu Tong were originally the ** of the imperial court, and they were helpless to go to Liangshan.

Because these three people are completely bent on being recruited by the imperial court, they are one.

Because the three of them are very righteous and have heavy troops, whoever has an accident will cause the other two regimes to be unstable, so they are one.

Because Guan Sheng is a famous family, he has strong ability and good background, so he can naturally be the head of the generals in Liangshan.

It stands to reason that Lin Chong, as a character who appeared in Liangshan very early, will definitely have a higher status than Guan Sheng, but in the end, according to the arrangement of Liangshan generals, Guan Sheng turned out to be a latecomer and became Liangshan, and the head of the generals overwhelmed Lin Chong, Qin Ming and others, this kind of arrangement also made us later readers argue, some people think that Lin Chong appeared early with strong force, and his contribution should be the first of the generals in Liangshan, and some people think that Guan Sheng also has many advantages, so there is no problem with such a ranking.

According to the Water Margin,Guan Sheng is a descendant of Guan Yu during the Three Kingdoms period, I don't know if this statement is accurate, but his reputation in the rivers and lakes is like this, so his bloodline and background are extremely important, Liang Shan is extremely important, Liang Shan was a small number of ruffians and hooligans at that time surrendered generals,Guan Sheng's bloodline is a fig leaf for them, so pushing Guan Sheng to the first place among all generals has indeed boosted their reputation.

Guan Yu's influence on the people of the rivers and lakes is extremely important, so let Guan Sheng be the head of the heroes and generals in Liangshan, and have a great influence on some people on the rivers and lakes who believe in the loyalty of the second brother GuanGuan Sheng's plaque is the plaque they attract other heroes from all walks of life, so there will be a reason to push him to the first place in Liangshan heroes.

As the descendant of Guan Yu described in **, Guan Sheng is naturally strong enough in force, and he is strong enough with a handful of Qinglong Yanyue, so he will not be disagreed with when he is pushed to the position of the first general of Liangshan heroes.