Hong Xiuquan s merits and demerits? What do you think?

In the process of the transformation of the Taiping revolutionary regime into a new feudal dynasty regime, Hong Xiuquan played a particularly bad leading role. The qualitative change in ideological style made it more like a feudal emperor in the future.

Hong Xiuquan led the peasant rebel army, dealt a heavy blow to the corrupt rule of the feudal dynasty, and shook the long years of the rule of the feudal dynasty and the Qing Dynasty.

Hong Xiuquan's Taiping Rebellion dealt a heavy blow to the rule of the Qing Dynasty, hastened the demise of the Qing Dynasty, and also dealt a blow to the aggression of foreign invaders against China to a certain extent. However, his thinking was relatively low and suspicious, which eventually led to the Tianjing Incident.

Hong Xiuquan's mistakes are mainly as follows: 1. After the capital of Tianjing, the feudal consciousness increased day by day, and the concept of hierarchy and the idea of pleasure were particularly prominent. Hong Xiuquan lived in a simple house in the Tianwang Mansion, and was seriously separated from the masses of soldiers.

The internal strife in Tianjing was the inevitable result of the development of this feudal ideology within the leading group. 2. In the later period of the Taiping Dynasty, in order to prevent the fall of power, Hong Xiuquan reversed the line of employing people in the early stage and "employed people nepotism", forming a Hong group that excluded different surnames, which made the politics of the later period increasingly corrupt and brought a fatal crisis to the Taiping Dynasty.

God's spokesman, but there is no benevolence and faithfulness, Hong Xiuquan is already suspicious, and after infighting, he is even more nepotistic. First of all, his elder brothers Hong Renfa and Hong Renda, who were named King An and King Fu respectively, let the two elder brothers take power, suppress and monitor Shi Dakai.

The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom was defeated by the joint strangulation of Chinese and foreign reactionary forces. However, as the supreme leader of the Taiping Movement, Hong Xiuquan's serious mistakes cannot be ignored.

The reason why the Taiping Movement became the highest peak of China's peasant war for thousands of years is inseparable from his tremendous contributions. Even Sun Yat-sen, the pioneer of China's democratic revolution, is willing to be the second of Hong Xiuquan, which can see his far-reaching influence on later generations.

It's all over! For his own selfishness, he has put the people in fire and water for more than ten years! Faith is nondescript! Destroy the monument collection! Taiping Rebellion!

Hong Xiuquan before the Tianjing Incident was still relatively good, but after the Tianjing Incident, he was not good, negative hedonism, corruption and degeneration. But I appreciate his tough attitude towards foreign powers: not an inch of China's land can be ceded to foreigners!

Shi Dakai is the best commander of the Taiping Army, and his department is the elite of the Taiping Army. He has both ability and political integrity, and has won the support of all the military and civilians, and after the internal strife in Tianjing, he is the only person who can unite the masses to assist Hong Xiuquan to revitalize the country.

Hong Xiuquan is the founder of the God Worship Society, but in fact it is a cult. After the rebellion in Guangxi, people were killed all the way north, and tens of millions of people were killed in the five southeastern provinces.

Without Hong Xiuquan, there would have been no rise of the Hunan Army and the Huai Army, and there would have been no Westernization Movement, and modern China would have to grope in the dark for a longer time.

The merits outweigh the faults. Hong Xiuquan is amazing, and he will be famous for centuries.

Hong Xiuquan's Taiping Heavenly Kingdom dealt a painful blow to the decaying Manchu Qing! In the later period of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, Hong Xiuquan gradually became corrupt and broke away from the masses!

Resisting the decaying Qing ** is meritorious, and after the establishment of Tianjing, it is just a foolish ......

Let tens of millions of people in China die in the flames of war, what is the credit, a short-sighted mediocre person who only knows pleasure!

It's all nonsense, Hong Xiuquan harms people and misleads the country.

In a word, Sun Yat-sen, the father of the nation, called himself "Hong Xiuquan's second." It is enough to prove Hong Xiuquan's greatness.

It's hard to say whether the merits or demerits are, anyway, in the later period they were more corrupt than the Manchus

It should be destroyed and then set up in Beijing! In this way, the invasion of Britain will not be so passive! Then you can even hit Japan! In the end, the world is peaceful!

There are no merits and demerits, the development of history is sometimes very strange, and sometimes no one can control it!

Lao Hong was greedy for the life of the powerful, and he pulled up a team to attack the city and plunder the land, and lived a comfortable life...

History is history, how can it be assumed at will?

It shook the feudal dictatorship, made important contributions to the Taiping Rebellion, played a great role in social progress, and promoted the development of modern China. At the same time, his personal ability was limited, and after achieving certain results, he began to covet enjoyment, which caused the internal strife of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, began to covet pleasure, and finally led to the failure of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom movement.

Gong struck a blow at feudal forces and imperialism.

It has caused great damage to the livelihood of the people in the south of the Yangtze River and has also done great damage to Chinese culture.

Gong: It directly led to the fall of the Qing Dynasty. (Premise: If the Qing Dynasty falls is a good thing).

Guo: It directly led to the fall of the Qing Dynasty. (if it's a bad thing).

Positive: The leader of the peasant uprising, who resisted the rotten rule of the Qing **, Sun Yat-sen said he would do it after listening to his story when he was a child"Hong Xiuquan is second''。Opposite: It has set China's industrial development back decades.

Positive: made an indelible contribution to the early end of the decadent rule of the Qing Dynasty, and reversed China's development by decades.

Front: Leader of the peasant uprising. Negative: Cult organizations have destroyed thousands of years of Chinese civilization.

Lustful, he has 82 wives.

Hong Xiuquangong1 Under his leadership, the Heavenly Kingdom learned advanced technology from abroad, such as the "Zizhi Tongjian"2 proposed that everyone is equal, which conformed to the trend of history, and after 1, he concentrated power in him alone, and 2 because of his disbelief in Shi Dakai, which was also a turning point in the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom.

The vigorous Taiping Rebellion occurred in the transition period when China began to degenerate from a feudal society to a semi-colonial and semi-feudal society, and played a role in the history of our country. Knowing Hong Xiuquan, it can be said that he basically got to know the overall cause of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom. This article discusses the formation, content and influence of Hong Xiuquan's revolutionary thought, introduces the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom Movement led by Hong Xiuquan, and focuses on the analysis of the different stages of the formation of his revolutionary thought, so that people can have a clearer understanding of Hong Xiuquan's historical achievements.