Evaluate the merits and demerits of Qin Shi Huang in building the Great Wall

Achievements: Resist the Xiongnu, defend the country, and save the people of Li from the suffering of war; Accumulate valuable experience for Chinese architecture, and make the Great Wall a gorgeous landscape of Chinese culture.

Negligence: Labor and loss of money, construction of a large number of buildings, resulting in the boiling of public resentment, people's wives and wives are separated, and their heads are in different places.

Historians are particular about looking at history with a third eye. We cannot measure the people and events of the past by today's standards. When Qin destroyed the Six Kingdoms, the Six Kingdoms rose up to resist, and many heroes emerged, and we still sing the praises of these patriots today.

At the same time, Qin Shi Huang unified China, and we are also singing the praises of his great achievements. Why? Because we are descendants of the Six Kingdoms, and we are also descendants of Qin.

The ancestors fought among themselves, and the younger generations did not intervene.

Back to your question. Qin Shi Huang built the Great Wall to defend against the invasion of the Central Plains by the Xiongnu from the north. Under the conditions of the time, the people could only be forced to serve in forced labor.

It seems cruel today, but at the time, it was a must. If according to the current standard, His Majesty the Emperor first issued a Zhaoshu, asking the ** of all counties in the world to mobilize the people, participate in voting, elect parliamentarians, and then rush to Chang'an to form the first Great Qin Imperial Council to discuss the feasibility of building the Great Wall and appropriation. At the same time, the people of the whole country will also have a referendum on whether to agree to the construction of the Great Wall, and before that, they will have to explain the reasons for building the Great Wall.

It is also necessary to assess the impact of the construction of the Great Wall on the situation in East Asia and report back to the Parliament and the Head of State. All of this still has a lot of work to do. Is it possible?

History is very interesting. Even the Xiongnu, their genes have long been integrated into the body of the Chinese nation. When we are the descendants, how can we make irresponsible remarks about our ancestors?

History is history, and it is important to be true.

First of all, Qin Shi Huang's construction of the Great Wall is inseparable from the historical background at that time, and the construction of the Great Wall was to defend against foreign enemies, and the Great Wall played a huge role in the stability of the southern region at that time

It is a manifestation of the resistance of civilized regions to barbarian invasions.

Merit is very good to say, I would like to add to it.

It not only intensified the already acute social problems of the time, but also created a conservative style for later generations.

Qin Shi Huang. The historical significance of the construction of the Great Wall is that it helped the Central Plains countries in later generations to defend themselves against foreign enemies. The purpose of Qin Shi Huang to build the Great Wall was to defend against the harassment of the Xiongnu and other steppe peoples in the north.

In Chinese history, it has played a huge role in resisting the grassland peoples.

The Great Wall, also known as the Great Wall, is a military fortification in ancient China, and is a tall, strong and continuous long wall.

It is used to limit the action beam stove of enemy cavalry. The Great Wall is not a simple isolated wall, but a defense system with the city wall as the main body and a large number of cities, barriers, pavilions and standards.

Gong: The Xiongnu are already very close to Xianyang. After Qin Shi Huang unified the six countries, he immediately helped the army move north from the eastern battlefield.

General Meng Tian led 300,000 elite soldiers to expel the Xiongnu and open up the northern territory. Later, a longer and stronger wall was built on the basis of the original Great Wall of the northern countries. The Han dynasty completely inherited the rule of the Qin dynasty.

The Xiongnu in the north had been expelled by General Meng Tian and most of the fortified walls had been repaired. The south has been sent by Qin Shi Huang to emigrate, and tends to be stable. These most basic talents formed the foundation of the Han Dynasty's century-old self-cultivation.

History is always created by a small number of people, and it is true that the majority of people are pointing fingers and tampering with it for their own selfish desires.

Wasted a large amount of money and resources of the state, and brought suffering and heavy burden of forced labor to hundreds of people; It inspired the people to revolt, triggered the intensification of class contradictions, and hastened the fall of the Qin Dynasty.

First, to protect the Central Plains from the harassment of nomads, resist the invasion of external ethnic minorities, and protect the agricultural civilization of the Central Plains;

Second, it has promoted the integration of the Central Plains civilization of the Chinese nation, leaving an incomparable elite and incomparable wealth for future generations in the world, making the Great Wall a totem and symbol of China's image;

Qin Shi Huang built the Great Wall:

First, it wastes a lot of money and resources of the country;

Second, it brought suffering and a heavy burden of forced labor to hundreds of people, stimulated the people's revolt, triggered the intensification of class contradictions, and hastened the fall of the Qin Dynasty.

First, to protect the Central Plains from the harassment of nomadic peoples, resist the invasion of external ethnic minorities, and protect the Central Plains agricultural civilization;

Second, it has promoted the integration of the Central Plains civilization of the Chinese nation, left incomparable spiritual wealth for future generations of the world, and made the Great Wall a totem and symbol of China's image;

Qin Shi Huang built the Great Wall:

First, it wastes a lot of money and resources of the country;

Second, it brought suffering and a heavy burden of forced labor to hundreds of people, which inspired the rebellion of the lack of people, triggered the intensification of class contradictions, and hastened the fall of the Qin Dynasty.

In fact, the question of whether Qin Shi Huang built the Great Wall was a merit or a fault has always been controversial, at least at that time, people thought that Qin Shi Huang was wrong to build the Great Wall.

So, for the Qin Dynasty at that time, was it right or wrong to build the Great Wall?

In a sense, the construction of the Great Wall did consume a lot of manpower and material resources, and also consumed the Qin Dynasty's chaotic national strength, leading to the decline of national strength. However, from the perspective of the status of the ruler, the construction of the Great Wall can not only resist foreign invasion and protect the people, but also play a military role.

In any case, the construction of the Great Wall is still a great achievement, and the construction of the Great Wall plays a protective role. Second, it can prevent conflicts, so as to avoid the occurrence of war, compared with the consumption of manpower and material resources brought about by the war, the losses caused by the construction of the Great Wall are not worth mentioning, and the role played by the Great Wall in later generations can also be proven.

As for why people criticized the construction of the Great Wall at that time, firstly, it was because the people did not understand it, and they only cared about arguing with their grandchildren, and secondly, they brought a burning chain.

Summary: The Great Wall is a treasure of our Chinese culture, and it has unparalleled significance in both ancient and modern times.

Meng Jiangnu cried on the Great Wall.

Meng Jiangnu cried on the Great Wall.

During the Qin Dynasty, there was a kind and beautiful woman named Meng Jiangnu. One day, she was doing housework in her yard, when she suddenly found a person hiding under the grape trellis, which startled her, and she was about to shout, but the person waved his hand again and again, and begged back pleadingly: "Don't shout, don't shout, help me!"

My name is Fan Xiliang, and I'm here to flee. ”

It turned out that at this time, Qin Shi Huang was arresting people everywhere to do laborers in order to build the Great Wall, and he had starved to death and died of exhaustion. Meng Jiangnu rescued Fan Xiliang, and called Liang to see that he was knowledgeable and reasonable, with clear eyebrows and beautiful eyes, and fell in love with him, and Fan Xiliang also fell in love with Meng Jiangnu. The two of them were heart-to-heart, and after obtaining the consent of their parents, they were ready to get married.

On the day of marriage, the Meng family was full of lights, and the guests were full, and there was a joyful scene. Seeing that it was getting dark, and the people who drank the wine were gradually dispersed, the bride and groom were about to enter the cave room, when suddenly they only heard the chickens and dogs barking, and then a team of vicious officers and soldiers broke in.

At this time, the Great Wall was already a very long city wall composed of construction sites, and Meng Jiangnu came to find it from construction site to site, but her husband was never seen. Finally, she plucked up the courage and asked a group of migrant workers who were about to go to work: "Do you have a Fan Xiliang here?"

The migrant worker said: "There is such a person, a newcomer. ”

When Meng Jiangnu heard this, she was so happy! She hurriedly asked again, "Where is he?" The migrant worker said, "It's dead, and the corpse capital and the closed fortune have filled in the foot of the city."

Suddenly hearing this bad news, it was like a thunderbolt on a sunny day, Meng Jiangnu only felt that her eyes were dark, she was sad for a while, and she cried. I cried for three days and three nights, crying so dark that even the heavens and the earth were moved.

The sky was getting more and more gloomy, the wind was getting more and more violent, only to hear a "bang", a section of the Great Wall was cried down, revealing Fan Xiliang's corpse, and Meng Jiangnu's tears fell on his bloody face. She finally met her beloved husband, but he never saw her again, because he had been killed by the brutal Qin Shi Huang.