Isn t it a bit unreasonable for principals to punish students for mistakes with fines?

This measure is not reasonable, firstly, students are consumers and cannot make money on their own

As far as the students are concerned, they are still students who are studying and do not have the ability to earn money. So, for a student who is still a consumer, this measure is not very reasonable. If you look at it a little more shallowly, this is the principal asking students to pay for their mistakes, and if you look deeper, that is, the principal is filling his own pockets and sucking up the hard-earned money of parents.

As a teacher, the most important thing is to teach children to correct their mistakes, not to increase their consumption and make them a moth. <>

Second, fines do not establish students' perception of right and wrong, but rather make them develop the wrong idea that "spending money can solve problems".

In TV dramas and even in real society, there are many rich people who are willing to "spend money to eliminate disasters", for them, there is nothing that money can't get rid of. But is this notion correct? There is no doubt that this is distorting this generation's view of right and wrong.

If all mistakes can be solved with money, then why do you need police in this world? Why do you want justice? Therefore, the school must establish a correct view of right and wrong for students, what is right is right, and what is wrong is wrong, and it is not something that you can change with money.

Third, the money for the fine was paid by the parents, and the parents did not make a mistake in this matter, which is an unreasonable charge by the school to the parents

Fines, as the name suggests, are money that is paid to the relevant authorities because you made a mistake. However, when students make mistakes, parents are not involved, and it is not so much the responsibility of parents to supervise as the responsibility of the school. Because my child is in school, and I have also paid the tuition, then the school has the responsibility of supervision, according to the responsibility system, this is also the fault of myself and the supervisor, what does it have to do with the parents?

Why should parents pay for it? <>

Fourth, what is the money used for? The principal did not manage it, and there was a suspicion of embezzling a fine

Don't look at the fact that sometimes the amount of money fined is not much, but there are so many people in the school, and each person is fined dozens of dollars every month, then the account is big! This money will definitely not be returned to the parents, nor will it be sent to the students, and the parents will pay for the food, clothing, housing and transportation of the students, so where is such a large amount of money used? If it's used to reward teachers, it doesn't make sense!

Because my child makes mistakes in school, the first person to blame is the teacher!

The fine system may be binding on students, but after all, the money is obtained from the parents, and the children do not worry about the money. It's just reaching out for it.

It is indeed unreasonable, the principal should make the students mentally aware of their mistakes and pay attention to restraining their behavior in the future, instead of punishing the students materially, so that the children will have the idea that money can solve the mistakes.

Yes, if your child has been fined, you can report a complaint to the Education Bureau. Because the state has the right to impose fines except for the judiciary, no one else has it.

I don't think that's reasonable. Because schools should not punish students with money fines, they can use other appropriate methods.

I think it is extremely unreasonable, it is extremely unreasonable to punish students with fines for making mistakes in school, because students in school have almost no financial **, such punishment, not only will not make students realize their mistakes, but feel that they are making a fuss, because the money is not earned by themselves, they can reach out to their parents to ask, so that they do not feel the pain points, but it increases the financial pressure of their parents, so they will make the same mistake again next time.

I think it's a little unreasonable, because students don't have the ability to make money, their money is from their parents, and the school shouldn't be fined.

It is unreasonable to punish students for their mistakes with fines, because students do not earn money and spend their parents' money. Moreover, using money to measure the right and wrong of a thing will also create wrong values for children. Mistakes are punished, and can be done in other ways, such as running a few laps in the playground, writing homework several times, memorizing English**, etc.

It is unreasonable for principals to punish students for mistakes with fines, fines do not solve the problem, and schools should help students recognize mistakes and correct them.

I don't think it's appropriate. Because such behavior is an offense to the teacher, and it is not fair to the teacher at all.

This is not reasonable at all, and the poor grades of students are not all due to the teacher, it may be because the students themselves do not want to study, so they are like this.

I don't think it's appropriate to do this, because the situation of the students is diverse, and you can't force the teacher to do so.

No, partly because of the teachers, partly because of the students themselves, and partly because of the parents.

I strongly support proper reprieve education, as this approach not only helps students recognize mistakes, but also enables them to understand the consequences of mistakes and to grow in reflection and reflection.

Leave education refers to the process of making students recognize their mistakes and understand the consequences of their mistakes by temporarily suspending them from activities or participating in extracurricular activities. Compared with fines or corporal punishment, this method is more humane and can produce better results in a short period of time.

Leave of absence education can help students understand their mistakes. Sometimes, students need to think and reflect on their mistakes for a while, so that they can better understand the mistakes they have made. Through the suspension of punishment education, students can slowly think about their own problems during the period of suspension of activities, and think about how to solve the wrong problems, so as to better correct their mistakes.

In addition, leave education can help students understand the consequences of their mistakes. Students need to solve their mistakes in a short period of time so that they can make fewer mistakes in the future. Through the suspension education, students will better understand the consequences of their own mistakes, so as to avoid making the same mistakes in their studies and lives after Jinchangyan.

Not only that, but leave education can also promote the growth of students. Through reflection and reflection, students can grow from their mistakes and better understand what they need to correct.

In this way, students are more capable and less likely to make mistakes.

To sum up, proper leave education is a very humane and effective method of education, which can produce good results in a short period of time, and students will also benefit from it and grow into a better version of themselves. 1

Children will make mistakes, because the student is not yet ignorant age, as a teacher should still have a certain punishment, within the acceptable range, of course, can not let the student be injured, if the student makes a mistake, the teacher will not punish the student at all, and will not be obedient in the future, will not change, so for the student should be appropriately punished, so that the student can change the mistake, recognize their own shortcomings, so as to help the classmates continue to change the pants and progress, 1 life if the teacher does not punish any student, Students will not listen to the teacher, will not be particularly afraid of the teacher, and may even bully the teacher. From the perspective of a school teacher, it is also a responsible performance for a teacher to punish a student. They also want to use this method to urge students to learn, get rid of bad habits in learning, and help children establish correct learning concepts and values.

However, in the process of corporal punishment, some teachers have developed inappropriate ways and means, which have led to many social problems. Parents send their children to school and let teachers educate their children. However, in the process of educating children, some teachers do not exercise this right well and have violent tendencies and other illegal behaviors.

2.Teachers can appropriately punish students, because there are no rules, and appropriate corporal punishment is conducive to children's education. Because appropriate corporal punishment can make students realize their mistakes, and then better correct their shortcomings and grow better.

But corporal punishment must be moderate and never excessive. However, corporal punishment is not perfect, especially for students who are encouraged by their parents, or for some left-behind children. They really lack control and some students do whatever they want!

If violence is a regular occurrence on campus, everything is clear. Such students need to stop being punished appropriately when they start going astray! When I was a teacher at the time, my psychology teacher used to say that there was a professor at the university who discussed how to punish students, and it would work best.

It can be seen that it is not without benefit to stop the appropriate punishment of students.

3.When the child is learning or growing and learning some skills, some classmates who do not study hard or are naughty will be punished with a ruler. At that time, the students were influenced by the traditional idea of the dignity of the teacher, and they were punished and sincerely admitted their mistakes.

In the past, the children were very naïve and in awe of their teachers. When the teacher is rational and standardized, he uses a ruler to punish the student, which produces some good results. But what I have to say is that some teachers beat students impulsively or irrationally, and some even hurt students, causing serious adverse effects.

The teacher can't do anything to the student, this is an irrational way, and as a teacher, he should be cultivated, and the child is here to be educated, not purely ruined in the school to beat the teacher, of course, you can't beat the student, this is the wrong way, you can punish the student, for example, standing on the podium to learn a lesson, so that the student can recognize their own shortcomings and mistakes, write a review book These can be executed, so that the student can have a memory.

If a student violates discipline at school, the school has the right to take the following actions: warning; Serious warnings; Demerit; probation; Expulsion. However, it should be noted that for students who are in the nine-year compulsory education stage, the school may not expel them.

Regulations on the Management of Students in Colleges and Universities

Article 51.

For students who have violated laws and regulations, these Provisions, or school discipline, the school shall give criticism and education, and may give the following disciplinary sanctions depending on the severity of the circumstances:

a) Warning; b) Serious warnings;

3) demerits; 4) Probation;

5) Expulsion from school.

Regulations on the Administration of Students in Ordinary Institutions of Higher Learning

Article 54.

Schools giving sanctions to students shall persist in combining education and punishment, and be commensurate with the nature of the student's violation of law or discipline and the severity of the mismatch. Schools' sanctions against students shall be made so that the evidence is sufficient, the basis is clear, the characterization is accurate, the procedures are proper, and the sanctions are appropriate.

The school's spine can also be corporal punishment of students, but it is necessary to choose the right method within a certain range, and do not blindly promote students, otherwise it will affect the physical and mental health of children.

The principal does not have the right to physically punish students, because the principal is not a teacher, and the Teachers Act stipulates that only teachers can punish students.

There is no power, not only the principal has no power, but also the teacher, because corporal punishment of students is illegal.

You can take the initiative to ask for the TV to be repaired in person and be responsible for the cost.

And said that additional fines, and deposits could not be accepted.

As for what happened, I am willing to accept the punishment according to the school rules. Reviews, warranties, etc.

Penalties other than school rules can be protected by law.

I don't know what grade you are, but the most difficult thing for adolescent students is to control their emotions, and the school doesn't want to educate students in the first place, so they directly use money to restrict students, which is obviously an insidious way to take tricks. It's a bit of a fake.

There is a question, whether this is the opinion of the school or the opinion of individual teachers, and it is not necessary that the principal does not know about you.

There have been schools that have fined students and been exposed on television, and I feel that this kind of education is really ridiculous. What's even more surprising is what deposit to be paid by students, I feel that the school is incompetent to such a point, students are educated, and it is the teacher's responsibility to educate each student well.

Unreasonable, at that time, our class students were fined 50 yuan because they were late for the class meeting, and the classmates were not convinced and went directly to the Education Bureau, and then the class teacher was warned by the school to inform the whole school, and you can only compensate for the school's losses, give you criticism and the like, the Education Bureau clearly stipulates that fines are not allowed.

Absolutely illegal, report directly to the local education bureau, so it is generally black your money, and if you have not explained in advance that the damage will be compensated according to the price, you don't have to accompany it, besides, what deposit should not be, not for money, and you can't condone the school like this.

If the school asks for compensation for the damage to the TV, it is reasonable to repair the cost, but if it has to pay a security deposit, it is not legal. In fact, many schools have this practice, and it is difficult for students to manage nowadays, so it is no wonder that schools come up with such tricks.

First of all, you can't destroy the public facilities of your classmates because your classmates mess with you, don't be too impulsive when you encounter annoying things, be calm!! Secondly, the school fine is unreasonable, the school should consider the root of the problem, help the wrong students solve the psychological problems, the school system is to restrain people, not to punish people mentally or materially, schools like this should be criticized with the help of **.