Among the Five Tiger Generals , is it Zhao Yun or Ma Chao who ranks third? 5

Updated on history 2024-05-26
15 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    The first statement of the Five Tiger Generals came from "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", referring to the five fierce generals under Liu Bei, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, Ma Chao, and Huang Zhong (pay attention to the order), the original text was described as "Five Tiger Generals", and later generations are commonly known as "Five Tiger Generals". It is also a common title of military general in Chinese historical chapters or operas, usually there are five people, all of whom are the most powerful generals in the monarch or power. Later, it was also used to describe a person or group of people with outstanding abilities in various fields (the number is generally five).

    The numerical combination of "five" reflects the traditional Chinese thinking about the mystical structures of the five elements, the five squares, the five colors, and the five tones.

    Therefore, the third place is Zhao Yun, and the fourth place is Ma Chao, and the order of these five people is ranked in the order of talent and joining Shu Han.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    The Five Tiger Admirals are said to be in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Zhao Yun ranked third, followed by Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, and Ma Chao ranked fourth.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    It should be Ma Chao, Zhao Yun was moved to the front by Mao Zonggang and his son when he edited "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" because of Zhao Yungong's great achievements, and it turned out to be Guan Zhang, Ma Huangzhao. In the history books, Zhao Yun is far inferior to the status of Guan Zhang, Ma and Huang, because Zhao Yun and Liu Bei have different political views.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Personally, I think Ma Chao is the strongest Ma Chao fights Zhang Jaw Xu Chu is still very young Guan Yu Zhang Fei was already in the prime of life when he fought a famous general The prime of life is definitely better than the young man Ma Chao played Zhang Jaw for 20 rounds Zhao Yun played Zhang Jaw for 30 rounds Although Ma Chao was angry at that time with the hatred of killing his father, it can be known that Ma Chao is very explosive Zhao Yun is also very strong Ping Yi is brave Wearing a million troops Huang Zhong has a distance advantage So he can take Guan Yu's head in his twilight If you just look at the force Huang Zhongzhong can't compare with them I think it's Ma Guan Zhang Zhao.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Guan Zhang, Zhao Mahuang, Zhao Yun is also

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    In the romance, it is Zhao Yun, and in the Three Kingdoms, it is Ma Chao.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    In history, there were no five tiger generals in Shu, but Chen Shou's Three Kingdoms generals Guan Zhang Ma Huang were tied for a pass.

    Although Chen Shou wrote a biography for Zhao Yun in the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms, although the number of words is very small, he is juxtaposed with Guan Zhang Ma Huang because of the fact that they are brave and fierce, and their merits are comparable.

    This at least proves that Zhao Yun is qualified to sit on an equal footing with Guan Zhang and Ma Huang.

    In addition, the deeds contained in the biography of Yun Biography undoubtedly prove that Zhao Yun was a tiger general with both wisdom and courage, courage and insight, and his political foresight and strategic judgment were beyond the match of the other four generals.

    Although it is not a true story, it cannot be considered untrustworthy.

    Some people say that Zhao Yun's official position in his life is not very prominent, and he is even inferior to Wei Yan, but in fact, this is a misunderstanding.

    Zhao Yun's role is to be in charge of internal affairs, and he is the commander of the forbidden army, a position that is not qualified for a person who is not close to his confidence, wisdom, and courage.

    "Protecting the Army" is a very important position.

    Shu's ** army, "The Military System of the Past Dynasties" said: "Shu placed five armies."

    There is one general, one superintendent and one protector on the left and right, one each of the division, superintendent, protector, warden, and army, one former division, one general, one superintendent, one superintendent, one general, and one concurrently after the superintendent.

    It will be abbreviated as the Han. "The five armies are the front, rear, left, right, and middle armies, and the middle army is the same as Cao Wei's guard troops at the same time, and the front, rear, left, and right armies are slightly equal to Cao Wei's foreign army.

    According to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Shu Zhi. Guan Zhang Ma Huang Zhao Biography", the commanders of the front, rear, left, and right armies are the former general, the rear general, the left general, and the right general.

    As for the Chinese army, because Shu did not set up a central leader, it was commanded by the Central Protector Army.

    Therefore, Guan, Zhang, Ma, Huang and Zhao were the military commanders of the five armies in the front, right, left, and rear respectively, and Chen Shou listed them as a class of legacy, which has its own reason.

    The reason why Zhao Yun did not leave a brilliant record of killing generals and capturing the pass was because the division of labor between the Chinese army and the foreign army was different.

    Zhao Yun's duty is to guard rather than break the enemy in battle, and he is defensive rather than taking the initiative to attack, and he rarely has the opportunity to lead the soldiers to confront the enemy head-on like Guan Zhang and Ma Huang, because the safety of the leader is the first priority, and attacking without authorization is a dereliction of duty.

    Looking at Zhao Yun's deeds from this angle, he has done a very good job as the commander of the Chinese army, just as Guan Zhang and Ma Huang are very competent as the commander of foreign armies, Zhao Yun has made outstanding contributions to his work and is impeccable, and he must not be discriminated against because of the different nature of his work.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Because Zhao Yun's background is not as good as Guan Yu, Zhang Fei and Ma Chao, the qualifications are not as good as the veteran Huang Zhong, and Liu Bei only hopes that he will be his personal guard and protect himself and his familyI don't want to give him too high a status and let him go to the battlefield to fight.

    Speaking of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Zhao Yun and Zhao Zilong, who are full of courage, left a deep impression on us, and the sentence "I am Changshan Zhao Zilong" when he appeared I don't know how many enemies' courage was broken, and his superior martial arts are second only to the first god of war Lu Bu, becoming the second place in the force value ranking during the Three Kingdoms period. Zhao Yun of the white horse and silver spear crisscrossed the battlefield, leaving behind many legendary heroic stories that can be sung and criedOne of the most commendable contributions is the protection of Liu Bei and his family, and is therefore regarded by Liu Bei as the best personal guard. But Zhao Yun, who is so loyal and brave, has the lowest status among the five tiger generals, is it because Liu Bei doesn't value him, he is a figure who has saved Liu Bei and Adou, why does Liu Bei give him a low status?

    Of course, there is a reason for all this, and Zhao Yun also expressed his understanding of this, and he never had superfluous thoughts. In fact, Liu Bei valued Zhao Yun more, but it was precisely because he trusted the loyal and brave Zhao Yun very much that he made Zhao Yun a personal guard for himself and his family, and said on his deathbed, "Zhao Yun is not a big person." It means that he doesn't approve of letting Zhao Yun take on the heavy responsibility to fight on the battlefield, he just needs Zhao Yun to protect his son Liu Chan and his family.

    And Liu Bei did not give Zhao Yun too high a status, which was related to the contribution and background made by the five tiger generals, which was also a decision made by Liu Bei in order to balance the relationship between the five tiger generals. Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are Liu Bei's sworn brothers, and they have made countless achievements on the battlefield, and their status is naturally a little higher, and although Ma Chao is a general who joined later, but behind him represents the entire Xiliang soldiers and horses, so Liu Bei must not treat him badly, although the last veteran Huang Zhong has a low force value, but his qualifications are the oldest among the five tiger generals, and the age is also the oldest.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Zhao Yun's martial arts are indeed relatively powerful, but because the top 4 generals are all generals who lead the troops and lead the team alone, and Zhao Yun is Liu Bei's bodyguard captain, his status is relatively low.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Zhao Yun's main duty is to protect Liu Bei, although it is a very important position, but it lacks the opportunity to make contributions.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Because although his martial arts are powerful, he is still slightly weaker than others, and he has no talent, and his intelligence is low.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    The four generals of Liu Beifeng in the official history are: former general Guan Yu, left general Zhang Fei, right general Ma Chao, and later general Huang Zhong, but unfortunately Zhao Zilong was only a miscellaneous general throughout his life, and until his death, he had no name.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Zhao Yun is the general of the five tigers, and the five tiger generals are Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, Ma Chao, and Huang Zhong.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Zhao Yun is a general of the Five Tigers, loyal to the country, brave and resourceful, and is known as the image of a victorious general, which has been widely spread in later generations.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    No, Zhao Yun is a general of the Five Tigers, but he is Liu Bei's guard commander, not a general in the strict sense.

Related questions
26 answers2024-05-26

There are no five tiger generals in history, only 4, range front, back, left, right, four generals, Zhao Yun is not among them, only Guan Yu (Yun Chang), Zhang Fei (Yide), Ma Chao (Meng Qi), Huang Zhong (Han Sheng), who can fight in the specific sleep, it is estimated that no one has the right answer, in terms of official position, Ma Chao is stronger than Zhao Yun. >>>More

15 answers2024-05-26

Changshan Zhao Zilong! The handsome guy with super strong force, how can he say that he is a woman?

27 answers2024-05-26

Zhao Yun belongs to a typical overlooked role, although he does not have the ability to be handsome, but he is still no problem as a general in charge on the battlefield. Zhao Yun served as the captain of Liu's guard all his life, so his status was still worse than that of other generals.

26 answers2024-05-26

Guan Yu's children all died, Zhang Fei's son died in battle, his daughter entered the palace, and Zhao Yun had two sons and one daughter. The female and Guan Ping became husband and wife, the second son Zhao Guangzhan died Ma Chao more children, three sons and one daughter, the eldest and the second were all sick and died very early, and the third Ma Cheng returned to the mountains and forests after the destruction of Shu Han. Huang Zhong is even more miserable, he has only one son, who died of illness at an early age and has no queen.

9 answers2024-05-26

Huang Zhongzi Hansheng, Nanyang people also. Jingzhou Mu Liu Biao thought that he was a Zhonglang general, and he guarded Changsha Youxian with his cousin. and Cao Gongke Jingzhou, pretending to be a general, still in office, under the command of Changsha Shou Han Xuan. >>>More