Science How to view the relationship between astrology and astronomy

Was mankind's understanding of everything in the universe correct from the beginning? Of course not, fortune-telling, worshipping all things as gods, all kinds of superstitious activities are full of human society, and human beings have made many attempts to find their own connection with the world, and of course most of them are wrong. It was not until the Greeks began to "explain nature with nature" that the germ of science was born.

Astrology and astronomy were not separated at the beginning, and most of the "ancient astronomers" as we know them were engaged in both astronomical research and soothsayers, serving as emperors and magnates. Astrology (constellation divination) has always been just a "wrong connection", the "constellations" on which it depends are only a random distribution of stars from the perspective of the earth, and their shapes and positions are constantly changing (astrology does not care about these), it links people's character with the image of the constellations, and the constellation images are purely artificial imagination and the division of ancient peoples, just as the boundaries of countries are full of historical changes and there is no "natural correctness", and the constellations of modern astronomy are only for the convenience of counting stars. <>

Astrology is actually no different from ancient astrology, and the association of human character (which is almost impossible to quantify) with a certain position in the zodiac is a foreign superstition to China, not much different from the fortune-telling of blind people in China. The mystery of personality lies in the fact that you can be described ambiguously, for example, you are humble (no one thinks you are arrogant), you are wronged by villains (no one thinks you have gained too much by giving too little), and you are <> that your efforts will be rewarded (no one does not want to have a good future).

The real universe, the solar system - the Milky Way - the universe, the earth and we are insignificant in the universe have been revealed to us, why should the universe take care of our character and destiny at all times? Will children born within 30 days of the same hospital share the same fate? Modern biology has revealed to us the mystery of the origin and evolution of life, are these gods of the universe of knowledge already written in the sky?

Do the chickens, ducks, pigs, and fish we eat also share the luck of these zodiac signs? <>

Constellation knowledge is actually a kind of culture, and constellation myths reflect the morality and ethics of ancient peoples, and the imagination of the world and human nature may be interpreted with the help of myths. However, if you have to associate with the constellations, and if you have to rely on superstition to gain a sense of security and self-confidence, you will inevitably be too unconfident in human intelligence, and it will be an insult to human culture and modern science.

In fact, you can use horoscope divination as ancient astronomy, after all, in the case of ancient science and technology is not developed, they can not make the most scientific explanation of the starry sky on their heads, so the unknown and mysterious universe on those stars are connected, into similar to the common creatures or objects in life, and then understand it as a kind of divination, it is very normal, perhaps in the eyes of ancient people, this is science.

Of course, in the eyes of modern science, this view is obviously no longer suitable for the present era, but it still has the meaning of existence, such as... Name the galaxy ...

Astrology can be called a kind of metaphysics, ancient.

Sometimes there will be one between metaphysics and science and numerology.

For example, there are some intersections between astrology and astronomy in science and technology, and early astronomy has gained some experience from these contents.

However, when people study science (astronomy), they will continue to explore and put forward some new ideas to overturn the old theories, which is a process of continuous improvement, and metaphysics has always been complacent about its own theories, unable to verify the real connection between things, so there has been no development, so the various disciplines of science have gradually parted ways with metaphysics, and there is no connection at present.

Astronomical constellations:

It is a number of regions that divide the natural distribution of stars in the sky, and each region is called a genus constellation. Bright stars in the same constellation are connected with lines to form various figures, and according to their shapes, they are similar to animals and utensils. There are nearly 6,000 stars visible to the naked eye, each of which can be assigned to a unique constellation, each of which can be identified by the shape of the bright star in it.

Zodiac Signs: The Ascendant and the Sun and Moon are the three types of zodiac signs that are often mentioned, among which the Sun sign is the most well-known. The orbit of the sun is called the ecliptic, which divides the ecliptic into 12 zones, each of which is 30 degrees, and these 12 zones are what we call the sun constellation.

The relationship between the two is almost the same as a masterpiece and a fandom.。 One is the official scientific dun of the main palace, and the other zhi is the pseudo-science of non-scientific official recognition derived from **.

The word "constellation" in astronomy refers to "constellations", and the International Astronomical Union divides the sky into 88 official constellations, each with a specific constellation.

In astrology, the meaning of constellation is "sign", "mark", "symbol".

The constellations in astronomy contain astrological constellations and are based on the ancient Greek tradition constellations.

It doesn't matter much, astronomy divides the whole day into 88 constellations, and the constellations in astrology generally refer to the 12 constellations in the zodiac, and the constellation from which sign the sun is in to divinate the horoscope, so in terms of scope, the constellations of astronomy should include the constellations of divination astrology.

In ancient times, astronomy and astrology were actually indiscriminate, and people carried out divination by observing the image and combining it with the person's character.

That is, a very superstitious behavior, astrological horoscopes are completely constructed, with a self-soothing component.

The constellations in astronomy are names given to them in order to distinguish different stars, and it is more convenient to count the stars.

Yes, in astronomy, there are more than 12 constellations. In astronomy, there are more than 12 constellations. In astronomy, the entire sky is divided into 88 constellations. This has been divided into 88 constellations. That's it.

There are 88 constellations in astronomy, and most of them have names from ancient Greece, ancient Roman mythology, and can even be traced.

Go back to ancient Egypt, ancient Babylon and Sumerian civilizations. Astrology has only 12 constellations, all of which are within the 88 constellations in astronomy. Because it is very close to the ecliptic plane of the earth, it can be observed in both the northern and southern hemispheres, and is called the "zodiac".

The constellations referred to in astronomy include the constellations of astrology.

These constellations don't know whether they are happy or not, this question is also what I have always wanted to know,

The constellations in astronomy are actually much more than astrology.

Like astrology, what we often know is.

There are 12 constellations inside. It's just that in Tianrong literature, there are more than 12 constellations. In astronomy, the entire sky is divided into 88 constellations. This is already much more than astrology.

It's just that the constellations in astrology can be found in astronomy. That is, astronomical constellations include astrology.

Astrology and astronomy have been inseparable since ancient times, and from a historical point of view, the relationship between the two can be said to be one family five hundred years ago.

Because the people who observed the celestial phenomena did it because of the need for astrology, some scientists later believed that astrology was a feudal superstition. Therefore, there was a difference between astronomy and astrology, but now astrology is still based on astronomical knowledge in order to know the position of the stars more accurately, and the data used is also accurately calculated.

Astrology and astronomy are closely related, astrology must rely on astronomical observations to calculate the position of the stars, and if you want to learn astrology, you must understand basic astronomical knowledge.

In the eyes of some people, planets and zodiac signs have some kind of relationship with people's personalities, fates, and even a few minutes apart when two people are born will be different. For others, there is no essential difference between astrology and fortune telling. However, the reality is:

The more educated students and white-collar workers, the more popular "astrology" becomes.

This collision of astronomical and astrological perspectives is not the first time in the history of science, and it will never be the last. Astronomer Zhu Jin has used the word "nonsense" many times, but it does not eliminate the doubts in people's minds. Over the past few decades, a series of new discoveries in psychology, physiology, medicine, and earth sciences have only opened up more possibilities, and these discoveries have also suggested that astronomy alone is far from sufficient to prove or falsify astrology.

In English, astrology has the same root word as astronomy. Astronomy can also be combined well with astrology – astronomy can count all the constellations in the sky at the time of a person's birth, as well as the positions of the sun, moon, and planets. Or rather, a person's astrolabe.

And the astrolabe is the beginning of astrology.

Astrology began around 2500 BC. At the heart of its assertion is the connection between the celestial bodies and the human being—in the context of Greek philosophy's two-hundred-year inquiry into the universe and the soul.

According to Aristotle's summary in The Treatise on the Soul, the question of the soul begins with the nature of the soul. At that time, it was believed that the reason why man is human and the soul is soul is because the soul can cause movement and move the body with its own movements. This is the starting principle.

The second principle can be called the principle of perception. Philosophers believe that the soul is able to perceive all things because there are elements in the soul that are identical to the natural elements.

The astrologer's belief in the existence of some kind of cosmic unity comes largely from Plato. Plato said in the Timaeus: "The heavenly bodies are visible, but the soul is not."

The soul is the embodiment of reason and harmony. The way it works is to silently follow its own movements, acting on everything with the same precision. ”

The most obvious question about astrology is: different people are divided into 12 zodiac signs, and there are 7 billion people in the world, are there so many people who are the same? In the eyes of professional astrologers, this question is raised because of a misunderstanding of astrology.

Horoscope is a category of 'news posture or science', not of astrology. "Horoscopes are like our entertainment news – gossip news has nothing to do with astrology. "Serious astrology uses the Sun, Moon, and planets, not just general constellations.

The point that astronomy has questioned the most is also related to horoscopes. Astrology uses 12 constellations located on the ecliptic, and there is a concept called "precession" in astrology, which is the periodic oscillation of the Earth's axis of rotation. Due to the existence of precession, the constellations on the zodiac are no longer 12 as thousands of years ago, but 13, and there is an extra ophiuchus.

How can we explain the fact that the zodiac signs are still used in astrology?

Astrology, an "ancient science", does have the form of science (note, it is not astrology that collects materials for astronomy, the two were together at that time and belonged to astrology, if you really subdivide it, it is still astronomy earlier, seasons, calendars, are all part of astronomy, astrology based on the five-star movement of the constellation calendar, you have to eat enough to play), but just as the countries named "democratic" are not necessarily democratic, the things crowned "science" and "logic" are not necessarily science.

Constellations and astronomy are still related to a certain extent, there must be causes and effects, Tianwangxue is a theory, and constellations can be described as derivatives.

I think astronomy is a science, and the other two are fascinating.

I don't think it's okay, after all, horoscope divination is too mysterious.

There doesn't seem to be any necessary connection between them, astronomy is science.

Constellation knowledge is actually a kind of culture, and the horoscope mythology reflects the ancient people's morality and ethics, and imagination of the world. Perhaps human nature can be interpreted with the help of mythology. However, if you have to associate with the constellations, and if you have to rely on superstition to gain a sense of security and self-confidence, you will inevitably be too unconfident in human intelligence, and it will be an insult to human culture and modern science.

It's a little bit related. Constellations are indeed a way of dividing the stars in the night sky in ancient astronomy. The constellation divination ** in the constellation chart, the ancients believed that the arrangement and combination of constellations had some mysterious power.

There are actually many more constellations in astronomy than in astrology.

Like astrology, what we often know is the 12 zodiac signs. It's just that in astronomy, there are more than 12 constellations. In astronomy, the entire sky is divided into 88 constellations. This is already much more than astrology.