Xiang Yu is a reckless man? What kind of person is the real Xiang Yu? Is it really a reckless man wi

Updated on history 2024-05-02
15 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    His character should be complex instead of extreme, it can be said that Xiang Yu is a miracle in itself, or a kind of performance art;

    Xiang Yu was ambitious as a young man, and his achievements can be said to be inversely proportional to his age, and Wujiang was only 30 years old when he killed himself; And Liu Bang is 24 years older than him;

    I don't think Xiang Yu is a woman; The Spring and Autumn Period and the Warring States Period was an era of a hundred schools of thought, especially focusing on faith and righteousness, Xiang Yu, who was born in the aristocracy, was more deeply affected, his grandfather Xiang Yan was a general of the Chu State, defeated the Qin army and died, and his hatred of Qin was connected with Xiang Yu's blood, which led to his later brutality towards the Qin people; But it is undeniable that he was very upright all his life, and like the literati and heroes of that era, he had high requirements for his own heart, such as "assassin spirit" and "friend of the neck"; Xiang Yu only used political means once in his life, on the eve of the Battle of Julu, in order to reverse the unfavorable situation of the rebels to destroy Qin, he had to kill Song Yi in the name of King Chu Huai, and won the supreme power of the army cleanly and beautifully; It can be seen that he is not ignorant of politics, but he is ashamed of using means;

    I think he must have felt quite emotional when he entered Xianyang Palace, the invincible tiger and wolf army that he was invincible in the past, the myth of the Qin army that swallowed the Six Kingdoms in one fell swoop, and the first emperor who looked down on the world for a lifetime, but now he was trampled under his feet. At this time, Xiang Yu was 26 years old and began his career as the "Overlord of Western Chu";

    Perhaps from this time on, Xiang Yu gradually became a lonely high-ranking person who was thrown into a lonely high by his own genius, excessive conceit and even the expansion of self-consciousness, but ignored the subtlety of the changing times; His later failures were manifested in the unclear nature of his political purpose; Gradually, militarily the active to the passive step by step began with the Battle of Pengcheng; It can be said that the miracle of victory in the Battle of Pengcheng did not bring Xiang Yu help in the current situation, but fueled his original conceit; Later, he had a strong sense of repentance for the war, which showed that his mind was gradually maturing, but it was not the right time to mature, and he subconsciously became ashamed of using troops (the situation of the Chu-Han dispute, I felt that Xiang Yu had missed a lot of opportunities, which was very different from his military talent when he destroyed Qin); His conceit and loneliness, his wishful thinking, eventually led to the final defeat; He did not lose to Liu Bang, but to himself;

    Only genius will achieve a ridiculous goal in a self-destructive way, and perhaps this is the art of one's destruction.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    He is not a reckless man, just a soldier, and he has no blood at all.

    In the battle of Qixia, he abandoned all the 100,000 troops, and pulled 800 people to escape with him.

    If a soldier is bloody, he should live and die with the soldier.

    He is not a flesh-and-blood general, he is a stubborn, face-saving, brave and unscrupulous, brutal person, a damned person, fortunately there is Liu Bang, otherwise I believe that Xiang Yu will become a sinner through the ages, thanks to Comrade Sima Qian's writing, after he was insulted (palace punishment), he devoted himself to writing Xiang Yu eloquently and eloquently, and wrote him as a powerful person. This Xiang Yu is not worthy of our respect, if Liu Bang is not unified, we will return to the Spring and Autumn Period and the Warring States Period. It was Liu Bang who reunified the world, the emperor, and a series of systems, so that the world could be unified.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    People who say that he is a reckless man do not know how to pretend to understand, and people who are like clouds, and those who have read the historical records will not think so.

    There is some truth in saying that he is stubborn, a woman's kindness, and cruel.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    To say that a reckless man is indeed a little, but his brain is also good, and the historical records record that he is indeed a reckless man.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Victory is the king, defeat is the villain, history is written by people.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    The real Xiang Yu is a powerful and resourceful person. He still has a lot of wisdom. It is precisely because of this that Sima Qian wrote him in the historical records.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Xiang Yu is heroic, very charismatic, and good at commanding troops, at that time, the battle of Pengcheng, with less to win more, the battle of Julu, the cauldron and the ship, are very wise.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Xiang Yu became the co-owner of the world at a young age, and the shortcomings he showed were because his career was too smooth and there was no inevitable result of setbacks. Imagine if Xiang Yu is a little older and has a more mature mentality, then can he have a better vision in strategy.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Xiang Yu does love soldiers, he really treats those soldiers as brothers, but he has hatred in his heart, his Xiang clan was killed in battle because of the first emperor Qin general, and he began to flee and flee at the age of nine, and the Xiang family was scattered overnight, so he hated the Qin people to the core, so he was also bloodthirsty and cruel.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Support the second floor. There is more than one hand, and the emperor's material is insufficient. At first, it must be like a soldier, but people will change.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    is a soldier who loves his own life.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    It's not a reckless man, he is a typical representative of the brave fighting faction, a practical military strategist, many people say that he is just a horseman, this is very one-sided, Xiang Yu's tragic ending stems from his character, the landlord thinks that the reckless man can fight the battle of the giant deer and the battle of Pengcheng such a classic battle of winning more with less? The answer is definitely impossible, because he is a very powerful military strategist, but his personality drives him to not achieve great dreams.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    No, he values love and righteousness and disdains calculations, but this is also a shortcoming, and he is destined to lose to Liu Bang.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    The sadness of history, now many ignorant people like Xiang Yu very much.

    Except for his fighting skills, Xiang Yu really couldn't find anything commendable in other aspects. This person is too selfish, except for the previous one, except for shortcomings or shortcomings.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    He is both a hero and a reckless man.

Related questions
9 answers2024-05-02

First of all, it should be stated that the death of Qin Shi Huang was in 210 BC, when even Liu Bang and Xiang Yu had not yet raised troops, and the second year after the death of Qin Shi Huang, the famous Chen Sheng and Wu Guang uprisings broke out. Then there was Chu Xiang Yan who raised troops against Qin. Therefore, Liu Bang and Xiang Yu did not fight with Qin Shi Huang. >>>More

13 answers2024-05-02

There are many reasons for this, and there are many reasons for his failure. >>>More

6 answers2024-05-02

In fact, Liu Bang took advantage of Xiang Yu's army to quell the rebellion of Qi in the east, and the rear was empty, so he had an opportunity to kill all the way. And basically, Xiang Yu at that time was equivalent to one as a hundred.

22 answers2024-05-02

Xiang Yu is a famous god of war in ancient times, and he is also a great hero that many people admire very much, and there have been many people who have portrayed the role of Xiang Yu, but my favorite Xiang Yu should be Xiang Yu played by Tan Kai in "Mythology". <> >>>More

40 answers2024-05-02

Personally, I think it shouldn't be beaten, I feel that Xiang Yu should be more powerful, however, the two of them have not been compared on the same stage, who knows who wins and who loses. Personally, the reason why I think Xiang Yu will be more powerful is because I have a good impression of Xiang Yu more than I have a good impression of Zhang FeiThat's why I think so, in terms of force value, it shouldn't be worse than **, after all, Zhang Fei is also one of the famous generals of the Three Kingdoms. >>>More