Why is the fault of the lost street pavilion in Ma Tan, and why is Ma Jian lost the street pavilion?

There are many mistakes, such as Zhuge Liang's mistake in material selection, Ma Tan's intelligence is outstanding, but he has no talent.

But the main reason for this is mainly because Ma Jian is conformist, only knowing the place of death and then living, not knowing the place of death.

It is easier to die, and the key depends on whether the opponent is brave and unscrupulous, or proficient in change.

He himself thought that he was familiar with military books, and he didn't listen to Wang Ping's words and stationed the army on the mountain Zhuge Liang had ordered Wang Ping to set up a village along the road He didn't listen to you and said that he would not die.

In fact, it should be Zhuge Liang's responsibility! Improper employment.

Opinionated. Bent.

Complacency.

Liu Bei said in the White Emperor City: Words are exaggerated and cannot be used.

Ma Tan lost the street pavilion and committed an unforgivable capital crime, Zhuge Liang had no choice but to act in accordance with the law and slash Ma Tan with tears. There are two real reasons why Ma Tan lost the street pavilion, the first reason is that Ma Tan is on paper, talented, and too arrogant, and the second reason is that Ma Tan is eager to prove himself and make meritorious contributions; The third reason is that the opponent Zhang He is very strong.

1. Ma Tan talks on paper, is talented, and is too arrogant.

Ma Yan, who is very talented, did not take Zhuge Liang's orders and advice to heart, and felt that Zhuge Liang usually had to ask his opinions on military affairs, so if he listened to Zhuge Liang's words, it would not seem that he had no ability, so he would definitely want to do another set of plays.

2. Ma Tan is eager to prove himself and make contributions, and he is eager to make contributions.

Ma Tan had never led troops alone before this, and he followed Zhuge Liang to make suggestions as a member of the army. Now is the time for me to lead my troops to fight, and it is also the time for me to raise my eyebrows and raise my eyebrows in the army neutrality, and I want to prove that I don't just talk about it on paper.

Another is that at that time, the three counties of Nan'an, Tianshui and Anding all surrendered to Shu, at this time, if you hold the street pavilion, then Zhuge Liang can lead the troops to take Chang'an, it can be said that he won the entire Wei State, this is the first class of merit, no one will let go of such a good opportunity to make contributions. So Yuandan is thinking only about proving himself and taking credit, and his mind is not on strategy.

3. The opponent Zhang He is very strong.

Zhang He has experienced a hundred battles, not only can he be on par with Zhang Fei, but also very strategic, even Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang are afraid of him, so it is not surprising that Ma Tan was defeated under Zhang He's hands.

The story of Ma Tan's lost street pavilion

Ma Tan lost the street pavilion is about Zhuge Liang led the army to the Northern Expedition, when attacking Qishan, everyone suggested that Zhuge Liang use the old generals Wei Yan and Wu Yi, Zhuge Liang did not listen, and reused Ma Tan. When attacking the military stronghold of Jieting, Ma Tan did not accept Zhuge Liang's suggestion, insisted on going his own way, did not occupy the town, but occupied Nanshan, and finally, due to the problem of drinking water, lost the military important place of Jieting. Ma Tan and his subordinates were finally executed.

After Zhuge Liang lost the street pavilion, the road of the Northern Expedition was repeatedly unsmooth, and finally ended in failure. Later, Shu Han also carried out many northern expeditions, but they were unsuccessful, which greatly damaged the vitality of the Shu Han army. After Liu Bei requisitioned Sun Quan, he also fell ill and died of hail and repented, Liu Bei's son became the emperor, and the later ending was just like what he read in "The Teacher's Table", Shu Han was lonely.

In the sixth year of Jianxing (228), Zhuge Liang sent troops to Qishan to the north to attack Wei. Zhuge Liang ordered Zhao Yun and Deng Zhi to occupy Jigu (present-day Hanzhongbei, Shaanxi) as suspicious troops, and personally led an army of 100,000 to raid Qishan (present-day Gansu), which was guarded by the Wei army.

When Emperor Cao of Wei Ming learned that Shu Han was coming, he sent his general, Governor Zhang, to block Ma Jian at Jieting (now northeast of Qin'an, Gansu). Because Ma Tan violated Zhuge Liang's operational deployment, abandoned the water source and stationed the troops on Nanshan, the division and dispatch of troops was chaotic.

Moreover, Ma Tan relied on the topography of Nanshan Mountain, and did not defend the city under the mountain. Zhang cut off Ma Tan's way to get water, launched an attack and defeated Ma Tan, Ma Tan's soldiers fled in defeat and scattered, and the street pavilion was lost.