Should Zhuge Liang behead Ma Jian Why

When chopping. Although the location of the street pavilion is important, it is easy to keep, as long as Ma Tan obeys Zhuge Liang's arrangement, it is easy to guard the street pavilion, otherwise Sima Yi will not be sad as soon as he hears that the street pavilion is guarded, and praises Zhuge Liang as a true god. Ma Tan usually has the best friendship with Zhuge Liang ("The prime minister regards a certain as a son, and a certain prime minister as his father" [Ma Tanyu] "I am the same brother as you, and your son is my son, so there is no need to ask more."

Zhuge Liang]), although he also gave advice for Zhuge Liang, but none of his exploits in the war, I think Zhuge Liang asked him to go to Shoujie Pavilion is also intended to cultivate him, but unfortunately Ma Tan is arrogant and arrogant, arrogant and conceited, and only made a little merit and did not know how thick the sky is, even Zhuge Liang does not put it in his eyes, he has to camp on the mountain, and he loses the road, which eventually leads to the loss of the street pavilion and the abandonment of his efforts before leaving Qi Mountain. In this case, Zhuge Liang no longer kills Ma Yan, why does Du Youyou talk heavily? If it weren't for Ma Tan, it was Zhao Yun or Wang Ping or other generals, Zhuge Liang might not behead, but Ma Tan, if he didn't behead, it wouldn't be enough to convince the public!

It should not be chopped. The current law also talks about human feelings, that is, the sentencing can be within a certain range. where the facts are unclear, the sentence is to be given as long as possible.

Victory and defeat are a common thing in soldiers. Ma Tan only fought a defeat, just when he was employing people, he killed a fierce general, although he could establish military prestige, but it could not be said that it was not a painful loss. Besides, Zhuge Liang knew that Ma Jian might make this mistake, so why did he send him?

Is it intentional homicide?

Speaking of Ma Yan, he can become a general, which shows that he is not a brave and unscrupulous person, he must have some ability, and he can learn a lesson this time, and he can also make achievements in future battles.

No, Zhuge Liang's way of doing things is to punish if he has a fault, but Cao Cao is just the opposite - as long as there is a skill, the elders can be used by me, so in the end, the Cao family won the world.

This problem has been solved for more than a thousand years, but no reason has been solved.

Personally, I think that although Ma is incompetent, he is finally in Shu.

It's better not to chop.

It should be beheaded, and if it is not beheaded, it will ignore military law

Prestige in the military will also decline.

For the sake of the future of the Shu army, this can only be done.

It should be, Ma Jian and Zhao Kuo belong to a type, talking about soldiers on paper, and have little practical value.

should be beheaded, otherwise sooner or later there will be mistakes, human nature, he can't change it.

Should. There was no joke in the army, and Ma Jian set up a military order.

It should be chopped, he lost the street pavilion. This is a landmark. How much damage it will cause in the army.

Everyone's so fast! I'm just going to learn something.

Should be chopped! And it should not be chopped! All make sense!

This is real, and it can be found in history books.

It really exists, and you can also see this fragment in the history books, and it can be seen that Zhuge Liang is also very reluctant, but he still did such a thing for the sake of the military.

It's real, because there are chapters like this in history.

It does not exist, such a statement is artistic processing, and his death is most likely to be suicide, after Ma Tan's death, Zhuge Liang did cry bitterly, and personally went to Ma Tan's home to pay respects.

According to historical records, this incident is real, because Ma Jian did not obey the arrangement of the military advisor, and in order to stabilize the army's morale, he could only kill him.

If it doesn't exist, although I want to order the beheading, but later I die of illness, so there is no such thing as beheading.

If you don't kill Ma Tan, you will break the Mu Hefa and lose credibility, and anyone can break the law in the future.

It is said that the Shu army has undergone several years of strict training by Zhuge Liang, with a neat lineup and brigade faction, strict orders, and very patient morale. And Ma Jian has indeed read a lot of military books, and he usually likes to talk about military affairs. Zhuge Liang came to him to discuss the war, and he talked endlessly, and he also came up with some good ideas.

Therefore, Zhuge Liang trusted him very much. But when Liu Bei was alive, he saw that Ma Jian was not very down-to-earth. He specially told Zhuge Liang before his death, saying:

Ma Yan's words are exaggerated, you can't send him to do big things, you have to take a good look at it. But Zhuge Liang didn't take these words to heart. This time, he sent Ma Jian as the vanguard and Wang Ping as the deputy general.

Ma Tan and Wang Ping led the men to the street pavilion, and Zhang's Wei army was also coming from the east.

The Shu army lost an important stronghold and lost a lot of men. In order to avoid suffering greater losses, Zhuge Liang decided to retreat all his men and horses to Hanzhong. Zhuge Liang returned to Hanzhong, and after detailed inquiry, he knew that the loss of Jieting was entirely due to Ma Tan's violation of his combat deployment.

Ma Tan also admitted his mistakes. Zhuge Liang put Ma Jian in prison and convicted him of a capital crime in accordance with military law.