If Xiang Yu didn t kill himself in Wujiang, would it be possible to make a comeback?

Failure is the mother of success. The things of the past life, the teacher of the future.

Impossible, don't you know that Liu Bang will definitely chase and kill Xiang Yu, how can he make a comeback.

It's hard to say, but I think it's unlikely. He is not as decisive as Liu Bang, and he is not ruthless enough when he should be "ruthless", it is difficult for such a person to win the world.

No way. The hearts of the people belong to Liu Bang, and Xiang Yu's failure is sooner or later!

It is impossible for Xiang Yu to cross the Wujiang River Even if he crosses the past and becomes a king, he will still fail. In a word, it is clear that Liu Bang is a politician, and Xiang Yu does not understand politics. If you want to elaborate, as a few people upstairs said, go and see Yi Zhongtian in "Hundred Lectures", Wang Liqun's Han Dynasty figures.

History is not an inch! Xiang Yu as a hero, is indisputable, but not as a leader, in terms of his life experience, Wujiang self-killing can be regarded as a complete end!

Xiang Yu is a waste, he can succeed, it all depends on his father, from the day his father died, Xiang Yu has no hope of victory!

Yes. If Xiang Yu can change his bad habits, he can reuse talented people. There are no absolutes.

Probably, listen to "Hundred Lectures".

Personally, I think Xiang Yu is too sentimental and a little too kind. How good it was to kill Liu Bang at the Hongmen banquet at that time! History cannot be repeated now, and it is useless to say anything.

Yes. You can take a look at Yi Zhongtian's "Han Dynasty Figures", which is very good.

At most, he can only dominate one side, and he will never be able to unify the whole country!

If he hadn't died, I think maybe history would have changed!

You can make a comeback. If Xiang Yu doesn't kill himself, he can go back to Jiangdong and start over.

I don't think it's possible for him to make a comeback, because he didn't have any confidence in himself after the defeat, and he felt sorry for the local people, so even if he didn't kill himself, he would be very decadent.

I don't think it's possible, because Xiang Yu is not a suitable person to be an emperor, and his character determines that he will definitely make certain choices for the sake of righteousness, so even if he doesn't choose to kill himself, he will not be so firm in the future.

There was no chance to do it again, because Xiang Yu had completely lost the opportunity to deal with Liu Bang at the Hongmen Banquet that year. There are certain differences between Xiang Yu and Liu Bang in terms of wisdom, and their backgrounds are also different, so on the whole, even if Xiang Yu does not kill himself in Wujiang, I am afraid it will be difficult to make a comeback. The details are as follows:

First of all, let's talk about the origin of Liu Bang and Xiang Yu, Liu Bang is an ordinary person, and even a person who will do anything to succeed. He grew up in the people, which is both an advantage and a disadvantage. Because the advantage is that he can know what the people are thinking, in today's words, he is down-to-earth.

Therefore, after achieving success in the future, I know how to win people's hearts and stand on the side of the people. The people of the world are one family, which is the biggest advantage of Liu Bang's success at that time.

Xiang Yu is different, Xiang Yu has a concept that he cares about the "Jiangdong fathers". For the people in other regions, for Xiang Yu, they are not their own people. So at this point, Liu Bang is different from him.

Although Liu Bang also calls himself Pei Gong, he has done relatively little to the people in other regions.

In addition to his own stubbornness, Xiang Yu's failure was also due to his arrogance, which was unpopular. Xiang Yu's background is higher than Liu Bang, and he looks down on Liu Bang in his eyes. So in some things, Liu Bang can do it, but Xiang Yu can't do it.

For example, Liu Bang can put down his son when he is alive and dead, but Xiang Yu can't, so Xiang Yu is doomed to failure.

Xiang Yu had an advantage, and Xiang Yu's reputation was still relatively high at that time, and he was still strong. But such a powerful Xiang Yu, being defeated by Liu Bang in the end is really something worth reflecting on.

In current terms, Xiang Yu did not attach importance to Liu Bang tactically and strategically. Liu Bang's strongest ability is to survive, if you can fight, you can fight, if you can't beat me, you can give in, whatever you want, as long as I live!

In fact, this is Liu Bang's strategy, showing weakness to survive. If Xiang Yu is like Liu Bang, maybe he can become a generation of emperors, but he will not make people feel sorry for him as much as he is today, and he is even willing to talk about him.

Xiang Yu's failure is doomed, because he has received that decent education since he was a child, and he can't let go of many things. A leader of the army talks about affection, meaning, and chivalry, and it is useless when the two armies face each other!

Therefore, Xiang Yu is not Wujiang himself, and it is difficult to have a chance to make a comeback.

I don't think there will be such an opportunity. Because Xiang Yu has completely lost the opportunity in the Hongmen banquet. And I believe that if there is an opportunity, Xiang Yu will not choose to commit suicide.

I don't think there's a chance. First, Xiang Yu is thirsty for killing, and every time he attacks a city, he will slaughter a city, which has lost the hearts of the people, and those who have won the hearts of the people since ancient times have won the world. The second is that there is no Han Xin who has a plan, and he has only won once against Han Xin.

If there is a chance, with Xiang Yu's military talent and personal charm, he will definitely regroup and recruit a stronger army after returning to Jiangdong, and Xiang Yu will also be more stable and will definitely make a comeback.

I don't think there is much chance, at that time Liu Bang's victory was already the trend of the times, and the repetition was just a send-off.

OK. Because Xiang Yu is an emperor's talent and has strong ability, if Xiang Yu does not kill himself, he will definitely be able to make a comeback when he returns to Jiangdong.

No, because Xiang Yu is indecisive, and there are not many soldiers around him, on the other hand, Liu Bang has a lot of strange people.

Personally, I don't think so, first of all, he is too conceited, he despises Liu Bang, and he may only be depressed when he returns to Jiangdong.