If Xiang Yu had crossed the Wujiang River back then, would he still be able to rise in the mountains

No way. There are several main reasons:

1. There is no talent, and he has no ability to discover talents and use talents. For example, he had Ji Bu and Zhong Liwu and others under him, but the first time he was fighting, he only saw him performing, and he didn't see what these people were doing. Ji Bu's real fame became big after he mixed with Liu Bang after Xiang Yu's death.

Also, why Chen Ping, Han Xin and others left him was because they felt that they would not meet Xiang Yu.

2. He has no political vision. After coming to Xianyang, the capital of Qin, he first slaughtered the city and then set it on fire. I couldn't see the social form at that time, and I was divided.

The end of the Qin Dynasty was not the beginning of the Zhou Dynasty, and the feudal system had been proven to be unsuitable for social development as early as the Warring States Period. The princes have all discussed this, but unfortunately he does not understand. When dividing the seal, it is not fair, and it buries the roots of the goods.

Liu Bang entered the Mid-Autumn Festival without committing any crimes, and he won the hearts of the people in Guanzhong in three chapters. What the two did was a world apart.

3. No strategic vision. When dividing the seal, leave the good place to others, and go to break Pengcheng to be the king yourself. Liu Bang was different, he returned to Guanzhong soon after he arrived in Hanzhong, and used Guanzhong as his base, which was also the material basis for defeating Xiang Yu.

Xiang Yu is basically a typical rogue's tactics, and if he doesn't rob for three days, he won't eat or drink, so he can't make a big deal.

4. Love money, stinginess, and the kindness of a woman and suspicion.

Okay. Because he still has many people in Jiangdong who support him, and even if Han Xin chases across the river, his combat strength is greatly reduced due to the fatigue of boats and cars, and the soldiers in Jiangdong are enough to deal with it.

has the ability to make a comeback, and because of absorbing this experience, he no longer takes Liu Bang lightly, and he will definitely be able to make a comeback.

War is fraught with variables"games"

1.The land of Western Chu is not only Jiangsu, but also has a considerable number of elite soldiers with strong combat effectiveness.

2.It's not that Xiang Yu can't beat Liu Bang, it's that Han Xin under Liu Bang is more difficult to deal with, and the 300,000 elite soldiers under him are the biggest trouble in Xichu, if the discord plan can succeed, it's hard to say.

3.War not only depends on the wisdom of the generals, but also on the grain and grass, the army, and the people's hearts are also very important, but in Xichu, the people's hearts are thinking about Xiang Yu.

4.Not all of Xiang Yu's allies were lost, and Lu followed Xiang Yu all the time.

5.Most of Xiang Yu's soldiers are still very loyal and brave (as evidenced by the quick battle in Dongcheng)6Xiang Yu has won many battles against Liu Bang, as long as he changes his nature and treats the soldiers and the people well, I believe that with his ability, he can turn defeat into victory.

So it's possible to make a comeback.

No, even if he crosses the river, Han Xin will cross the river and send troops, no matter how high Xiang Yu's ability is, he can't resist it.

No! Liu Bang has already occupied an absolute advantage, there are more soldiers than the overlord, more food than the overlord, more talents than the overlord, and the people's hearts are also towards him, plus Liu Bang himself is more like a person who can achieve great things than the overlord!

The overlord will be defeated! Let's be honest"The kindness of a woman"Xiang Yu is doomed to perish in the troubled times where whoever is thicker and who wins the world is doomed, even if he defeats Liu Bang, there will be thousands of Liu Bang who will come out to destroy him.

It's hard to say. Xiang Yu's general trend has gone, and it is difficult to make a comeback.

However, he still has appeal in the Chu State, and it is possible.

In fact, it is not difficult to see from Xiang Yu's stepping on the stage of history that he is too conceited. And such a person cannot tolerate his own failures, he is an overlord, and one person can defeat ten thousand. Even if Xiang Yu had the possibility of escaping at that time, he would not escape with his personality.

With the character of the people before the Han Dynasty, he was able to cross the Wujiang River, and he could only save his reputation, so he was most likely to commit suicide. "Speechless in the face of Jiangdong's father".It can be seen.

It's hard to say whether he can make a comeback, but at least he can save his life, as long as there is life, what do you say is impossible? However, from a historical point of view, if Xiang Yu had not died, there would have been no (or delayed for many years) the later Han Dynasty, and China's influence on the world would have been much smaller.

No, heroes are created by the times, at that time, the world was decided, everyone hated war, if you can live a good life, who is willing to die for him???

Xiang Yu has no chance.

On wisdom There is no one under Xiang Yu who can compare to Han Xin, and he is not an opponent even if he adds a piece.

On martial arts There are not many soldiers of the Xiang family, and they can't form a strong combat power, not to mention that Han Xin is a god-level general who will take the rabble and win the victory, and the overlord is just turning ninety-nine coffins with one as a hundred.

What's more, the hearts of others have been lost, and the economy is not strong, so what can they rely on?

No, because after the large-scale war at the end of the Qin Dynasty, people are at ease, those who win the hearts of the people win the world, and Liu Bang will not be stupid enough to let him develop his power again in Jiangdong and then go to a showdown with him. Relatively speaking, Liu Bang is a villain, and he will not tolerate it.

The times make heroes, heroes make the times, and there is no way to do it without the current heroes.

After the defeat of the overlord Xiang Yu, many people felt that it was a pity and felt that he should make a comeback after escaping. However, Xiang Yu did not do so. I think the reason why Xiang Yu didn't choose to run away but killed himself has something to do with his character, and he feels that running away will make others look down on him.

First, Xiang Yu is not a person who can bend and stretch, and he doesn't want to steal his life after defeat. When Xiang Yu was defeated, he walked to the river, and a pavilion chief parked the boat on the shore, and he told Xiang Yu to let him escape by boat quickly, and he could make a comeback in the future. But Xiang Yu smiled and said that he was going to heaven to destroy him, what else was he doing crossing the river?

Besides, he and 8,000 people from Jiangdong crossed the Jiangxi expedition, and now he is the only one who comes back, even if he goes back to Jiangdong, even if Jiangdong's father and brother want him to continue to be the king, but he has no face to meet them, he will feel guilty.

From Xiang Yu's words, it can be seen that Xiang Yu is a person who regards affection as more important, and he feels that he has brought so many people out, but many of them have died in battle. If he is the only one who runs away and goes back, others will despise him, and he will not be happy in his own heart.

Second, Xiang Yu felt that it was not interesting to live after defeat, he didn't want to live. I think Xiang Yu also understood the situation at that time, he knew that he was defeated, and he knew that the enemy's strength was very strong. He knew that even if he fled back to Jiangdong, there would be no way to make a comeback.

On the other hand, the reason why Xiang Yu didn't run away was that he had nothing to love。The person he loved most before his death was Yu Meiren, but in order to keep Xiang Yu from worrying about each other, Yu Meiren had already died. If Xiang Yu couldn't find hope for life at this time, he felt that without Yu Meiren by his side, he would be lonely in the world, so he simply gave up his life and chose to kill himself.

Why do you think Xiang Yu chose to kill himself?

Impossible, because Xiang Yu is a very strong person, he can't withstand a failure, even if he returns to Jiangdong, he will lose his fighting spirit.

Yes. The people of Jiangdong are very supportive of Xiang Yu, and Xiang Yu's ability to lead troops to fight is already very strong.

I think if Xiang Yu returns to Jiangdong, he can make a comeback. Because Jiangdong is his base, he has deep roots here, and there is also the Yangtze River as a moat. He can rest and recuperate well in Jiangdong, and wait until the army is strong and strong in Dongshan to make a comeback.

Dongshan has a great chance of making a comeback, first of all, the Jiangdong area is Xiang Yu's chassis and there is no need to assemble the younger brother, Jiangdong also has at least 200,000 horses, do you think Xiang Yu has the courage to be strategic? Hehe, Xiang Yu has a record of more than 70 games in his life, only losing the last one, and the rest are all winning more with less. Another point, before the battle of Qixia, Han Xin forced Liu Bang to crown him as the king of Qi, and Han Xin's death was sooner or later.

Moreover, Han Xin may return to Qi State and mercenaries will be self-reliant. With Xiang Yu and Liu Bang who returned to Jiangdong, there will be a situation where the Three Kingdoms are in power.

First of all, Xiang Yu's personality is relatively arrogant, and he rarely listens to other people's opinions, and what he says is the truth. Secondly, he fell from the original overlord of the Central Plains to the current point, which is very difficult to accept from a psychological point of view, and he can't get over it with any face. There are many reasons why Xiang Yu finally killed himself in Wujiang, and he didn't want to make a living, but Xiang Yu's military talent should be affirmed by our descendants.

King Xiang smiled and said: "I am dead in the sky, how can I do it!" And with 8,000 people from Jiangdong crossing the river to the west, no one has returned today, and the father and brother of Jiangdong have mercy on me, how can I see it? Even if he doesn't say anything, he is worthy of his heart? ”

I think there are personal reasons for this, and there are also practical reasons, Xiang Yu is too arrogant, does not listen to advice, and acts arbitrarily, one of them; Second, none of the 8,000 children in Jiangdong have returned today! He has no shame to face the Jiangdong fathers and fellow villagers! Third, he vowed to destroy Qin Xingchu, and now although Qin is destroyed, Han is alive, and he divides the world into two worlds, but they attack each other, and now he is defeated by Wujiang, and he has no face to face the ancestors and ancestors, only one death.

Third, the defeat of Wujiang, its strength is no longer enough to fight against the Han, he should have seen that the general trend has gone, so he didn't want to see the Han blood wash Jiangdong, so he had to kill himself.