Schools are fines right, are school fines legal

Of course it's unreasonable, you can hit your education department **! Or your student council can organize a strike! I think when I was in high school, the school tuition was too much, and we all went on strike, and we ended up paying more than 200 less!

Money, money, money. When did the current society become like this, but if you want to change. One is to report to the superiors, and the other is to inform the reporter, but anonymously. The school may have a good starting point, but it is too profitable, and it is a great harm to the students' body and mind!

It's not reasonable, you should report it to the Education Bureau.

If it is unreasonable, you can find the local education bureau and newspaper.

When you become a teacher, you don't have to complain.

When you grow up, you can understand that the world is very helpless. Just like in the hospital, if you can't pay the hospitalization fee, you can only wait for death.

Study hard, kid! I hope you can be the Minister of Education.

Sue it ygotta hate this kind of school the most.

The collection of fines and fines by school teachers is illegal and falls within the scope of abuse of power. Legally speaking, schools are public institutions and not law enforcement agencies, and the state does not give schools the right to impose fines. Only state administrative organs and organizations authorized to manage public affairs have the qualifications of administrative subjects and have the power to impose administrative punishments.

The school is a public institution and does not have the qualifications of an administrative entity, and of course it has no power to impose administrative penalties, including the right to impose fines on students. Fines are stipulated in the criminal law, and only the courts are qualified to exercise this judicial punishment power for the economic punishment of the offender, and no other organ, group, enterprise or institution has the right to exercise it, otherwise it is a violation of the law.

Legal Analysis: School fines are illegal. Fines are applied by the organ or unit with the power of administrative punishment in accordance with relevant laws and regulations, and the school has no right to fine students and teachers, and the school may issue a warning to the person who violates discipline, expelling the student and other sanctions, but cannot impose a fine.

Schools must not collect fees in violation of state regulations, and must not seek benefits by selling or covertly selling goods or services to students.

Legal basis: Article 29 of the Education Law of the People's Republic of China Schools and other educational institutions exercise the following rights:

1) Self-management in accordance with the charter;

2) Organize and implement educational and teaching activities;

3) Recruiting students or other persons receiving education;

4) Conduct student status management for the educated, and implement rewards or sanctions;

5) Issuing corresponding academic certificates to the recipients;

6) Hiring teachers and other staff, and implementing rewards or sanctions;

7) To manage and use the facilities and funds of the unit;

8) Refuse any illegal interference in education and teaching activities by any organization or individual;

9) Other rights provided for by laws and regulations.

The State protects the lawful rights and interests of schools and other educational institutions from being infringed upon.

Illegal. Regardless of whether the fines are useful or not, and whether the purpose of the fines is regulated or not, schools do not have the right to fine students, and the system of fines should be stopped in all schools throughout the country.

1. It is an illegal act to fine a student. The Education Law stipulates that schools and other educational institutions shall fulfill the obligation to "safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of the educated, teachers and other employees". The legitimate rights and interests of students include students' property rights, and the acts of schools and teachers that infringe on students' property rights mainly include damage to students' property, confiscation of students' property, arbitrary fines, arbitrary fees, etc.

More importantly, "fine" is a kind of administrative punishment measure, and the "Administrative Punishment Law" stipulates that only normative documents above departmental rules have the right to establish, and if there is no statutory basis or legal procedures are not complied with, the administrative punishment is invalid. In the absence of clear provisions in laws, regulations or rules, the school does not have the right to impose fines and other provisions on its own.

2. Fines on students are also not in line with the scientific principles of education. The Ministry of Education promulgated the "Regulations on the Work of Primary and Secondary School Class Teachers", which stipulates that "class teachers have the right to criticize and educate students in appropriate ways."

However, punishment education is not free from norms, and the scientific spirit of education should be followed.

At the same time, according to the Regulations on the Management of Students in Ordinary Institutions of Higher Education promulgated by the Ministry of Education, "schools shall give criticism, education or disciplinary punishment to students who have violated the law, rules and regulations, or discipline." The disciplinary sanctions given to students by schools shall be commensurate with the nature of the student's violation, violation, or disciplinary conduct and the severity of the offense. ”

There is a school governed by law.

Schools and teachers have the right to strengthen teaching management and rectify teaching order, but when carrying out this work, they need to adopt correct methods and act in accordance with the law, they should strengthen criticism and education of students, and individual students who refuse to change their ways may also be disciplined, but they cannot arbitrarily impose administrative punishments on students.

Schools and teachers shall exercise their rights in accordance with the law. When formulating any rules and regulations and management measures, they should be based on relevant laws and regulations, and should "govern the school in accordance with the law" rather than "governing the school in violation of the law".

Legal Analysis: Schools cannot fine students. Schools and their educational institutions are required to fulfill the following obligations:

1. Comply with laws and regulations;

2. Implement the national education policy, implement the national education and teaching standards, and ensure the quality of education and teaching;

3. Safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of the educated, teachers and employees;

4. Provide convenience for the educated and their guardians to understand the academic performance and relevant information of the educated persons in an appropriate manner;

5. Collect fees in accordance with relevant national regulations and disclose the charging items;

6. Accept supervision in accordance with the law.

Legal basis: Article 29 of the Education Law of the People's Republic of China Schools and other educational institutions exercise the following rights:

1) Self-management in accordance with the charter;

2) Organize and implement educational and teaching activities;

3) Recruiting students or other persons receiving education;

4) Conduct student status management for the educated, and implement rewards or sanctions;

5) Issuing corresponding academic certificates to the recipients;

6) Hiring teachers and other staff, and implementing rewards or sanctions;

7) To manage and use the facilities and funds of the unit;

8) Refuse any illegal interference in education and teaching activities by any organization or individual;

9) Other rights provided for by laws and regulations.

The State protects the lawful rights and interests of schools and other educational institutions from being infringed upon.