Is Song Jiang in Water Margin a hero?

Song Jiang deceived the world and stole his name. He's not a hero!

Song Jiang's nicknames are Timely Rain, Hu Baoyi, and Xiaoyi Hei Saburo; In the Water Margin world, people's unanimous evaluation of him is: helping others for pleasure, dispersing wealth, being loyal to the liver, brave, and filial. Therefore, everywhere Song Jiang went, the heroes worshipped him, and later became the master of Liangshan.

But compared with these three heroes, you will find the true face of Song Jiang.

Song Jiang squandered money for fame and fortune.

In Yuncheng County, Song Jiang is a well-known philanthropist. He helped Tang Niu'er, the king of medicine, the mother and daughter of the Yin family, and all the people in difficulty around him. But can Song Jiang's salary support him to be so generous?

It is clear that he had a lot of "extra" income when he was Minister of Justice. To do a good job with this money is to buy yourself a good name.

Moreover, Song Jiang is the most profitable to buy people's hearts: he went to Chaijia Village to give money, and all the villains didn't like him; He went to Huarong Village to give money, and all the servants didn't like him; When he went to Jiangzhou to join the army and donate money, all the people in charge of the camp did not like him.

Especially when he met a hero, Song Jiang never let go. When he first met Li Kui, he gave Li Kui ten taels of silver to gamble; saw Xue Yong, who was making guns and sticks and selling gypsum, so he rewarded him with five taels of silver; When he saw Wu Song say goodbye, he gave him ten taels of silver, which made Wu Song cry. It's a real win.

Let's take a look at Lu Zhishen: In order to save Kim's father and daughter, he punched and kicked Edison Zheng; He helped Liu Taigong fight the little overlord; In order to save monks and women in distress, he fought at Watang Monastery; In order to save Lin Chong, he made a big show in the wild boar forest; In order to save Shi Jin, he was trapped in prison. Each time, he goes out of his way to help others.

Lu Zhishen is serious.

Song Jiang was very cold to his brother.

After Song Jiang ascended the mountain, Zhao Gai gradually rose. After several battles in Liangshan, Song Jiang ordered Zhao Gai to stay and lead his troops to contribute. Moreover, Song Jiang collected all the way, and most of the leaders in Liangshan listened to him. Although he claims that he does not want to be the leader of the cottage, his actions expose his ambitions.

Song Jiang's fame and achievements completely surpassed Zhao Gai's. This made Zhao Gai very uncomfortable, and he couldn't help but fight, and finally died in Zengtou City.

After the conscription, Song Jiang led his brothers to defeat Fang La, and became very indifferent to his former brothers.

Song Jiang's filial piety is suspected of showing off.

On the way to Liangshang, after hearing the news of his father's death, Song Jiang cried to death, which deeply touched many people. After entering Liangshan, Song Jiang planned to pick up his father by himself.

Zhao Gai said: "If there is a mistake in the way of Brother De, no one can save it. Song Jiang said: "If you are a father, you will die without complaint." ”

When disaster strikes during the trip:

Song Jiang walked away, thinking to himself: "If you don't listen to Zhao Gai's words, there will be a disaster today." The emperor was pitiful, but only when he fell saved Song Jiang. ”

I forgot about my father.

If you look at Li Kui's idea of picking up his mother on the mountain, chatting with her, carrying her on the road, and killing the tiger to avenge his mother, it is somewhat moving. Stronger than Song Jiang.

To sum up, although Song Jiang is extraordinary, his heroic reputation is nothing more than his own meticulous creation.

It depends on your position, if you are on the right, Song Jiang will be counted, after all, he is willing to recruit peace in order to maintain the unity of a country. If it's a left-leaning stance, it doesn't count, so why not continue to overturn the old era and create a new era with a difference?

Song Jiang is the smallest person, and he will only buy people's hearts. I wanted to serve the court, but I didn't meet the situation at that time.

Lu Junyi should be the owner of the village.

Count, if not, can it be ranked?

Later generations passed on to the Water MarginSong JiangThere are great differences in the evaluation, the pants are mixed, some people think that Song Jiang is a hero, and some people think that he is a selfish villain.

Some people think that Zhao'an killed one hundred and eight generals, and some people think that Song Jiang wanted to live a good life before recruiting An, but they didn't think that after Song Jiang recruited An, he didn't live a good life, and kept leading troops to fight, often winning, which was also doing his "loyalty" for the imperial court. God imitates Song Jiang and is still a person who has "righteousness" towards his friends. He is a member of the imperial court, and he can know Chao Gai.

After committing a crime, he immediately went to report the news, and he also took responsibility to let Chao Gai go, which saved him.

Song Jiang was a combination of a half-peasant and half-official landlord class and feudal intellectuals. Filial piety, he is modest, he is righteous, he has outstanding military talents, he is full of ambitions, but it is difficult for him to jump out of the strange circle of the times. A touch of loess on the Tate'er Depression is his tragedy, the author's tragedy, and the tragedy of society.

"Water Margin" Song Jiang Introduction:

Song Jiang, people call "timely rain."

Earlier, it was Yuncheng County, Shandong.

Oshi, dancing and writing all day long, writing documents, is a knife and pen clerk. Chao Gai and other seven heroes outwitted the birth gang and were arrested by the government, but fortunately Song Jiang informed them in advance. Chao Gai sent Liu Tang to send gold and letters to Song Jiang, Song Jiang's wife Yan Poxi found out that Song Jiang had fornicated with Liangshan, and took the opportunity to threaten him, Song Jiang killed Yan Poxi in anger and fled to Cangzhou.

Forced to go to Liangshan.

Later, Song Jiang became the leader of Liangshanbo. After being recruited, he was Song Huizong.

He was named Dr. Wude and Chuzhou.

The pacification envoy and the head of the soldiers and horses were finally Gao Yu.

Killed with poisoned wine.

The times create heroes From the perspective of the times, Shuntian protects the country, is loyal and brave, and from the perspective of social background, the traitor seeks glory and is a real villain.

I think it's a hero, we look at whether a person is a positive image, or we have to combine it with the social environment at the time, although Song Jiang has a lot of shortcomings and cowardice, but after being forced to go to Liangshan, what he did was beneficial to the people at that time, so from the perspective of the turbulent society at that time, he was a hero.

I don't think Song Jiang is a hero, I personally think that Song Jiang didn't do much, but because he lost the lives of many heroes in Liangshan, and Song Jiang is also more selfish.

No. Song Jiang in "Water Margin" is just a weak scholar who also likes to use means, so he can't be called a hero.

Song Jiang is the number one person in "Water Margin". He was originally a small official in Yuncheng County, Shandong, with a dark face, short stature, and a good way to make friends, and was nicknamed "Timely Rain".

Due to the incident of Chao Gai and other Huang Nigang robbery of the Birthday Gang, Song Jiang informed Chao Gai of the news of the pursuit by the official army. After Chao Gai and others went to Liangshan, they sent Liu Tang to send a letter and fifty taels of ** rewards. Unexpectedly, this letter fell into the hands of his concubine Yan Poxi.

Helpless, Song Jiang angrily killed Yan Po and was sent to Jiangzhou. However, he was sentenced to death for inscribed anti-poems in Xunyang Building. Fortunately, the heroes rescued him to Liangshan. Later, during the attack on Zengtou City, Chao Gai died of poisoned arrows, and he sat on the top spot.

Song Jiang—1124), the character Gongming, nicknamed Hu Baoyi, Timely Rain, Xiaoyi Hei Saburo, the protagonist of Shi Nai'an's classical masterpiece "Water Margin".

Originally the city and county of Yun (yùn) in Shandong Province, his eyebrows resembled that of a lying silkworm, his eyes resembled that of a danfeng, his lips were square, his stature was short, and his face was dark. Later, he was the leader of the Liangshan Rebel Army, and sat firmly in the first position of Liangshanbo among the one hundred and eight generals, and was the Tiankui Star at the head of the thirty-six Tiangang (gāng) stars. Because of the private release of Chao Gai and others, he fled overnight after killing Yan Poxi.

During this period, he made friends with many heroes and heroes, and went to Liangshan after many twists and turns. and accepted the book of heaven presented by the Nine Heavens Xuannu, and then led the troops to recruit Zhujiazhuang and Gaotang Prefecture. After Chao Gai's death, he succeeded as the third lord of Liangshan.

Accepting the recruitment of the imperial court, in order to serve the country, he successively went to Liao, Tianhu, Wang Qing, Fang La, etc., repeatedly made military exploits, and was named the doctor of martial arts, and the pacification envoy of Chuzhou and the head of the soldiers and horses. At the end of this book, the imperial court built a temple, because it is very effective, and has been worshiped by the local people for generations.

It's just a bandit leader. There are basically few good people in Liangshan, and they usually have no proper income in Liangshan, so they rely on robbery.

The most controversial character in "Water Margin" is Song Jiang.

On the one hand, he attaches great importance to righteousness and has won the support of most Liangshan heroes; But at the same time, he advocated Zhao'an, which was appreciated by some royal tenants.

Betraying his brother and recruiting peace is by no means a hero.

The reason why he can gather so many heroes around him is because he should be a hero himself.

Song Jiang was a defender of the feudal era, not a hero.

Song Jiang is not a hero, he can only be regarded as a hero.

First of all, I have to admit that it is conscious to write anti-poems, vent dissatisfaction with the imperial court, go to Liangshan Ant Bud, and rebel against the imperial court.

But the problem is that he can't get rid of the inferior nature of the peasants, and he still wants to accept Zhao'an, ignoring the future of the heroes of Liangshan and not thinking about their future. got married, was used as a pawn by the imperial court to attack Fang La, and as a result, most of the heroes of Liangshan were betrayed, and the dead and wounded were ruined, ruining the future and losing their lives.

In the end, although someone recruited An as an official, he was inevitably assassinated and killed by medicine behind the scenes of the imperial court.