The battle of Pengcheng was missed by Sima Qian, and Liu Bang s thousand mile defense line?

Updated on history 2024-05-04
17 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    I think Sima Qian may indeed be missing this battle, but now historians have not given an answer, after all, most of Liu Bei's history is defeatedTherefore, everyone thinks that Liu Bang did not win the battle of Pengcheng, but I think it is very credible, and there is indeed a thousand-mile defense line.

    When many people talk about Xiang Yu and Liu Bang, they will like Xiang Yu's heroism even more, and Liu Bang was just lucky, but in the Battle of Pengcheng, I think he did win, relying on a thousand-mile defense line. Although Liu Bang failed to kill Xiang Yu in the Battle of Pengcheng at that time, he did not flee to the west in defeat, but gained a lot and completed his goal.

    However, the following history is not known by many people, so you can listen to it and laugh. That is, Liu Bang Pengcheng Battle invaded Xiang Yu's feudal country for more than 1,000 miles, conquered Xiang Yu's capital, robbed Xiang Yu's money, grain and assets, and at the same time showed the world that Xiang Yu was a paper tiger. He also seized Xiang Yu's Dongjun, Nanyang County and other places.

    After the Battle of Pengcheng, Liu Bang had already dominated 18 counties, while although Xiang Yu recaptured the capital and recovered Surabaya County, he only had 5 counties under his jurisdiction, and only 6 counties with allies. It can be said that Liu Bang's strength is three times stronger than Xiang Yu and has an overwhelming advantage.

    And the thousand-mile line of defense that Sima Qian missed is also a key point. At that time, Liu Bang deployed the existing strength of the Han army in Dangjun, and Xiayi was the outpost. Then with Dangjun as the core, Dongjun and Chenjun as the two wingsA defense line about 1,000 miles long was constructed, which Sima Qianyi did not record.

    Later, Liu Bang relied on the advantage of dominating 18 counties, requisitioned heavy troops to Dangjun, and then attacked Pengcheng, eliminating Xiang Yu in one fell swoop, which was completely different from Sima Qian's Pengcheng Campaign. I don't know if Sima Qian really missed it, or how, it still needs to be studied

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    The battle of Pengcheng was omitted by Sima Qian, and Liu Bang's thousand-mile defense line was because Liu Bang really hadn't fought a few battles at the beginningThey all think that Liu Bang's ability is very poor.

    After the fall of the Qin state, Liu Bang was made king of Han China. Liu Bang was satisfied that he was only a king in Hanzhong. What Liu Bang wants is the world, followed by the contest between Liu Bang and Xiang Yu.

    In the past four years, Liu Bang has been defeated repeatedly. However, Liu Bang eventually won the Battle of Chu and Han. The reasons for Liu Bang's victory were Zhang Liang, a smart man, and Han Xin, who was good at fighting

    It is even true that many people think that Liu Bang's military ability is very poor. Liu Bang never fought a few battles in his life.

    After Han Wangxin surrendered to the Xiongnu, Liu Bang led an army of 300,000 to attack Han Wangxin. The scale of victory in the entire war was completely on the side of the Han army. In fact, Liu Bang's lone army was deeply wrapped in the Xiongnu army, but Liu Bang's army was the elite of the Han army.

    Although the Xiongnu army had a great numerical advantage, it was not the same. It was difficult for tens of thousands of Han troops to win, so the two sides began to stalemate, and the main force of more than 200,000 Han troops led by Zhou Bo covered the Xiongnu army from the flank. If the Xiongnu army did not retreat, it would be surrounded and annihilated by the main force of the Han army, so the Xiongnu army surrounded Liu Bang for seven days, and then quickly retreated.

    After four years of the Chu-Han War, the combat effectiveness of the Han army was not weak. It's just a lack of maneuverability for horses.

    Gold and silver treasures can only be exchanged for the loss of power and humiliation of the state. Only military force can bring true peace. Later generations always grasped Bai Deng's encirclement and expanded it infinitely.

    They believed that the Han army at the beginning of the Han Dynasty was no match for the Xiongnu army at all. If the Han army is not the opponent of the Xiongnu army, it is necessary to lead the Xiongnu army into the Central Plains as soon as possible. We can only fight it.

    Through analysis, Shou Zhan will find that Mr. Ma Qian of Taishi Company is biased against Bai Dengwei's record, and maybe Taishi Gong has something to hide.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Because Sima Qian was not wary of Liu Bang at the beginning, he omitted it.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    What Liu Bang wants is the world, followed by the contest between Liu Bang and Xiang Yu, which is also a fact. Liu Bang never fought a few battles in his life.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    If you want to break through the defense, you will definitely find loopholes.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    People have weaknesses, and there will be negligent places in arming, which can be found by looking for them.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    <> "How did Liu Bang get out of trouble in the Battle of Pengcheng?" What is the truth?

    The Battle of Pengcheng is a famous battle in Chinese history that took place in 208 AD. In this battle, the commander of the Han army was Liu Bang, who led a large army into battle. However, during the battle, Ding Gong let Liu Bang go.

    So, why did Ding Gong let Liu Bang go?

    First of all, Ding Gong was a visionary. He was well aware of the strength and potential of the Han Dynasty, and knew that if Liu Bang was killed, the Han Dynasty might fall into an even more difficult situation. Therefore, he decided to let Liu Bang go in order to preserve the vitality of the Han Dynasty and leave opportunities for future cooperation.

    Secondly, Ding Gong is also a benevolent person. He saw the tragic situation of Liu Bang and his soldiers on the battlefield, and felt deep sympathy and pity. He believed that a person's life was more important than the victory of a war, so he decided to let Liu Bang go in order to save his life.

    Finally, Ding Gong is also a wise man. He knew that if Liu Bang was killed, the Han army might find themselves in an even more difficult situation, and if he could cooperate with Liu Bang, he might be able to defeat the Wei army together and establish a more stable and powerful regime. Therefore, he decided to let Liu Bang go in order to seek better opportunities for cooperation.

    To sum up, the reason why Ding Gong let Liu Bang go was due to the combined effect of various factors such as his foresight, benevolence, and wisdom. This decision not only protected Liu Bang's life, but also provided important lessons for the later historical development.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Of course, you can't rely on yourself, you can't rely on others. At the beginning, there were really a lot of talented people under Liu Bang, and Liu Bang's nature had not been exposed at that time, and his subordinates were also very heartfelt to him. He's not stupid himself, and if he loses the war, he'll start all over again, of course, it's no problem.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Because although Liu Bang was almost wiped out, he still had many capable people who were willing to follow him to help him and help him recover his strength together.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Liu Bang was defeated and fled to the west, occupied Xingyang Chenggao, and took advantage of the abundant local resources to develop and strengthen himself. At the same time, he has been fighting guerrilla warfare with Xiang Yu, consuming Xiang Yu's troops.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Liu Bang is a very good leader, although he is not talented, but his subordinates are more powerful than the other, I can fight, there are military advisors, and there are brave.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Although Liu Bang came from a relatively humble background, he has a forbearant personality and is good at employing people, although he suffered a big loss here, but he still slowly recuperated and regained his strength.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    With the talents absorbed by Liu Bang. Liu Bang is very smart, he knows how to recruit talents everywhere, even if it is someone from Xiang Yu's side, he does not hesitate to spend money to recruit them.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Although Liu Bang's team was almost wiped out in this battle, those who remained were heartfelt and talented, so they had the ability to recover their strength.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    At that time, although it was said that most of the living forces were lost, with the help of Xiao He, Zhang Liang and others, as long as there was no loss of money, there would still be soldiers.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    At that time, Liu Bang was actually relatively smart, he gained a lot of outstanding talents by absorbing people's hearts, and he also won the hearts of the people.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    <> "How did Liu Bang turn over after the fiasco in the Battle of Pengcheng?"

    After the Battle of Pengcheng, many people thought that Liu Bang could no longer compete with Xiang Yu, because the capital accumulated over the years was defeated by Xiang Yu. Many people may choose to give up at this time, but Liu Bang is different, he has no idea of giving up. Not only did he not give up, but he eventually forced Xiang Yu to kill himself in Wujiang.

    Why is that? Because Liu Bang has a spirit of not giving up and not abandoning.

    Although Liu Bang was defeated in the Battle of Pengcheng, his combat key-based skills were also excellent, and he also had a rogue temper that never flinched when faced with adversity. Most importantly, he has the courage to never give up.

    In real life, how many people can get up after a fall? Even without any capital, many lack this courage. But Liu Bang is different, he chooses to fight again. That's half the battle.

    The most valuable thing about a person is not how much ability he has, what is more valuable is that after failure, he has the courage to start over again, Liu Bang is such a person, after the defeat in the Battle of Pengcheng, he did not give up, packed up his mood, and continued to fight against Xiang Yu.

    In the end, everyone also found out that Xiang Yu failed once, but Xiang Yu's fame outside was too great, and he couldn't fail once, so he didn't have the face to live anymore, and finally chose to kill himself. Such a choice and Liu Bang's cautious choice are completely opposite choices, and the results of Kuanliang's guess can be imagined, and they are also different.

    So Liu Bang had the last laugh. So to sum it up. How did Liu Bang turn over? In fact, it depends on the spirit of not giving up.

Related questions
7 answers2024-05-04

If you eat obediently, you will be called by others, such as hehehehe.

4 answers2024-05-04

Literary Scholar - Sima Qian.

Sima Qian (c. 145 BC - 90 BC), the character is long, and he was a native of Xiayang, Fengyi (now Hancheng, Shaanxi). He began to read ancient books at the age of 10, studied very seriously, and when he encountered difficult problems, he always thought about them repeatedly until he understood them. At the age of 20, Sima Qian set out from Chang'an and traveled to various places. >>>More

18 answers2024-05-04

Man is inherently dead.

People are born to die, this sentence comes from Sima Qian's "Book of Reporting to Ren'an". The whole sentence ""Man is inherently dead, or heavier than Mount Tai, or lighter than a feather." ” >>>More

5 answers2024-05-04

The way the wind happens.

15 answers2024-05-04

Endure humiliation and bear the burden of perseverance.

The disabled will be strong, and his will will will be strong. >>>More