Yu Ban is dragged and incompetent? Why did Yu Ban surrender?

Yu Ban is also one of the five good generals, characterized by rigor and stability. However, this battle with Guan Erye is really strange, and he was ruined. It's a pity, it's a

No... Strictly enforce the ban on soldiers. For example, the Qingzhou soldiers are doing evil underneath. In the ban first cut and then played. Deeply appreciated by Cao Cao.

Three reasons. The first is that Yu Ban was forced to surrender. Second, Yu Ban may make meritorious contributions. Thirdly, Yu Ban itself is talent.

First of all, Yu Ban did not voluntarily surrender and mutiny, nor did he suddenly surrender in an otherwise warlike situation. He surrendered after exhausting his strength. Although this kind of surrender is not as noble as Pound, it is human nature, and most people do it.

So it's not a particularly big sin. Liu Bang can forgive Yongya who took the initiative to betray him, and even if Cao Cao can't forgive Ma Chao who took the initiative to betray, it is not difficult to forgive Yu Ban.

Secondly, Yu Ban may also use other ways to repay Cao Cao, and he doesn't have to do it all at once. Cao Cao himself had a similar experience. He also captured Guan Yu at the beginning, but Guan Yu did not forget Liu Bei and ran back.

Cao Cao also captured Fu Zhu, who also plotted to escape back to Yuan Shao's camp. At this time, Cao Cao didn't know Yu Ban's heart, if he killed his family casually, he would only force Yu Ban to follow Guan Yu with a broken heart.

Finally, Cao Cao cherishes talents very much. In the early years, Chen Gong once led the entire Yanzhou to surrender to Lü Bu when Cao Cao avenged his father, and in this way, Cao Cao still wanted to reconquer Chen Gong in Baimenlou. Yu Ban's talent is not under Chen Gong, and the mistakes he made are far smaller than Chen Gong's, doesn't Cao Cao have the heart to love talents?

There are not many records of Yu Ban's early actions, and he participated in the battles of Lü Bu, Zhang Xiu, and Yuan Shao. He is known for his selflessness. He was deeply valued by Cao Cao.

Landlord, you can really imagine that the military general can sit in the forbidden position, he cares a lot about reputation and glory, he is not an ordinary incompetent person, according to his character, he should not carry out such a dangerous strategy without informing anyone. Guan Yu is powerful, and the success rate of internal and external cooperation should not be high, and if he surrenders, I don't know if Second Brother Guan wants his life. Instead of being trapped in the enemy camp and not knowing life or death, it is better for the defeated army to fight again and regroup.

Furthermore, as a senior general of Cao Wei, he should not be ignorant of Lü Meng's plan to attack Jingzhou.

It is impossible to flood the Seventh Army, Pang De was captured in Yu Ban, Pang De died unyieldingly, and Yu Ban surrendered, but was not used by Guan Yu. It was later put back as a dog.

100% of it was not a ban, but it was because Guan Yu was demoted that Cao Pi was angry to death.

History is not. The historical records may not be true, objectively looking at the ban, he may not be greedy for life, afraid of death, afraid of death, and dare to fight Guan Yu. Judging by the minds of the people who came before.

To each his own. You beat me, I beat you, that's no way to do it. In fact, to put it bluntly, who is not greedy for life and afraid of death, this is the instinct of human beings.

Even if you are greedy for life and afraid of death, it is reasonable. It's just that the values of the people in the past were different, and they said at every turn that they wanted to repay the country with death or something. In fact, who of them does not want to live well.

It's just that the form of expression in the view of life and death is different.

It's just that I'm in awe of Guan Yu.