Is Zhuge Liang really very godly?

Updated on history 2024-05-23
1 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    Zhuge Liang, known as Kong Ming, known as Wolong, was an outstanding politician, military strategist, diplomat, writer, calligrapher, and inventor. He is a legendary figure of Shu, and every time he fights, he will win, and there is almost no defeat. So is Zhuge Liang really so godly?

    Zhuge Liang is a political wizard, there is no need to deny it, but Zhuge Liang is definitely not a military wizard. There are two reasons, one is that many of Zhuge Liang's schemes that really show his military talent are fake, such as burning Bowangpo - this is Liu Bei's doing, and it has nothing to do with Zhuge Liang. The burning of Bowangpo occurred in 202 A.D., and Zhuge Liang was a mountain that only came out in 207 A.D.; Borrowing the east wind - during the winter solstice, there is a southeast wind (Cao Cao's luck), and it is the east wind calculated by Zhou Yu; In 213 AD, Sun Quan took a boat to inspect the situation on the other side, just so that Cao Cao saw (Sun Quan was possessed by Cao Cao), and then "white light flashed in the sky", and finally Sun Quan took "the hedgehog went back", and Zhuge Liang did nothing; Battle of Chibi - Zhuge Liang is just a diplomat, and he is just angry with Sun Quan......It can be seen that Zhuge Liang's real opportunities to show his military talent were all compiled by the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

    The second is that although Zhuge Liang is a resourceful person, he lacks the courage to make a decision on the spot, although Zhuge Liang has to be cautious because of the gap in national strength, which led to Zhuge Liang's final failure.

    Second, in a Three Kingdoms with many heroes, Zhuge Liang is not a real person who knows people. Liu Bei, Cao Cao, and Sun Quan all have their own methods of employing people, but Zhuge Liang is weaker in comparison. It is highlighted in the fact that he does not listen to Liu Bei's advice, and Wei Yan can see that he reuses Ma Jian and lightly uses the materials of the pillars.

    Ma Tan was originally a man who read the art of war, but his words and deeds were too much to stand up to reuse, but Zhuge Liang sent him to guard such an important street pavilion; Wei Yan was originally a civil and military general, and he made meritorious contributions several times, but he was never valued by Zhuge Liang"I see that Wei Yan has a bone ...... in the back of his headTherefore, it was beheaded. to eliminate the root of the bane.

    But the backlash is coming? And in the end, Wei Yan didn't oppose (there was no motive to rebel).

    The third is that Zhuge Liang made many huge mistakes, such as taking power alone after Liu Bei's death, which seems to be a good idea, making Shu strong and prosperous, and showing Zhuge Liang's quality of dedication, but is it really the right thing to do? On the contrary, this ultimately led to the early demise of Shu, didn't Zhuge Liang know that he was the last hope of Shu? Zhuge Liang worked day and night, which seemed to have a remarkable effect, but it led to Zhuge Liang's poor physique and early death, what should Zhuge Liang do when he died in Shu.

    And people's energy is limited, not everything goes smoothly, naturally there will be some mistakes, which is why Zhuge Liang's many Northern Expeditions have not succeeded.

    It can be seen that Zhuge Liang is not a god, but Zhuge Liang is definitely a political wizard who governs Shu in an orderly manner.

Related questions
8 answers2024-05-23

Yes, but his father's name is too prosperous, and his descendants are mediocre.

10 answers2024-05-23

This is fake, Zhuge Liang died of Zhou Yu This is just an artistic component in the romance, Zhou Yu in real history is a broad-minded Confucian, and he will not fight with Zhuge Liang, but he died young because of illness.

20 answers2024-05-23

Zhuge Liang is not so godly, but he was deified in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms And he has a very bad problem, that is, he is too arrogant, and he always sends the generals with the sentence "Mountain people have their own clever plans", and the generals don't know why they do it. At this point, I don't think he can compare to Cao Cao.

8 answers2024-05-23

Sima Hui, the word Decao, Yingchuan Yangzhai (now Yuzhou, Henan) people. >>>More

6 answers2024-05-23

I think Zhuge Liang is a politician, but I don't agree with his military talents. It was because of Zhuge Liang's letter of praise that Guan Gong was conceited, and finally carelessly lost Jingzhou and defeated Maicheng, if he was a strategist, how could he make such a mistake. Even if he is a strategist, I don't think he is better than Cao Cao. >>>More