Historically, was Liu Chan during the Three Kingdoms period really so mediocre?

Liu Chan in history is not really mediocre, it was recorded in the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms" that Zhuge Liang once praised Liu Chan as a very smart and wise person. Liu Bei had three sons, and when he chose the heir to the throne, he was also selected as a virtuous person. And Liu Chan still served as an emperor for 29 years after Zhuge Liang's death, if he was really mediocre, then he couldn't be an emperor for so long.

Liu Chan in history should not be as incompetent as in literary works, but he is not very good, because if he is very good, it will not end like that in the end.

In fact, no, Liu Chan is actually a very powerful emperor, but Liu Chan's talents were covered up by Zhuge Liang before, you must know that Liu Chan was the longest-reigning emperor during the Three Kingdoms period.

Yes, Zhuge Liang worked so hard to assist him, but he still failed to make Shu Han strong, so he also called him Adou, who couldn't be helped.

For Liu Chan, people's most direct impression may be that he can't be supported by Adou, they always feel that he is a mediocre person. Once, did happiness and running away from home show that Liu Chan was a mediocre person? I'm afraid not.

Let's start with joy. In 263 AD, the state of Shu was destroyed by the state of Wei. After Liu Chan surrendered, Cao Huan, the king of Wei, named him "Duke of Anle" and moved him to Luoyang, the capital of Wei.

The Wei Emperor had no real power, but Sima Zhao was in power. At a banquet, Sima Zhao deliberately arranged a performance of Shu dance in front of Liu Chan. Liu Chan's followers were very sad at the thought of the imminent demise of their homeland.

When Sima Zhao saw this, he asked Liu Chan: "An Lejun doesn't miss Shu?" But Liu Chan said to Sima Zhao:

In this happy time, don't think about Shu. As a result, the idiom was handed down, and Liu Chan also put on the hat of being happy but forgetting his origin, not wanting to go to the motherland, and greedy for pleasure.

Therefore, Liu Chan is often considered to be a person without ambition and compassion. However, this incident can prove that Liu Chan is not stupid, he is a master of power and strategy. Why do you say that?

First of all, Liu Chan is not mentally retarded. After Zhuge Liang's death, Liu Chan reigned for 29 years. In those war years, if he was not smart enough, he could have sat on the throne for a long time.

Liu Chan is at least a normal person, what normal person wouldn't miss his hometown? Liu Chan is the master of a country, and he is no stranger to Shu, but he can't speak. Because he was a prisoner at the time, if he publicly said that he missed the days of being emperor, he would have choked him by the neck with a knife.

So Liu Chan sold stupid men just to protect herself, and she wasn't really stupid.

After 41 years as emperor, he voluntarily surrendered to Wei, Shu disappeared, and he became the ruler of the conquered country. He also suffered a lot of abuse because of it, is he really weak? In fact, this is not the case.

At that time, the power gap between Shu and Wei was still very large. Sima Zhao's ambitions are also obvious. After much consideration, he decided to surrender.

Alleviating the suffering of the people. He has no personal interests of his own, but is dedicated to the people, how can such an emperor be supported? His surrender, he had to make Sima Zhao think that he really didn't want to restore the survival of the country, so he had to pretend to be crazy, so he succeeded in deceiving Sima Zhao, but he also fell into the name of happiness and nostalgia.

Liu Chan was very politically minded, so he had a correct attitude towards the Northern Expedition. Zhuge Liang knew very well that Shu was not an opponent of Wei, so Zhuge Liang proposed the Northern Expedition, but Zhuge Liang opposed it and wanted to persuade Zhuge Liang. Zhuge Liang did not understand this, and when the determination of the Northern Expedition was formed, Liu Chan still gave his full support, which reflected Liu Chan's tolerance.

After Zhuge Liang's death, Liu Chan immediately stopped the wasteful Northern Expedition and resumed production. However, Liu Chan's history is not without merit, and although he does not have much talent, he is a monarch, but it is not a mediocre waste as people say.

Liu Chan is the son of Liu Bei, and in history he was a very untalented person and a mediocre talent.

In fact, Liu Chan is a person who is very deep in the city, and his emotional intelligence is also very high, and at the same time, in the era at that time, he was also capable of sitting on the throne of the God King. It's not a mediocrity, it's just a disguise.

Although Liu Chan is a person who can't be helped up in history, I think he is a wise and foolish person.

Liu Chan is not incompetent, but makes a difference.

The first is the system, after Zhuge Liang's death, Liu Chan immediately abolished the prime minister system, let Fei Yi be Shang Shuling and the general, with Jiang Wan as the great Sima, the power of the two intersected with each other, restrained each other, but each had its own emphasis. Jiang Wan is mainly in charge of government affairs and also in charge of the military; Fei Yi is mainly in charge of the military, and is also in charge of government affairs, and the power of military and internal affairs is no longer grasped by the same person. Later, Jiang Wan died of illness, and Liu Chan was the regent and directly held power for 19 years.

followed by winning people's hearts, after Cao Shuang and Sima Yi were killed in a struggle for power, Xiahou Ba was afraid of being connected to Shu and entered Shu, and Liu Chan personally greeted him. Xiahouba's father, Xiahou Yuan, was suspected of being killed by the veteran Huang Zhong, and when Liu Chan appeased Xiahouba, who came to surrender, he said: "Your father's murder was not done by my ancestors.

After a sentence, he almost said: "My son is still your nephew!" It turned out that Liu Chan's wife was Zhang Fei's daughter, and Zhang Fei's wife was Xiahou Yuan's sister, so Liu Chan said so.

After the fighter's dust, Liu Chan "favored Xiahouba". Liu Chan's set of gentle methods to win over Xiahouba, even if his father Liu Bei is alive, is probably not like this.

The real Liu Chan is not as idle as ** said, although he has not done anything, but he is not mediocre, but he has no ability to govern the country.

In my personal opinion, Liu Chan is not a faint monarch, but he is a mediocre monarch, although Liu Chan surrendered early, but his ability to govern the country is still there.

Of course not. He is actually very far-sighted, he did not favor the villain during his reign, he took the initiative to surrender, but avoided a lot of **.

After Zhuge Liang's death, Liu Chan maintained the Shu Han regime for 29 years, which shows that he was not stupid.

is not as exaggerated as romance, and it is completely a means of self-preservation, but Liu Chan really has no ability and talent, and his IQ is not high.

Liu Chan is not stupid at all, but very smart, otherwise Kong Ming is in power, the power is inclined to Shu Han, Liu Chan did not pretend to be incompetent and was killed by Kong Ming a long time ago, and the world has decided, Liu Chan pretended to be Emperor Wu of Jin to save his family's life, and finally Liu Chan was able to die well and was a smart man.

It's not stupid, he was arrested by Wei Guo, and his subordinates asked him to pretend to cry, he knew that it was useless to lie to Sima and them, it was better to be honest and tell the truth.

In a turbulent era, it's not a bad thing to be stupid, at least you can save your life, don't you say?

In fact, the main thing about Liu Chan is that he can't be said to be stupid, he can only say that he can't govern the country, and he can only rely on his father Zhuge Liang. to point.

As an emperor without any real power, silence is not the best way, only when others feel that you have no ambition and lose any threat, you are the safest, and what is the good of being born in the emperor's family, with the personality of the children now, as long as you have food, who wants to worry about it! Just like Liu Chan, with Zhuge Liang in front, enjoying life by himself is the real happiness.

If you are not stupid, at least you can protect yourself, and if you know how to be sleek, it will be commendable.

is not as smart as Cao Cao's son, but he is not as clumsy as in film and television dramas.

Don't really think that he can't help Adou,

No, it's just that Zhuge Liang is too powerful, and it seems that other tasks are too small.

First of all, I have not read "Three Kingdoms", only "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and my views may not be comprehensive.

Liu Chan had few opportunities to participate in battles, and he followed women for a long time, so he did not get a better play in his talents.

Second, Liu Bei led his troops to fight in the east and west, Liu Chan did not participate in the war, but his ability to defend still exists.

Third, Zhuge Liang cares about Liu Chan no matter how big or small, Liu Chan may not be stupid, but there is one person who is in charge, so he naturally doesn't have to worry about it. In the same way, if Zhuge Liang takes care of everything, the child will not be productive. Just like today's parents, they have thought about their children, they have less practice and thinking, and suddenly let them grow up right away, that's unrealistic.

Fourth, Liu Chan surrendered, on the one hand, to protect the people of Shuzhong.

If he is really useless, why has he been an emperor for more than 40 years Even if it is because of Kong Ming, but after his death, Liu Chan has also been an emperor for more than 20 years Which emperor has a long life during the Three Kingdoms period, Boss Cao needless to say, he was the first to go to see the Lord of the West Heaven, and the Sun family was not very good, and in the end, he died with a glass of poisoned wine Only Liu Chan died

Who can say what kind of person the real Liu Chan is, whether he is ambitious and stupid or a complete fool?

Never miss it"I think it's one of the most effective ways for Liu Chan to preserve himself, and that's what makes him so special, and it's something that people can imagine, and I think he's very smart.

Actually, he wasn't stupid, an adult covered him.

Yes, it's still confused, not a talent for governing the country.

This is because it was misled by "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

Liu Chan should be a person with brains, what can he do under the shadow of Zhuge Liang? After Zhuge Liang's death, he led the weakest Shu State for 30 years, which is impossible for a cowardly and mediocre person to do. After surrendering, he can live to old age and death. It's not something that ordinary kings of the dead country can do.

It was changed by the Ming and Qing dynasties ** "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

Although the Romance of the Three Kingdoms and the Romance of the Three Kingdoms describe the events of the same period, the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is a history book of technological history written by Chen Shou of the Western Jin Dynasty.

And "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is a step in the historical theme changed by Luo Guanzhong in the Ming and Qing dynasties. A lot of the author's feelings are added to it.

is the so-called "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" "three points false, seven points true", because the author despises Wei. For example, Cao Cao was a famous military strategist, politician, and poet at that time, and had deep attainments, and his talent and ambition were also the most prominent at that time.

After the rewriting of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", he became the "traitorous male Cao Mengde" who was scolded by people; There was no Diao Chan in history, and she was not mentioned at all in the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms", but I think that even the young generals can record the "Three Kingdoms", wouldn't Diao Chan, who had a great impact on the political situation at that time, not be recorded?

There is also the author who "deified" Zhuge Liang, Zhuge Liang was undoubtedly extremely smart at that time, but the author made it too far, and the empty city plan or anything was fictional. When he hated the dead monarch of Shu...

Well, to put it simply, the Adou that ordinary people say is the Adou of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", not the real Adou.

A moment of silence for the Russian fight -

In the eyes of the Chinese, the monarch of the dead country is no better, and this view and traditional thinking have caused many emperors to suffer for hundreds of years!

Because people's impression of Zhuge Liang is too good, he doesn't listen to good people, giving people a feeling of not distinguishing between loyalty and treachery. And he is the king of the dead country, and the impression must be bad, just like Chongzhen, who got rid of the eunuch party, and can be regarded as having made a difference, but there is only one fault of killing Yuan Chonghuan, which is not much of a big deal, but the country is lost, and later generations believe that he is not good. Emperor Yang of Sui was the same.

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms", coupled with the fact that Shu was destroyed at the hands of Liu Chan, Liu Chan chose to surrender without resistance.

The winner is king, and the loser is the loser. Plus an idiom that can't be missed.

It's all to blame for "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

The god-like Zhuge Liang, the pig-like Adou...

Because of political needs, Liu Chan was deliberately smeared.

defeated Liu Bei so hard! Still dragging Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition! Everyone wants to give him a slap in the face! Those who are still happy to think about it ignore politics.