If Han Xin led the Shu army on a northern expedition, could Shu unify the world?

Yes, Han Xin is known as a "soldier immortal", and his ability to use soldiers is still above Zhuge Liang.

I think it still can't, Han Xin's talent may not be above Zhuge Liang, the fundamental reason for the failure of Shu's Northern Expedition is that the national strength is too weak, and Han Xin may not be able to change this weakness.

Yes, because Han Xin is a rare general, not only is his martial arts strong, but he is not as conceited as Guan Yu, so it is okay.

If during the Three Kingdoms period, even if there was a Sun Quan who followed Liu Bei in the same art of war as Han Xin, Liu Bei would not have been able to unify China, and such a result had long been confirmed by Zhuge Liang. Among the three countries, there is a name that Feng Chick Wolong Mountain has to determine the world, Liu Bei and both of them have it, and in the end the world is not at peace, on the contrary, Feng Chick was shot to death by the enemy in Luofeng Slope, leaving a Zhuge Liang, even if six out of Qi Mountain, Jiang Wei Northern Expedition Cao Army, brave and loyal, and do his best, can not guarantee that Liu Bei's foundation will be evergreen. Why is it that even if Liu Bei wins the world, the most outstanding talents cannot dominate the whole country, and the world is in chaos?

First, Liu Bei Group has a weak foundation. Therefore, Han Xin defected to Liu Bang and opened up a path for Liu Bang, although it was because Xiang Yu did not value Han Xin, but also because Liu Gang not only had strategists and generals at that time, but also had a strong overall strength, which could compete with Xiang Yu and was the most powerful force besides Xiang Yu. So, what was Liu Bei at that time?

At first, there were only three brothers, and then there were only a hundred and ten, and they ran to this end all day long, like a lost dog, and had no time to take care of it. Han Xin, who does more good deeds, only arranges troops and guides the battle, but You Jingchu has no scheming to recruit talents for the main general and expand the main lineup.

Second, Liu Bei Group is not easy to be completely defeated by Han Xin. And Liu Guanzhang of Liu Bei Group is ironclad and nepotistic. Therefore, Han Xin can make great contributions to Liu Bang Group and retire successfully.

Liu Bang has many shortcomings, but there is no concern if there is no doubt, and there is no attention if there is no attention, which is very worthy of our learning. Naturally, Liu Bei also has this advantage, and is more inclusive than Liu Bang, but Liu Bei can, Liu Bei Group cannot. Guan Yunchang is Liu Bei's most trusted person, but he is very persistent, arrogant and arrogant, often ignoring the appropriate strategic line formulated by management decision-makers, arrogant and arrogant, and finally becoming a member of the home team, pulling the entire group back and plunging the entire group into the abyss from which it is difficult to extricate itself.

If Han Xin arrived at Liu Bei Group, he might be the same as him at that time, he couldn't be trusted in Xiang Yu Group, and Han Xin was an arrogant person, and he didn't disdain to be like Zhuge Liang, who insisted on going his own way, insisting on going his own way, and insisting on going his own way to unite Liu Bei Group and Han Xin. Not to mention that Han Xin was the load rate of Liu Bei's group, it would have been very good not to throw a counterattack at that time. Han Shin is not virtuous, and he does not have the heart of two masters.

No, he doesn't have this ability, although Liu Bei is relatively gentle and generous, he lacks some decisive ability.

If Han Xin could lead the three sentences at that time, then Liu Bei would also be able to unify the world.

Han Xin was a very well-known general during the Han Dynasty, and his military strength was very strong and was finally killed by Liu Bang Lubi, if he was placed in the Three Kingdoms period, he could help Liu Bei, maybe history will be rewritten.

No, with the strength of Shu Han, it is not enough to defeat Cao Wei, Zhuge Liang came out of Qishan, and he didn't even know how sure he was, this was just a strategic direction.

Zhuge Liang understood that if he didn't cut down Wei, the catastrophe would come faster, and the biggest effect of the Northern Expedition was to create trouble and pressure on Cao Wei at the same time, prompting Eastern Wu to maintain a certain ambition for Cao Wei and avoid Sun Quan and Cao Wei from getting too close. Among the forces of the Three Kingdoms, Shu Han was the weakest, and uniting with Eastern Wu was the only choice for it not to perish. Although the animal verbally agreed, it has always maintained a wait-and-see attitude, and has not twisted into a rope with Shu Han to fight against Cao, Dongwu can be said to have been watching what Shu Han does, what is the situation in the world?

If Shu Han did not perform well, Eastern Wu would turn to approach Cao Cao, as Eastern Wu was unwilling to become a shield for Shu Han. You Shu Han shrank behind and didn't make a force, why should I sell my life to anger Cao Cao? Therefore, Shu Han, who is relatively weak, wants Dongwu to really unite with him, he must show his strength and give Cao Wei a substantial blow, so that Dongwu feels that he can profit from Shu Han's containment of Cao Wei, so that he can maintain his ambition for Cao Wei.

Shu Han was able to survive under the checks and balances of power.

The strategic significance of Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition was to maintain a balance of interests between the Three Kingdoms, because once the balance was broken, Shu Han would be the first to be eaten. Since it is for balance, even if Zhuge Liang achieves some strategic victories, he will not have the idea of destroying Cao Wei, because once Cao Wei and Shu Han have a reversal of strength, Shu Han has achieved great results, and Cao Wei is facing extinction, Eastern Wu will immediately turn against him and help Cao Wei suppress the development of Shu Han, and the balance of power has been reached.

Therefore, even if Han Xin is alive and helps Zhuge Liang to fight, he may achieve more results, and even balance the strength of Shu Han and Cao Wei, but it is even more difficult to destroy Cao Wei, one is that his own strength is not so great, and second, the variable of Eastern Wu still interferes a lot.

In addition, the replacement of one regime by another does not depend entirely on force, if Liu Bang relies on Han Xin alone, he will not be able to defeat Xiang Yu, Liu Bang has Xiao He to manage internal affairs, develop production, provide a stable rear, and at the same time transport grain, grass and soldiers. There is also a strategic thinker like Zhang Liang, who is decisive thousands of miles away. Coupled with Han Xin's invincible attack, this won the Han world.

In the troika of the early Han Dynasty, if anyone is missing, it will be more difficult for Liu Bang to win the world, and no one can rely on one alone.

In terms of ability, Zhuge Liang has Xiao He's ability to govern internal affairs, and there is also a bit of Zhang Liang's strategic thinking, but he may be weaker than Han Xin militarily, but Zhuge Liang can replace Xiao He and half Zhang Liang and half Han Xin, and the troika Zhuge Liang can pull two by himself, Han Xin can only be one, so Han Xin assists Zhuge Liang, and there may be hope, Han Xin replaces Zhuge Liang, then Shu Han may have a worse result.

I think it will work. Because Han Xin's military ability is stronger than Zhuge Liang's, the Northern Expedition of Shu may be successful.

If the Northern Expedition of Shu was not Zhuge Liang, but Han Xin, the Northern Expedition might not be successful, because of Wei, he is also full of talents, and there are many elite soldiers and strong generals.

I think that even if it is Han Xin, the result of the Northern Expedition is about the same, after all, the gap between the comprehensive strength of Shu Han and Cao Wei is too big, and it is Shu Han who loses every time.

No, the main reason for Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition was that Shu Han's strength was too weak, and it was the same result for Han Xin.

The Northern Expedition should also be successful, because Han Xin's own ability is also relatively strong.

Is this still Han Shin, who has been humiliated by boasting? If so, then this Han Xin is finished with Liu Bei. I can't figure out whether it was Zhang Fei who humiliated him in the first place. Zhang Fei didn't beat the other soldiers when he was drunk, so he greeted Han Xin alone.

Putting aside the factor of boasting and humiliation, we can only analyze it with Han Xin's talent. Han Xin was able to fully display his military talents under Liu Bang because Liu Bang gave Han Xin the space to display freely. Liu Bei was able to enjoy this kind of treatment only Guan Yu.

Don't expect Han Xin to be able to sit in Jingzhou, at best, Han Xin can only assist Guan Yu. With Guan Yu's character, Han Xin is almost the same as Xiang Yu. Han Xin's persuasion of Guan Yu would not have any effect, and after Han Xin found out that Guan Yu was bound to fail, Han Xin also left Guan Yu to try his luck with Cao Cao!

If Liu Bei had a better attitude towards Han Xin, Han Xin would still be good to follow Zhang Fei. Han Xin's strategies were very attractive to Zhang Fei. After Zhang Fei was impressed by Han Xin's talent, he would definitely recommend Han Xin to Liu Bei.

Between Zhuge Liang and Pang Tong, Han Xin generally chooses Pang Tong. Pang Tong will also recognize Han Xin's military talent. Because Liu Bei was influenced by Pang Tong, he was more able to give full play to Han Xin's talents.

But Liu Bei couldn't give Han Xin much autonomy, at best, he was just replacing Wei Yan to guard Hanzhong.

The important land in Jingzhou must still be handed over to Guan Yu, and the important land such as Shangyong must still be handed over to Liu Feng, the righteous son. According to Liu Bei's arrangement, the loss of Jingzhou is still inevitable. If Han Xin had guarded Hanzhong, Liu Bei would not have taken Han Xin with him.

Liu Bei will still suffer a crushing defeat in Yiling. If Han Xin didn't guard Hanzhong at the beginning, he was just an ordinary general. As long as Han Xin doesn't dissuade Liu Bei from attacking Wu like Zhao Yun, Liu Bei is likely to bring Han Xin with him.

In this way, as long as Liu Bei could follow Han Xin's advice, he would not suffer a fiasco at Yiling. If Liu Bei didn't even listen to Han Xin's advice, there would be no way!

It is very likely that the battle of Yiling will be won, and then continue to advance towards Eastern Wu. At this time, Cao Wei's side can no longer sit idly by, and will inevitably take action. Regardless of whether Cao Wei sent troops to Eastern Wu or Cao Wei attacked Liu Bei, Liu Bei would reach an agreement with Sun Quan to reconcile.

Shortly after the Battle of Yiling, Liu Bei died. At this time, it was the successor of the later lord Liu Chan, and the power of the entire Shu Kingdom was in the hands of Zhuge Liang. Because Zhuge Liang and Han Xin have fundamental differences, Zhuge Liang is bound to suppress Han Xin.

Han Xin's military career is basically the same as Wei Yan!