Hua Tuo was killed in the end, was Cao Cao really killed Hua Tuo just because he was suspicious?

Updated on history 2024-06-11
16 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    The reason why Hua Tuo was killed by Cao Cao, in addition to Cao Cao's suspicious nature, there was also a reason for political reasons, because if Hua Tuo could not be used by Cao Cao, he would inevitably help Wu or Shu, which was a great danger to Cao Cao, so he killed Hua Tuo. Hua Tuo is a famous doctor in the Three Kingdoms period, his methods are actually comparable to modern medicine, especially Guan Yu's bone scraping to cure poison, Cao Cao suggested a craniotomy to treat headaches, which was very rare at that time, even if it is the current medical technology, craniotomy is not very easy to do, which shows how superb Hua Tuo's medical skills are. But as a time of war, the more powerful a person is, the more dangerous he is, for himself and for others.

    In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", there are not many incidents about Hua Tuo, but there are two things that are particularly famous, one is that Hua Tuo scraped Guan Yu's bones to cure poison, when Guan Yu was shot in the arm by the enemy's poisonous arrow, if ** is not timely, Guan Yu's arm will be abolished, just at this time Hua Tuo traveled to the territory of Shu, so Hua Tuo helped Guan Yu scrape the bones to cure the poison. There is another thing that Cao Cao asked Hua Tuo to give himself a headache, but in the end, Hua Tuo died at the hands of Cao Cao. <>

    At that time, Hua Tuo's suggestion to Cao Cao was a craniotomy, and then Hua Tuo gave Cao Cao ** his headache, not to mention in the Three Kingdoms period, even now, craniotomy is not a minor operation, for Cao Cao, who is suspicious by nature, naturally he will not believe Hua Tuo's words. So he thought that Hua Tuo might have taken this opportunity to kill Cao Cao, just like Cao Cao wanted to assassinate Dong Zhuo back then, Hua Tuo found an excuse to assassinate Cao Cao. But this is only one of the reasons, there is another reason why Cao Cao had to kill Hua Tuo, because if Cao Cao did not accept Hua Tuo's **, then he would inevitably travel to other places, or be invited by Shu, or be invited by Dongwu to stay in the army to treat diseases and save people, which is a very dangerous thing for Cao Cao, this is undoubtedly strengthening other people's armies, and it is a threat to himself, so Cao Cao had to kill Hua Tuo and kill Hua Tuo.

    Therefore, in addition to Cao Cao's suspicion, Cao Cao killed Hua Tuo, but also because of political factors.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    Yes, Cao Cao did not trust Hua Tuo's healing methods, believing that Hua Tuo wanted to kill him in the name of healing.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    It's not like this, because Hua Tuo** Cao Cao's illness requires Cao Cao's craniotomy, which is very difficult now, let alone ancient times, not only Cao Cao can't accept it, but others can't accept it.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Yes, because he didn't believe that Hua Tuo had the ability to perform surgery, and thought that Hua Tuo was trying to kill him, so he killed him.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    "Repent shouldn't kill that Hua Tuo", this is a popular stalk on the Internet, through this sentence, it can also be seen that Hua Tuo died really unjustly. What makes people regret is that his superb medical skills have not been successfully passed on to the world, so that future generations cannot be blessed by it.

    Hua Tuo, a generation of famous doctors, did not die on the road of ** incurable diseases, but died in the hands of Cao Cao. There will be such an ending, all because Cao Cao is suspicious by nature, thinking that Hua Tuo wants to take the opportunity of treatment to take his own life.

    As everyone knows, Cao Cao killed, the only one who could save his life. When Cao Cao had an unbearable headache, he may have regretted his reckless decision.

    Celebrities in ancient times had their own arrogance, even the famous doctor Hua Tuo was no exception. Hua Tuo didn't want to become Cao Cao's personal doctor, he had the people of the world in mind, and wanted to hide in the world and treat the people of Dawn.

    Cao Cao is not only suspicious by nature, but also very domineering, if he can't be used by him, he wants to deal with him quickly. This is also the best embodiment of his "rather call me the world".

    Hua Tuo angered Cao Cao by repeatedly refusing Cao Cao's requests and falsely claiming that his wife was ill, and sent him to prison. The cautious Cao Cao ended Hua Tuo's life in prison like this, and a generation of miracle doctors came to an end, which made people feel very wronged.

    Hua Tuo was a very famous doctor at that time, and he was good at all kinds of incurable diseases. Cao Cao's headache, and when Cao Chong was sick, if Hua Tuo was alive, the outcome might be very different.

    In my personal opinion, when Cao Cao saw that his beloved son Cao Chong was seriously ill and there was no doctor to treat him, he would think of Hua Tuo in his heart, and he would regret his impulsive behavior back then.

    Hua Tuo's skills, with his departure, were also taken underground. It is said that he kept his medical works, but they were not handed down because they were not kept well.

    If Hua Tuo's medical achievements can be handed down, I think it will be of great help to today's Chinese medicine. It's a pity that all of this was buried in Cao Apu's hands.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    It was really wronged, because at that time, Hua Tuo, as a doctor, wanted to show Cao Cao a headache, and the plan given at that time was a craniotomy, but because Cao Cao was more suspicious, Hua Tuo would be executed in a fit of anger.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Hua Tuo has some grievances, because Hua Tuo was killed by Cao Cao for not treating Cao Cao, and it is really a pity, because Hua Tuo is a very good doctor. I think Cao Cao has some caution in doing this.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    In fact, Hua Tuo's death was not very unjust; Because Cao Cao was suspicious by nature, his deception of Cao Cao would inevitably arouse Cao Cao's inner anger, so Cao Cao beheaded him.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    No, there is a risk of infection in craniotomy until now, not to mention that in ancient times, which could only rely on fire and alcohol disinfection, it was impossible to succeed.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Cao Cao had a headache, so he asked Hua Tuo to come **, Hua Tuo wanted to give Cao Cao a craniotomy, Cao Cao was suspicious by nature, because Hua Tuo came to stab himself, so he killed Hua Tuo.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Because he felt that Hua Tuo had discovered his secret, in fact, Cao Cao would rather kill 100 by mistake than let go of one. And Hua Tuo was not willing to listen to Cao Cao's words.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Because Cao Cao felt that such a god-man could not be obtained by others, and Hua Tuo was unwilling to belong to him, he would be destroyed if he couldn't get it, and this was the real reason.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    History is indeed like this, and it is also recorded in detail in some history books, because Cao Cao suspected Hua Tuo, Hua Tuo offended Cao Cao, so he was killed.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Yes. Cao Cao was very suspicious, he felt that Hua Tuo might harm him, so he killed Hua Tuo, Hua Tuo's death was a pity.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Yes, according to relevant historical records, Hua Tuo was indeed killed by Cao Cao, there are relevant historical reasons, and there is such a thing in history.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Speaking of Cao Cao, if you know that the Three Kingdoms must know this famous hero in history. There are good and bad opinions about Cao Cao, some people think that Cao Cao would rather kill a thousand people by mistake than let one go, and there are too many people killed. Therefore, Cao Cao has an extremely cruel side.

    Of course, some people think that Cao Cao is not as cruel as others say, at least Cao Cao is better at employing people. The simplest example is that in order to get Guan Yu's help, Cao Cao not only didn't care about the relationship between Guan Yu and Liu Bei, but also made various demands on Guan Yu. On the contrary, he gave Guan Yu a lot of rewards, and it can be seen that Cao Cao does have another side.

    Cao buried Soucao killed so many people in his life, basically all of them were soldiers on the battlefield, with one exception, that is, Hua Tuo, who was known as the miracle doctor. As we all know, Hua Tuo and Bian Que are both famous doctors in history. In ancient times, when heroes were vying for supremacy, the importance of highly skilled miracle doctors could be reflected at this time.

    Anyone who has watched "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" knows that Cao Cao always has a symptom called Lei Gong's disease, and his head often hurts badly. No matter which doctor is invited, nothing works. In desperation, he had no choice but to send someone to invite Hua Tuo, the miracle doctor at that time.

    The name of Hua Tuo's imperial doctor is by no means groundless. He was good at acupuncture, and at first it did relieve Cao Cao's headaches, but it was not the solution to all problems, so Hua Tuo proposed to Cao Cao to cut off his head with an axe and take out the wind saliva. In this way, the disease can be completely relieved.

    Cao Cao was suspicious by nature, and he believed that Hua Tuo must have been sent by the enemy to kill him, so he ordered Hua Tuo to be imprisoned. In fact, as a doctor, Hua Tuo definitely puts the patient first. The treatment he sincerely proposed was not wronged, but wronged and imprisoned.

    Hua Tuo actually had the conditions to do surgery at that time, because Hua Tuo invented Ma Boiling Powder at that time, but Hua Tuo did not meet Bole. After that, Hua Tuo was tortured to death by Cao Cao in prison. Before he died, Hua Tuo wanted to hand over his life's work "The Book of Green Bags" to the prison guards, saying that with this book, he would not be afraid of getting sick.

    However, due to fear, the prison guards did not accept it, and the "Dumping Book" was buried along with Ma Ma and Hua Tuo's lifelong wisdom achievements. Twelve years later, Cao Cao's son Cao Pi ascended to the throne, and people discovered Cao Cao's correct decision to kill Hua Tuo.

    First of all, although Hua Tuo is a doctor who cannot compete with the world, he refuses to accept Cao Cao in his heart. Cao Cao is guilty of killing too many people in his life, and Hua Tuo's duty is to save people one after another. From this we can see that two people are destined to be incompatible.

    Secondly, Hua Tuo gave Cao Cao acupuncture for a long time each time. In addition, he didn't want to have only ** people with the power of Qiduan, so he repeatedly lied that his wife was sick and asked for leave to go home. Later, Cao Cao knew that he would never give up, if he was soft-hearted to Hua Tuo, his prestige would be lost, maybe this is where Cao Cao's talent lies.

Related questions
30 answers2024-06-11

I think Cao Cao's approach is very dialogue, and it is not very wronged, everyone has their own ideas, if he does the same thing as Cao Cao thinks, Cao Cao will not kill him, since Cao Cao chose to kill him, Cao Cao has his own ideas, so they do not agree with each other, so Cao Cao will kill him, this is not questioned,

16 answers2024-06-11

Speaking of Hua Tuo, everyone must be familiar with it, in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", his most famous story is to scrape bones to cure poison, but he was killed when he finally decided to operate on Cao Cao.

7 answers2024-06-11

Yes, Hua Tuo wanted to open Cao Cao's brain to remove the tumor, and Cao Cao thought that Hua Tuo wanted to harm him, so he killed him.

32 answers2024-06-11

Hua Tuo (c. 145 A.D. 208 A.D.), a native of Peiguo County, was a famous medical scientist in the late Eastern Han Dynasty. Hua Tuo, Dong Feng and Zhang Zhongjing are known as the "Three Divine Doctors of Jian'an". When he was young, he traveled abroad to study, and practiced medicine in Anhui, Henan, Shandong, Jiangsu and other places, studying medical skills rather than seeking a career. >>>More

14 answers2024-06-11

If Cao Cao hadn't killed Hua Tuo at that time, then his illness would not have been cured by Hua Tuo. Because after Hua Tuo was caught by Cao Cao to treat his headache, he made it clear that even if Cao Cao was cured, then Cao Cao would only live for a few days. At the same time, Hua Tuo also told Cao Cao his method, but Cao Cao at that time was very suspicious, so he thought that Hua Tuo wanted to kill him, so he locked Hua Tuo in prison, which led to Hua Tuo's death. >>>More