Which is stronger, the peak Ming Dynasty or the peak Qing Dynasty?

The peak of the Ming Dynasty was stronger, the Yongle Dynasty, and the Wanbang Dynasty came to the Dynasty, which was a few grades higher than the peak Qing Dynasty, and the army in the early Ming Dynasty was extremely strong in combat effectiveness, and the Qing Dynasty could not defeat it.

This is still stronger at the peak of the Qing Dynasty. Because the land area and population of the Qing Dynasty at that time, as well as the economy and military, were much stronger than those at the peak of the Ming Dynasty. There is no comparison between the two dynasties.

The Qing Dynasty was even more powerful, because even if there was a closed country, the Qing Dynasty also learned a lot of Western technology, and its combat effectiveness also improved.

The Ming Dynasty was the last dynasty established by the Han Chinese in the stage of Chinese feudal society. Its historical achievements were so high that it should have been ranked first in the world at that time. Later, the Ming Dynasty was often compared with the Tang Dynasty, but in terms of military strength, economy and culture, the achievements of the Ming Dynasty should be higher than that of the Tang Dynasty.

Even during the Ming Dynasty, the germ of capitalism had already appeared, which shows the degree of prosperity of the society at that time. We can get a glimpse of how powerful the Ming Dynasty was at its peak from the following data.

1. The military strength is the largest in the world.

According to historical records, the Ming Dynasty had an army of no less than two million people stationed in various places. Even at the end of the Ming Dynasty, it could no longer support such a huge army, but the number of troops was still very large, almost equivalent to the entire army in Europe at that time, or even more.

Second, the world's largest holdings of **.

According to historical records, the Ming Dynasty's foreign commerce was already very developed at that time, and many countries came to buy Chinese goods, including silk, porcelain, etc., which also led to the inflow of many ** and ** into the Ming Dynasty. According to estimates, almost one-third of the world's ** at that time were in the Ming Dynasty.

3. The territory is the largest in the world.

The territory of the Ming Dynasty was basically maintained at about 9 million square kilometers throughout the history of the dynasty, making it the largest country in the world at that time.

Fourth, the world's largest mineral output.

The output of the Ming Dynasty was the highest in the world at that time, and according to documents, the mineral output of the Ming Dynasty alone reached more than 9,000 tons. The level of development of the metallurgical industry is already quite high.

Fifth, the world's first navigation strength.

One of the most well-known achievements of the Ming Dynasty is Zheng He's seven voyages to the West. The most important thing to go to the Western Ocean is to have strong ships and navigational strength. According to records, the largest ship built during the Ming Dynasty, with a length of 150 meters and a width of more than 30 meters, was the largest ship in the world at that time.

Zheng He went to the West and traveled to more than 30 countries.

No. 1 in the world. In fact, before the Opium War in 1840, China's comprehensive national strength was always the first in the world.

The cultivated land area is the first in the world: it reached more than 7.8 million hectares at the end of the Ming Dynasty, and this level has not been broken even in the later Kangqian Dynasty;

The population of the Ming Dynasty was about 7,000 to 80 million at that time, and the population of the world at that time was no more than 400 million;

The world's largest mineral output: more than 9,000 tons in the Wanli period, and for more than 200 years, no country in the world can break this record;

**Largest in the world: In the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, one-third of the world's ** went to China through **;

The largest number of troops in the world: at that time, the Ming Dynasty still had a large number of troops, even if the whole of Europe was not as large as China;

The world's largest military output value.

The spy agency is the largest in the world.

The total tonnage of ships is the largest in the world: when Zheng He went to the Western Ocean in the early Ming Dynasty, the largest treasure ship in the Ming Dynasty was 150 meters long and more than 30 meters wide, which was the largest ship in the world at that time.

The land area of the Ming Dynasty was the largest in the world: the land area of the Ming Dynasty remained at about 9 million square kilometers for most of the time;

Most fortifications in the world: The Great Wall of the Ming Dynasty is the second longest fortification in the history of China and the world.

Personally, I still think that the Ming Dynasty at its peak was better than the Qing Dynasty at its peak, because the Ming Dynasty at this time made all the surrounding countries fearful and did not dare to pick quarrels and provoke trouble.

Compared with the two peak feudal dynasties, I think it must be the Qing Dynasty, the land area of the Qing Dynasty is far better than that of the Ming Dynasty, and the population and tributary ** of the Qing Dynasty are also stronger than the Ming Dynasty!

The Ming Dynasty at its peak was stronger than the Qing Dynasty. The peak period of the Ming Dynasty should belong to the era of Zhu Yuanzhang and Zhu Di, the expansion of the country's territory, and the qualitative leap in economy, culture and military were incomparable to the Qing Dynasty.

I think it's the Qing Dynasty. Because according to the comparison of historical books, the Qing Dynasty at its peak had more troops, the treasury was more abundant, and the common people also praised the imperial court, and the court was united inside and outside, and it was more powerful than the Ming Dynasty.

I think that at the peak of the Qing Dynasty, the strength was stronger, and the Qing Dynasty was very peaceful and secure, and it was very concerned about people's livelihood issues, and the treasury at that time was also very sufficient.

It was one of the most powerful countries in the world at that time. Just by Zheng He's voyage to the West, one can imagine how strong the comprehensive strength was at that time.

At the peak of the strength of the Ming Dynasty, it was so strong that you can't imagine it, first of all, the population of the Ming Dynasty was very large, in the whole world at that time, the population of the Ming Dynasty was the largest, and all countries had to come to the Ming Dynasty to worship, and the military strength at that time was also very strong, ranking first, and it is said that the total number of troops and population added up to the sum of the number of European armies

At the peak of the strength of the Ming Dynasty, they had the most powerful army in the world, the most powerful naval army in the world, and the Ming Dynasty at that time, all countries came to the dynasty, which can be called the most powerful country in the world.

1.Strong sea power: The naval strength of the Ming Dynasty was the first in the world at that time, and Zheng Chenggong's recovery of Taiwan was a peep in the tube, which can be seen.

2.Huge population: At that time, looking around the whole world, the Ming Dynasty was the most populous country.

3.Inheritance of the hukou system and unification of state action: During the Yuan Dynasty, the hukou system existed, which was created by the khan to motivate the enthusiasm of soldiers, craftsmen, and other professionals.

4.Strong military strength: The number of army soldiers of the Ming Dynasty ranks first in the world, and its strength cannot be underestimated.

5. Economic prosperity: since the opening of the ** road on the road and at sea.