From which three aspects did Zhao Liang compare Shang Ying and Baili Xi?

Shang Ying and Baili Xi are both reformers of the Qin State, and their contributions are very large, so who is more loved by the common people compared to these two people, this is not Shang Yang is also more confused, so he asked this Qin man named Zhao Liang, and the result was that people said in their hearts: Who is good, do you have no points in your own heart? So how did this Zhao Liang reply to Shang Ying, let's talk about it briefly.

There may be friends who don't know much about Baili Xi, a little introduction, this Baili Xi is the doctor of Yu in the Spring and Autumn Period, Jin Xiangong destroyed Yu and Yu, and captured Yu Jun and his doctor Baili Xi. He also sent Baili Xi to the Qin State as a slave for the marriage of the Duchess of Qin Mu. This Baili Xi ran to the State of Chu soon after arriving in the State of Qin, who would have thought that Duke Mu heard that Baili Xi was talented and wanted to ransom him with heavy money, but he was worried that the State of Chu would not give it, so he sent someone to the King of Chu and said:

My dowry slave Baili Xi has fled here, please allow me to redeem him with five black ram skins. ”

In this way, 5 sheepskins were used to buy Baili Xi back, so this Baili Xi is also nicknamed "Wuli Xi (G, Gu) Doctor". Baili Xi really has great talents, and it took 7 years to let the Qin State rule and help Qin Mugong dominate the world.

As for Shang Ying, everyone is familiar with it, so I won't talk about it much. So in the eyes of the Qin people, Shang Ying is good, or Baili Xi is better, it is estimated that Shang Ying was also full of confidence when he asked, but the Qin people gave him a resounding slap in the face. Why?

Let's take a look at how this Qin man evaluated the difference between the two at that time.

This Qin man named Zhao Liang said: During Baili Xi's tenure as Qin Minister, he crusaded against Zheng State to the east, supported the monarch of Jin State three times, and sent troops to rescue Chu once; He carried out Dehua in the territory of Qin, and Ba came to pay tribute; He governed the princes with virtue, and the ethnic minorities from all over the world came to see him, and after Yu heard about it, he came from thousands of miles to knock on the door and defect. Moreover, Baili Xi is of noble character, does not take a car when tired, does not use an umbrella in the hot summer, walks around the country without an entourage of vehicles, and does not bring armed defense.

Finally, a summary is given: fame is hidden in the treasury, and virtue is applied to future generations.

And the evaluation of Shang Yang is much worse: as the minister of the Qin State and the state of Qin, he built a palace on a large scale without benefiting the people, which is not to talk about establishing a meritorious cause for the country. Punishing the prince's master and mutilating the people with harsh punishment is accumulating resentment and accumulating calamity.

In short, it was useless to say that Shang Ying's change was useless, and finally advised Shang Ying to leave quickly, otherwise there would be danger.

Others are still second, let Shang Ying leave quickly, it is indeed right, and then he was really split by Qin Hui Wang Che and died, the same is a change, why is Baili Xi so great in the eyes of the Qin people, and the Qin people are not interested in Shang Ying? This is probably because Shang Ying only made the country rich and the army strong, but he couldn't see the benefits for the common people, or was oppressed by the aristocracy, and Shang Ying's changes did not directly benefit the people, so the short-sighted people were not grateful to Shang Ying, but in the long run, he made the Qin State rise and laid the foundation for the Qin State to dominate the world in the future.

From the political aspect, during Baili Xi's tenure as Qin Xiang, he crusaded against Zheng Guo to the east, supported the monarch of Jin State three times, and sent troops to rescue Chu once. The evaluation of Shang Ying is to say that as the minister of Qin, he does not benefit the people, but builds a palace on a large scale. In terms of morality, Baili Xi implemented deification in the territory of Qin, and Ba came to pay tribute.

He ruled over the princes, and the ethnic minorities from all over the world came to the court. The evaluation of Shang Ying is not high, and he uses severe punishment to kill the people and accumulate resentment.

What Zhao Liang said was completely nonsense.

That conversation was like an old lady's footwrap - smelly and long. You know, at that time, the brush and paper had not yet been invented, and all the words had to be engraved on the bamboo slips word by word. How could such a long conversation be recorded in such a private meeting?

Who is making the record next to it? Moreover, if the content of your dialogue is very important, it is okay, I have read it several times, it is just some flowery and marginal rhetoric, and I have been talking for a long time, quoting a lot of famous quotes, which seems to be quite powerful, but it is just some nonsense, otherwise it is a personal attack on Shang Ying. In the end, Zhao Liang's suggestion to Shang Ying was to let Shang Ying resign.

This level of advice is also embarrassing to mention? Everyone can see that it is better to hold on to power, and once you hand over power, you will die faster!

According to Sima Qian's records, while Zhao Liang was talking nonsense, Shang Ying's performance was even more intriguing. Zhao Liang said that Shang Ying is not good, Shang Ying can come up with his own political achievements. You see, after Lao Tzu came to Qin, Qin suddenly changed from a weak country to a strong country, the road was not forgotten, there were no thieves in the mountains, and the people's living standards were significantly improved.

The common people are very happy, and I, Shang Ying, also personally led the troops to recover the lost territory for the Qin State. As long as these iron-clad facts are taken out, doesn't Zhao Liang have to shut up? I know all the things, but Shang Ying didn't know, he didn't take these ironclad evidence, and specifically talked about those little things, saying that before the Qin State, father and son lived in the same room, and he changed this Di Rong atmosphere, and then asked Zhao Liang, who is more virtuous between himself and Baili Xi.

doesn't use things like changing the law to force Qin and recovering lost land to justify himself, but specifically talks about these customs and habits, what kind of thing would a person like Shang Ying would do? Later, it was even more fake, and inexplicably pulled out Baili Xi, which gave Zhao Liang an excuse, and Zhao Liang immediately began to praise how virtuous Baili Xi was, saying how virtuous Baili Xi was, and then how immoral Shang Ying was. This is not a-for-tat debate at all!

Shang Ying was simply talking to Zhao Liang about cross talk, and he was willing to do Zhao Liang's praise! Praise Zhao Liang just right, have you ever seen such a debate? It's just a laughing person.