In Dream of Red Mansions , Ping er and Qiu Tong, who has a higher status?

Ping'er and Qiu Tong in "Dream of Red Mansions", on the surface, Qiu Tong's status is high, but in fact, Ping'er's status is higher.

Ping'er is just a maid in the room, but Qiu Tong is a real concubine, so only from the perspective of the names of the two people, Qiu Tong's status is indeed higher. And Qiu Tong was specially rewarded to him by Jia Lian's father Jia Yu, so that means Qiu Tong is more loved by the elders, so he is also a faceless person in Jiafu, so even if it is to express the respect of the elders, the people of Jiafu will respect Qiu Tong a little more.

But in addition to Qiu Tong's little bit of elders, her background is not particularly good, and she actually has no backers in Jiafu. But Ping'er is different, she is the dowry maid brought by Wang Xifeng from her mother's family, so she is the person Wang Xifeng trusts the most, Ping'er basically represents Wang Xifeng in Jiafu, so how Ping'er is treated also represents Wang Xifeng's face, so in Jiafu, everyone dare not offend Ping'er, and may have more respect for her than Qiu Tong.

Wang Xifeng, as Jia Lian's wife, naturally has a status in Jiafu, although Qiu Tong is a concubine and has a higher status than Ping'er. But Ping'er is Wang Xifeng's person, and it is obvious that Ping'er's status is also rubbing**, so you don't have to take Qiu Tong in your eyes at all. After all, the status of concubines in ancient times was also very low, and there was no way to compare with the status of the main wife.

Even if Ping'er doesn't have Jia Lian's love, at least she still has Wang Xifeng's backer to support her, so that she can live a good life in Jiafu. But once Qiu Tong loses Jia Lian's favor, then it can be said that he is isolated in Jiafu and has no backers. You can be kicked out of Jia at any time.

It can be seen from this that Ping'er's status is much higher than that of Qiu Tong.

Who has a higher status in "Dream of Red Mansions" Ping'er or Qiu Tong?

Different identities, different statuses, Ping'er is Jia Lian's roommate, and Qiu Tong is Jia Lian's concubine, it seems that Qiu Tong's status is higher.

Compared with Ping'er and Qiu Tong in "Dream of Red Mansions", Ping'er should have a higher status, because the ancestors all prefer Ping'er.

Whether Ping'er and Qiu Tong's real status is high or low is not whether Ping'er is a girl in the room, or whether Qiu Tong is Jia Yu's concubine, but the master behind them. The master behind Ping'er is Wang Xifeng, and Wang Xifeng is Jia Lian's wife, who can advance and retreat with Jia Lian and control the big and small things in Jia Lian's house. Moreover, Ping'er has been operating in the Grand View Garden for several years, which is incomparable to Qiutong. ”

This is a rather hesitant option, it stands to reason that Qiu Tong was assigned to his son Jia Lian by Jia Yu, and according to the theory of father and son, strict orders cannot be violated. From the facts at that time, it is estimated that Jia Lian is more emotionally inclined to Ping'er. Ping'er was originally Jia Lian's big girl and concubine.

What's more, Jia Lian knows that Ping'er's character is defeated, and even when Sister Feng is there, she treats Ping'er with deep feelings. Although Qiu Tong was pointed out by her father, there was no way to see how much Jia Lian liked her in the book, not to mention the gap between the second sister You, it was impossible for Jia Lian not to be resentful of her. Is the so-called trembling cow not telling the rough drinking water and pressing the head?

At the same time, Jia Yu later contracted tuberculosis and was anxious to need Jia Lian to take care of what happened before and after him. In view of the above reasons, I feel that Ping'er is more likely to be corrected, and I like Ping'er's kindness and virtuousness.

It should be Ping'er. Because Ping'er is Wang Xifeng's daughter. Qiu Tong is just the second daughter, and she is not qualified to inherit the family position.

According to the rules, Qiu Tong and Ping'er are actually not qualified to be corrected, and the one who should be corrected the most should be Second Sister You.

Although Second Sister You, Qiu Tong, and Ping'er are all Jia Lian's concubines, their identities are still different. Under such a hierarchical feudal etiquette system, the status of the concubine is not only much lower than that of the wife, but also because of the difference between the concubines, there is also an obvious difference in status and the distinction between high and low.

1. Second Sister You has the highest status According to the classics, ancient concubines were also divided into grades, and they could be divided into noble concubines, good concubines and cheap concubines according to their status. If it is related to the main room and relatives and relatives, it can be divided into concubines, side rooms, auxiliary rooms, partial rooms, partial rooms, accompanying rooms, concubines, concubines, through rooms, outer rooms, and foreign women. I have to say that there are so many doorways in this.

Among Jia Lian's three concubines, Second Sister You should still have a higher status than Qiu Tong and Ping'er, after all, she and Jia Lian worship heaven and earth and have a formal ceremony of marriage contract, while concubines don't need any ceremony. Seriously calculated, Jia Lian and Second Sister You are married, and Qiu Tong and Ping'er are concubines.

Second, Qiu Tong and Ping'er have a low status Qiu Tong was originally a maid by Jia Yu's side, and she had already met Jia Lian at that time, but Jia Lian never had a chance to start, and then by chance, Jia Yu gave her to Jia Lian, and the two were bound to have a strong relationship when they first got together, and they were like glue all day long. However, because she was given to Jia Lian by Jia Yu, she has a higher status than ordinary aunts, and it is because of this that she is so arrogant, and even often bullies Second Sister You who has a higher status than her.

And Ping'er has been Wang Xifeng's personal maid ring since she was a child, grew up with Wang Xifeng, and later came to Jiafu with Wang Xifeng as a dowry maid. For the sake of his virtuous name, and in order to cage Jia Lian's heart, Wang Xifeng forced Ping'er to be Jia Lian's room. On weekdays, he will also help Wang Xifeng deal with some affairs, and use his extremely high double business to help them mediate the balance, which has accumulated a lot of good popularity for Wang Xifeng.

In general, although the three are concubines, their status is still different, and this is a true reflection of that hierarchical era.

Second Sister You was married by Jia Lian on a whim, and her status is very low. Qiu Tong was actually given to Jia Lian by someone else, and his identity was just a girl's ring. Ping'er has a higher status than both of them, and has won the trust of Wang Xifeng and Jia Lian.

Second Sister You was born in a good family, and she was the stepsister of You Shi, the head of Ningguo Mansion, so she was certified by Jia's mother as Jia Lian's second room. belongs to a noble concubine, a good concubine, second only to his wife Wang Xifeng in terms of identity. Qiu Tong is the concubine that Jia Yu rewarded Jia Lian, because she was Jia Yu's maid and belonged to the lowly class.

One is what I like, the other is given by my father, and the other is brought by my wife, so I think Jia Lian should still prefer Second Sister You.

Among the three of them, Ping'er has the highest status, and she is still Wang Xifeng's maid. Qiu Tong is slightly lower, as for Second Sister You, she has the least status, but she is just a person brought back by Jia Lian from outside, and she is bullied in the house.

Legally, Qiu Tong is higher than Ping'er, but sometimes a person's status depends on his strength and has nothing to do with his reputation. The girl in the room has the lowest status among the concubines in the family, and she is called a concubine or a girl, and it is Wang Xifeng's private property. Only after the promotion of the aunt (concubine, concubine) will there be legal (family hair) protection and family status.

Ping'er is a girl in the room, and her status is very low. However, because of Wang Xifeng's status, no one dares to underestimate her, a real powerful person. It's a pity that she couldn't be promoted to her aunt, once Wang Xifeng is suspended, Ping'er is destined to go with Wang Xifeng and can't stay in the Jia family.

Qiu Tong was given by her parents, and she was taken over as a concubine and aunt. A large part of the concubines of the ancients were given by their parents and elders, for example, Jia Zheng said that he was optimistic about the two girls and wanted to give Jia Baoyu and Jia Huan; Jia's mother is optimistic that Qingwen will give Jia Baoyu; Mrs. Wang is optimistic about the promotion of her prospective aunt, which is all given by her parents. The difference is that Jia Baoyu is young and can't take a concubine, so she can only delay, Qiu Tong doesn't need it.

Among them, Second Sister You has the highest status, because she is the concubine who is welcoming into Jiafu, and she is pregnant. It's Ping'er and Qiu Tong again, but because Ping'er is Wang Xifeng's right-hand man, everyone will respect Ping'er a little.

Personally, I think their status must be different, after all, each of them has a different relationship with Jia Lian, which is why there is such a situation.

You must choose one is Ping'er, Ping'er is a maid to marry, but she is also considered innocent, and her body deed is in the hands of Wang Xifeng, she can be destroyed at any time to become a woman from a good family, and Qiutong's background is not as good as Ping'er.

Wang Xifeng was divorced, and Ping'er followed him back to Wang's house. It can only be that Qiu Tong is righted. Besides, Mrs. Jia and Xing don't like Ping'er.

Ping'er, needless to say, has a relationship with Jia Lian, and Ping'er is more like a housewife than Qiu Tong, and she is very good to both the upper and lower levels.

Of course, it's Ping'er, Qiutong, and it's old.

If Jiafu is still very brilliant, Jia Lian will only hire the daughter of the low door to come back as a successor outside, and Qiu Tong and Ping'er are not qualified to be corrected, such as Mrs. Xing.