The influence of Heshen on the Qianlong Dynasty was great or disadvantageous?

It's hard to say, it's just a personal opinion to guess something like this that didn't happen.

If you want me to say that whether it is good or bad, it depends on which angle you look at, and it is said that Li Hongzhang is the biggest traitor, but there is also a desirable side to him. Heshen, how much money did you say he was greedy Didn't Jiaqing go up and be confiscated I didn't see where the money was going. Isn't it still declining This is the inevitable development of history I think He Shen has to do things at least, no matter how difficult it is, at that time, there were still people to help him, this is where his success is left to Liu Yong, and he has made a lot of contributions to the development of the Qing Dynasty.

In the wheel of historical development, no one can stop it, and we can only talk about the problem of loyalty to the monarch at that time, if a country is controlled by one person, do you want to say how much development is possible? It is said that the things of the predecessors are the teachers of the future, and you can only consider the problem with the thoughts of your ancestors For example, how was Kangxi's ban on the sea opened in the Qing Dynasty.

Whether the pros outweigh the disadvantages or the disadvantages outweigh the pros I say it doesn't matter, the history of the Qing Dynasty is doomed.

The big disadvantage is that the momentum of the Qing Dynasty's already declining has accelerated.

Overall, Qianlong used and Shen.

Because He Shen gave what Ji Xiaolan didn't have, how can He Shen say it. Patting sycophants is never direct, not public, always when the emperor needs it most and doesn't know what to do, I think this is the reason why Heshen is really favored. The emperor is indispensable to capable people like Ji Xiaolan, but it is also indispensable to people like He Shen who know what the emperor really wants, and it can be said that the two play a complementary role.

The emperor is also a human being, and he can't talk about his family and country every day, he also needs to relax...

He will flatter you and wish you good luck and remember to give a little more thank you.

Qianlong didn't kill He Shen, in order to give his son a tool to establish power at the beginning of his ascension to the throne, and he made an appointment to spoil him, the more he could make him greedy, and the more cool Jiaqing would be when he copied it.

Just like the current public security rule in black and white, let the boss help take care of the younger brother outside. There seem to be very few bad things in China, and there are basically unorganized individuals who can be caught committing crimes.

Personal opinion:

Although Qianlong was a good emperor, he was far from the first emperor of the ages. Qianlong made great efforts in the early stage and then had a prosperous era, but most of the so-called prosperous times were also blown out by historians.

Qianlong reigned for 60 years and served as the emperor for another 4 years. In these 64 years, no one can do it wholeheartedly. Qianlong after the middle and late stages had a lot of desires, but he wanted to be an emperor through the ages, and he couldn't say what he wanted to enjoy, which was born of Heshen.

The emperor didn't think of it, not to mention that He Shen did it, and He Shen, who the emperor couldn't think of, also did it. All the things that hurt Qianlong's evaluation and Shen did it for the emperor without a sound, and Qianlong could only enjoy it aggrievedly, and the infamy was all given to He Shen.

Qianlong wanted history to leave his reputation of being the country in everything and always putting the people first, but he didn't want to treat himself as an emperor, so He Shen was so favored.