Why is Liu Bei s territory so big, but he can t restore the Han Dynasty?

<> is not mainly about the size of the land, but about how to win the whole country.

Liu Bangduo's main focus in the whole country is to collect troops to seize Guanzhong, and then go out from the east of Guandong to seize the whole country, so it is said that without the support of Guanzhong, there would be no peace between Liu Bang and Xiang Yu and Chu and Han, let alone victory. Hanzhong, Bashu or anything is not the main thing, due to the convenient transportation, others can't play, I can't play.

Because Liu Bei has Jingzhou, he has a way to come in and fight, and it seems that Guanzhong in the north is not so important. According to the concept of the group, Liu Bei should be after seizing Shu, and go north to occupy the relevant center steadily, which is the real unification strategy. Although Shu is large, it can only be entrenched, and it cannot be used as the basis for unification.

Whether Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition was to seize Guanzhong, the Three Kingdoms have not seen much, and it is not well evaluated. That is, it did not achieve a steady and steady possession, but tried to seize Chang'an in one fell swoop. The mountain areas of Guanzhong and Shu felt that they could only encroach on Guanzhong.

The reason why Liu Bang was able to seize Guanzhong quickly was mainly because Zhang Han and the other three did not have the support of the Guanzhong people because of their rebellion against Qin.

If you're tired of watching, let's have a joke to make you happy:

How much is 1+1?

During the arithmetic class, the teacher asked the imbecile Xiaojun, "What is 1+1?" ”

Xiaojun thought for a moment and replied, "Teacher! I do not know. ”

The teacher was furious and said, "You're such a rice bucket!" I can't even figure out the subject. I ask you again: How much shall I add you, for example? ”

Xiaojun said: "I know this, two rice buckets." ”

First: It depends on Liu Bei's employment and work.

may be in the eyes of the people of Dawn, Liu Bei is a Ming lord, the most benevolent among all the monarchs of the Three Kingdoms, but the real Liu Bei is fake benevolence, under Liu Bei's hands, there are many capable people, including Wolong and Phoenix Chicks, Five Tiger Generals, ......

But many of these people have not been reused, Feng Xiao was ignored by Liu Bei because of her appearance, and she did not give full play to her talents; Ma Chao and Zhao Yun were not reused by Liu Bei; Huang Zhong has always been looked down upon by Guan Yu ......If Liu Bei leads the relationship between the subordinates and doesn't care about the general's life experience, I'm afraid he won't end up like this in the end.

Second: the loss of Jingzhou.

Jingzhou is the beginning of the destruction of Shu, the loss of Jingzhou all depends on Liu Bei's protection of Guan Yu, there would have been better generals to guard Jingzhou, but because of the relationship between brothers, let the arrogant Guan Yu guard Jingzhou, so Zhuge Liang's "Longzhong pair" lost its core.

After losing Jingzhou, Zhuge Liang has been using his own ability to make up for this shortcoming, but no matter how much he makes up for it, in the end, it only delays the deadline for the destruction of his country.

Liu Bang only has Hanzhong, and Liu Bei's territory is much larger", which is not accurate. In fact, Liu Bei and Liu Bang's territory is about the same. When Xiang Yu divided the world, Liu Bang was named the king of Han, and his fief was in the Bashu area.

Zhang Liang acquired Xiang Bo and sought Hanzhong County for Liu Bang. Liu Bang owned Hanzhong and Bashu in this way.

Judging from the territorial area alone, Liu Bang's Korea is not a small country, and Liu Bei's Shu Han is not much larger than Liu Bang's Korea. The two regimes can be said to be evenly matched.

In the end, Liu Bang successfully escaped from Bashu and finally unified the whole country, Liu Bei was completely trapped in Bashu, and he did not unify the world in his life. Why can Liu Bang dominate the world, but Liu Bei and his descendants can't prosper the Han Dynasty?

The reason why Liu Bei and his descendants (later called Liu Bei) were unable to prosper the Han dynasty can be attributed to their lack of strength and the strength of the enemy. Liu Bang and Liu Bei lived in very different environments.

When Liu Bang was the king of Hanzhong, there were more than a dozen princes at that time. There were three kings in the Guanzhong region, known as the Three Qins in history. Xiang Yu was the strongest prince in the world, but he was far away from the Guanzhong region.

Liu Bang is the first person in the history of our country to start a "grassroots" business and finally complete the imperial hegemony, and the Han Dynasty established after the Qin Dynasty can be said to be a historical miracle that lasted for more than 400 years.

Liu Bang's strength was not strong when he built the army, he was oppressed by Xiang Yu and other princes, after Liu Bang won the land of Hanzhong, he further destroyed Xiang Yu and created the Han Dynasty, the reason why Liu Bei did not complete Liu Bang's feat is not that his personal ability is not as good as Liu Bang, but the situation in the world at that time was different.

At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, when the Han Dynasty building was tilted, Liu Bei, the descendant of the Liu family, angrily raised troops to restore the glory of the Han Dynasty. He also occupied Hanzhong militarily throughout his life, and the territory in his hands was far more than Liu Bang at that time, why did he fail to realize the plan to counterattack the Central Plains?

When the time came, Liu Bei and Liu Bang were both in a period of great chaos in the world, Liu Bang was lucky, but Liu Bei's luck was always burdened. When Liu Bang became a big prince, Liu Bei was still a deserter, so Liu Bei didn't have much savings.

Mainly because Liu Bei's territory is too scattered. If you want to attack a country, you basically can't concentrate all the troops in these areas.

Because the opponents they faced were different, Liu Bei faced very strong opponents, so he did not succeed in recovering Han.

First of all, in terms of national strength, Liu Bang is stronger than Liu Bei, and secondly, there is a big gap between the two for opponents, Liu Bei is facing Cao Wei's forces, and his troops are strong, while Cao Wei is facing only Liu Bei and Sun Quan.

Liu Bei could not return to Han because the enemy country was too strong, and his own strength was too weak, and Liu Bang occupied Hanzhong and could compete for the world because his own strength was strong and had the opportunity to develop and grow, and there were many talents.

Liu Bei is the peak of strength after seizing Hanzhong, at this time Liu Bei still has half of Jingzhou, and his subordinates have accumulated troops in the past, and at the same time there are some people and horses obtained from Xichuan and Hanzhong, but after the battle of Yiling, Liu Bei's power is not as good as before, because Guan Yu was defeated in Jingzhou before, coupled with the defeat of the Battle of Yiling, a large number of elite troops under Liu Bei were lost, and his own subordinates also died in the past few years, and Shu Han entered the stage of green and yellow. And his opponent Cao Cao occupies the richest place in the whole territory, although the battle of Chibi and the battle of Hanzhong have losses, but it is not unacceptable, and Sun Quan has been steadily developed for many years, and has obtained half of Jingzhou, the national strength of the two countries is stronger than Shu, and then the three kingdoms entered a period of peaceful development, and the gap between Wei and Shu is naturally getting bigger and bigger, and under various predicaments, Liu Bei has not succeeded.

Liu Bang also occupied Hanzhong, but Liu Bei's situation was different. Liu Bei's opponents were Wei and Wu, two countries with very large land areas, and their strength was above Liu Bei. And among Liu Bang's opponents, only Xiang Yu is stronger than him, and when Liu Bang and Xiang Yu compete for dominance in the world, there are other princes at the same time, some of these princes are united and some are hostile, this is Liu Bang's opportunity, he exterminated other small princes step by step, and united some princes to attack Xiang Yu, the strength continued to grow during this period, and Liu Bei did not have such an opportunity, when he established the foundation of Shu, Wu and Wei had already established the basic plate, and when many princes fought in the past, Liu Bei's power is still very weak, and after Liu Bei lost Jingzhou, he could only occupy Hanzhong to develop, and he could not compare with Liu Bang.

Liu Bang's subordinates also have more talents than Liu Bei, and Liu Bang's subordinates are full of talents, which is enough to compete with Xiang Yu. And Liu Bei's subordinates also had a lot of talents in the past, but after Liu Bei established the Shu State, many of Liu Bei's subordinates have grown old, and most of his subordinates have died, in the battle of Yiling, Liu Bei focused on cultivating a large number of talents who died in the battle of Yiling, such as Ma Liang, the battle of Yiling, the blow to Liu Bei's forces is not only in terms of troops, if there are so many talents in the late Shu Han Dynasty, maybe it will not be so easy to be seconds, after all, there is no general in Shu, and Chunyuan Sui Liao turned into a vanguard. Liu Bang has Xiao He, Zhang Liang, Han Xin and other talents, plus Liu Bang also has the emperor's tolerance and ambition, and he was repeatedly defeated in the battle with Xiang Yu, and finally won the world.

He told Jian because Liu Bei's ability was not very strong, and he began to slump after experiencing the failure of the Northern Expedition, but Liu Bang thought that victory and defeat were a common thing in soldiers.

Because Liu Bei was hindered by Sun Quan and Cao Cao at that time, Liu Bang was the only one in his time, and Xiang Yu was a fool.

At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, a three-legged Huaijian situation was formed, and the reason why Liu Bei failed was because of the situation. And the reason why Liu Bang was able to establish the Han Dynasty was because Liu Bang had a unique talent to know and dislike.

Because the geographical location of this place is relatively special, there are more talents in this place, the food in this place is more sufficient, and then the regional culture is relatively rich, it is an important place for military dependents, and if you want to fight for this place, you need to cross the Qinling Mountains and the Huai River, this place is very important to the Shu Kingdom, for example, the war in Hanzhong is a relatively big test of the strength of both sides.

Because in Liu Bei's era, agriculture in Hanzhong was the most developed, and Hanzhong could occupy a place. Well, you don't have to worry about your own military, food, supplies.

Because the resources in this region are relatively good, and there are many talents, food, and a good geographical location.

Because Liu Bei claimed to be a descendant of the Han Dynasty, he could only continue the Han Dynasty, not the Han Dynasty, after all, the founder of the Han Dynasty was Liu Bang, and if Liu Bei founded the Han Dynasty, it would be tantamount to admitting that the Han Dynasty founded by Liu Bang had completely perished.

When Liu Bei founded the country, the country name he typed was "Han", but in order to distinguish it from the previous Han Dynasty, we called the Han Dynasty established by Liu Bei "Shu Han".

The Han Dynasty was founded by Liu Bang. And Liu Bei is a descendant of Liu Bang. In this way, it was impossible for Liu Bei to establish the Han Dynasty again.

There are basically 3 reasons for this:

Liu. First: the basis is different.

Liu Bang was named the king of Hanzhong by Xiang Yu, and at that time Hanzhong was occupied by the Qin State during the Qin Huigong period, until Liu Bang was named the king of Hanzhong here, there has been no major war, and it has been operated by the Qin State for 300 years, with a good foundation; <>

Liu Bei's king of Hanzhong was sealed by himself after capturing Hanzhong, so that Hanzhong was damaged by the war, and then Cao Cao moved all the people in the area he controlled at that time, so the Hanzhong occupied by Liu Bei can almost be said to be a scorched earth, and the foundation is too poor.

Second: external factors.

At that time, Liu Bang was divided into three after Xiang Yu's sub-feudal Guanzhong region, and the Central Plains was also divided into feudal countries, so that the forces were dispersed, and there was also Xiang Yu's capital Pengcheng, which was too far away from Hanzhong, so no one would attack Hanzhong, and he could rest assured that he would march to Guanzhong;

Liu Bei At this time, Cao Cao had occupied the entire Guanzhong, the north and the Central Plains, and the forces were concentrated together, Cao Cao set the capital of Xuchang, and had been building Luoyang, and wanted to set the capital Luoyang, which was close to Hanzhong, so the capital Hanzhong was easy to be attacked by Cao Cao.

Third: the people's hearts are back.

After Liu Bang invaded Guanzhong, he made three chapters of the law to pacify the Guanzhong area, and Xiang Yu had a notoriety of killing and surrendering before entering the pass, and after entering the pass, he killed the prince of Qin, and the people of Guanzhong hated him very much, and the three kings of Guanzhong were set up by him, and he was a general, unpopular, so Liu Bang had the support of the people in the Guanzhong area;

Liu Bei never occupied Guanzhong, and Cao Cao eliminated the war in Guanzhong, pacified the people, and won the hearts of the people, so Liu Bei did not have the support of the people in the Guanzhong area.

Because Hanzhong was damaged by the war at that time, it can also be said that it was a scorched earth at that time. The second is because if you settle in Hanzhong, you will be vulnerable to Cao Cao's invasion. Liu Bei actually did not occupy the pass, it was Cao Cao who eliminated the hidden dangers and was deeply loved by the people.

Because Hanzhong belonged to Cao Cao's territory at that time, and Liu Bei's strength was not Cao Cao's opponent at all, Liu Bei could not settle in Hanzhong.

may be because he doesn't have the ability to fight in Hanzhong, so he can't learn from Liu Bang and set the capital in Hanzhong.

Because the terrain of Hanzhong is flat, it is not conducive to defense, while Sichuan is easy to defend and difficult to attack.