The problem between Guan Yu and Kong Ming, the relationship between Guan Yu and Zhuge Liang

Have you forgotten Zhuge Liang's Longzhong, right?

If Cao Cao died, the north would inevitably be in chaos, and then Eastern Wu would be able to take the opportunity to attack the north and expand its territory; At that time, Liu Bei was weak, but he wanted to protect himself, and he didn't have the strength to expand his territory. When the power of Eastern Wu was large, the next one to be eliminated was Liu Bei; As long as Cao Cao does not die, Liu Bei will have a glimmer of life, and Dongwu will not dare to act rashly. So it's good for the world.

As for Zhuge Liang and sending Guan Yu to collect it, he wanted to take this opportunity to subdue Guan Yu.

This is my personal opinion, just for reference, because I am not Zhuge Liang.

This is **, not to be taken seriously.

** is an artistic creation, usually using history to invent a story to express an idea or point of view. In this story of "catching and releasing Cao", Luo Guanzhong wants to show the three characters to all the officials (readers):

1.Guan Yu --- righteousness (this is the underworld and the white way can be eaten, later, Guan Yu was named the "martial saint" by the emperor, and was respected by the Qinghong Gang as the "second master of Guan" who burns incense every day).

2.Kong Ming --- clever calculation (this is the essence of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", the most attractive place).

3.Cao Cao --- rigid, suspicious, and unlucky ("Romance of the Three Kingdoms" has damaged him too much, but in history, he is precisely the strongest).

It is precisely because these non-historical characters are so vividly described that "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" attracts all the officials (readers).

In fact, there is no such thing as Guan Yuyi interpreting Cao Cao in history

But it is not difficult to explain the plot in **.

A very important point, a few people upstairs have mentioned that for the implementation of the three-point world, and Cao Cao is one of the protagonists of the three-point world, the protagonist of the north. Without Cao Cao, it would be impossible to implement the three-point world.

There is also a reason to release Cao Cao, from the actions of the Cao army later, it is obvious that they think that the battle of Chibi was defeated by Zhou Yu, ignoring the role of Liu Beijun, in fact, it is also the case, the main battle of Chibi is the two armies of Sun Quanjun and Cao Cao's army are fighting. Liu Bei, as the commander of Liu's army, did not command the army in his own army, but was a spectator in Zhou Yu's barracks. Under such a premise, another Guan Yu will explain Cao Cao, and Cao Cao will be even more hostile to Eastern Wu and downplay the role of Liu Jun in the Battle of Chibi.

The Battle of Chibi said that it was Cao's army against Sun Liu's coalition army, but Liu's role was far less important than Sun's army. Zhuge Liang did this, and Cao Jun ignored Liu Jun's role in Chibi.

Cao Cao could not die at that time, and if he died, the north would be in chaos, which was not conducive to the policy of dividing the world designed by Zhuge Liang.

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is **, and the credibility is not 100%.There's a lot of fiction in it.

Everyone thinks that the contradiction in the relationship between Guan Yu and Zhuge Liang is mainly in the Battle of Fancheng, saying that they borrowed a knife to kill people, and they did not destroy and dismantle them.

Back then, Liu Bei took Huang Zhong and Pang Tong to attack Liu Zhang, and after Pang Tong was killed, Zhuge Liang took Zhao Yun and Zhang Fei to support, leaving Guan Yu to guard Fancheng, many people think that Zhao Yun was left, why? Because Zhao Yun is brave and strategic, calm and calm, he is the best candidate, he should not choose Guan Yu, in fact, it is Liu Bei's intention to let Guan Yu guard Fancheng, why keep Guan Yu and not Zhao Yun? 1, Liu Bei doesn't trust Zhao Yun, when he sealed the Five Tigers, Zhao Yun was a miscellaneous general, it can be seen that it won't be Jingzhou's strategy to be handed over to a distrustful person to guard, 2, to defend Jingzhou, you must know the navy, and Guan Yu will be the navy, when the battle of Changbanpo was the battle, Guan Yu and Liu Qi brought 20,000 sailors to respond, so Guan Yu is the best candidate.

Next, we will discuss the cherry blossom disturbance battle of Fancheng, Guan Yu besieged Fancheng and did not get Liu Bei's order, but he also did not get any objections, that is, Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang acquiesced to Guan Yu, and after that, Guan Yu flooded the Seventh Army, captured in the forbidden beheading Pang De and other news persuaded Liu Bei to his ears, Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang were of course very happy, why Zhuge Liang was happy, one is to correspond to his Longzhong countermeasures, that is, Liu Bei prescribed from Yizhou Second, he sent a general to set off from Jingzhou, and the great cause can be achieved, 2, Zhuge Liang is sincerely serving Liu Bei Group, Of course, I hope that Liu Beijun will have a great cause, even if he has grievances with Guan Yu, he will not ruin Liu Bei's group because of personal grievances, you must know that Guan Yu is guarding a strategic place. There are also people who say why Liu Bei Zhuge Liang didn't come to the rescue, when it was all good and stingy to the ears of Liu Bei's group, suddenly came a Guan Yu lost Jingzhou, defeated Maicheng, and died at the hands of Dongwu, Liu Bei didn't have time to prepare, let alone support, Liu Bei of course was unwilling to lose a strategic place and a general, so he sent troops to attack Dongwu, and finally Yiling was defeated, 750,000 troops were destroyed, and Liu Xiansong Zaobei Group has fallen behind since then.

Zhuge Liang did not frame Guan Yu. Guan Yu died when he was defeated by Maicheng, and was framed by Wu Guo. And Zhuge Liang knew Guan Yu's loyalty, so Liu Bei ordered Guan Yu to guard Jingzhou, Guan Yu fell into the trap of Cao Cao and Wu Guo because of his pride, lost Jingzhou, and defeated Maicheng.

After Guan Yu was captured by Cao Cao, Cao Cao cherished his talent and specially sent Zhang Liao as a lobbyist to persuade Guan Yu to surrender. After some good talk, Guan Yu agreed with Cao Cao on three things:

1. Emphasizing that he surrendered to Emperor Xian of Han instead of Cao Cao;

2. You must not treat your two sisters-in-law badly;

3. As soon as there is news of his brother Liu Bei, thousands of mountains and rivers will be pursued.

After that, Cao Cao entertained all kinds of delicious food and drink, and did this as a prisoner, which shows that Guan Erye is indeed a talent.

First of all, one thing is certain: Liu Bei Kongming could not kill Guan Yu.

One reason is enough:

Liu Bei's greatest ideal was to eliminate Cao Cao and Sun Quan, but at that time, he was not in a position to eliminate either side. Unless Liu Bei has a strong enough army and military talents, he will use troops against Cao Cao and Sun Quan respectively. Otherwise, if you use troops against one side, will the other side sit and watch the play?

You must know that at that time, the three were all eyeing each other and waiting for an opportunity. After Guan Yu's death, Liu Bei ignored the reality and everyone's opposition (except for Zhang Fei), commanded the soldiers of the country, drove the expedition in person, and swore to wash the Eastern Wu bloodied to avenge his brother. In fact, this war was wrong, and the fact that it was lost in the end also proves it.

It can be deduced from this: since Liu Bei had the intention of killing Guan Yu, why did he launch a war to take revenge? Don't say he's acting, is there such an acting?

The price is also very big, and it indirectly puts a small life into it. From this analysis, it is enough to show that Liu Bei will never kill Guan Yu.

Many friends are asking: Why didn't Kong Ming go out with the army in such a big war as the crusade against Eastern Wu?

Answer: Judging from the war scene, it is grandiose, but Kong Ming's mind is quite clear, Liu Bei can defeat the Eastern Wu is the best, even if he can't conquer the Eastern Wu, it is a big deal to retreat. The real threat was Cao Cao, so Kong Ming had to stay on guard against Cao Cao.

Cao Cao has experienced Kong Ming's power many times, and he is very afraid of him, so as long as Kong Ming stays behind, Cao Cao will not dare to act rashly.

Liu Bei Zhuge Liang has a reason to harm Guan Yu, but I don't know if he did it or not.