Are Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang responsible for Guan Yu s death?

Absolutely responsible! And the responsibility is not small! From the loss of Guan Yu Jingzhou to the defeat of Maicheng, for a long time, Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei must have known about this matter, it stands to reason that they should express it to Sun Quan, or send reinforcements to help Guan Yu, you must know that Liu Bei's army, which was closest to Guan Yu at that time, was only less than half a day's journey Zhuge Liang obviously knew that Liu Feng and Guan Yu had a gap!

Besides, it is clearly recorded in the history books that Guan Yu has never been to Liu Bei in his life, that is, Chengdu, the capital of Shu Han! What does this mean?! Therefore, Guan Yu's death has a lot to do with Liu Bei and Kong Ming!

Neither of them was responsible, and the heavy responsibility of guarding Jingzhou had no second choice in Liu Bei's camp at that time except for Guan Yu. Guan Yu has followed Liu Bei on the road since he mixed around, like Zhang Fei, he is the oldest, in China, which pays attention to seniority, he goes to sit in this position, and others are unlikely to gossip; And in terms of ability, he is almost perfect, in the years when he guarded Jingzhou, Guan Yu can almost be said to have reached the peak of his life, at that age, his experience is rich enough, he is more experienced in dealing with people and things, and dealing with emergencies is already relatively sophisticated; He has been in battle for a long time and has mastered enough experience in commanding the army and governing the army, he treats the soldiers well, has a good relationship with the grassroots officers and soldiers, and the soldiers are willing to serve him, in Jingzhou, a territory where forces are intertwined, it is unimaginable without a group of loyal subordinates, and the life in the land of Jingchu, which is crisscrossed by lakes and rivers, seems to have made him more capable of commanding the navy; He is familiar with the Spring and Autumn Period, he is familiar with righteousness and reasoning, has a certain academic foundation, and does administrative work, which may be slightly insufficient compared to professional civil officials, but it should not be too bad, and it is much stronger than ordinary generals. Although there may be a decline in martial arts, after all, when people are middle-aged, they can't be compared with young people like Zhao Yun and Ma Chao, and the emaciated camel is bigger than the horse, and the title of "Ten Thousand Enemies" is not apocryphal, but has its name.

There is also his fame, just the word Guan Yu has a certain appeal and deterrence, such a big man is sitting in Jingzhou, whether it is a soldier or a civilian, he will probably feel at ease, right? Moreover, the enemy is afraid of prestige, and does not dare to attack easily. His only flaw is that he is "disrespectful to the doctor", and his death can only be attributed to his failure to deal with these people he hates, which is a personality problem and has nothing to do with others.

Guan Yu seems to have a lingering dislike for the bureaucracy in his bones, and the so-called "arrogance" he is criticized for is only revealed in front of these people, so Guan Yu is not a red-faced man who is coaxed by cowhides, and his pride is for those he hates.

Zhuge Liang had no responsibility, because Zhuge Liang's official title at that time was only "military general", equivalent to Liu Bei's "big housekeeper", and his responsibilities were mainly administrative, civil affairs, not military politics, and Guan Yu launched the Xiangfan War, Zhuge Liang had no right to manage, and Guan Yu also destroyed his strategic deployment and lost Jingzhou, and Guan Yu's death was related to his own arrogance and willfulness, and also related to Liu Bei, Liu Bei let Guan Yu go too far, and was finally killed by Ma Zhong or Pan Zhang.

are all responsible. Liu Bei employed nepotism and did not send Zhao Yun there. Zhuge Liang knew that Guan Yu was too arrogant to be so useful, but he didn't try to persuade him.

Yes, on the premise of understanding Guan Yu's character flaws, he did not send someone to control him, which led to Guan Yu rashly sending troops to Fancheng, and finally died of defeat.

No, Guan Yu was killed by Sun Quan, because Guan Yu was proud later, lost Jingzhou, and the tiger fell to Pingchuan, and was killed by Sun Quan's father and son.

Zhuge Liang has, he should know that Second Brother Guan can't keep it. Liu Bei also has it, so it's time to help Second Brother Guan with the funeral.

If there is no responsibility, blame Guan Yu for being too arrogant!

Yes! How to say that it is also Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang asked Guan Yu to go to Jingzhou.

As everyone knows, it is said that it is a helpless move to stay in Jingzhou and guard Jingzhou.

Liu Bei, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhuge Liang's order of death ranking: Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang.

Guan Yu (160 220 years), the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, Guan Yu surrounded Xiangfan, Cao Cao sent Yu Ban to reinforce him, Guan Yu captured Yu Ban, beheaded Pang De, and shocked Huaxia, Cao Cao had wanted to move the capital to avoid its sharpness. Later, Cao Cao sent Xu Huang to reinforce, and Lü Meng of Eastern Wu attacked Jingzhou again, Guan Yu suffered from the enemy on his back, lost Jingzhou, was captured by Pan Zhang's department, and was killed in Linfang.

Zhang Fei (c. 165-221), because of his violence and lack of kindness, was killed by his generals Fan Qiang and Zhang Da.

Liu Bei (June 10, 161, 223), the third year of Zhangwu (223), died of illness in the White Emperor City, at the age of sixty-three, called Emperor Zhaolie, the temple name Liezu, buried in Huiling.

Zhuge Liang (181-October 8, 234), due to overwork, died of illness in the 12th year of Shu Jianxing (234) in Wuzhangyuan (now in Qishan, Baoji, Shaanxi), at the age of 54. Liu Chan posthumously named him the Marquis of Zhongwu, and later generations often called Zhuge Liang as the Marquis of Wu.