How much do you think there is a difference between punishing and disciplining a child?

I think there is a big difference, punishing a child because the child has done something wrong, or because the parent is unhappy with the child, and disciplining the child is to make the child meet the needs of development or to conform to the values that the parent thinks.

I think the difference is not small, because the reasons for punishment and disciplining children are different, punishment usually comes from parents' feelings of frustration and despair, and disciplining children is more than parents' hopes for their children.

The difference between the two is not a star and a half, first of all, the means of discipline include punishment, when I punish my child, I am disciplining him a process, so punishing the child is only a part of the content of discipline.

These two education methods reflect the cultural literacy of parents, generally parents with quality discipline children, and parents who don't know anything will punish their children, so the difference between discipline and punishment is quite big.

When I'm educating a child, there's a huge difference between punishment and discipline, punishment is my intervention, it's reprimanding the offense to the child, and discipline is the focus on teaching the child new skills.

I think these are two completely different ways of education, discipline is to educate the child in a way that he can accept, which is more useful, but punishing the child will not accept it at all, but will make him afraid of me.

Discipline is not the same as punishment, and the way I educate children is usually discipline rather than punishment, because discipline does not hurt children, and punishment sometimes hurts children.

There is a huge difference between these two methods, in the process of educating my children, I mostly use discipline and rarely use punishment, because I think discipline is useful, and punishment often does not achieve the desired effect.

Personally, I think that punishing children is a small-scale concept, which refers to the beating and scolding education of children after they make mistakes, and discipline focuses on training children to learn from mistakes and find a good way to solve problems.

In my view, discipline is divided into management and education, and the focus is on education, and punishment is mainly to make the child remember the impression, and does not let him associate with the inability.

In many family educations, parents will set a lot of rules for their children, and children will be punished accordingly if they violate them. Over time, many parents have found that it is effective for their children to be punished for obedience when they are young. But as they get older, the children become disgusted and the effect of punishment becomes less and less.

This is a lot of parents who think that punishing their children is disciplining him, and they are often prone to make such mistakes.

In fact, this is completely wrong, and there is a fundamental difference between "punishment" and "punishment". Rules are not made to restrict children, but to benefit them. Rules are not always meant to punish children, but to allow children to be disciplined well.

The difference between punishment and punishment is reflected in the following aspects: talk about the difference between "punishment" and "punishment" in family education.

The purpose is different, punishment is only to punish the child for some wrong behavior, no matter what method parents use, it is to stop the child's current wrong behavior. After the child is punished, he or she knows that he is in pain or resistant. Discipline is training children from their mistakes in the long run, not only helping to correct them, but also telling them the right way to mature them.

The focus is different. > parents who impose punishment focus on their children's past mistakes, and parents who impose punishment hope that their children will behave correctly in the future. The attitude is different. Parents are emotional when it comes to punishing their children.

It was a time of hostility and frustration. It is disappointing to think that the child is challenging the authority of the parents, or to think that the child is useless at all.

Discipline is different, and parents replace all kinds of complex feelings such as anger and disappointment with love. The approach is different. Punishment is often to insult the child or do something they don't want to do, while punishment is to guide the child to replace the child with his own good behavior.

Children have different emotions. The child's immediate response to punishment is fear and anger, and the child who is being disciplined still has a sense of security.

Therefore, parents are especially reminded not to punish their children in anger and to discipline calmly.

The main difference between punishment and discipline is that punishment is a form of discipline that commits a mistake of principle and is relatively made. Discipline is to play a role in teaching by word and deed in ordinary times.

There is a big difference between punishment and discipline in the child's education, punishment is to punish the child for having done wrong, and discipline is to restrain him before he has done wrong.

The difference is still relatively large, general punishment, it will cause serious pressure and impact on the child's psychology, and this way can not achieve the effect of education, and then discipline can restrain the child's behavior, and the child will also respond positively.

The difference is very big, because the punishment is very different for the child, and the child will be very scared in his heart, and the harm to the child is great.

For the sake of discipline. Children, many parents are using punishment to achieve their goals. But later, Yu Qinyu found that there would be a lot of problems in this way, which was the difference between punishment and discipline. So how big is the difference between punishment and discipline?

OnePunishment and disciplineEssential differences

1. The essence of discipline is to guide, and to let children go to the right track through guidance. This is a way for children to understand where the mistakes are, to understand why they can't do it, to better understand and to avoid the same mistakes next time. It can make the children retain good judgment and decision-making, and can make them realize what kind of mistakes have occurred in their behavior.

2. The essence of punishment is to counter violence with violence, which is to educate children in a very simple and rough way of education, and tell children through suppressive education that this way is wrong, but it does not tell children that it is wrong, why can't it be done? What to do if you encounter the same problem. In this way, the child will become more and more rebellious because of the child's negative emotions.

If it is not alleviated, it will only make their negative emotions accumulate more and more. Many children are not able to learn the correct behavior from the punishment, and the children accept the punishment only to carry the majesty of their parents and cannot resist. <>

2. The final result of punishment is different from that of discipline

1. Discipline can not only make the parent-child relationship between each other more intimate, but also give the child other positive role models. The key is to let children reflect on their own wrong behaviors, which plays a positive role in promoting children's growth. Every child grows up in the process of making mistakes, and the most important thing about how to correct these mistakes is the way parents discipline them.

2. Punishment is different, punishment will hurt the child's self-esteem.

Let the child become more and more inferior, and the child may vent his negative emotions in the same way. The emotional needs of children are very important, and when disciplining children, the most important thing is to see the emotional needs of children and let their needs be respected as they deserve.

The gap is very different. Because of the punishment, it is too late to make the child feel the severity of the parents, and many parents will choose corporal punishment, or cold violence, which will bring psychological shadows to the child. Discipline can gradually let children understand the truth, and children will become more sensible.

It is very large, because not only the intensity of the punishment is different, but also the object and content are different, so there is a big difference.

The effect of the two will be very different, I think discipline is more effective, punishment will only make children scared, they will not really recognize their mistakes.

Punishment may make the child overly depressed, and even more want to rebel and discipline the child to learn the importance of etiquette, so that the child can follow the right path of discipline The education style is the most effective.

Punishment may lead to the child's psychological depression and dislike of school, and the discipline will make the child more obedient, know how to follow the rules more quickly, and not easy to go crookedly, so the discipline of the law is the most useful.

It is undeniable that punitive education has a role. When children are punished, they are afraid to make such mistakes again. But fear is often only temporary, and when the fear is over, they still go their own way, and the mistakes they should make will not be less.

To a certain extent, punishment education can play a role in educating children, but it will also bring all kinds of drawbacks, and parents must be cautious. When children are faced with parental punishment and education, they have to choose to obey. But in fact, the negative emotions in their hearts have not dissipated, they are still accumulated in their hearts, and once they are out of the supervision of their parents, those negative emotions that cannot be resolved will come back.

Punishment education can be effective in a short period of time, but the use of punishment in a long period of time can cause a series of negative effects.

In fact, the benefits of punitive education outweigh the disadvantages.

1. Punishment education will affect the relationship between parents and children. After the parent has punished the child, the child will feel scared. At this time, they will subconsciously avoid parents and reduce contact with parents.

If parents have been punitive and educational to their children, then the fear will always linger in the hearts of children. In the long run, there will be a gap between parents and children, which in turn will affect the relationship between parents and children.