During the Song Dynasty, foreign wars were often lost, so why not reform the military system?

Updated on history 2024-07-18
14 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-13

    Because the Song Dynasty itself was a dynasty that emphasized literature and suppressed military force, even if it often failed in foreign wars, it did not have a great impact on itself, so there was no need to reform the military system. The Song Dynasty's policy of emphasizing literature and suppressing military force has been implemented since the opening of the dynasty Emperor Zhao Kuangyin, so the system that has lasted for so many years, people have adapted to such a system, and it can better protect the rights of the rulers and protect their status, so they don't want to reform the military system at all, in case of failure, it will be a great threat to their throne, and although the Song Dynasty is not very good at foreign wars, as long as it loses some money and cuts some land, it will be over, Why bother to go to great lengths to reform the military system, which not only consumes the country's financial resources, but also has a certain degree of danger. <>

    First of all, I have to understand the military system of the Song Dynasty, in the early days of Zhao Kuangyin's founding of the dynasty, he had already begun to implement the policy of emphasizing literature over military force, so at that time, the strength of the army was slowly weakening. He knew that if the army was too strong, it would endanger the ruler, so in order to protect his throne and keep his country, he must constantly weaken the strength of the army, so that they have no way to be strong, so there is a phenomenon of civilian management of the army. <>

    It is precisely because of this that the combat capability of the army is much worse than before, and it will often fail in foreign wars. But then again, the Song Dynasty was relatively wealthy at that time, the economy was relatively good, although it lost, but as long as it lost some money, and then cut some places, the matter could be solved, so the notice felt that there was no need to reform the military system, compared to the land reparations, reforming the military system was much more troublesome, and it may not be able to work quickly. <>

    Therefore, it is not that the Song Dynasty does not know that its military strength is relatively weak, but because they have adapted to such a system, they feel that there is no need to change the system, and it is also a threat to the imperial power.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    Because the Song Dynasty emphasized literature over military force at that time, the emperor was afraid of another armed coup, so he had been weakening the army.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    The power of the literati and doctors is too great, and the military is discriminated against in society, and it is often the literati who lead the troops in war, and it is impossible to divide the interests and power to the military attachés, and naturally no one supports the reform of the military and government.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    The Song Dynasty was originally a dynasty that emphasized literature over military force, and the Song Dynasty was relatively wealthy at that time, and thought that it was easier to cut some land and pay some compensation than to reform the military system.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    It is because there are also a lot of civilians in this army, and they have a lot of internal problems, which makes many people think that the strength of the key banquet is relatively weak.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Because the emperor of the Song Dynasty was too cowardly, he dropped the chain at a critical time, and he didn't have any guts, which gave people such an impression.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Because the courage of the Song Dynasty was relatively small, the ability of the ruler was not particularly good, and the Zhaosheng Brigade was very afraid of other countries, so many clan stools would think that the Song army was very weak.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Because at that time, in the Song Dynasty's foreign wars, the Song army won by numbers, and the king at that time was timid and afraid, even if he led a large number of troops, he would blindly retreat when he encountered a war; And during the Song Dynasty, vigorously promoted civil officials, for the selection of military generals and filial piety, the selection policy was relaxed, and the selected people were not satisfactory Liang Ye's draft, which was not very powerful, led the army, military discipline was loose, there was no strong sense of combat, and the combat effectiveness was weak, so people thought that the Song army was too weak.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Indeed, everyone is greedy for enjoyment, and they are in a safe corner.

    He was also worried that defeating the other party and rescuing the captured emperor would affect the status of the emperor of this dynasty.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    The Song Dynasty had three redundant and two accumulations. Emphasizing civility over military force is just one of his policies, aimed at suppressing military attachés, fearing that someone will usurp the throne like himself and release military power with a glass of wine. The problem is complicated, and it is also related to one's own weakness, which could have won the battle and sometimes fell to his knees and begged for mercy.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    It is directly related to Song Taizu's emphasis on literature and light on military force, the military generals of the Song Dynasty are all civilian officials, the higher the rank, the more so, suppressing the generals, Zhao Kuangyin is a military general, how to establish the Song Dynasty He knows best, the Southern Song Dynasty has changed slightly, in general, the Northern Song Dynasty lacks the Southern Song Dynasty.

  12. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Independent. The Song Dynasty (960-1279) was a dynasty that inherited five dynasties and ten kingdoms and descended from the Qiyuan Dynasty, divided into two stages: the Northern Song Dynasty and the Southern Song Dynasty, with a total of 18 emperors and 319 years of reign.

  13. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Open the history books are written by people, if you want you to know, write it, don't write it if you don't want you to know, there is no perfect system, only the difference in the times, people have no food to eat in winter, you are still eating and drinking here, who do people rob if they don't rob you"?

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Hello, all of this you want has been sealed.

Related questions
8 answers2024-07-18

During the Song Dynasty, in order to strengthen education, the imperial court at that time set up the first official school and the local official school, and later in order to promote the continuous development of education, even built academies, and also promoted the development of Mongolian learning, resulting in the rapid development of education in the Song Dynasty. >>>More

2 answers2024-07-18

People have faces, trees have bark, and they have no faces, no skin, and no income.

10 answers2024-07-18

In the Ming Dynasty, because the territory of the Ming Dynasty was further expanded, and the national strength was stronger, the national strength of the Ming Dynasty was stronger than that of the Song Dynasty.

24 answers2024-07-18

Mainly because the literati of the Song Dynasty had a good desire to become famous. Therefore, this hairpin is not only an aesthetic performance art, but also expected to carp jump over the dragon gate and become the prime minister of the country once, so the men of the Song Dynasty will have the habit of hairpins. <> >>>More

26 answers2024-07-18

Mainly because the Song Dynasty paid more attention to civilian governance, and there was some exclusion of military generals. The Song family's country was seized by rebellion, so the rulers themselves would definitely learn a lesson and curb military development.