Huo Qubing often beat the soldiers, why didn t those soldiers mutiny?

Throughout Chinese history, most of the famous generals who can win battles cherish their soldiers very much, such as Yue Fei, Qi Jiguang and so on. A commander-in-chief who regularly beats his own soldiers and does not take pity on his own soldiers may lead to a mutiny among the soldiers. In that case, the consequences will be unimaginable, but the famous player we are talking about today is very special.

He is Huo Qubing of the Han Dynasty, and legend has it that he often beat his own soldiers in the army, but strangely, he mistreated the soldiers so much, why didn't these soldiers mutiny? Today we are going to talk to you about this problem:

First, the place where Huo Qu fought was either the grassland or the desert, and the soldiers who mutinied and escaped would die

Anyone who has seen Huo Qu's deeds knows that Huo Qu's main battle is with the Huns, and the place where he fought is either the grassland or the desert, if people go to that place, if there is no team strength, it is difficult for a person to survive, not to mention the territory of the enemy country, if Huo Quai's soldiers do not follow him, even if they escape, they will die, so these soldiers do not dare to act rashly.

Second, because he could win the battle by following Huo Quai, the soldiers didn't care about being wronged

Huo Qubing is a generation of famous generals, and following him can win the battle, which is also something that everyone can see, so some soldiers may have been comforting themselves in their hearts, feeling that the current conditions are very hard, but as long as they have been following Huo Quai, and when they win the battle, everything will get better again, so even if they follow Huo Qubing now and suffer some grievances, the soldiers are willing to endure it, plus Huo Quzhi's talent and ability are indeed extraordinary, and the soldiers obey him, so everyone does not rebel.

Third, Huo Quzhi did not beat the soldiers for no reason, it was Sima Qian who deliberately smeared him because of prejudice

I think Sima Qian is biased against Huo Quzhi. Sima Qian admired Li Guang and his descendants very much, and Huo Quzhi personally shot Li Guang's son Li Kang to death. So I feel that Sima Qian often beats soldiers when he writes about Huo Quzhi, which is deliberately smearing Huo Quzhi, which is definitely not the truth.

Huo Qubing is such a talented general, and he has been winning battles, I don't think he should beat soldiers for no reason.

To sum up, Huo Quzhi, as a famous general of the Han Dynasty, even if he has a little flaw in his personality, but compared to his great achievements, this bad temper is nothing. What do you think? Welcome to pay attention and leave a message.

Because Huo Qubing was beaten because the soldiers violated military discipline, the soldiers were very convinced.

Because the soldiers knew that Huo Qu's illness was strict in his treatment, and that he could win battles, earn military merits, and have meat to eat and drink, they did not mutiny.

Because of the historical environment at that time, if you want to be promoted to a knight, a soldier must have military merits, and they have a lot of opportunities to make meritorious contributions with Huo Quai, and he himself will lead the troops, and soldiers are born to obey orders as their duty, so they generally will not rebel. I think there are very few real mutinies in China in the past 5,000 years, a well-disciplined army, a court with a complete system, basically will not mutiny, only a change in the system, can easily lead to a mutiny among soldiers.

Because these soldiers knew that they could win the battle by following Huo Quai, and at the same time, they were also afraid of their own generals.

Huo Qubing and Zhang Fei are the same characters, they will get drunk at every turn and "whip Laos athletes", and the team around him is mostly composed of Hun generals and soldiers, not to mention that the soldiers under his command fought bloody battles with him, once he arrived at the territory of the Huns, even if Huo Qubing really occasionally fought soldiers, what can this be regarded as a person of his level? What boss hasn't humiliated his subordinates? Could it be that the employees of the company will go on strike because the boss humiliates their colleagues?

<> Huo Quzhi has served the emperor in the palace since he was a child, and he has never suffered hardships and does not know T-shirt soldiers. When leading the team, there were dozens of truckloads of food just pulled. After the battle, the food couldn't be eaten, so Huo Quzhi threw it away.

As for the hungry soldiers, they are good at long-distance runs, quick raids, and big detours, big interspersed battles. His operational thinking, strategy and tactics seem to be ahead of his time, and they are similar to the military strategies of later generations of Temujin.

It may be that Sima Qian has some prejudice against the nobles of this kind of relatives, thinking that they rely on their relationships to get to the top, even if they have merit, but they hurt social fairness, especially Sima Qian's friendship with Li Guang's family, and Li Guangming, who was excluded by Wei Qing, may not be upset. But Huo Qubing is not a abolished generation, and the leader he follows is Liu Che, the emperor of the Han Dynasty. Although Huo Quzhi relied on his status as a relative, he relied on his own ability to become noble, which is different from Deng Tong, Dong Xian, Han Yan and other leaders.

The same is true for Huo Qu's disease! How many people are sick with Huo! On the other hand, if you mix with Li Guang, "Li Guang is difficult to seal".

He can't even wait for it himself. What is the future with such a boss? Even if he calls you a brother and is approachable every day, when the poor cause the death of a soldier, the generals at all levels of this battalion will be punished.

Through the policy of rewards and punishments that combine grace and power, the combat effectiveness of the soldiers can be stimulated, and they will become the famous Qi family army and the Yue family army, and the soldiers often lack food when they fight outside the Saiwai, but Huo Qubing does not care whether the soldiers have food or not, and only cares about playing Keju in the barracks.

Because these soldiers knew that it was for their good, and Huo Quzhi was a very capable general who often led them to victory.

Because everything he does is for the good of the soldiers, the soldiers also trust him very much, and they also believe in his words.

Because Huo Quzhi is still very capable of leadership, and he is also very brave and resourceful. He is also very talented in military affairs, and he has always been at the forefront of the battle.

Because although Huo Qubing often beats and scolds soldiers, he is not beaten and scolded for no reason. And in daily life, Huo Qubing cares about the soldiers very much, treats the soldiers as family members, and will come forward to help him solve any difficulties, so his subordinates are loyal to him.