What do you think about pushing down the old woman for no reason who has a mental illness?

I think even if a woman is mentally ill, the woman's family should be responsible, after all, the woman is mentally ill and the family is not taking good care of it.

If there are people with mental illness in the family, the family must ask them to take care of them, although they will not bear criminal responsibility for harming others, but their injuries may cause tragedy in other families.

I think patients with mental illness should go to a regular hospital** to ensure that they are normal before appearing in public, otherwise people with mental illness may affect public safety and cause trouble to others.

While mental illness can make people uncontrollable about their behavior, having a mental illness is not a reason to harm others, and everyone is responsible for their actions.

I don't think I can accept it, even if it's mentally ill, but she can't do things without punishment, and she can't be let go.

No. Because such reasons are perfunctory, there is no detailed evidence to prove it, and even if they are mentally ill, their families should be held responsible.

No. If a loved one is mentally ill, he should be closely guarded and not allowed to come out and harm others.

The woman who pushed down the old man for no reason suffers from mental illness, how to get along with the mentally ill in life? I believe everyone knows that the woman who pushed down the old man for no reason has a mental illness. ThatIn real life, how should we ordinary people get along with the mentally ill?

In real life, it can be said that people often have to stay away from the mentally ill. I once read a book called "Genius on the Left, Madman on the Right", and generally speaking, mental illness is the so-called madness, but they are more of a state of extreme concentration close to the mind. So for the mentally ill,We can't treat them as very different or something.

In the face of psychopaths, we need to knowThey are suffering from the pain of disease and prejudice and discriminationTheir legitimate rights and interests and human dignity cannot be fully protected. This will not only be detrimental to their ****, but even create a vicious circle.

Everyone can say that the warmest and safest harbor is home. It is very important for people with mental illness to be able to have the company, support and understanding of their family and friends** for their health**.

So for ordinary people, how should they get along with the mentally ill? First of all, when we communicate with them, we should be calm and reassuring, and never put pressure on them. Don't be critical or even accusatory.

In order to show that we care about them, we should also try to use greeting or questioning language, for exampleAre you in a good mood today? How are you feeling today? Never ask suggestive questions to get the truth about the patient.

In order to alleviate their anxiety and depression, the conversation should be encouraged as much as possible and interrupted as little. To show empathy and understanding of the intellect.

And we ordinary people should try our best to avoid them immediately when we encounter mentally ill people in our daily lives. Because then they will feel very misunderstood and prejudiced. We should let patients understand that we are not blindly denying them, but that we should pay attention to them, and although we should not get too close to them or contact them directly, we should also try to avoid showing our own discrimination or prejudice.

You should keep a certain distance from these people in your life, because in the next second you don't know what the other person is going to do, it will hurt your body.

There is no way to get along with situations like this, and it is best to keep a certain distance from them, otherwise there is a high chance that the psychiatric hospital patients will accidentally injure themselves.

It is important to put yourself in the patient's shoes. Respect them more and care for them more. Find a topic they like and talk to them. But only if you protect yourself.

In our daily lives, we often hear that some elderly people will slander others. But we still haven't heard that some people will just push the old man down. An old man was walking well on the road, when suddenly a woman came and pushed the old man to the ground.

If there is any illness in this old man,This action is likely to cause the old man to lose his life, which happened in Zhangjiakou.

After this incident, ** also immediately investigated, and later found that the woman had a mental illness, and now she has been sent to the hospital for investigation. In fact, there are many people in this society who will suffer from mental illness, but family members should pay attention to the fact that they must not let these people go out alone, if this is the case, it is likely to cause some trouble to the society. And after this incident happened, many netizens also felt that even if she was mentally ill, she couldn't just forgive her casually.

And if the family of a mentally ill person does not take good care of her, then they should indeed be held responsible by the family. Mental illness is indeed a very serious disease, and there are many people who suffer from mental illness, and if they get sick, it will be very troublesome for some people in society, and these psychopaths do not know what they are doing. Therefore, many times when we see some mentally ill people, we will avoid them, and I also hope that everyone can pay attention to these things.

I think the woman should be responsible for this incident, although he is suffering from mental illness, but his family did not take good care of him. Therefore, his family also has a great responsibility for this matter, and in today's society, the society is developing very fast, and people's lives are under great pressure. Therefore, many people gradually have mental illnesses, and at this time, family members also have to take care of these people.

If the family members are not able to take good care of them, then they are placed in a psychiatric hospital. If it is caused by other people's interesting things or caused other people's **, then it is also a very heavy blow to other people's families.

Therefore, in daily life, if we see some people behaving abnormally, we must stay away from them, otherwise we are likely to bring some harm to ourselves. And if a mentally ill person goes out, his family must be by his side. I also hope that the old man is okay, and the family members who are also mentally ill should also go to see the old man, because this will also make the old man's family more comfortable.

Look at the extent of the old man's injuries. It is true that suffering from mental illness is subject to some legal relief, but if a woman is in good mental condition at the time of pushing, she is also punished according to the normal punishment.

Of course, she should be responsible, mental illness is not a shield for making mistakes, but still having to bear it.

I don't think the woman is responsible for the fact that if she is suffering from a mental illness.

On January 28, Zhangjiakou ** issued a reward to find a woman. The woman was on a road and squeezed into a walking old man, and the old man did not hinder her beforehand. At the same time, after the woman pushed the old man, she did not help the old man and other behaviors, but glanced at the old man and walked away.

Although the old man was not seriously harmed by this, this kind of behavior once it was **, which caused condemnation from various netizens. The woman has now been found and is mentally ill. However, although the woman did not cause serious injuries, will she be punished if a special group of people like the woman did something hurtful?

The author has seen this article in the current Criminal Law: A mentally ill person who has not completely lost the ability to recognize or control his or her own behavior shall bear criminal responsibility, but the punishment may be mitigated or commuted. In other words, if such a group of people are in a state of self-control when they commit illegal acts, they need to bear legal responsibility.

1. It is difficult to define the mental state of special populationsSome special populations, especially mentally ill patients, are still in a controllable and conscious state when they commit criminal acts, and it is sometimes difficult to define. And this is sometimes easy for some criminals or people with crooked eyes to take advantage of loopholes.

In view of this situation, the relevant legal personnel need to be more insistent on finding out the truth, and at the same time, the relevant experts or departments in response to this situation, encourage the society to contribute ideas or encourage the development of relevant scientific research, so that they can more accurately judge the mental state at the time through words and actions, and do not let go of every intentional criminal, and also maintain the humane care of the law.

Two: Special Populations FamiliesIf there is a patient in a family, any burden will be aggravated. The situation of the mentally ill is even more special.

Some people may have normal physical functions, but it is difficult for them to control themselves, and they will behave differently than ordinary people, and even harm themselves and others. So, it's often the case that either the family will lock the patient in the home, but how to make sure the patient's home is safe, and adding a caregiver is really a coping measure. But for families who are not wealthy, this simple approach often becomes a big burden; Either send the patient to a suitable medical institution, in addition to the financial burden, the eyes and discussions of the people around you are also very testing of the patient's family.

Whether there is a better way to care and help this kind of family remains to be discussed.

No, it won't. Because the woman's mental state is problematic and there is no way to hold her accountable, special groups of people cannot be punished.

I think there should be a punishment. Now there are many accidents, and some people use their illness to escape the law.

Special groups of people will also be punished, otherwise fairness in this society will not be reflected.

It is pitiful to suffer from mental illness, but this is not a reason to hurt others, everyone's life belongs to him, and it should not be controlled by others. In fact, in recent years, there have been many cases of people suffering from mental illness, causing serious accidents, but the situation of mentally ill people being "scattered among the people" has not been changed little by little, and the occurrence of this kind of thing is unreasonable, but it does exist. But I've always thought that it is unreasonable to judge the mentally ill to be "scattered among the people".

With regard to the unjustified pushing of an elderly woman suffering from mental illness, is it reasonable to determine that the mentally ill are "scattered among the people"? That's my opinion:

1. Causing distress to the family.

Mentally ill people are often emotionally unstable, and they are not able to control their emotions enough, which can cause distress to their families. His family needs to spend a lot of time taking care of him and protecting him, which is undoubtedly a huge burden on his family. So it's unreasonable.

Second, it poses a hidden danger to the safety of innocent people.

Mentally ill people may not know what is the right thing to do, so they will do what they want to do according to their mood, even if it is not allowed, but it will cause great harm to other innocent people, especially those children who have no ability to protect themselves, and most importantly, they should not be treated like this, and no one has the right to hurt others. So it's unreasonable.

3. It is dangerous for the patient to collapse.

Mentally ill people do not have a correct outlook on life, values, and worldview, and they cannot rely on themselves to distinguish what is dangerous, and if they are accidentally alone outside and cannot have enough knowledge of the world, this situation will be dangerous to their safety. So it's unreasonable.

It's very unreasonable, unless people with mental illness have family members to take care of them, otherwise it can't be.

This is unreasonable, when I find some mentally ill patients in our daily life, we should send these patients to the hospital in time, otherwise these patients will bring some serious effects to others in Tuansui's life.

Of course, it is unreasonable, if such people are constantly wandering the streets, then the society will be unimaginable.

In fact, it is not very reasonable, the crowd itself is a certain harm, and it is also very dangerous for other passers-by.

Recently, a paragraph has been circulated on the Internet, which has made many people feel very angry, including an elderly man who was walking on the side of the road when he was suddenly pushed down by a woman. And after the woman pushed the old man, she walked away, without any regard for the old man's injuries, and later the public security organs also issued a reward order. The woman was finally found, only to find out that the woman was mentally ill, and many people were very suspicious about whether the mentally ill crime should be given a certain understanding or should be punished.

The old man was sent to the hospital by his family for **, and found that the old man had a fracture of his left hand due to a fall, and many people were very sympathetic and angry at the same time.

In fact, the fault is not all in this mentally ill woman, but in the unfavorable care of her family, because if such a mentally ill person commits a crime in society, it will be easy to understand, which will make many people feel very dissatisfied. The refusal of families to compensate or bear the consequences on the grounds of mental illness is very painful for many families. And in 2020, there was also a case of mental illness hurting people, a mentally ill middle-aged man, when he met a child, he casually picked up the wrench in his hand to beat the child, and finally caused the boy to die.

Just because he is mentally ill, shouldn't he have consequences? So if he doesn't have to bear the consequences, then in this society, it is equivalent to talking about the spirit and killing people without bearing legal responsibility. At the same time, if someone falsifies their psychiatric results at this time, then they will do whatever they want in this society.

Not having to bear legal responsibility just because of mental illness makes many people feel very angry, and at the same time makes the whole society feel very frightened, because if this loophole is exploited by someone with intentions, then the society will also become a mess.

Psychopathic crimes should not be understood, but should be punished in other ways, both to soothe the public and to serve as a warning to some people. In this process, it is necessary to condemn the family members of the mentally ill who should take strict care of them when they are mentally ill in the car, so as to avoid causing injuries to the mentally ill themselves, and at the same time to prevent the proof of mental illness from harming others. If the family does not care about the mentally ill, then the mentally ill person should bear the legal responsibility for the unfavorable care of the mentally ill person after making a mistake, and at the same time compensate the medical expenses of the injured person.

The most important thing is that China should improve the relevant laws and regulations to regulate the normal order of the whole society, and I believe that there will be a better way to judge this case in the future, so that everyone can be treated fairly by the law.