Who do you think is better for Guan Yu, Liu Bei or Cao Cao? Why?

In my opinion, I think Liu Bei is better for Guan Yu, because Cao Cao himself belongs to a treacherous and cunning person, he will not be sincere to anyone, he is actually a relatively big traitor in this country, and Liu Bei is Guan Yu's master, so he will treat him better.

Personally, I think Cao Cao is better for Guan Yu, Cao Cao could have killed Guan Yu back then, but he didn't kill him, and put Guan Yu back, he can show that Cao Cao's relationship with him is very good, if Guan Yu is willing to join Cao Cao's banner, I think Cao Cao may have unified China long ago. So I think Cao Cao is better for Guan Yu.

I think Liu Bei and Cao Cao must be Liu Bei is better to Guan Yu. Because Liu Bei and Guan Yu worshipped back then, they may have sacrificed their lives for each other. And about being very loyal to Liu Bei, Liu Bei must have a very deep affection for Guan Yu, so I think Liu Bei is better to Guan Yu.

I think between Liu Bei and Cao Cao, Liu Bei is better for Guan Yu, because after all, Guan Yu is Liu Bei's brother, after all, they were a pair of Taoyuan Sanyi back then, and they are better than brothers, so it stands to reason that Liu Bei must be better for Guan Yu, and it is true that Liu Bei is indeed better for Guan Yu.

I think Cao Cao is better than Liu Bei to Guan Yu, because Cao Cao has always been a meritocracy, he is very appreciative of Guan Yu, but Liu Bei has always been more cautious, for Guan Yu, the brother of the worshipper, in the end, he was not named a marquis, so I think Liu Bei is really not particularly good to Guan Yu, and he is not as good as Cao Cao to Guan Yu.

In fact, in our history, Liu Bei is the best for Guan Yu, after all, Liu Bei and Guan Yu are brothers who have sworn in Taoyuan, the two of them were born and died, and it was Liu Bei who took a fancy to him at first sight and used his talent very well to help him fight his own country, so I think Liu Bei is the best one for Guan Yu.

I am a very righteous person, so together is the best thing in my heart, so I think Liu Bei is better to Guan Yu than what Cao Cao gave, because after Liu Guan Zhang Taoyuan was in the third grade, what Liu Bei gave Guan Yu was together, and this thing was particularly difficult to encounter at that time.

I think Liu Bei and Cao Cao are better than Liu Bei to Guan Yu, because Liu Bei and Guan Yu are brothers after all. Brotherhood Then in some more important battles, Liu Bei trusted him very much to play the striker to be the coach, but Cao Cao was able to let Guan Yu go back to Liu Bei's camp at that time, which was to give Guan Yu a chance to kill Huaxiong.

Liu Bei, because I think that although it is said to be this kind of relationship, I personally think that Liu Bei is actually very responsible among them, especially for Guan Yu, there are many historical events that can be seen, he is very important to Guan Yu, and it is very obvious that he cares about and helps between brothers.

Those of us who have watched the TV series "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" all know that after the defeat of Cao Cao in the Chibi War, on the way to escape, he was intercepted by Guan Yu. In the case that Cao Cao no longer had soldiers and horses to protect him, Guan Yu risked violating the military order and being beheaded, but chose to let Cao Cao live.

Seeing this paragraph, people not only marveled at Guan Yu's love and righteousness, but also sighed: Alas, if Guan Yu had killed Cao Cao at that time, what would have happened to the world?

History has no ifs. But the question left is: what kind of relationship is Guan Yu and Cao Cao?

We all know that in a war, Guan Yu and Liu Bei were broken up and were captured by Cao Cao. Cao Cao liked Guan Yu very much, so he gave Guan Yu all kinds of favors, wanted to buy Guan Yu, and wanted him to submit to his command.

I think Cao Cao really likes Guan Yu. And it makes sense that he likes Guan Yu, in current terms, because their three views are quite similar.

One of the common characteristics is that neither Cao Cao nor Guan Yu disliked Shi Dafu. Zhang Fei is the opposite of Guan Yu, Zhang Fei is polite to the scholars, but not good to the soldiers. Guan Yu likes soldiers, but he hates scholars and clans.

Cao Cao also hated the clan in his heart, and Cao Cao did think that Guan Yu was righteous and Bo Yuntian. He appreciated this very much, so when Guan Yu knew that Liu Bei was going to leave after he left, Cao Cao was righteous and let him go, requiring that the checkpoints along the road could not be stopped, and there was nothing written in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" to pass five levels and kill six generals.

So, what did Guan Yu think in his heart? He felt that Cao Cao was indeed very good, but I followed Liu Bei earlier, since I am a loyal person, I can't betray Liu Bei.

Then, if he wants to choose one of the two, he must also choose one of the two, and he still chose Liu Bei.

This reminds me of a popular song that goes like this: You come to me with a smile and bring my troubles. I already have him in my heart, oh, he arrived before you.

This is Guan Yu's thoughts, Liu Bei arrived first. If Liu Bei hadn't arrived first, we can assume that Guan Yu would have followed Cao Cao.

What do you think?

Cao CaoOf course I really like itGuan YuTarget. Let's take a look at the story between Cao Cao and Guan Yu first.

In 200 AD, Cao Cao defeated Liu Bei.

Liu Bei defected to Yuan Shao.

Guan Yu was arrested by Cao Cao.

Cao Cao named Guan Yu as a partial general, especially respected him, and especially admired Guan Yu's personality, but looking at Guan Yu's appearance, it seemed that he didn't plan to stay with Cao Cao for a long time, so he sent Zhang Liao.

Go ask Guan Yu. Guan Yu also said truthfully: "I know Cao Gong.

He treated me very well, but General Liu was very kind to me, and I could not betray him if I had sworn to live and die with him. I won't stay here in the end, but I'm going to repay Cao Gong for my meritorious service before leaving. "Zhang Liao told Cao Cao what Guan Yu said, and Cao Cao felt that Guan Yu was very loyal.

Later, Yuan Shao sent the general Yan Liang.

In Baima to attack Liu Yan, the Taishou of Dongjun, Cao Cao took Zhang Liao and Guan Yu as the vanguard to attack Yan Liang. Guan Yu was among the ten thousand troops, beheading Yan Liang, and none of the generals under Yuan Shao could resist Guan Yu, so he relieved the siege of the White Horse.

Cao Cao knew that Guan Yu had made a great contribution and was definitely leaving. The above table seals Guan Yu as the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion.

Many things were rewarded.

Guan Yu sealed the gold seal, left a letter to say goodbye, and went to Yuan Shao to defect to Liu Bei. Cao Cao's subordinates wanted to recover Guan Yu, but Cao Cao said that each or the boss should let his subordinates stop chasing.

After Cao Cao captured Guan Yu, he immediately named him a general and rewarded him a lot. This shows that Cao Cao admires him very much and wants to collect other people's burning for his own use. It can also be understood here that this is a means for Cao Cao to win people's hearts.

After Guan Yu beheaded Yan Liang, he sealed the gold seal and went to Yuan Shao to find Liu Bei. Cao Cao also let him go. This is not just the surface work of winning people's hearts and setting a benchmark, this is really like Guan Yu.

In order to keep Guan Yu, Guan Yu was named the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion. But after all, Guan Yu couldn't be kept. Liu Bei was there with Yuan Shao, and Guan Yu had to go to Yuan Shao to find Liu Bei.

If it is simply to establish an image of loyalty and righteousness, and to show the heroes of the world that he is eager to seek talents, Guan Yu can be put under house arrest, eat and drink well, and don't kill him.

I think Cao really likes Guan Yu, because Cao Cao is a suspicious person, so he especially likes the kind of military generals who are very loyal and strong, and Guan Yu is very consistent with these two reed acacia points, and Sencha is naturally loved by Cao Cao.

Cao Cao likes Guan Yu's wild search, because when Guan Yu was in Cao Ying, Cao Cao entertained him, and also gave Guan Yu the red rabbit horse. When Guan Yu was about to leave, Cao Cao did not kill him, but let him go. After Guan Yu's death, Cao Cao also buried Guan Yu's head.

It's a real camaraderie.

Cao Cao likes and admires Guan Yu very much, he thinks that Guan Yu is very righteous and affectionate.

If Guan Yu is just to be successful and famous, it is definitely a better choice to follow Cao Cao, after all, Cao Cao coerced the Son of Heaven to order the princes, no matter the financial and material resources are not comparable to Uncle Liu, Uncle Liu at the peak of the run, also needs to unite with Wu to resist Cao Cao, so this is really a battle between brothers, and the oath was made at that time in order to join hands and share weal and woe. The depiction of Guan Yu can be regarded as more beautiful and outstanding, from the overall to the key points, the brand image of Guan Yu is burly and majestic to show everyone. But in ancient times, the general image description also has a very great relationship with temperament, <>

For example, he wrote Guan Yu's "single phoenix eyes, lying silkworm eyebrows", which are all nobles helping each other, and they are all heroic portraits, so Guan Yu himself has an extraordinary temperament. In fact, this name is not unreasonable, after all, the status quo at that time was there! Under the premise that the princes of the Eighteenth Route were courting Dong Zhuo, Cao Cao of the Three Kingdoms had a good impression of Guan Yunchang.

The bronze statue of Guan Gong beheaded Yan Liang and Zhu Wen Chou, which can be regarded as the martial arts that made Cao Cao of the Three Kingdoms see Guan Yunchang. At that time, Cao Cao of the Three Kingdoms was in the stage of starting his own business, and he was very important to be an outstanding talent like Guan Yunchang. It is also because Guan Yunchang left a good impression on Cao Cao of the Three Kingdoms, <>

Therefore, Cao Cao of the Three Kingdoms can not forget him. During this period, Guan Yu used his own ability to make contributions to Cao Cao, "stabbing Yan Liang", relieving the siege of Longtan, and selflessly dedicating his professionalism. Cao Cao, this time, he followed his service commitment, not only favored Guan Yu, but also left Guan Yu in an atmospheric place.

Therefore, the relationship between Guan Yu and Cao Cao, everyone doesn't need to think too much. They are not friends, nor are they masters and slaves. Only, in the corresponding time frame (Cao Cao encountered Yuan Shuweixie, the overall strength was not good; Guan Yu will die if he does not surrender), between professional talents and technical CEOs, <>

A dedicated collaboration. Pei Songzhi introduced a story in "The Legend of Guan Yu in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms", in which Cao Cao and Uncle Liu Huang surrounded Xiahou Chun in Xiapi, and Xiahou Chun sent his subordinate Qin Yilu out to ask for help. Guan Yu made a clear request to Cao Cao several times, and when the city was broken, he would marry Qin Yilu's wife Du Shi Xu to himself as his wife.

On the day of the city breaking, Guan Yu was not at ease, and asked Cao Cao several times. Cao Cao saw that Guan Yu attached such great importance to it, and felt that the Du family was peerless, so he sent someone to take a look first, and it was really a beautiful beauty, and he took the opportunity to take the Du family as a concubine. Guan Yu was uneasy after understanding.

Therefore, some people believe that Guan Yu's departure from Cao Cao was due to the Du family.

Because he felt that Liu Bei was a usable talent, he had thought about taking refuge in Cao Cao, but Cao Cao's scheming made him feel that this person was unreliable.

Because Guan Yu and Liu Bei Taoyuan have formed a righteous alliance, as long as he follows one person, he will never betray another person, he has never thought of taking refuge in Cao Cao, and feels that Cao Cao is treacherous.

Because he felt that Liu Bei was better for his subordinates, he originally thought about it, but later saw that the people who took refuge in Cao Cao were dead, and he was afraid.