Do you think the Teacher List should be removed from secondary school textbooks?

In my opinion, the "Teacher Table" should not be withdrawn from the middle school textbook, and Xie Fang's "Article Track Style" in the Southern Song Dynasty quoted An Zishunzhi as saying: "Those who read the "Teacher Table" and do not cry are disloyal, those who do not cry when they read the "Chen Qing Table" are not filial, and those who do not cry when they read "Sacrifice Twelve Lang Wen" are not kind." The influence of the "Teacher Table" on later generations can be seen.

The "Former Teacher's Table" is divided into two parts, "Former Teacher's Table" and "Later Teacher's Table", which is a recital presented to the later lord Liu Chan before Cao Wei's two northern expeditions (227 and 228) by Zhuge Liang, the prime minister of Shu Han during the Three Kingdoms period. "The Table of Former Teachers" was written in the fifth year of Jianxing (227), and was included in the "Three Kingdoms" volume 35, the article is sincere and touching, showing Zhuge Liang's determination to go on the Northern Expedition. In the text of "The Teacher's Table", Zhuge Liang persuaded the later lord Liu Chan to open his words, reward and punish strictly, and be pro-virtuous and far-reaching, in order to inherit the legacy of the first emperor Liu Bei; He also stated his "gratitude" to the first emperor and his determination to "revive the Han dynasty".

Debate has been going on for many years about whether the Teacher's List should be withdrawn from secondary school Chinese textbooks. As early as 10 years ago, Hu Juezhao, a 65-year-old history professor at the Party School of the Xi'an Municipal Party Committee, submitted a letter of suggestion to the Department of Textbooks of the Ministry of Education, arguing that Zhuge Liang's "Teacher's Table" should be withdrawn from the middle school Chinese textbook and replaced with Hua Xin's "Stopping the War". Professor Hu believes that Zhuge Liang's "Teacher Table" shows a kind of foolish loyalty.

For junior high school students who do not have the ability to fully discriminate, it is easy to form the idea of "foolish loyalty", which is not conducive to the formation of a scientific military outlook, and even to the formation of the concept of "stopping the war and stopping the army." Opponents believe that the "Teacher's Table" is brilliant and tear-jerking, and in today's increasingly weak traditional cultural concepts, the edification and nourishment of classics such as "The Teacher's Table" are indispensable for middle school students who are forming values.

Let's delete it, from now on, the army will collect the arsenal, and the horse will be released in Nanshan, and the national blood will be completely lost. Everyone is fond of internal fighting, but afraid of external wars. Someone's plot has already been achieved.

Of course, if you want to delete it, the students are not Liu Chan, what's the point? Advocating feudal foolishness and loyalty, and claiming to be the first emperor, there is a serious conflict with the core values of modern society.

What are you doing when you quit, it's completely unnecessary, what's the point of doing it, you don't have to do it at all.

Let's not talk about whether we should quit or not, now that my country's education is already deformed, I keep my own quintessence and don't learn, but learn foreign things? Pathetic!

A teacher's table, a full memorization of texts, a teacher's table has many elements such as encouragement, sadness, tears, sighs, sadness and anger. I'm skimming with mixed feelings.

I was in the second year of junior high school in 03, and it took me four years of early self-study to memorize it, and I was still very impressed after more than ten years. Keep it.

I don't think it should be quit, it's a good article. Tells a lot of things.

Now I'm carrying it

The teacher's table is written about Confucian orthodoxy, which embodies benevolence, wisdom, propriety, righteousness and faith, which is a model for us to stick to the ideal in our hearts and a treasure of Chinese civilization. To give up on him is to abandon the traditional limits of Chinese civilization and to betray Chinese civilization.

"The Teacher's Table" is a Chinese essay that I like very much. I've always felt that classical Chinese is really powerful, because a few words can express a lot of emotions. There is basically not a single nonsense in the "Teacher's Table", and most of the sentences and phrases have become classics since then.

Zhongling is the last sentence, and the bitterness and helplessness in it have been used by me many times. Classical Chinese can be translated into the vernacular, but the feelings in it are difficult to replicate. When he says, "I don't know what to say", if you feel it deeply enough, it can even make your nose sour.

And when it is translated as "I can't help crying when I look at this watch, I don't know what I'm saying", it's just a very ordinary sentence. There are also various vernacular texts of Mr. Lu Xun, because it seems that we have never experienced such things in such an era as I have ever experienced again, so they have less resonance. But the feeling of patriotism has always been the same.

For example, when you study this text, if something happens to be a national event, you will feel that your chest is filled with righteous indignation.

Why should the teacher list be withdrawn from secondary school Chinese textbooks? There doesn't seem to be a very obvious reason for this, and as a college student, I can't think of why a professor would propose that the teacher list should be withdrawn from the middle school Chinese textbook.

At that time, when we were studying, the teacher list was studied as a key text. What a good article the teacher table is, it has both the subtlety of classical Chinese and the integration of modern society, and the teacher table is written by Zhuge Liang to express his determination and euphemistically express his worries, but this table is worth learning from us. Zhuge Liang's articles have been extraordinary since ancient times, and there are not many that can be selected into middle school Chinese textbooks, the only one of the teacher's table should be withdrawn from the middle school Chinese textbook, which really shouldn't, as a literary essay can give people profound enlightenment and give people wise wisdom, Zhuge Liang's extraordinary speech and careful thinking in the teacher's table make us have to learn, the teacher's table reads catchy, as a morning reading text, it is also very good, which allows us to read the text soberly, Understanding the ancient society and the way the ancient people behaved, and Zhuge Liang's style of acting also left a deep impression on us, and it will give us guidance in the subtle way, and give us guidance in life and work.

In short, this article has been studied by us, and we all have a deep understanding of it, and it should not be withdrawn from middle school Chinese textbooks.