What do you have to say about Zhu Yuanzhang not appointing his second son Zhu Di as the crown prince

Zhu Di is the second son, it's nonsense, there are two brothers above Zhu Di, he is the fourth!

Zhu Biao is the son of Empress Ma, and without Empress Ma, there would be no Zhu Yuanzhang, probably out of gratitude, so he wants to pass on the emperor's throne to Empress Ma's descendants (personal guess).

Zhu Di is really eloquent!

The emperor loves the eldest son! The people love their children! This is a matter of course. The descendants of the lineage!

Zhu Di is the fourth son. Not the second son.

Zhu Di is not Zhu Yuanzhang's second son!

Zhu Yuanzhang loves his son very much, Zhu Yuanzhang said that the emperor set up Zhu Biao as the prince in the first month, and Zhu Biao is the heir that Zhu Yuanzhang focused on cultivating at the beginning, very good, Zhu Yuanzhang is equipped with all kinds of equipment, all kinds of sweeping, helpless life, Zhu Yuanzhang is very sad, I estimate that the grandson is the emperor He has not walked out of the shadow of Zhu Biao's death, in front of Zhu Biao, the other sons are nothing, in order to commemorate him, so directly set up the grandson.

In the past, the emperor was very cautious about establishing a crown prince, and he had to combine various factors, and Zhu Di may not have been welcomed at that time.

Because of his deep love for his eldest son, he loves the house and the black, so it is inevitable to ignore his own thoughts and opinions and those of his other sons.

I think there must be a reason for this, because the son is too ambitious, so he chooses the grandson to a certain extent.

Perhaps in the eyes of the older generation of Chinese emperors, they should still follow the order of the eldest and youngest, and think that the eldest son should inherit the throne.

Zhu Yuanzhang can achieve hegemony, and his behavior and ideas are naturally beyond the reach of ordinary people, everyone thinks that Zhu Di is the prince but does not do this, this is not a mortal.

What we all know is that Zhu Yuanzhang was born at the grassroots level, and he doesn't have a good identity, but he is brave and strategic, and Zhu Di at that time was relatively cowardly and didn't have the courage to do big things, so he didn't make a prince.

No one can guess the thoughts of the ancient emperors, and since ancient times, Lichu has also been a topic of disturbance, and only he knows what Zhu Yuanzhang thought at that time.

Maybe he doesn't like his child very much, it is rumored that Zhu Yuanzhang is more suspicious by nature. Maybe I saw something suspicious.

Because Zhu Di is ambitious, his other brothers may not be able to live after he becomes emperor, and Zhu Yuanzhang has a son he likes.

It is precisely because of Zhu Di's both civil and military skills that he will pose a great threat to Zhu Yuanzhang, and will also cause unnecessary crises to other siblings.

Because Zhu Yuanzhang was more jealous of him. Zhu Yuanzhang was afraid that Zhu Di would usurp power and seize the throne, so he had been ignoring him intentionally or unintentionally.

Because he is not the eldest son, Zhu Yuanzhang's eldest son is very capable, and Zhu Yuanzhang doesn't like this son very much.

<> Zhu Yuanzhang is the emperor, and the establishment of an heir is a relatively big issue, which is worth careful consideration. In the political reality of the early Ming Dynasty, Zhu Yuanzhang and the crown prince Zhu marked a factional nuclear conflict, and Zhu Di often beat his prince. If it's just Zhu Yuanzhang or Zhu Di doing it alone, it may be a problem with their personalities, but if both of them do it, it definitely doesn't happen by chance.

This problem is the double-headed political pattern. Zhu Yuanzhang started in troubled times and faced all kinds of dangers all the time, so he did his best to cultivate the prince, just because he was afraid that something would happen to him, and the prince would not be able to control the scene. As a result, the power of the crown prince became stronger and stronger, forming another core in the imperial court other than the emperor, which was the two-headed political pattern.

In this case, the emperor and the crown prince are divided into two levels, who do they listen to? Therefore, Zhu Yuanzhang and Zhu Biao will inevitably have contradictions, which is very common in history.

Zhu Di was difficult, and Zhu Gaochi relied on Zhu Gaochi to guard the rear, and when he became the emperor, he went out to fight Mongolia, and he also relied on Zhu Gaochi to supervise the country. In this case, Zhu Gaochi naturally rose to the top, resulting in the formation of a double-headed political pattern between him and Zhu Di. Therefore, Zhu Di must often beat Zhu Gaochi and tilt the scales to his side.

These two monarchs have a very high evaluation in history, and they will not mess with the prince because of some of them, and there is a deep political background behind them. Considering the political reality, you will know that Zhu Yuanzhang chose Zhu Yunwen entirely because he is politically weak and will not be separated from the emperor like the crown prince Zhu Biao. Zhu Yuanzhang's arrangement is based on the relatively stable foundation of the Ming Dynasty, otherwise he would still have to choose a strong heir.

Originally, there was nothing wrong with this judgment, but after his death, the situation changed too quickly, and everything changed, which was more embarrassing. As for some people saying that they shouted that Zhu Yunwen was chosen because of etiquette, this doesn't make sense at all. Zhu Yunwen is the eldest son of Zhu Biao's stepfamily, it is impossible for him to have a higher inheritance right than the original eldest son, how can he be chosen according to the etiquette law?

Because the princes at that time were the eldest sons of Li, this was the system of the Ming Dynasty, not that it could be changed, only in this way could some disputes within the royal family be avoided.

It should be said that Zhu Yuanzhang chose Zhu Yunwen because of Zhu Biao, because Zhu Yuanzhang attaches great importance to Zhu Biao, the prince, but Zhu Biao died young, and Zhu Yuanzhang also wanted to see Zhu Biao's shadow from Zhu Yunwen, so he chose Zhu Yunwen. In terms of talent and ability, Zhu Yunwen is far inferior to Zhu Di.

The reason why Zhu Yuanzhang didn't dare to make him the crown prince was because he felt that he was actually a sanctionable sanction, but the more decisive he was, the more unreliable he was, so he was not chosen to be the prince.

Because Zhu Yuanzhang thought that Zhu Di was too similar to himself and had too much murderous heart, if he was made emperor, he would definitely kill him, which was not conducive to the stability of the Ming Dynasty in the future, so Zhu Yuanzhang chose Zhu Yunwen as his heir and gave up Zhu Di.

Because Zhu Yuanzhang felt that all his sons were not as good as this grandson, and this grandson was the most suitable person to be the emperor, so Zhu Yuanzhang chose this grandson because his sons were already old. Okimori.

Because this child is Zhu Yuanzhang's first child, Hail Changgao is also a child who has high hopes for Zhu Yuanzhang, and he is very smart and quiet, so Zhu Yuanzhang will pass on the throne to him.

Because he likes this grandson, he feels that this grandson is capable, and he loves this grandson.

Let me give you my personal opinion.

Judging from Zhu Di's actions after becoming the emperor, he was a very good emperor, and during his reign, he was not inferior to Taizu Zhu Yuanzhang. However, in Zhu Yuanzhang's heart, Zhu Di has never been in the ranks of the candidates for the prince. There are several main reasons:

First of all, Zhu Di's upbringing does not conform to Zhu Yuanzhang's positioning of the prince

As far as Zhu Di himself is concerned, he is far more than being able to say that he is both civil and military, and the aspect of martial arts is full of martial virtue, but there is a huge gap in literature. Judging from the review of Zhu Di, Zhu Di's cultural education has not reached the level of the prince, and he has not even reached the level of an ordinary royal family, and he is ridiculed as a semi-literate person.

This is closely related to the environment in which he grew up.

When Zhu Di was born, it was during the period when Zhu Yuanzhang was fighting the world, and Zhu Yuanzhang's busy military affairs made Zhu Yuanzhang have no energy to take care of the education of the princes. Among the sons, only the crown prince Zhu Biao has enjoyed the teachings of the great Confucian Song Lian since he was a child, and Zhu Di has no such treatment at all. After the day was decided, Zhu Yuanzhang still focused on Confucianism in his heart for the governance of the world, and later emperors definitely needed to learn Confucianism.

Therefore, when Zhu Biao died early, Zhu Yuanzhang chose his grandson Zhu Yunwen to inherit the throne.

Secondly, Zhu Di is the barrier to the north of the empire in Zhu Yuanzhang's heart

In the later period of Zhu Yuanzhang, in order to fill the problem of frontier defense caused by the wanton slaughter of meritorious deeds, he divided the princes as kings. Especially in the north, led by Zhu Di, the king of Yan, Zhu Quan, the king of Ning, and others, a barrier against the Mongols in the north was built.

Therefore, in Zhu Yuanzhang's heart, Zhu Di's position has been determined. Judging from Zhu Biao's attitude after Zhu Biao's death, he has no intention of readjusting. Later, Zhu Yuanzhang once told his grandson Zhu Yunwen his thoughts, all possible dangers inside have been cleared, and the kings outside help him guard the frontier, so that the emperor can sit firmly on the throne and enjoy peace.

At this time, Zhu Di is only the cornerstone of Zhu Yuanzhang's defense of Zhu Yunwen's world, and it will never change.

To sum up, Zhu Yuanzhang's arrangements for Zhu Di have long been determined, and he has no intention of letting him succeed him as the crown prince.

Because in ancient times, special attention was paid to respect and humility, and Zhu Di was not the eldest son, so Zhu Yuanzhang did not let him be the prince.

Because Zhu Yuanzhang doesn't like him, Zhu Yuanzhang prefers his grandson, so he wants to pass the throne to his grandson.

Because Zhu Yuanzhang especially doted on Zhu Biao's son, when Zhu Biao died, he had to give all his love to Zhu Biao's son, so he didn't let Zhu Di be the prince.

Zhu Yuanzhang, the founding emperor of the Ming Dynasty, was a person with a lot of dissent. There are two things in Zhu Yuanzhang's body that have been discussed the most by future generations, one is to kill the father, and the other is to send his little grandson to the emperor's throne. Many people's suggestions for Zhu Yuanzhang to send the throne to Zhu Yunwen are very big, especially when Zhu Yuanzhang has a child Zhu Di who is both wise and brave.

So, why is Zhu Di so capable, and Zhu Yuanzhang still needs to send the throne to Zhu Yunwen?

Zhu Di was born in the war era at the end of the Yuan Dynasty, and when he was eleven years old, he obtained military merits with his own ability, and was therefore named King Yan. By the age of twenty, Zhu Di had also become King Pan, garrisoning the border for the Ming Dynasty to defend against external opponents. Twice led his division to the north, once persuaded the Mongol Naier not to surrender, and once shouted that he captured the key Beiyuan general Solin Timur alive, which increased his danger in the troops in the northern region.

Zhu Di's overall strength, in the eyes of many people, is the emperor's right-hand man. At this time, Zhu Yunwen was only an ignorant teenager, he had no experience in fighting for hegemony on the battlefield, he did not have the ability to win a thousand miles in front of the court, and he did not have much prestige. If it is considered from the perspective of the country, it is not easy for normal people to turn over Zhu Di and send the throne to Zhu Yunwen.

However, Zhu Yuanzhang still did it, and he also had his own reasons.

First, Zhu Yuanzhang and Queen Ma have a very good relationship, and except for Zhu Di, Zhu Yuanzhang's remaining three sons were all born to Queen Ma. But unfortunately, except for Zhu Di, all three of them died young. Zhu Yuanzhang's feelings for Empress Ma prompted him to be reluctant to make a child under another life path an emperor, so he never thought of setting up Zhu Di as his successor.

Second, Zhu Yunwen is Zhu Biaodi's child, this person is the sister-in-law of Queen Ma and the original crown prince. Zhu Biao is a normative candidate for the emperor, he not only has outstanding ability to deal with the world, is honest and kind-hearted, but also very filial. But unfortunately, when Zhu Biao was 38 years old, he died of illness.

On this day, Zhu Yunwen was very moved by Zhu Yuanzhang because he took care of his father day and night, and became a very good successor candidate in Zhu Yuanzhang's heart.

Third, Zhu Yunwen, as the eldest grandson, actually has a certain number of supporters, such as Liu Sanwu, a bachelor of Hanlin, is one of them. Liu Sanwu thinks that Zhu Yunwen is a loyal, loyal and honest person, and has great ambitions, or Zhu Biaodi's child, he will definitely be able to govern the country well.

In general, Keling Zhu Di has a lot of ability, but he will not be loved by Zhu Yuanzhang due to his own situation, and in the end he can only rely on rebellion to sit on the emperor's throne, which is also quite sad. However, Zhu Di's administration is still very talented, and during his reign, he improved the political system of the Ming Dynasty, developed the economy of the Ming Dynasty, developed the territory of the Ming Dynasty, and moved the capital of Beijing to Beijing, so that Beijing has become a management center so far.

The main reason is that although Sun or he is both civil and military, he does not have some ability to govern the country at all, and he is not suitable to be a king, so he is not allowed to be the emperor.

is because Zhu Yuanzhang didn't like this child at that time, he felt that this child was too ambitious, and Zhu Yuanzhang had a prince at that time.

is because Zhu Yuanzhang doesn't like Zhu Di, and he feels that Zhu Di's identity is too humble, and Zhu Yuanzhang likes his eldest son at that time.