What are the shortcomings of Zhou Yu in history?

Zhou Yu during the Three Kingdoms period in history.

The disadvantage is that it is more conceited. He was proud. At a young age, he became the governor of Wu State, so he was very proud at times.

Historically, Zhou Yu was very wise, but his personality was a little impulsive and extremely emotional.

First of all, Zhou Yu's intelligence is outstanding, tall and handsome, good at martial arts, and he also understands strategy.

1. Contrast marriage.

Zhou Yu's marriage: "Back then, Xiao Qiao first married" Twenty-four-year-old Zhou Yu, co-grandson to attack Anhui, and got the two daughters of the Principality of Qiao. Ce Zi Na eighteen-year-old Da Qiao, Yu married sixteen-year-old Xiao Qiao as his wife.

Zhou Yu has only one wife, Xiao Qiao, in his life, the husband and wife lack more affection, have a happy marriage, have two sons and a daughter, and later generations are called heroes and beauties, a match made in heaven.

Wang Fu is the wife of Su Shi and the daughter of Wang Fang, a Gongjinshi of Meizhou, Sichuan. After marrying Su Shi at the age of sixteen, she can be called Su Shi's right-hand man, and there is a story of "listening behind the scenes". Su Shi was a generous person and relatively negligent in dealing with people, so Wang Fu listened quietly behind the screen and informed Su Shi of his suggestions.

However, Wang Fu and Su Shi died of illness after living for eleven years.

2. Contrast image and temperament.

Zhou Yu's image temperament: "Majestic and heroic." Lupine towels.

Zhou Yu was born in a scholar family, and his grandfather Zhou Jing and uncle Zhou Zhong were both Han Taiwei. His father, Zhou Yi, once served as the Luoyang Commander. Zhou Yu himself is tall and handsome ("Yu is long and strong" and has great ambitions.

When Zhou Yu was twenty-three years old, he was named "Zhonglang General" by Sun Ce, and the people of Jiangdong called him "Zhou Lang".

Su Shi's image and temperament: "The sky is wide and the road is three thousand, looking at the eyebrows and the clouds in the distance." Last year, I had a little lovesick tears, and I still can't shed on my cheeks.

said that Su Dongpo's forehead is flat, the distance between his eyebrows is far, and his face is long; The second is: "A clump of withered grass comes out of the lips, and the beard is even sideburns, and the apricot is absolutely talking." The corners of the mouth were nowhere to be found a few times, and suddenly I heard a sound in the hair.

It is said that Mr. Dongpo is bearded.

3. Compare achievements.

Zhou Yu's exploits "Talking and laughing, the canopy is in ashes" at the age of twenty-three, Zhou Yu awarded Jianwei Zhonglang General. At the age of thirty-three, Zhou Yu was the governor of Zuodu, and led his troops to fight against Cao with Liu Bei. Zhou Yu won more with less in the Battle of Chibi, broke Cao's army, and laid the foundation for the three-point world.

Since then, Zhou Yu has been famous in history as a generation of famous generals.

Su Shi's achievements: Su Dongpo, as the leader of the literary world of the Northern Song Dynasty, learned to be rich and rich, and was already famous all over the world at that time, Su Shi was also an intellectual with such ambitions, and the achievements of poetry, calligraphy and painting were far less than those of Zhou Yu on the **, which made him more fascinated. However, his political ideals were repeatedly frustrated by complicated political struggles and bumpy life paths, especially because of the blow of the "Wutai Poetry Case" in Huangzhou.

Zhou Yu met Sun Ce when he was a child and became friends of life and death. After Sun Ce broke away from Yuan Shu and became independent, Zhou Yu took the initiative to defect to Sun Ce. In Sun Ce's war to pacify Jiangdong, he played the dual role of a strategist and a general, and subdued Tai Shici with stratagem.

After Sun Ce pacified Jiangdong, Zhou Yu served as the governor of the navy. In 200, Sun Ce died early, and before he died, he said to Sun Quan, "Ask Zhou Yu if you don't decide on foreign affairs." After Sun Quan succeeded to the throne, he also trusted Zhou Yu very much.

In 208, Sun Quan went west to conquer Huangzu, and Zhou Yu made great contributions. In 208, Cao Cao went south, and his goal was directly aimed at Jiangdong, and Sun Quanzhan and undecided. Zhou Yu rushed back from Poyang Lake in time and correctly analyzed the various drawbacks of Cao Cao's distant arrival, so that Sun Quan decided to fight Cao Cao.

Zhou Yu, as the governor of the navy, used fire to attack Cao Cao, which was the famous Battle of Chibi. After the Battle of Chibi, Zhou Yu was poisoned by arrows when he attacked Nanjun, but he still desperately took Nanjun. Subsequently, Zhou Yu ceded the south bank of the Yangtze River to Liu Bei, but Liu Bei went to Jingkou to see Sun Quan and asked for the whole of Jingzhou, Sun Quan agreed, so Zhou Yu had to retreat to Chaisang County to recuperate, and during his illness Zhou Yu reminded Sun Quan to beware of Liu Bei.

In 210, Zhou Yu led his troops to attack Xichuan, and when he arrived at Baqiu City, he suffered an arrow wound and died young at the age of 36. After Sun Quan heard the news, he immediately welcomed Zhou Yu's coffin back to Chaisang.

Zhou Yu in history was heroic and broad-minded. Cheng Pu, a veteran of Eastern Wu, followed Sun Jian in his early years, thought of himself as a meritorious person, and looked down on the young Zhou Yu. But Zhou Yu didn't care about Cheng Pu, and finally convinced Cheng Pu himself, Cheng Pu said:

Having sex with Zhou Gongjin, like drinking alcohol, I don't feel drunk. By the time of the Song Dynasty, the world still liked Zhou Yu very much, which can be seen from Su Shi's "Nian Nujiao". But after the Yuan Dynasty, people gradually scandalized Zhou Yu, and by the time "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" was written, Zhou Yu became a completely different person.

One of the very important reasons for this is the relationship between Zhou Yu and Liu Bei, on the one hand, Zhou Yu took the initiative to cede the south bank of the Yangtze River to Liu Bei, but this is largely a diplomatic act; On the other hand, Zhou Yu saw Liu Bei's heroic nature, and did not want Liu Bei to grow stronger day by day, so he wrote to Sun Quan and asked Sun Quan to put Liu Bei under house arrest in Jingkou (this is the origin of the beauty plan in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", but in fact, Zhou Yu himself did not use the beauty plan, and Sun Shangxiang was also married to Liu Bei by Sun Quan on his own initiative), but Sun Quan was unwilling. In terms of attitude towards Liu Bei's side, Zhou Yu and Lu Su took a completely different approach, Zhou Yu was a radical, while Lu Su saw a farther vision. It's a pity that thousands of years later, these two people have become the backers of Zhuge Liang, who was still unknown at the time, Zhou Yu has become synonymous with narrow-mindedness, and Lu Su has become a surprisingly stupid person who is honest.

According to Mr. Yi Zhongtian's evaluation, Zhou Yu has two more prominent characteristics.

First, Zhou Gongjin cherished his talents, and his strategic goal in Eastern Wu was to eliminate Liu Bei, because Liu Bei robbed Jingzhou of Wu. But Lu Su's goal was to unite Liu Bei and resist Cao Cao together. It can be said that the political differences between these two people are very large.

However, before his death, Zhou Gongjin still recommended Lu Su to Sun Quan as his successor, which can be seen.

Second: Zhou Gongjin is very loyal, in the open and secret battle with Liu Bei Group, Zhou Yu has always been dedicated to the Lord, racking his efforts, until he died, he never forgot to ask Sun Quan to take back Jingzhou. He is not a narrow-minded person, but his political goal is to destroy Liu, so he and Zhuge Liang will definitely have a fight, but his skills are not as good as others and he is angry to death.