Which of the four famous novels do you think was the best filmed?

"Three Kingdoms" was filmed, and the plot in it made people feel very grand and looked very enjoyable, especially the various wars in it, the picture was much better than the old version, which took advantage of science and technology. In contrast, "Water Margin" can't give people that grand feeling, it looks heroic, but it's actually all miscellaneous things, of course, it may also be related to personal preferences. So I personally think that this "Three Kingdoms" is the best remake of the four famous classic TV series.

Of course, the fly in the ointment is that this "Three Kingdoms" ended when Sima Yi took the Cao family's power, leaving a little regret.

Water Margin is the leader. Because the CCTV version of the adaptation of the original book is the most in line with my appetite. Not only did the secondary characters be removed to ensure the compactness of the whole story, but also some of the evil things that Liang Shan did were hidden, instead of being targeted to wash the floor.

Especially in the later stage, which has been reduced to a list of battles that are heads-up, the TV series also highlights the key points, and does not fall into the strange circle of copying, but shows different characteristics for each battle as much as possible. It can be said that CCTV Water Margin is the biggest change to the original book among the four famous TV series, compared with the other two (I haven't seen Dream of Red Mansions), one episode of Journey to the West and one story seems to be rushed, and the Three Kingdoms are even more anticlimactic due to the original work. Just one thing, the first appearance of CCTV Water Margin was Gao Yu, who was splashy, and the last scene was the palace marshal Gao Qiu to set up a temple for Song Jiang, who had died at his hands.

The irony and bleakness of the world are self-evident.

Romance of the Three Kingdoms", in the nineties, invested more than 100 million yuan, mobilized hundreds of thousands of people, and deliberately built several cities for this purpose. So when filming the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the conditions were relatively much better, but this kind of large-scale war drama and men's drama now seems to be better than literary drama and martial arts. The production level of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is a step higher than that of "Dream of Red Mansions" and "Journey to the West".

However, Zhang Shaolin, the director who filmed "Southern Expedition and Northern War" in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", later filmed "Water Margin", and it can be said that "Water Margin" is currently the most perfect of the four famous novels.

Because I like "Dream of Red Mansions", I also particularly favor the 87 version of "Dream of Red Mansions", but objectively speaking, the 87 version of Dream of Red Mansions has many regrets, but this is the regret of that era, not caused by someone. The actors in the 87 version of Dream of Red Mansions are actually more difficult than the actors in Journey to the West, because the director Wang Fulin uses a group of amateurs, although they are also carefully selected people in theater troupes across the country, but basically have no experience in film and television performance, like Xue Baochai's actor Zhang Li, who used to dance in the Chengdu Art Troupe, was selected by Mrs. Xing Xia Minghui (the person in charge of recruiting actors at that time) because she accompanied her friends. Like Miaoyu's actor Ji Yu is a worker, as for Lin Daiyu's actor Chen Xiaoxu is the only one who recommended himself to join the Dream of Red Mansions crew, and Chen Xiaoxu does not rely on acting experience but temperament.

Therefore, whether the actors of the 87 version of Dream of Red Mansions are good or not depends on the actors, because they don't know how to act, they are all a blank slate. This is a complete test of the director's skills, so the difficulty of directing "Dream of Red Mansions" by Wang Fulin mainly lies in people, while the difficulty of directing "Journey to the West" directed by Yang Jie mainly lies in things, because of the lack of materials and a serious shortage of funds.

At that time, when filming "Water Margin", it had reached its best state. But now, if you remake "Dream of Red Mansions", at least in terms of architecture and food, it can surpass the 87 version of Dream of Red Mansions, because it was too poor at that time. If the remake of "Journey to the West" can surpass the 86 version of Journey to the West at least in terms of special effects, these are indisputable facts.

The remake of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" can also make the war scenes more exciting, but it seems difficult to remake "Water Margin", because there is no place that can be surpassed. All in all, from the perspective of the TV series itself, "Water Margin" was the best filmed, both the actors and the funds at that time were in the best state.

Journey to the West is the best, it captures the essence of the original work, and the special effects, sets, costumes, etc. are also very careful, in my personal opinion, it is very good. Dream of Red Mansions, although it looks like chatting about Zhai, it can be seen that the main creator is attentive, but the effect of the expression is a little unsatisfactory.

Zhang Chen Jianbin version of "Three Kingdoms", the actors invited are basically actors with very good acting skills. Chen Jianbin who plays Cao Cao, Yu Hewei who plays Liu Bei, Lu Yi who plays Zhuge Liang, He Rundong who plays Lu Bu, Lin Xinru who plays Sun Shangxiang, etc., these actors have a certain reputation, and their acting skills are very outstanding. Being able to invite so many good actors to participate in the Three Kingdoms shows that his skills are huge.

In contrast, only "Water Margin" can be compared with "Three Kingdoms" in terms of actors, and the actors of "Dream of Red Mansions" and "Journey to the West" cannot catch up with these two in terms of fame and acting skills.

The script of Journey to the West focuses on adjusting the style of the original work. A large number of dark content in the original work has been diluted and transformed, the Buddhist doctrine is expounded, and the content that excessively worships Buddha and derogates Taoism has also been deleted, forming an overall humorous and enthusiastic and warm-hearted tone, which is suitable for all ages and families, laying the most solid foundation for the series to be popular for many years.

Tang Guoqiang's Romance of the Three Kingdoms is the best.

Just know that the most garbage is the Water Margin.

1, He Qing. In 1984, he met Yang Jiehe, the chief director of the TV series "Journey to the West", and starred Liu Xiaolingtong, and selected her to play Lingji Bodhisattva in "Journey to the West". In 1988, he was selected by Xie Tieli, the director of the movie "Dream of Red Mansions", to play the amorous and unfortunate Qin Keqing in the film.

In 1993, he played the glamorous and moving Xiao Qiao in the TV series "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". In 1996, in the TV series "Water Margin", he played a generation of famous tricks Li Shishi.

2, Wang Zhongxin.

In 1983, the Shandong version of "Water Margin" played Wu Yong ("Li Kui" unit). In 1986, the CCTV version of "Journey to the West" played Tai Baixing. In 1987, the CCTV version of "Dream of Red Mansions" Lu Rangzhao played Zhen Shiyin and Dai Quan.

In 1994, the CCTV version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" played Hua Tuo, Qin Mi, and Fu Wan. In 2000, the CCTV version of "Journey to the West Sequel" was slippery and pure as Tai Bai Xing.

Famous works, art through the ages".

The four famous works were made into TV dramas, which is a major event in art, and it is also a great event in China's literary and artistic circles, which has very important practical significance for the dissemination of art and the great achievements of civilization.

Just like the four famous novels have their own merits, their artistic achievements cannot be generalized, and the remake into a TV series also has its own focus, which has affected different audience groups according to its content and artistic characteristics, and has caused different repercussions among different classes of people.

1. Interesting and boring, suitable for all ages - "Journey to the West".

In terms of popular influence, "Journey to the West" is the most successful, since the 1986 version of "Journey to the West"**, the TV series has become the "trump card program" of the student holidays, and people never get tired of watching it.

Of course, the intriguing plot is one reason, and the actors' performances are also in place, and "Journey to the West" has become an insurmountable classic recognized by the whole country since its broadcast.

2. The culmination of feudal family culture - "Dream of Red Mansions".

There has always been a saying that "I don't read "Red Mansions" and "Three Kingdoms", and the specific reasons have not been interpreted, but the artistic achievements of "Dream of Red Mansions" are regarded as the highest of the four masterpieces.

The 1986 version of the TV series "Dream of Red Mansions" should be the most widely disseminated, and we can also feel that the remake of "Dream of Red Mansions" among the four famous novels should be the most difficult to grasp, and the cultural level, court etiquette and traditional customs involved need to be figured out. Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, Wang Xifeng, Grandma Liu, etc. are all classics.

From the perspective of literature and art, the value of the remake of "Dream of Red Mansions" is far greater than that of the TV series itself.

3. Bow to Zhuge Liang, and be brave and loyal to the five tiger generals - "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

The 1994 version of the TV series should be a classic that is difficult to surpass, and the highlights in it have been interpreted by various ** editors later, and the characters created are also lifelike and fixed as "non-reproducible".

Zhuge Liang played by Tang Guoqiang is deeply rooted in the hearts of the people, Zhao Zilong played by Zhang Shan is full of courage, Guan Yunchang played by Lu Shuming is loyal and righteous, and Bao Guoan plays Cao Cao well. But since Zhuge Liang died in Wuzhangyuan, it seems that the "Three Kingdoms" has no prospects.

The remake of the "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" TV series should be a favorite of history lovers and middle-aged and elderly friends.

The positioning of "Water Margin" has always been criticized, of course, the characters created in it are also very distinct, but they often make the audience go to extremes, young people may watch it is to fight and kill, rob the rich and help the poor, but friends who study deeply love to ask "why Song Jiang recruits An", and the result is unbelievable and inconsistent. Therefore, the repertoire of "Water Margin" was later dismantled into an independent repertoire**, which can be described as an independent chapter.

I think it's "Dream of Red Mansions", because the story content of the play is very complex Tanyin Bridge, and it is very difficult to present the feeling of Ling Meng's original work, but the remake is perfectly restored, so it is very shocking.

Journey. This work can be said to be very shocking, and it has also been liked by many people. I feel like the Chinese have seen it.

A very shocking TV series is Journey to the West, because it is a mythological TV series of Xinmeng, so after it is produced, it will make people very shocked.

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms brings the strongest sense of shock, and there are many war scenes in it, and the number of people needed is relatively large.

I think Journey to the West is the most shocking, because Journey to the West left a deep impression on me, so I think Journey to the West is the most shocking.