If Wei Yan doesn t die, what chance does Wei Yan have of winning against Sima Yi Shu Han?

Updated on history 2024-08-07
54 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-15

    Wei Yan's ability is still very strong, he is a brave general of the Shu army, but because of his personal temperament, he is more impulsive and likes to make strange moves, which is tantamount to throwing himself into a dead end for Sima Yi, who is cautious and cautious, Wei Yan fights against Sima Yi, the Shu army and the Wei army, then there is only a ten percent chance of winning.

    Zhuge Liang had six times out of Qishan, and Sima Yi was fighting wits and courage, and finally had the opportunity to trap the Wei army led by Sima Yi in the upper valley and carried out a fire attack on the sixth time, but it was a pity that the heavens were not beautiful, and it rained and saved the life of Sima Yi's army. What level of military talent did Zhuge Liang have to force Sima Yi into such a situation. And Wei Yan is on par with Zhuge Liang, let alone a level, it is simply a small thing.

    When Zhuge Liang died, Wei Yan once said: How can I give up the great cause of recovering the Central Plains because of the death of the prime minister, and let me lead the troops to destroy Sima Yi and his party.

    If Wei Yan really led his troops to attack Sima Yi directly, it would be simply asking for a dead end, the losses of the Shu army would be greater, and there would not be many people left in the Shu army, and the main force on their side would be in front, if the main force fell, what would happen to the Wei army in the back, and Dongwu was still there, not to mention the great cause of recovering the Central Plains, and directly withdrawing from the Three Kingdoms after fighting against Sima Yi.

    Do you still remember that Liu Bei chose Wei Yan as the Taishou of Hanzhong instead of Zhang Fei? The reason is that Zhang Fei is good at attacking, while Wei Yan is good at defense, and Wei Yan took the initiative to attack Sima Yi, isn't this using his own shortcomings to collide with others? Moreover, Wei Yan's temperament likes to make strange schemes, such as the Meridian Valley Scheme, at that time, that plan was not feasible at all, he only planned the smooth progress but not the consequences of failure, and did not consider the enemy's defense, which was undoubtedly the only recklessness.

    Therefore, Wei Yan is not dead, and the chance of winning against Sima Yi is only one percent. Even if this victory is a narrow victory, the ** brought by the Shu army must be disastrous, and Wei Yan's prestige in the Shu army will also decline, coupled with his personal character, in the end, he will also be rejected by others and squeezed**.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-14

    There is no chance of winning. Because he is a martial artist, when Zhuge Liang was there, he missed his hand a few times. Thanks to Zhuge Liang's thoughtfulness, he saved him several times.

    After Zhuge Liang died, he did not measure himself and tried to take power in vain. When he fled after the defeat, he was chased and killed by Ma Dai. Just such a military general is obviously not Sima Yi's opponent.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-13

    Even if Wei Yan didn't die, Shu couldn't beat Sima Yi, because Shu was already in the stage of breaking his muscles and bones at that time, and he didn't have much troops at all.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    If Wei Yan does not die, Wei Yan's combat power is definitely above Sima Yi, and Wei Yan knows Sima Yi very well and will not be deceived by Sima Yi.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    It is estimated that not, even if Wei Yan goes to fight against Sima Yi, it is still Sima Yi who has the upper hand.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    There isn't much chance of winning, there won't be anything, and there's no difference between the two, so don't bother each other.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Wei Yan is not dead, Shu Han will perish faster There is no need for Sima Yi to clean him up He is too ambitious, and someone in Shu Han will kill him Besides, he is not Sima Yi's opponent at all.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    There was no chance of victory, and the geographical defects of Shu Han's backwardness and Wei Yan's own personal character problems determined that he could not match Sima Yi.

    But we have to ask: is Wei Yan a talent? Absolutely!

    Wei Yan was able to get into Liu Bei's car, so naturally he couldn't be a mediocre talent, but he didn't live up to Uncle Liu's trust in him, and he really realized the garrison of Hanzhong, and Hanzhong City was also impregnable. And the truth is that Zhuge Liang did not dismiss Wei Yan like in the romance, Wei Yan became the general of the Western Expedition, led the Liangzhou Assassin History, and was the front of the army, all of which were pulled by Zhuge Liang, which shows that Wei Yan is indeed a talent.

    Zhuge Liang has made great efforts to keep Wei Yan. Sima Yi, who has fought against Zhuge Liang many times in history, has always chosen to avoid Wolong's constant challenges, but he has always chosen to avoid his sharp style of play and stick to it. In real history, Zhuge Liang's confrontation with Sima Yi was limited to the last two Northern Expeditions, and the first three basically ended without a problem.

    If Wei Yan had enough wits to fight with Sima Yi, the geographical defects could not be made up for in any case, we sometimes only pay attention to the intrigue of the Three Kingdoms period, and rarely pay attention to the geographical aspect: the Western Han Dynasty Wudu ** led to the Han River and the Western Han River has been diverted, and several routes of the Northern Expedition cannot be completely connected through the Han River, which greatly limits Zhuge Liang's strategic space, and in the north-south direction, the Tianchi Daze Waterway has also disappeared, and there is no convenient waterway for grain and grass transportation, and the soldiers can only conquer the Shu Road with two legs. When Zhuge Liang was alive, he tried his best to overcome the problem of Shu Dao, and if Wei Yan took over, he would not have put much thought into it.

    Since then, there has been no successful case of the Northern Expedition in Shudi. It was precisely because he realized the changes in Shu Dao after Wudu ** that Sima Yi chose to use delaying tactics. Personally, I don't think Wei Yan has the strength to overcome thisAct of God.

    What's more, Wei Yan still has a fatal weakness: emotional intelligence is too low! It is not to blame Wei Yan's overly distorted image in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and Chen Shou's evaluation of it as "high in nature" in the official history "Three Kingdoms" is also a bit derogatory.

    The personality is too arrogant, it is difficult to get along with others in real words, and the leaders have a headache when they have conflicts with others in three days. To be honest in this situation, it's still okay to bring some small soldiers to fight, but it's definitely not the leader's material, you can't manage it yourself, you can control others, otherwise you won't have a conflict with Yang Yi, and you will lose your life.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Sima Yi is a wise man at the same level as Zhuge Liang, he and Zhuge Liang are overstretched, compared to Wei Yan, it is too simple to play with him. If Wei Yan attacked the Wei army without his own strength after seizing power, the outcome would be quite miserable.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Wei Yan didn't die, and he didn't have much chance of winning against Sima Yi, because Shu Han's national strength was there. Jiang Wei's nine Northern Expeditions, with many victories and few defeats, did not shake Wei's roots, and only touched a little skin.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Wei Yan's wisdom can not be compared with Wolong and Tsukahu, after Wei Yan grasped the power, he attacked the Wei army without his own strength, and the Shu army would suffer heavy losses, even if it won, the main force would be exhausted, what to use against the Wei army and guard against the sneak attack of Eastern Wu.

  12. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    With Wei Yan's strength at that time, it is estimated that Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition may have other progress, and he is still not as wise as Zhuge Liang, even if he does not die, the chance of winning against Sima Yi and Shu Han is still very small.

  13. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    There is almost no chance of winning, Sima Yi is scheming and has the first power of the Three Kingdoms, it is clear that he bullies the weak with the strong and Wei Yan is far inferior to Sima Yi in terms of the art of war, if the strategists of the Three Kingdoms are ranked, Sima Yi is at least a first-class strategist, and Wei Yan can only be regarded as a second-rate military strategist, not a level.

  14. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    If Wei Yan attacked the Wei army without his own strength after grasping power, he would not know how to die. In the face of Sima Yi, who was more cautious than Zhuge Liang, he had little hope of winning by being opportunistic.

  15. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    If Wei Yan hadn't been killed by Zhuge Liang, with Wei Yan's strength at that time, it is estimated that Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition might have other progress and other better results.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    It is estimated that there is a little more chance of winning, because at that time, Shu still needed instant combat power like Wei Yan, so with Wei Yan, the Northern Expedition should have a better chance of winning.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Although he is a rare general, he is still inferior to Zhuge Liang in wisdom, even if he does not die, the chance of winning against Sima Yi and Shu Han is still very small.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi are the heads of the martial arts masters! Wei Yan is a professional fighter! If the same military power, Wei Yan killed the wheel combination of the two in seconds.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Wuhou did not, the general of Shu Han Yansheng attacked the east and west and took the meridian road, and was ambushed, and Shu Han lost his troops and lost the country.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Personally, I don't think there is much chance of winning, the survival of a dynasty is affected by many factors, and this person is only one of them, and he can't play much of a role.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    If Wei can lead troops to attack Wei: two scenarios. First, Wei can fight well and dare to think of methods, which is much stronger than the timid Zhu. Two, guard, no problem. So: I am optimistic about Wei, but unfortunately I was killed, and Shu self-destroyed the Great Wall.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    It is difficult for Shu Dao to go to the blue sky This problem is already doomed to be unsuccessful The population will also decline with the war Zhuge Liang has fought several times The population has declined severely The people live very hard The people are also complaining Cao Cao's side is much better Zhuge Liang came out of Qishan Why is the reason why he fought the war is for his own rights Mixed military merit promoted his younger brother His younger brother is also a real scum.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Wei Yan can't do it, it's okay to fight alone, if he leads the whole army and Sima Yidou, Wei's ability is much worse, and there is no chance of winning at all!

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Wei Ting is not dead, although he has little chance of winning against Sima Yi, the best defense is to attack. Maybe Shu won't die so soon.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Wei Yan is a reckless adventurer, and Shu Han has a thin foundation and can't withstand his toss. Moreover, Wei Yan is arrogant and does not fit in with the crowd, so I am afraid that he will not be able to lead the generals.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Zhuge Kongming is just a waste of fame.

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    I don't think the odds are good. Because Wei Yan is not the core figure, and the Three Kingdoms in the later period is mainly a melee of teams, whoever has stronger comprehensive strength will easily win the war. At this time, the strife is no longer the early individual hero performance competition.

  28. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    I think that even if Wei Yan doesn't die, Sima Yi can still unify the world, because his ability to unify the world is due to various reasons, and it will not change because of one or two people.

  29. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    If Wei Yan does not die, it is very likely that he will be able to confront Sima Yi and Shu Han, but the chances of victory will not necessarily be very great, since Sima Yi can unify the world, then he will be stronger than Wei Yan in all aspects.

  30. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Even if Wei Yan doesn't die, it won't become a big climate, and most of them will take refuge in Sima Yi. Because Wei Yan himself is a villain who sees the wind and steers the rudder, he has no ambition and can't become a climate.

  31. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    I don't think there is much chance of winning, even if Wei Yan doesn't die, he won't be of much use, and the Three Kingdoms in the later period are no longer a situation where one person can decide the odds. Moreover, Sima Yi's ability to unify the world shows that he has extraordinary skills, which Wei Yan may not be able to compare.

  32. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    I don't think there will be a great chance of winning, after all, Wei Yan was not the only one who was staring at Sima Yi at that time, but Sima Yi still unified the world, so even if Wei Yan existed, it couldn't have much impact.

  33. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    Sima Yi considers the overall situation, and Wei Yan is the winner or loser of a war, not a grade.

  34. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    Let's see if Wei Yan has the ability to survive Sima Yi, if he can, the Sima brothers will definitely not be the opponent of the general of Zhengxi.

  35. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    The defeat was faster, Wei Yan was a good general, but there were no generals in the later period of Shu Han.

  36. Anonymous users2024-01-11

    Basically there is no chance of winning, Wei Yan is unpopular in the Shu Han army, he is not good at unity, and in the face of Sima Yi, there is only the danger of annihilation of the whole army.

  37. Anonymous users2024-01-10

    Wei Yan is not dead, Shu Han is not dead! Ideas: Wei Yan commanded the Shu Han army, seven out of Qishan, Ding'an, broke Luoyang, the Wei army fled, Wei Yan swept Cao Wei in one fell swoop, welcomed Liu Chan in Luoyang, and reorganized the Han Dynasty! Of course, history has no ifs! With ifs, anything is possible!

  38. Anonymous users2024-01-09

    Joke! Wei Yan and Sima Yi are not at the same level at all

  39. Anonymous users2024-01-08

    It is estimated that there is not much, because Sima Yi's intelligence is very treacherous, and he infiltrated himself into the Wei Dynasty step by step. So his ability is still very strong, and he can't completely fight against Sima Yi.

  40. Anonymous users2024-01-07

    The odds of victory are not great, and it is difficult for individuals to achieve the final victory with the strength of one person, just as Zhuge Liang could not make Shu Han stable for a long time. The tide of history cannot be changed by one person.

  41. Anonymous users2024-01-06

    Yang Yi stepped on Wei Yan's head after killing Wei Yan: Yong slave can do evil??? If Liu Bei had knowledge under the spring, how would he feel???

  42. Anonymous users2024-01-05

    Wei Yanhui will do Liu Chan and replace him ......

  43. Anonymous users2024-01-04

    It's not a grade, and it can't be compared.

  44. Anonymous users2024-01-03

    If Wei Yan is here, Shu will not die.

  45. Anonymous users2024-01-02

    Wei Yan will not die and will not attack Wei at every turn, Wei Yan has a view of the overall situation, once there is an opportunity to take the Shu State west of Chang'an in one fell swoop, the dilemma of lack of food will be completely changed. The next focus is to take Jingzhou.

  46. Anonymous users2024-01-01

    Basically, there won't be much chance of winning, after all, when this matter reaches the late stage of Zhuge Liang, there are not many people who can continue to support them to be able to defend their families and the country.

  47. Anonymous users2023-12-31

    Wei Yan may rebel, the Shu Kingdom will perish faster, Wei Yan is a more arrogant and conceited person, he always feels that Zhuge Liang doesn't give him a chance, but in fact, he can't do it.

  48. Anonymous users2023-12-30

    Shu Han may be destroyed early, because Wei Yan is an ambitious person, and if he is there, it is very likely that he will rebel.

  49. Anonymous users2023-12-29

    Wei Yan immortalized Shu Han will have civil strife and may perish, he has a rebellious heart, and Zhuge Liang killed it for Shu Han.

  50. Anonymous users2023-12-28

    Rest assured, if Wei Yan is lucky enough not to die, Shu Han will not be affected in any way, and he should still perish. It's just a matter of time.

  51. Anonymous users2023-12-27

    If there are no special circumstances, Shu Han may speed up his demise even more, after all, Zhuge Liang will not kill a friend, someone who helps.

  52. Anonymous users2023-12-26

    If Wei Yan doesn't die, Shu Han may be destroyed, after all, Zhuge Liang is still very considerate of Shu Han, and he should not be the kind of villain who seeks public power for personal gain.

  53. Anonymous users2023-12-25

    will perish early. Wei Yan had always wanted to rebel, but Zhuge Liang didn't dare to do so. If you don't die, you will rebel.

  54. Anonymous users2023-12-24

    I think Wei Yan is not dead, maybe the Shu Kingdom will perish faster, because Wei Yan just wanted to rebel a little, but it was difficult to implement it because Zhuge Liang was alive.

Related questions
27 answers2024-08-07

I Wei Yanyi said that he is a very powerful hero in the Three Kingdoms, he continued to work hard to grow, and finally chose a very good leader, that person is Liu Bei, since he chose Liu Bei, he has followed Liu Bei wholeheartedly, and wants to govern Shu better, but his strength is really limited, and more importantly, because many people in the motherland know that he is very jealous of his talent, plus he has a very hot temper, and in the end he has a conflict with many people, and his talent has not been brought into play. >>>More

11 answers2024-08-07

Success, it's not better.

Let's talk about the problem of Wei Yan'an first - Chang'an, as the five capitals of Wei State, its importance and vigilance are no less than the current Zhangjiakou, even if Wei Yan captures Chang'an, it is impossible for the army to be smooth sailing in the short term (Cao Wei Chongzhen surrendered without resistance at all), or the grain and grass are burned, or the street battles and meticulous work in the city, or the Wei army is constantly harassing outside the city. >>>More

9 answers2024-08-07

Wei Yan (?) 234), a native of Yiyang. During the Three Kingdoms period, he was a famous general of the Shu Han Dynasty and was deeply valued by Liu Bei. >>>More

10 answers2024-08-07

The Five Tigers will be the name of the combination of the five fierce generals of Shu Han in the "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", namely Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, Ma Chao, and Huang Zhong. >>>More

19 answers2024-08-07

Yes, Wei Yan has experienced a hundred battles and has rich battlefield experience, so he can quickly judge the key points on the battlefield and will not make that kind of low-level mistake.