Xu Shu didn t offer a plan in Cao Ying, why didn t he punish him?

Because for Cao Cao, as long as Xu Shu is forcibly pulled into his camp, it is already a great success, and whether Xu Shu gives advice to himself or not is not so important, because his goal has been achieved. <>

First of all, pulling Xu Shu into his camp is a kind of weakening for Liu Bei, which is actually what Cao Cao is more willing to see. Xu Shu should be regarded as the first real strategist that Liu Bei met in the process of development, and the importance of Xu Shu is self-evident, a top think tank is very important to Liu Bei, if this top think tank is lost, then Liu Bei will lose more soldiers and horses in the process of fighting. Secondly, Liu Bei has always flaunted himself with benevolence and righteousness, so Cao Cao's move also made Liu Bei suffer a certain blow in terms of reputation, after all, a person who can't even protect his subordinates is likely to be hypocritical.

In addition, Cao Cao's move is also to establish an image for himself. In fact, there was no shortage of strategists under Cao Cao at that time, and the reason why he tried every means to pull Xu Shu into his camp was not only to weaken Liu Bei, but also to establish an orthodox image for himself. After digging Xu Shu over, Cao Cao actually didn't reuse it, because Cao Cao's real purpose was actually to reflect his "thirsty for talent" side, so that more capable people in the world could take refuge in him.

Of course, no matter what, the loss of Xu Shu was indeed a big blow to Liu Bei in the early stage, because Liu Bei had basically been defeated repeatedly since he started his army, and finally waited for a Xu Shu to let Liu Bei taste some sweetness. But Xu Shu was not yet hot in his camp, and he was poached by Cao Cao to find a way, which also made Liu Bei particularly angry, but Liu Bei was particularly helpless, after all, according to his personality, he couldn't kill Xu Shu.

Because Cao Cao values love and righteousness, loves talents and cherishes talents, especially those who are talented and virtuous, and Xu Shu happens to be loyal and trustworthy, so Cao Cao does not punish him.

First of all, Xu Shu is a particularly talented person, Cao Cao generally respects talented people, and secondly, because Xu Shu is particularly filial, in ancient times, filial people were generally respected.

Because punishing Xu Shu would damage Cao Cao's reputation. Xu Shu was originally deceived into Cao Ying's camp by Cao Cao, and if Xu Shu was punished, it would chill the people who took refuge in him.

Because Cao Cao felt guilty about Xu Shu, after all, he could come to Cao Ying or Cao Cao arrested Xu Shu's mother first.

Because Cao Cao's purpose in coercing him was not to make him work for himself, but to make him unable to serve Shu Han.

Xu Shu entered Cao Ying without saying a word. Who is this Xu Shu? Oh, it turns out that he is a very famous figure in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, he and Zhuge Liang are good friends, and he also recommended Zhuge Liang to Liu Bei, which shows that Xu Shu's talent is very powerful.

Moreover, he is also a person with lofty ideals who is loyal and filial. This afterword also evolved from a story that happened to him.

Because Xu Shu admired Liu Bei's personality very much, he followed Liu Bei to assist Liu Bei in fighting the world. Cao Cao heard that Xu Shu was very talented, and he also wanted to recruit Xu Shu to serve him. Cao Cao is very hot-hearted, he knows that Xu Shu is loyal to Liu Bei and will not give in easily.

sent someone to arrest Xu Shu's mother and put her under house arrest in Cao Ying. also used Xu Shu's mother's spoken language to write a letter to Xu Shu. Xu Shu knew that it was a plan, but he had to say goodbye to Liu Bei with tears in his eyes, and galloped to Cao Ying on horseback.

Xu Shu's mother thought that Xu Shu was going to abandon Liu Bei and go to Cao Cao, scolded Xu Shu, and finally committed suicide. Xu Shu was very sad, but he knew that Cao Cao would not let him go when he entered Cao Ying. Since then, Xu Shu has been in Cao Ying, no matter how big or small, he has not expressed his opinions, and has never said a word.

This is also what people later said, "being in Cao Ying, and being in Han".

Today I am very happy that I have learned another piece of history by consulting the materials. But when I praised Xu Shu's loyalty and filial piety, I also felt that my extracurricular knowledge was particularly shallow. Therefore, I will read more extracurricular books in the future to learn more about the history and culture of my country, so that I will not be a frog at the bottom of the well.

Xu Shu originally assisted Liu Bei, assisted Liu Bei in governing Xinye, and successively made plans to help Liu Bei defeat Cao Jun. Cao Cao suffered a loss, and felt that this was not Liu Bei's ability. I inquired about it and knew that it was Xu Shu who helped Liu Bei with the idea, and I admired Xu Shu very much.

Sending someone to solicit failed to succeed, at this time Cheng Yu came up with an idea, saying that Xu Shu was a very filial person, why not send someone to trick Xu's mother to Xu Du, so that he would not worry about Xu Shu not returning. So Cao Cao sent someone to deceive Xu's mother to Xuchang in the name of Xu Shu. Xu Shu had no choice but to follow Cao Cao, but before leaving, Liu Bei promised that he would never help Cao Cao with any ideas.

After Xu Shu came to Cao Cao, Xu's mother found out that she had been fooled and was very angry, saying that Xu Shu should not give up her loyalty because of her mother, so she committed suicide. Xu Shu was very sad and did not make any plans in Cao Ying all his life. This is the origin of Xu Shu's entry into Cao Ying without saying a word.

After Xu Shu defected to Liu Bei, he defeated Cao Ren, the general of the Cao army, several times in succession, and captured Fancheng. After Cao Ren and his lieutenant Li Dian fled back to Xuchang, they went to see Cao Cao and informed Liu Bei that he would rely mainly on "Shan Fu" to win.

Cao Cao's advisor Cheng Yu said with a smile: "This person is not Shan Fu, but Xu Shu of Yingzhou." Shan Fu is the name of his pretense. ”

Cheng Yu also told Cao Cao that Xu Shu's talent was much higher than him, and offered advice to Cao Cao to win Xu Shu into Cao.

It turned out that Xu Shu was filial piety, lost his father when he was young, and only his mother was at home, and his brother Xu Kang was dead, and his mother had no one to support; Cheng Yu then taught Cao Cao to earn Xu Shu's mother to Xuchang, and then ordered him to write a letter to recruit Xu Shu to return.

For this reason, Xu Shu had to leave Liu Bei and join Cao Ying.

However, although Cao Cao got Xu Shu, Xu Shu never gave him advice. The first reason is that Xu Shu is devoted to Liu Bei's affection, and he returned to Cao Ying not out of his own heart; The second is that after he returned to Cao Ying, the truth was revealed, and the old mother hanged herself angrily.

Xu Shu knew that he had been deceived, so he hated Cao Cao deeply and vowed not to set up a plan for Cao Cao. This is the famous story of "Xu Shu entered Cao Ying without saying a word".

This story later evolved into a sentence after the break: Xu Shu entered Cao Ying - without saying a word. It is used as a metaphor for people who are not good at talking or who cherish words like gold.

Xu Shu is a resourceful figure in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", when Liu Bei was almost defeated repeatedly, he was first hired as a military advisor, so he used a plan to kill Erlu, set up an ambush and anti-robbery camp, cracked the "Eight Gates Golden Lock Array", and secretly took Fancheng. Later, because Cao Cao pretended Xu's mother's handwriting to write to Xu Shu, Xu Shu had to leave Liu Bei. is the same as Xu Shu, and the display of his wisdom skills is very different from that of Liu Bei and Cao Cao, which is determined by the loyal quality that Xu Shu has.

Loyalty, as a moral category, regulates people's words and deeds, so that what they say and do is consistent with what they want in their hearts. Be loyal!

Xu Shu was Liu Bei's adviser and assisted Liu Bei in his fight against Cao Cao. Cao Cao kidnapped Xu's mother to Caoying, and wrote a letter in the name of Xu's mother to summon Xu to abandon Liu Bencao. Mother Xu thought he had betrayed Liu Bei and died of anger.

Xu Shu deeply felt Liu Bei's kindness, and since then he has never said a word about political affairs in Cao Ying. This story derives from a post-break sentence - "Xu Shu entered Cao Ying without saying a word".

Xu Shu entered Cao Ying without saying a word, but why did he get a good death?

A word is empty.

Xu Shu, a figure in the Three Kingdoms period at the end of the Han Dynasty, visited famous teachers all over the world, and became friends with Sima Hui, Zhuge Liang and others. Liu Bei, who was an official in Xinye, had to abandon his preparation because Cao Cao imprisoned his mother, and recommended Zhuge Liang's talent to Liu Bei before leaving.

After Xu Shu returned to Cao in the north, he was still very attached to his late master Liu Bei and his friend Zhuge Liang. Although he had outstanding strategy and talent, he was unwilling to give advice to Cao Cao and became enemies of Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang. Therefore, Xu Shu was in Cao Wei for decades, but he never made a difference in politics and military affairs, and almost disappeared into oblivion.

Therefore, in later generations, there is a proverb that "Xu Shu entered Cao Ying without saying a word".

The main reason why Xu Shu was unknown after entering Cao Ying was the four words "personnel system". Cao Cao's meritocracy is true, but his subordinates are too talented, after Xu Shu entered Wei, as a newcomer, his qualifications are still shallow, and he surrendered halfway, and it is not difficult to understand that he cannot get Cao Cao's trust.

He didn't say a word, he just didn't provide Cao Cao with any scheme; He was a very filial person in history, and he was very capable, and he planned many schemes for Liu Bei.

Xu Shu was a very well-known politician and military strategist during the Three Kingdoms period, and his political and military talents were very strong. After entering the Cao camp, he was silent.

Xu Shu in history, did he really say nothing when he entered Cao Ying.

Xu Shu entered Cao Ying without saying a word, but why did he get a good death?