Why didn t Zhuge Liang go to the street guard pavilion in person

Updated on history 2024-02-09
15 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    This is also a very big regret left by Zhuge Liang's first Northern Expedition.

    According to the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms: The Biography of Zhuge Liang": In the spring of the sixth year of the Jianxing of the Shu Han Dynasty, Zhuge Liang made a big noise to the outside world and said that he would march from Xiegu Road and capture Meixian. Zhao Yun and Deng Zhi were sent as suspicious troops to occupy the southern section of the valley, and Cao Zhen, the general of Wei, led the army of Wei to defend the valley and resist Zhao Yun and Deng Zhi.

    Zhuge Liang personally led the main force to attack Qishan, the army lineup was neat, the rewards and punishments were serious, the order was clear, the three counties of Nan'an, Tianshui and Yong'an broke away from Wei and responded to Zhuge Liang, and the Guanzhong area of Wei was greatly shaken. Emperor Cao Rui of Wei Ming personally went west to Chang'an and ordered Zhang He to resist Zhuge Liang. Zhuge Liang appointed Ma Tan as the commander-in-chief of the former enemy, commanding all armies, and fought with Zhang He in Jieting.

    Ma Tan violated Zhuge Liang's moderation, behaved inappropriately, and was defeated by Zhang He. Zhuge Liang relocated more than 1,000 families in Xixian County, returned to Hanzhong, and killed Ma Jian to thank the generals.

    At that time, the Northern Expedition, out of the surprise of the Wei State, progressed smoothly, had a huge impact, and the situation was good. Although it may not be possible to unify the Central Plains in one go, it is still very possible to take Shaanxi Guanzhong. However, due to the defeat of the street pavilion, he lost a good situation and was forced to retreat.

    In the following Northern Expeditions, there was no more suddenness of the first time, and such a good situation was not achieved again.

    At that time, Zhuge Liang authorized Ma Jian to serve as the commander-in-chief of the former enemy and sit in the rear himself. Obviously, he overestimated Ma Tan's talent and prestige, and his authorization was too large, and Ma Jian did not completely follow Zhuge Liang's deployment, and the generals may not all obey Ma Tan's command, resulting in the Shu army being more numerous than the Wei army, but it suffered defeat. If Zhuge Liang had personally commanded it, it would have been possible to avoid such a situation.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Zhuge Liang is going to the Northern Expedition to Wei, so he must wait for the opportunity to move, and want to take advantage of the situation to attack the Wei Guanzhong, rather than defending it himself.

    The street pavilion was the choke point for Cao Wei to attack Shu Han, so someone had to guard it.

    But after this failed employment, Zhuge Liang will personally sit in the future war

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Zhuge Liang is not a charge-type general, he is a military division-type commander, so he will not go to the front line, and he usually gives orders from behind.

    If you don't believe it, look at history, he almost never went to the front line, and even the empty city plan that he made up was because Sima Yi came to him, and it was too late to leave, so he had to do it.

    And in fact, he was more cautious than timid, and you see all the battles he fought, and every success was attributed to him, and every defeat was attributed to the generals.

    I have to say that he is very good at dealing with things.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Jieting is just a transportation transit station on the front line His goal is to cut Wei He went to guard the street pavilion Who is in command of the troops of Vawei.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Zhuge Liang is the supreme commander of the three armies, and he is not the commander-in-chief of the front line.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Guarding the street pavilion is a matter of the scope of the battle.

    There are higher-level strategies than battles waiting for Zhuge Liang to do.

    Zhuge Liang went to do something in the scope of the campaign, so who will command the three armies?

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Stupid, will the commander-in-chief of the three services work on the front line?

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    It is good to use Jiang Wei to guard the street pavilion, but Zhuge Liang has just subdued Jiang Wei, and he is not yet able to fully trust, and Ma Jian voluntarily proposed to Zhuge Liang to go to the street pavilion first, Ma Jian and Zhuge Liang have been proficient in the art of war for many years, so Zhuge Liang thought about it for a while and let him go, and said that Zhuge Liang had already sent Jiang Wei to be a pioneer, so it was impossible to let Jiang Wei go to the street pavilion.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Ma Du himself said that he wanted to defend it, and made a military order. You're asking Jiang Wei to guard, the impact is not good.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    It is!! Yikes! If you don't ask Ma Ji to guard, you don't trust him.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    The reason why Zhuge Liang did not personally guard the street pavilion was that Zhuge Liang was the commander and needed to be responsible for the command and dispatch of various fronts in the army, so there was no way to guard the street pavilion, and he chose Ma Tan to guard the street pavilion, which was easy to defend and difficult to attack.

    Zhuge Liang (181 - October 8, 234), the name Kongming, the name Wolong, Langya Yangdu (now Yinan County, Shandong Province), the prime minister of the Shu Han Dynasty during the Three Kingdoms period, was an outstanding politician, military strategist, writer and reformer in ancient China.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    <> "The street pavilion is so important, why doesn't Zhuge Liang personally guard it?"

    Speaking of street pavilions, everyone should know that in this battle, Ma Ji was killed by Zhuge Liang with tears because of his loss. In the situation at that time, the defense of the street pavilion was still very important, since everyone knew this, why didn't Zhuge Liang personally collect it? Why do you have to wait until you lose at the end to regret it?

    Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition by Changchen Gao can be said to be very bumpy, although when he first attacked Wei, he captured the three counties of Tianshui, Nan'an, and Anding. So let Cao Wei send troops to shootout strategic places, of which the street pavilion is one. You must know that the strategic location of the street pavilion is still very important, and Zhuge Liang should be aware of this.

    sent Ma Ji as a pioneer to guard the street pavilion.

    However, as a result of Ma Ji's defense, everyone should know that he was completely defeated by Zhang He, and Cao Wei also successfully occupied the strategic location of Jieting. For such a result, Zhuge Liang is indeed very angry, of course, this will not be fatal, the reason why Zhuge Liang beheaded Ma Ji was because he wanted to escape later, so he was killed after being captured. But if this street pavilion is so important, why didn't Brother Zhuge Liang guard it himself?

    In fact, how could Zhuge Liang not think of this question? In fact, this point was indeed thought about, but Zhuge Liang was the boss at that time, and in ancient times, the main brush of the ruler was to coordinate the overall situation, how could it be possible that he was personally present in every battle, and it was not only the street pavilion that needed to know the battle. The choice of Ma Tan to guard the street pavilion is actually caused by the characteristics of the street pavilion and Zhuge Liang's excessive conceit, it is obvious that the street pavilion is easy to defend and difficult to attack.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    The main reason is Zhuge Liang's mistake in employing people, everyone suggested that the generals Wei Yan, Wu Yi and others should be used as the main generals, but Zhuge Liang did not adopt it, but appointed his own army Ma Jian to lead the army。Therefore, in the battle of the liquid of the street pavilion, Zhuge Liang was defeated.

    The Battle of the Street Pavilion went by:

    Zhuge Liang was a famous military strategist and statesman during the Three Kingdoms period. When he attacked Qishan, many people suggested that Wei Yan, Wu Yi and others should be the main generals, but Zhuge Liang did not have this suggestion, but appointed his own army member Ma Jian to lead the army. Later, Ge Liang ordered Ma Tan to guard the street pavilion to resist the attack of Cao Wei's Zhang He.

    However, Ma Tan disobeyed Zhuge Liang's instructions and made a dissatisfying move in Jieting, and abandoned the water source, choosing to defend on Nanshan instead of occupying the town below the mountain. General Wang Ping persuaded Ma Jian many times, but Ma Jian did not have any. Soon after, Zhang He arrived and surrounded the mountainous area, cut off the water source of the Ma Tan army on the mountain, and used rockets to attack the Ma Tan army, breaking the Ma Tan army, scattering the soldiers and disintegrating the army.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition, because the street pavilion is a military location, sent Ma Tan to guard it. Ma Tan claimed to have been familiar with military books since he was a child, and was familiar with the subtlety of the art of war, and did not listen to the persuasion of the deputy general Wang Ping, so he stationed his men and horses on the mountain, condescendingly, and regarded one as ten.

    When Sima Yi led his troops to attack, he trapped Ma Jian on the mountain, cut off its waterway, and set fire to the mountain, causing Ma Tan's army to chaos without a fight, so he lost the street pavilion.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Summary. <>

    Hello, dear, I'm very happy with your question, how did Zhuge Liang deal with it after the loss of the street pavilion, and help you find out, the battle of the street pavilion is the eternal pain in the hearts of the Shu Han army and civilians, especially Zhuge Liang. Among Zhuge Liang's five Northern Expeditions, the best situation was the First Northern Expedition. But this Northern Expedition was buried due to the loss of the street pavilion.

    If the Jieting is lost, the back road of the Shu army will be cut off by the Wei army, thus losing all favorable situations. Zhuge Liang can only lead his troops back to Hanzhong, and the good situation will be ruined, I hope I can help you. Wishing you good health and a happy mood!

    How did Zhuge Liang deal with the loss of the street pavilion.

    Hello, dear, I'm very happy with your question, how did Zhuge Liang deal with it after the loss of the street pavilion, and help you find out, the battle of the street pavilion is the eternal pain in the hearts of the Shu Han army and civilians, especially Zhuge Liang. Among Zhuge Liang's five Northern Expeditions, the best situation was the First Northern Expedition. But this Northern Expedition was buried due to the loss of the street pavilion.

    If the Jieting is lost, the back road of the Shu army will be cut off by the Wei army, thus losing all favorable situations. Zhuge Liang can only lead his troops back to Hanzhong, and the good situation will be ruined, I hope I can help you. Wishing you good health and a happy mood!

    The Battle of Jieting, judging from the map operation, can be described as a genius's military deployment and a mediocre command operation. Street Pavilion is very important to Shu Han and Cao Wei. For Shu Han, the street pavilion was lost, the grain road was cut, and they either returned in rout, or held on until the whole army starved to death, and Hanzhong was lost again; For Cao Wei, the street pavilion was not obtained, and the military road was blocked, either the reinforcements were destroyed, or the five counties of Longyou were all lost, and Guanzhong was not guaranteed.

    For this reason, on the street pavilion, Shu Han blocked and guarded; Cao Wei advanced and attacked, and the balance between the two sides was inevitable. Ma Tan led the troops to the street pavilion, and Zhuge Liang issued a combat mission: regardless of **, stick to the street pavilion and block Zhang He.

    According to Zhuge Liang's deployment, Ma Tan defended the city, even if 25,000 elite soldiers could not stop Zhang He's 50,000 army, at least it would take three months, half a load, or even longer. After all, with Zhuge Liang's cautious and cautious way of doing things, he handed over the great cause related to the Northern Expedition to the Central Plains and the restoration of the Han dynasty to Ma Jian to complete. Without the certainty of success, Zhuge Liang will not and dare not take risks.

Related questions
17 answers2024-02-09

In fact, those who are familiar with the Three Kingdoms should know that there is a wonderful episode in the Three Kingdoms, that is, Zhou Yu is ready to marry his sister Sun Shangxiang to Liu Bei for the sake of the overall situation. At this time, Zhuge Liang arranged for Zhao Yun to accompany Liu Bei to Jiangdong, of course, the reason why Zhuge Liang had such an arrangement also had his own intentions, first of all, Zhao Yun was the same as Zhang Fei and Guan Yu, and they had followed Liu Bei a long time ago, so loyalty was definitely very reliable. Secondly, Zhao Yun is also a general, and it is also very important to know how to help Liu Bei get out at a critical moment. >>>More

4 answers2024-02-09

Because people who say this have not carefully read the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, let alone read serious history books such as the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, they will be followed by those few people who are talking nonsense on the Internet.

13 answers2024-02-09

Because many people in modern times think that what Zhuge Liang did was to go against the sky, dragging the people of the world into years of war, reckless and reckless, dismantling dissidents, disrespecting talents, and being too individual-centered.

15 answers2024-02-09

In the official history, Zhuge Liang did not use the empty city plan, and the matter of "Zhuge Liang putting the empty city plan" is Luo Guanzhong's artistic creation, and the battle of the street pavilion, the commander of the Wei side is Zhang He, not Sima Yi, Kong Ming can't use the "empty city plan" to scare off Sima Yi who is thousands of miles away. "The Biography of the Three Kingdoms, Shu, Zhuge Liang": "Later Lord Jianxing) in the spring of the sixth year, (Liang) raised the voice from the Xiegu Road to take the Yi, so that Zhao Yun and Deng Zhi were suspicious troops, according to Keigu. >>>More

18 answers2024-02-09

The number of level 18 And then the number that must be fought to a level seems to be forgotten Oh You'd better go to the official QQ to find the lighting page There are requirements for lighting up.