Which variety show is more popular with the public, Extreme Challenge or Running Man ?

Wanted to have two variety shows.

For evaluation, we must consider many factors, such as the star lineup, the type of program, and the impact on society. Through the comparison of these aspects, we can know which variety shows are more popular with the public. However, the categories of the general public are different, young people may prefer "Running Man" with many handsome guys and beautiful women, while young people or adults may prefer the challenging "Extreme Challenge".

1, boys and girls like "Running Man".

The first few seasons of "Running Man" were relatively good, mainly based on the sense of variety shows, and there were many stars with a strong sense of variety in the show. But then the show changed, and people with a sense of variety showed quit the show one after another, and now only handsome guys and beauties remain in this show. These people have a large number of young fans, and boys and girls may prefer "Running Man" to "Extreme Challenge".

However, from my point of view, the content of this show is not novel, and it is the same content for several seasons, and there is nothing to watch except for the stars.

2. "Extreme Challenge" has a wide audience

"Extreme Challenge" is a variety show that combines the powerful and the idols, and most of the people in it are based on strength, even the original small fresh meat.

Zhang Yixing, who debuted.

Now it has gradually become a powerful faction. And this show is challenging, every season promotes positive energy, and it will end with a public welfare program at the end, compared with "Running Man", I like "Extreme Challenge" more. When people reach a certain age, they no longer pay attention to their appearance, but will pay attention to the quality and impact of the program.

And watching variety shows is for fun, and it is obvious that "Extreme Challenge" can bring more joy to people now.

3. "Extreme Challenge" is more popular

If you compare the two, "Extreme Challenge" has a certain advantage. Whether in terms of word-of-mouth or impact on society, "Extreme Challenge" is far higher than "Running Man". And judging from the effect of the show, most of the male stars in "Extreme Challenge" know how to be humorous, which is much better than "Running Man".

I think "Running Man" is more popular with the public than "Extreme Challenge", because "Running Man" came out a little earlier, and the guests of "Running Man" will be more famous, so it is more popular.

I think the variety show Extreme Challenge is more popular with the public, because many of their links are very interesting.

"Running Man" and "Extreme Challenge" are both very famous variety shows in recent years, and because of the similar broadcast time, they are often compared, where is the gap between the two?

Gap 1: Most of the resident guests of "Extreme Challenge" are powerful people who have been in the entertainment industry for many years, such as Sun Honglei, Huang Lei, Huang Bo and others are all seniors in the entertainment industry who have a wide range of dramas and status. In other words, these people don't particularly need the show "Extreme Challenge" to boost their popularity, or that the show is at most the icing on the cake, so the guests have their own positioning, and they don't have to worry about stealing the limelight from each other.

But "Running Man" is different, the resident guests do not have enough accumulation in the entertainment industry, and they need the show to increase their popularity. In other words, in fact, the creators need to show themselves in the show and do their best to increase the shots for themselves, so as to better enhance their popularity and increase opportunities for themselves. The competitive relationship makes the guests have more implicit competition in the recording of the program, and the perception is relatively weak.

Gap 2: The script says that variety shows are scripted, and these two variety shows are like this. However, in comparison, the script of "Running Man" is more obvious, or the producer has put a lot of effort into the details of the whole program when creating it, and the laughter is also very prepared.

"Extreme Challenge" naturally has a script, at least a framework. But the men's gang can always perform beyond the existing framework, in other words, these people can routinely play the director team in the process of recording the show, so they even feel the thousand-layer game between the guests and the program team during the ** program, and can't think of the plot behind. In this regard, the running man is relatively weak, because the general plot links can be guessed, which is mostly expected.

Gap 3: In addition to the resident guests, the two variety shows will actually invite some guests to participate in the show. The guests who participated in "Extreme Challenge" may be "cleaned" very badly, and they feel that they are not taken care of by the resident guests at all, but the final result is still good, and there are all the shots that should be there, and even because "being tricked is miserable" can also cause widespread discussion.

The guests who participated in "Running Man" will feel the care of the resident guests, and everyone will smile, but in the process of recording the show, they will feel that everyone uses eighteen kinds of martial arts in order to compete for the camera. In the end, the show was presented, and there were not many individual shots, and there was not even a sense of existence, because everyone was in a competitive relationship, and the harmony was not so high.

The "Extreme Challenge" mentioned above refers to the seasons that the men's gang has not left yet, excluding the later seasons, because the later seasons are not fundamentally different from "Running Man", whether it is the program setting or the laughter, there is a lot less, and the harmonious atmosphere is also less. Of course, watching variety shows is just for the sake of having fun, whether it is "Running Man" or "Extreme Challenge", it can meet the needs of the audience, and it is the happiest to watch without thinking.

Nowadays, there are more and more types of variety shows, and many viewers know that in some variety shows, there are scripts, but compared with those variety shows without scripts, they are indeed a lot inferior. The audience of some shows knows that there is a script, but the program team wants to create an atmosphere that the audience doesn't know, and they keep acting, which makes people very embarrassed to watch.

Speaking of the variety show "Let's Run", I believe everyone is also very familiar with it, and since the change of guest lineup, it has also been controversial. Especially the issue of "Cat and Mouse Game", which makes people very tangled in watching, I can't help but feel sorry for Wang Yanlin, the new member of the starting man, at that time, the topic of "what a miserable man, I feel sorry for Wang Yanlin" also appeared on the hot search list.

In the show, "Rat King" Yang Ying and "Cat Companion" Wang Yanlin are also very obvious, but in this case, Zheng Kai still chose to believe Yang Ying, and wronged Wang Yanlin, and finally Yang Ying won. Judging from the whole season of the show, Yang Ying is almost the winner in every episode of the show, and the traces of the script are too obvious. But the show has always been reluctant to admit the existence of a script, in contrast, "Extreme Challenge" is much more sincere, and even puts the fact of having a script on the bright side, "Extreme Challenge" has a script.

Although "Extreme Challenge" has a script, it obviously doesn't work when I meet the characters of "Extreme Men's Gang"! Because they didn't follow the script at all, so much so that later there was a saying that "chicken strips have no rules", because most of the scripts were invalid, because the "Extreme Three Essences" (Huang Bo, Huang Lei, Luo Zhixiang) were too lazy to read, and the "Extreme Three Fools" (Zhang Yixing, Sun Honglei, Wang Xun) only read a rough idea, or they couldn't understand it. For the men's gang, they just don't have a script, and they are completely free to play.

The show "Extreme Challenge" appeared later than "Let's Run", but the show's limelight overtook "Let's Run", which shows that the variety show with free play has won the hearts of the audience more, perhaps it is the tacit understanding of the "Extreme 6+1" combination that fired this shot. After the change of members in the fifth season of "Extreme Challenge", the word-of-mouth has always been **, which shows that "Extreme 6+1" is indispensable.

Do you have any thoughts on this?

In fact, the gap between them is in the baggage, because the running man is actually very idol baggage, and there are extreme challenges, he has always been very arrogant, and he has always put down the baggage.

The gap is really in the way the show plays or how they operate. And the guests are also different.

Extreme Challenge: The game always has to make something very high-forced; Emphasize the display of the individual and promote the game by showing personal charm; Free to play the character, but there is a pretending atmosphere.

Running Man: Pure entertainment, based on the theme of the game, each with its own advantages and disadvantages complementing each other's large groups.

First of all, the character of the character, there are still actors with a sense of variety show in Running Man, and it feels very exciting to be supported by them in the early stage, but after inviting a lot of traffic students, I feel that it is not as good as before, and the three essences and three fools of the extreme challenge are really applauding, and Director Yan Min is also very powerful, the plot story line is eye-catching, and later after these two variety shows have changed people, especially after changing the director, I forgot my original intention, just to make money.

I think that Running Man and Extreme Challenge are both run in China with foreign models, and the difference is the novelty of the game setting, in fact, both are almost hot variety shows.

I feel that "Extreme Challenge" is more real and real, because the feelings revealed are also more sincere, which makes people deeply immersed and unstoppable; However, "Let's Run" is just a simple entertainment created with big scenes and big prices, lacking connotation.