Shang Ying s reform was very successful, and the Qin state became more powerful because of it, why w

The execution of Shang Ying was also an inevitability for King Qin Huiwen to vent his personal anger. Unlike Qin Xiaogong, Ying Si and Shang Ying have no personal feelings, their relationship is very simple, that is, an ordinary relationship between superiors and subordinates, and there are historical grievances between superiors and subordinates. Because when King Huiwen was the crown prince, because the fiefdom of the tribute was transferred, the young and vigorous Yingsi moved to anger the people and caused a popular uprising.

The state of Qin, which had just implemented the new policy, demanded that the country be governed according to law, and that the crown prince must also be punished for his mistakes. Faced with a difficult problem, Shang Ying resolutely chose to punish the prince and his teacher according to the law, rather than back down in front of the powerful. Therefore, the crown prince Yingsi was exiled, and the prince Fu Yingqian was even tortured by the poor nose (gouging out the nose).

Therefore, Ying Si took over the Liang with Shang Yang before he ascended the throne. The crown prince Fu Yingqian is the elder brother of Qin Xiaogong and the representative of the old forces of the Qin State, because of this incident, the seeds of hatred were planted against Shang Ying. After the death of Xiaogong, Shang Ying lost his biggest protective umbrella, and of course the veteran forces represented by Ying Qian wanted to take revenge madly, although Ying Si agreed to change the law, but he only hated Shang Ying and had no affection, so he did not hesitate to carry out capital punishment on him.

From Qin Xiaogong's point of view, the Qin State must have a person named Shang Yang in order to have Shang Jun Law. And from the perspective of King Qin Huiwen, it has become that the Qin State needs Shang Junfa, but it does not need Shang Ying.

Shang Ying's death is a political necessity and a historical need, regardless of his merits.

Because while the law change was successful, it also endangered the interests of the feudal family and aroused public resentment

Shang Ying's death is no wonder to others, because he has been digging his own grave.

Shang Ying's reform was supported by the whole Qin state, which made King Qin Huiwen vigilant.

This policy has implicated many innocent people, and the people also hate this law very much.

Hurt your interests and offend people!

Because Shang Ying's changes touched the interests of vested interest groups, especially when he offended the prince at the time. When Qin Xiaogong, who supported him, died, the crown prince Qin Huiwen, who had a conflict with him, succeeded to the throne and finally executed Shang Ying.

Because Shang Ying's reform touched the interests of the old clan of Qin, after the death of the prince, there was no one to protect Shang Ying, and Shang Ying was not able to escape to other countries, so he was executed.

Because Qin Shi Huang was very jealous of Shang Ying, he felt that Shang Ying was a very talented person, so he would be executed.

Mainly because Shang Ying's reform touched the interests of the nobles of the Qin State, so no matter how much he contributed, he still had to die in the end.

For this question, we must first understand what happened to Shang Ying before the change: Shang Ying was originally the concubine of the Duke of Wei, and belonged to the declining aristocracy, and when the Gong Shu was seriously ill, he recommended Shang Ying to King Wei Hui, saying that Shang Ying was talented, and if he was reused, he would be the pillar of the country; If not, kill Shang Ying to avoid bringing disaster to Wei in the future. King Wei Hui did not listen to Gongshuzuo's words and did not recognize Shang Ying's ability at all; Shang Ying thought that there would be people who would discover their talents and be willing to do their part for the Wei State, so he stayed in the Wei State for more than a year without listening to the advice of the Gong Shuzuo, but no one paid attention to him, and they were not optimistic about Shang Yan and thought he was a mediocre talent.

At this time, the Qin State was recruiting talents, and if it helped the country, the benefits would be abundant. Shang Ying, who had the ability to release nowhere, heard the news and went to the Qin State. At this time, the Qin State was facing a crisis, the geographical location was not dominant, the national strength was weak, the material strength was weak, and it was facing the disaster of annihilation.

At the beginning, Shang Ying did not recommend the Legalist system, but said that there were no specific practices for benevolent and virtuous government, only empty rhetoric, and what Wei wanted at this time was a concrete method that could be implemented to save the country. So Shang Ying proposed a system of changing the law, and Qin Xiaogong felt that this was good, which could enable the country to survive the crisis and change the original state of decline. However, the change involved the interests of the old aristocracy, and the old aristocracy would definitely not agree to the reform, so Qin Xiaogong gave Shang Ying the power to be a thug and fight wits and courage with the old nobles.

If the Shang Dynasty reform is successful, it can make the country strong and survive the crisis, and he can also profit from it; On the contrary, if it fails, it will be solved by the old aristocracy, and its own rights will be consolidated.

After the implementation of the reform, Shang Ying really offended the old aristocracy, achieved great success in the struggle against them, gained a lot of support, gained great prestige among the masses, and had some personnel rights. Historical records: Eight years of filial piety, illness and can't afford it, want to pass on the businessman, but can't resign.

Warring States Policy", which shows that Shang Ying's change of law threatened the monarch, and Qin Xiaogong was worried about the situation. After the death of Duke Qin Xiao, Duke Huiwen of Qin succeeded to the throne, and in order to establish his prestige, he had to kill Shang Ying. Therefore, Qin Huiwen Gong united with the old nobles who were threatened by the change of law to fight against Shang Ying, and finally Shang Ying was executed, and Qin Huiwen Gong grasped the power of Qin.

Lessons from history: Serving the royal family is thankless, and you must try your best to stay away from the royal family in order to stay away from calculations and control your own destiny.

It was because King Qin felt that his reputation was much lower than that of Shang Ying, and if the people supported Shang Ying as king, his life would not be guaranteed.

He offended many people in the process of changing the law, which caused the dissatisfaction of the family, and in order to appease the emotions of these people, he could only execute Shang Ying.

It was because Shang Ying's ambition was too huge, although he became the prime minister of the Qin Dynasty and his son became an official, he was particularly dissatisfied, and even wanted to assassinate the King of Qin many times.

Because he threatens the interests of some powerful people. These magnates were afraid that if he continued like this, they might have no money to spend, so they directly blew the wind in front of the emperor.

It was because Qin was afraid that talents like Shang Ying would fall into the hands of others and offer advice to other countries, so they killed Shang Ying to prevent future troubles.

The impact on the Qin State is very great, it is because of his changes that people can live a good life, and it also improves people's production capacity, because in the end he touched the interests of the powerful and was framed to die tragically.

The impact on the Qin State was very great, it was because Shang Ying implemented the reform that the national strength of the country was improved, and the economic strength was improved, and the enthusiasm of the people was mobilized.

laid the foundation for the unification of the six countries in the whole country, and after the Shang Dynasty changed the law, the Qin State became a powerful country. Because he harmed the interests of some nobles, the king of Qin was killed by the king of Qin in order to stabilize the country.

Because Shang Ying implemented a harsh and clean government, the people complained bitterly, and naturally hated him very much. And the nobles of the Qin Dynasty lost some of their interests because of Shang Ying's changes, and naturally they hated potatoes and slowed down him, so even if Shang Ying's changes made Qin become several spikes stronger, the Qin State still hated Shang Ying.

It was the people of Qin who benefited from Shang Ying, not the nobles of Qin, who hated him at that time, and in the end he was also killed by the nobles of Qin.

Because Shang Ying's reform was very radical, many of the measures were cruel and violated the interests of many people.