How do you evaluate Dream of Red Mansions written by Hongxue writer Liu Xinwu?

Liu Xinwu's comment on Dream of Red Mansions is biased and can be forgiven. You don't have to continue to write. To write Dream of Red Mansions, you must have a broader accumulation of knowledge and art than the content of the book, otherwise it will be full of loopholes and collapse.

The plot of "Dream of Red Mansions" written by Liu Xinwu is like a running account, written wherever he goes, imaginatively and without rules. The dialogue of the characters is inevitably "polluted" by modern Chinese, and I want to imitate the ancient vernacular but I can't imitate it well.

Liu Xinwu's continued "Dream of Red Mansions" is like a maggot on the tarsal bone, with a low style and disgusting. And the original can not be counted.

I think Liu Xinwu's continued "Dream of Red Mansions" did not write poetry, even if Miss Gongzi didn't have the heart to write poetry after the collapse of Jiafu, it would not be less to this point, and a few of them were at the level of limericks, and the pediatrics were very good, so it was better not to have them. As for other genres, such as qufu, it is even more lacking.

Liu Xinwu's "Dream of Red Mansions" has no descriptions of scenes and utensils, and the funeral of Jia's mother and the like are all brushed aside, without any details, so that people have no impression of whether they have not experienced the kind of life of that era.

Gao E's continued plot, if I give a score of 90 points on a 100-point system, because even if Cao Gong writes it himself, the whole work will have some small flaws and cannot be perfect, then Mr. Liu Xinwu, who has studied Dream of Red Mansions for decades, does have some views and novelty, but I will give at most fifty-nine points to his continued writing, because the overall writing is not connected, the style is completely disjointed, and a lot of effort is wasted, and I am afraid that it will not have a lot of impact on future generations. Cripples sometimes have flaws, and beauty is flawed!

Liu Xinwu's continued "Dream of Red Mansions" works Baoyu Xiangyun's body, and Sister Feng, Baochai, Daiyu, and Jia's mother are like dead people, and they don't even say a few words.

Writer Liu Xinwu continued to write "Dream of Red Mansions". The plot is not very good, because it is a bit like a running account, where you go, where you write, there is no complete plot sequence.

Dream of Red Mansions can't be continued! The reason for this goes without saying.

But whoever wants to write and see it out of interest, it's understandable.

It's just that by virtue of fame and relationships, propaganda in national propaganda agencies is carried out, and profits are made, what kind of crime does this ,,, match!

Don't say anything else, do you have a reason, or a basis, to guarantee that you did not misinterpret Cao Gong's original intention?

Tell you that you can't! You can't tell the reason or come up with evidence, because, I'm here to tell you for free, your cultural heritage, I'm sorry, I can't say that I compare with Cao Gong, that's too much to overestimate you, I can only say that your cultural heritage, according to your experience, is very ordinary, and it's really ordinary in today's China!

I like your **, and I like your passion for red science.

The reason why "Dream of Red Mansions" has become a discipline is because it actually reflects a period of history of Kang Yongqian's period, and the wind and snow in the book, romantic love are all a kind of cover-up, first: Liu Xinwu is written according to the history book, his main purpose is to restore historical events after a large number of archives, second: to revise the plot that cannot be justified in the last forty and the first eighty times of Gao E, as for the writing and poetry, it is not a matter for Mr. Liu to consider at all, and those who belittle Mr. Liu probably don't like to write. For people who like to write, it is a feeling to be able to accurately write what is in their hearts.

Liu Xinwu's continued "Dream of Red Mansions" has been criticized because he writes very one-sidedly, and the character descriptions are not specific and detailed.

Mr. Liu Xinwu is an admirable writer with profound skills and rich experience, and the continuation of "Dream of Red Mansions" is a great contribution to the study of Red Mansions. As for whether it meets the requirements of the original work, it is up to you to leave it to future generations to comment more.

Liu Xinwu commented that Dream of Red Mansions is a ruined masterpiece, and the continuation is a dog's tail and a mink, which is disgusting, this person belongs to the villain and the like, and it is not worth paying attention to.

The continuation is very good, and with Liu Xinwu's continuation, you will find that Gao E's continuation is actually very good.

Liu Xinwu's continued "Dream of Red Mansions" only wrote about the Jia family and lost the Zhen family. Forgot the comment in the original book that Jia is about to end and the real thing is revealed.

The general meaning is continued, but there are some people whose endings don't feel like the first eighty times! Dream of Red Mansions is not only **, but also includes the architecture, medicine, etiquette, clothing, hairstyle, food, home, poetry, etc., which are used to supplement and beautify**! It is the encyclopedia of the ancient **!

Liu Xinwu is a modern person, he can't add all these aspects, I think if Cao Xueqin's last eighty episodes exist, there should also be various parts of life!

The modern ** written by Liu Xinwu is still good, and the continuation of "Dream of Red Mansions" is really not flattering. Needless to say, the transparency of the ancient life scenes, and not the grasp of the storyline, the writing alone is inferior to Cao Gong. (Forgive me for learning Mr. Lu Xun's sentence structure).

The benevolent see the benevolent, and the wise see the wise. Mr. Liu Xinwu's courage is commendable, and he is grateful to him for dedicating us a different ending of "Dream of Red Mansions"!

Isn't it a good thing not to evaluate whether Liu Xinwu's Dream of Red Mansions is good, Liu Xinwu's contribution is that through his interpretation, more people can understand "Dream of Red Mansions" and understand a classical literary masterpiece, isn't it a good thing? As for some netizens saying that Liu Xinwu is qualified to continue the Dream of Red Mansions, Ah Q has already done it: The monk can touch it, but I can't touch it?

Liu's level shouldn't be continued, I know it's poor if I haven't seen it.

I haven't read Liu Xinwu's "Dream of Red Mansions", but it's certainly not as good as Cao Gong's. If you are not a person of that era, you have not experienced that social environment, and you don't have Cao Gong's experience, how can you compare with Cao Gong's "Dream of Red Mansions"?

A sequel to the dog's tail in the new era is too far worse than the sequel to Cheng Weiyuan and Gao E.

Without that experience and experience, how many fans of Red Mansion have tried to continue the Dream of Red Mansions, and they have become idiots and dreams, in the past, at present, and in the future, there should still be such people, and Cao Yiqin should laugh and laugh when he knows underground.

Classics are for appreciation, not for you to blindly evaluate and write randomly based on that level, why don't you go to get the Nobel Prize if you have that level.

I thought it was funny when I said that I would continue Dream of Red Mansions, but I didn't expect it to be retinted, you have the courage to serve,,, I can't comment if I don't see what you wrote. Advice dude, the first 80 times, I think it's very well written, don't change it.

If you have more than enough heart and not enough strength, it is better not to write it if you write it to attract evil.

Read, scribble. has to be pretentious to write in the direction of beauty, completely ignoring the setting of the tragedy of Dream of Red Mansions.

Personally, I think Liu Xinwu's ending is close to the original, but the language does not have the charm of the original.

Haven't seen it. But I still want to check it out. But after all, he is a modern person, and he should not write as Gao Yi of the Qing Dynasty.

You're asking a question, right? Qin Keqing hung up in the fifth episode of the original book, why use to continue writing, as for the cause of death, Mr. Liu believes that he died of political investment, according to Mr. Liu's inference: Keqing is the daughter of Yinren, the prince of the Kangxi Dynasty, Yinren has nothing to do with the Jia family because of political defeat, so he hid Keqing in the Jia family, and became Jia Rong's wife, and the Jia family sent Yuanchun to the palace in order to have stronger political security, and as Mr. Liu said, he was double-insured, and finally Keqing killed Mr. Liu, but he thought it was caused by Yuanchun's denunciation.

As for all the time, let's take a look at Mr. Liu's lecture for myself.

Jia Yuanchun had doubts about the identity of Qin Keqing in Xifu since he was a child, and he "identified who it was in the past twenty years", and later entered the palace and learned a lot of royal secrets in the palace, plus he heard what his family said about the battle for the throne of the royal family at home, so he deduced that Qin Keqing was the daughter of the abolished prince, so, In order to be able to climb faster in the palace of intrigue, In order not to have a time bomb in his family, In order to show his loyalty to the emperor (it is worth pointing out that this is not the same as Repeat, thought that Yuan Chun was indeed very loyal to the emperor), so she resolutely revealed Qin Keqing's true identity to the emperor, and naturally, the emperor managed to kill Keqing.

was denounced by Yuan Chun that her true identity turned out to be the daughter of the abolished prince, who was given death by the emperor!