-
This question, with all due respect, historical events and time can be verified, but what the ancients thought at that time, you and I were not themselves, how can we guess.
Xu Shu was originally a very clever person, but it was difficult to achieve both loyalty and filial piety, so he went to Cao Cao.
The Battle of Chibi has the most scenes... Your Excellency is looking at the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the Romance is based on **, and **not all are practical. For example, Guan Yu's thousands of miles of riding alone and slashing Huaxiong with warm wine are all made up.
As for in the official history, at that time in Cao Ying, who came up with the most ideas, in fact, there is no way to know.
-
Guo Jia died at that time, ......
Xun Yu is guarding the old nest ......
Sima Yi only mixed ......with Cao Cao after that
Cheng Yu reminded Cao Cao what to do if the boats were connected and people attacked with fire, but Cao Cao said that how could there be a southeast wind in winter......
Jia Xu once persuaded Cao Cao to settle in Jingzhou first, but Cao Cao didn't listen, so Jia Xu was out of the limelight ......Xu Shu is actually very awesome, he can see that others may not be able to see it, and the key to what he can see is that he knows Pang Tong ......
-
The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is just a **, there are a lot of bugs in it, and there are also a lot of plot needs.
In fact, when you look at Cao Cao's poem, Cheng Yu reminded Cao Cao what to do if the boat is connected and people attack it with fire, but Cao Cao said how can there be a southeast wind in winter. Later, no one expected that Zhuge Liang would borrow the scene of the east wind.
And Xu Shu knows Zhuge Liang's ability very well, so it can't be said that Cao Cao's strategists are not clever, but no one knows Zhuge Liang better than Xu Shu.
As for Jiang Gan's goods, is he a strategist?
-
Xu Shu's clear calling clan did not tell Cao Cao that he saw Pang Tong's series of schemes, because Xu Shu swore that he would never sacrifice a plan for Cao Wei in this life since he left Liu Bei and came to Cao Cao's camp.
-
Because Xu Shu was originally a strategist under Liu Bei, he was deceived by Cao Cao into Cao's camp, so he was very disgusted with Cao Cao because Xu Mo was promoted to Shu, so he would not remind Cao Cao.
-
That's because Cao Cao indirectly killed Xu Shu's mother, and he swore in front of his mother's grave that he would never offer a plan for Cao Cao in his life.
-
Zhuge Liang and Pang Tong's lives are magnificent and gorgeous lives, and Xu Shu may have some talent and abilityBut compared with the two who have gone down in history, they are obviously dwarfed.
-
Compared with Zhuge Liang's great achievements, Xu Shu is naturally much worse, and compared with Pang Tong's contributions, he is also inferior, but Xu Shu is also an excellent strategist.
-
Xu Shu's talent is still there, but no matter how talented he is, he passed away at a young age, and his talent has not been shown to the fullest, and I think Xu Shu's strength cannot be compared with Zhuge Liang and Pang Tong.
-
Xu Shu's strength should be a little worse than that of Pang Tong and Zhuge Liang, but his strength is indeed not to be underestimated, because Zhuge Liang was very surprised when he learned that Cao Pi did not reuse Xu Shu.
-
I mentioned it. When Liu Bei fled to Fancheng. Cao Cao told Xu Shu to recruit Liu Bei. In the Battle of Chibi, Xu Shu asked Pang Tong to teach him a plan to get out. I didn't mention it later.
-
In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, after Xu Shu defected to Cao Cao, he only became a small magistrate in Wei State, and he didn't do much, so he will not be rewritten in the romance.
-
35.Xuande Nanzhang Feng Yin fell Shan Fu Xinye met the British Lord (Shan Fu is Xu Shu's former name) 36Xuande used a plan to attack Fancheng Yuan went straight to Ma Recommending Zhuge (Yuan Zhi is Xu Shu's word) 57Chai Sangkou Wolong mourning Leiyang County Feng Yan director.
60.Zhang Yongnian rebelled, Yang Xiu, Pang Shiyuan, and discussed taking Xishu (Shiyuan is the word of Pang Tong) 63Zhuge Liang cried bitterly, Pang Tong and Zhang Yide explained Yan Yan.
The fall of Pang Tong in Luofengpo should be between 60 and 63 episodes.
Hope it helps!
-
Xuande Nanzhang fell into seclusion, and Shan Fu Xinye met the British master.
Xuande used a strategy to attack Fan Chengyuan, and went straight to Ma Zhuge.
Kan Zemi presented a book of deception, Pang Tong skillfully gave a serial plan (appeared) - Xu Shu.
Kan Zemi offered a letter of deception, and Pang Tong skillfully gave a serial plan.
Chai Sangkou Wolong mourning Leiyang County Feng Yan director.
Zhang Yongnian rebelled, Yang Xiu, and Pang Shiyuan discussed taking Xishu.
Zhuge Liang cried bitterly Pang Tong, Zhang Yide explained Yan Yan - Pang Tong.
-
Xu Shu appeared about 4 times.
-
35.Xuande Nanzhang Feng Yin fell Shan Fu Xinye met the British Lord (Shan Fu is Xu Shu's former name) 36Xuande used a plan to attack Fan Hao, only Bi Zaocheng, Yuan Zhi, Ma Zhuge (Yuan Zhi is Xu Shu's word) 57Chai Sangkou Wolong mourning Leiyang County Feng Yan director.
60.Zhang Yongnian rebelled, Yang Xiu, Pang Shiyuan, and discussed taking Xishu (Shiyuan is the word of Pang Tong) 63Zhuge Liang cried bitterly, Pang Tong and Zhang Yide explained Yan Yan.
The fall of Pang Tong in Luofengpo should be between 60 and 63 episodes. Random counting.
Hope it helps!
Liu Bei borrowed Jingzhou--- but did not repay it.
Romance of the Three Kingdoms author Luo Guanzhong How did he complete this book.
The sayings about the Romance of the Three Kingdoms are as follows: >>>More
For us as descendants, the history of the Three Kingdoms mainly comes from historical records such as the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms", although there are personal opinions of historians, but they are generally viewed from an objective perspective. And "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" was written by Luo Guanzhong, a native of the Ming Dynasty. If you look at "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", you will find that it is completely praising Liu and degrading Cao, although Wei was the strongest during the Three Kingdoms period, but in traditional Chinese feudal thought, it supports Liu Han orthodoxy, so Liu Bei, as the royal family of Liu Han, has been portrayed very positively in the book. >>>More
Cao Cao went down to the south of the Yangtze River -- came fiercely and lost miserably Zhang Fei threw chicken feathers -- it was difficult to make Guan Gong go to the meeting -- he went straight to the meeting with a single knife. >>>More