Which edition of the Historical Records is better, and which publishing house is better to choose fo

It depends on what kind of one your grandfather likes to watch.

The Baiwen edition of "Historical Records", that is, without annotations and translations, belongs to the Yuelu Book Society edition and the Zhonghua Book Company edition. But if you look carefully in the middle of the Chung Hwa Book Company edition, you will find a very small number of typos.

If you like to study, it's best to buy "Historical Records of the Three Collections of Notes", I don't like to read the annotations, so I haven't bought them, but I have an electronic version.

If you like to read translations, it is recommended to buy a white text of the historical records, with a vernacular version of the historical records. It's better to buy it from the same place. I've seen Xinhua Bookstore sell both of them in Yuelu Bookstore.

Selected ancient books, in the south, mainly Yuelu Book Company, in the north, mainly Zhonghua Book Company. In addition, the ancient books published by the Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House, the Commercial Press, and the Sanlian Publishing House are also good.

In addition, to buy books for your grandfather, you can consider buying the Chronicles of the Eastern Zhou Dynasty. I think there are quite a few elderly people who like to watch this.

Ahem, it seems to be you.

I've found two histories, so you can read them yourself.

Historical Records (Chinese Classics Collection) [Paperback] , Han Zhaoqi Editor, Translator Zhonghua Book Company This contains five articles of the Benji, two articles of the family, nine articles of the biography, plus "Taishi Gong's Self-Introduction", a total of 17 articles. Price: 20 Buy more than 10 yuan online. It's pretty simple.

Suitable for first-time readers.

Historical Records, Upper and Lower Commentaries, Yuelu Academy (Publishing House).

The annotations are strong and moderate, accurate and clear; The comments are concise and to the point. Ahem, the comment is also Han Zhaoqi (everyone who studies Chinese historical records, so many versions of historical records are based on him.) This is the upper and lower volumes.

That's a lot more. Pricing 90It's about 50-60 to buy online.

Hope it works for you.

The annotated version of the historical records of Yuelu Books is good.

The simplified horizontal layout of the three commentaries of the historical records of Zhonghua Book Company is very good.

**If you want an electronic version, you can get it.

Because there are so many.

I haven't used these two versions, so I don't know.

If it's the first time you read it, you should use Chung Hwa Book Company.

It's helpful for learning Chinese.

Chung Hwa Book Company published better. "Historical Records", one of the twenty-four histories, originally called "Taishi Gongshu" or "Taishi Gongji", "Taishi Ji", is a historical book written by Sima Qian, a historian of the Western Han Dynasty, is the first general history of Chinese history, recording the era of the Yellow Emperor in ancient legends, down to the first four years of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, a total of more than 3,000 years of history.

In the first year of Taichu (104 BC), Sima Qian began the creation of the Taishi Gongshu, which was later known as the Historical Records. It took 14 years for the work to be completed.

Narrative artThe unique narrative art of historical records, attaches great importance to the deeper level of the causal relationship between events, synthesizes various historical books of the previous generations, becomes a family, vertically represented by 12 books and 10 tables, and describes the various historical eras before the middle of the Western Han Dynasty, and horizontally represents the eight books, 30 families and 70 columns, and dominates all classes, all nationalities, all fields and industries, forming a criss-cross comfortable structure.

The best version of "Historical Records" is the Chung Hwa Book Company's school book.

1. Chung Hwa Book Company points to the school book.

This version is the classic version, currently recognized as the "best version". It is based on Jinling Bookstore, supplemented by three notes: (Liu Song) Pei Chu's "Collection of Historical Records", (Tang) Sima Zhen's "Historical Records Suoyin", and (Tang) Zhang Shoujie's "Historical Justice".

Segmented punctuation, with three notes after each paragraph, marked with a number. Simplified horizontal type.

2, Song Ben Huang Shanfu version.

The earliest version of the Three Commentaries is also the most complete version of the Historical Records in existence. (The so-called completeness is relative.) The "Historical Records" has successively absorbed and corrected a lot of content in the subsequent inheritance. Each article is followed by a vernacular translation, both academic and popular.

3. (Japanese) Takigawa Ziyan Edition "Historical Records Society Annotation Certificate".

Based on Jinling Bookstore, it includes three notes; At the same time, it refers to more than 120 kinds of materials in Chinese and Japanese classics. Among them, the pre-Song version of the "Historical Records" circulated in Japan; Proofreading results by Japanese scholars; After synthesizing various classics and adding their own research results, they are supplemented in the form of "research" at the end of the three notes. In particular, the research on ancient and modern place names is quite powerful.

4. Full annotation and translation of vernacular historical records.

Not marked, China Federation of Literary and Art Circles Press. The base of Jinling Bookstore, without three notes. There's a lot to be desired, though

The annotations are detailed and the translation is smooth, especially absorbing the research results of modern historiography and archaeology, and a large number of supplementary notes have been made on the basis of the previous three annotations. It is a good reference material.

Historical Records--(All Nine Volumes) Fine--Chinese Classics Full Annotation Full Translation Series" This set of books is very good, it is a complete historical record of horizontal typesetting, the annotations are very detailed, very accurate, and the whole translation is attached to the back, there is an inscription at the beginning, the preface is also well written, the font size is moderate, and the paper is very good.

That's good.

Questions. Can elementary school students watch it.

Fifth grade. Turn left to buy what version is good.

You can watch it even as a 5th grade in elementary school.

The annotation is clear.

Questions. Children have already read this set of books on juvenile reading of historical records, do you need to buy an original historical book? Please give an opinion, thank you!

Children may not be able to read classical Chinese, and the original book may not be understood.

It is recommended to read the original book after having a certain reading ability.

Questions. Then is this kind of historical record you recommended the original book, or is it the same as the historical record I bought for teenagers.

It's about the same as the thousand-year-old historical record you bought.

Questions. If there is a good version of the original book, thank you.

The "Historical Records" published by Chung Hwa Book Company is the most authoritative school book.