If Wu Sangui didn t switch on and off the Qing army, what would happen to Li Zicheng and the Ming Dy

If Wu Sangui doesn't switch it on, the most likely outcome is that Wu Sangui and Li Zicheng will fight, because the Ming Dynasty will be a certain thing, and the two will fight behind closed doors is the most likely result, and Wu Sangui is very likely to be unable to defeat King Chuang.

If Wu Sangui had not welcomed the Qing army into the pass, Li Zicheng and the Ming Dynasty would have died. At that time, the Ming Dynasty had already declined to a certain extent.

According to historical reasoning, if Wu Sangui did not switch, the Qing army would not be able to enter the customs at all, and Li Zicheng's political ability was too weak, and the people still had no way out, so in the end, the Central Plains was likely to be in chaos again.

Wu Sangui's defection to the Qing Dynasty was actually a blessing for Li Zicheng. Due to Wu Sangui's surrender to the Qing Dynasty, the Qing army changed its original strategy of moving back to outflank Li Zicheng, and attacked from Shanhaiguan instead, and the battle against the rebel army became a crushing battle, so that Li Zicheng was able to preserve a considerable number of troops.

Wu Sangui and Dolgon were both aristocrats, and it was the ruling class that raised the lead and oak, and it was the ruling class that blinded them to defend the interests of the landlord class, and it was inevitable to suppress Li Zicheng, who was born in mud. In fact, many troubled times in history are like this, the warlords are fighting each other, but as long as there is a peasant rebellion, the warlords who are fighting will immediately unite to suppress the peasant rebellion.

Because Wu Sangui knew very well what kind of person Li Heng called Zicheng, Wu Sangui knew that he would not get any benefits after following Li Zicheng, so he was unwilling to surrender to Li Zicheng.

Mainly because the Qing Dynasty gave Wu Sangui better conditions, and Wu Sangui and Li Zicheng had a grudge, so they were unwilling to surrender to Li Zicheng.

Because there was a big gap between Li Zicheng and Wu Sangui's ideas, the two would not be able to get along, so he surrendered to the Qing army.

In the final analysis, it is not the right and quick disadvantage is caused by Li Zicheng, the key is Wu Sangui's personal subjective reasons, at that time the Ming Dynasty has fallen, when Wu Sangui sent troops to aid the Ming Dynasty, he already knew the news halfway, so he withdrew his troops, rather than helping a court that has perished, it is better to sit on one side and become the emperor of the soil. Another reason is that Li Zicheng's subordinates occupied his concubine Chen Yuanyuan, and he has always been haunted by it. Wu Sangui himself has a changeable personality, and is an obvious role of a traitor seeking glory, and he has not been loyal to anyone in his life, but he will pay more attention to his actual interests.

1. Introduction of Wu Sangui.

Wu Sangui, the word Changbo, the word Yuesuo, a native of Liaodong in the Ming Dynasty, a famous political and military figure in the late Ming and early Qing dynasties. When Ming Chongzhen was the general soldier of Liaodong, he sealed Xibo and guarded the Shanhaiguan. Emperor Chongzhen ascended the throne, opened the martial arts department, and Wu Sangui won the martial arts department.

2. Follow-up to the fall of the Ming Dynasty.

When the Ming Dynasty fell, the old general Wu Sangui still led 30,000 heavy troops to guard the Shanhaiguan fortress, the Ming Dynasty hoped that Wu Sangui galloped to the aid of the Beijing Division, but who knew that Wu Sangui later returned to Shanhaiguan with illness, Li Zicheng at that time entered the capital to establish a peasant regime, Li Zicheng became a consolidation of his own power for Wu Sangui to adopt a strategy of appeasement, Li Zicheng had sent his subordinates to Shanhaiguan with 10,000 taels ** to the Shanhaiguan Division, but Wu Sangui did not appreciate it, and the two had a military conflict after that.

3. Three surnames are domestic slaves.

After the battle between the two sides, the Qing army had the idea of surrendering to Wu Sangui before, but Wu Sangui had been moving his chess and not making a decision, after he and Li Zicheng had a battle, he was worried about the loss of Shanhaiguan, so he sent someone to contact Dolgon secretly, and Chang Pin borrowed troops from him to deal with Li Zicheng, and also expressed his willingness to belong to the Qing Dynasty. After the agreement was reached, under the attack of Dolgon and Wu Sangui, Li Zicheng was defeated. The reason why Wu Sangui is a slave with three surnames is entirely because this person has no loyalty to the king, and once it comes to his own interests, he will immediately betray his master to seek glory.

Of course, Li Zicheng single-handedly made it, if he hadn't taken away Wu Sangui's most beloved woman, Wu Sangui would not have done this to him.

Yes, Wu Sangui at the beginning originally wanted to take refuge in Li Zicheng, but Li Zicheng dominated the woman who occupied his empty size, so he chose to defect to the Qing Dynasty for a while.

It's not like that, and it's a very wise choice for him to take refuge in the other party, and then he also saved himself, and at that time, Wu Sangui was laughing at it for Yihong to accept a woman, so he was very angry.

The reason why the contemptible people think that the Qing Dynasty may still exist is as follows:

The politics of sages, the general trend of history

First of all, history makes the masses of the people createTherefore, if the Qing Dynasty can be established, it cannot be attributed to the sage governmentBecause to be more specific, even if Wu Sangui really took refuge in Li Zicheng's forces outside the Shanhai Pass and defeated the Eight Banners of East Asia at that timeThat long line of defense on the northern frontier of the Central Plains Empire, on the coastline, at any point. It is possible that it will become a breakthrough point for the Eight Banners Army to attack the Dashun Dynasty. And at every breakthrough point, there will be a "Wu Sangui" appearing.

Moreover,Therefore, the existence of natural disasters such as the great plague and the ice age in the Ming Empire at that time made Emperor Chongzhen helpless. the betrayal of Korea and Mongolia; The loss of popular support. Let the Ming army advance and retreat.

In short, the Ming Empire is going through,At that time, all political forces could not face the test of natural and man-made disasters. And this is by no means a problem that can be easily solved by changing a dynasty with one surname

So even if Li ZichengTaking over the mess of the Ming Empire will be walking on thin ice for the recovery of the empire. Then the opportunity of the Eight Banners Army will come again。You must know that the Qing Empire really cleaned up the mess for the Ming Empire, but it took several generations.

The entanglement with Nan Ming alone took twenty years. SoIn the face of various difficulties, the historical trend that is difficult to return. What about Li Zicheng's virtuous politics!

Eager to win, Stud gambles

Secondly, the bloody battle between Li Zicheng and the Eight Banners soldiers outside Shanhaiguan carried the meaning of being forced to clean up the mess for ChongzhenBecause objectively, the main force of the Dashun Army is outside Shanhaiguan, playing the role of Chongzhen's royal conquest, but for Li Zicheng,He has to win, he has to do it. Directly blocked the Eight Banners Army outside the Shanhai Pass, winning a short peace for the survival of the dynasty in the future。In other words, this is a stud gamble, but to the Eight Banners, this is a loss.

Because Wu Sangui has it, the Dashun regime is extremely weak! Maintaining the established strategy and winning the country is still realistic and feasible!

There will still be this dynasty of the Qing Dynasty, because Li Zicheng burned, killed and looted after entering the city of Beijing, and there was no monarch's vision at all, so it would still fail.

There would be no Qing Dynasty, because Wu Sangui's strength was very strong at that time, and if he took refuge in Li Zicheng, he would succeed in the rebellion.

Of course, there will still be the Qing Dynasty, because Nurhachi is very strong, and Li Zicheng is a stubborn person, and he may not be able to sit firmly in the world.

Yes, it's just a matter of time, it will appear when it should appear, and it won't block the coming of this dynasty because of one thing.

If he surrendered at that time, there should be no Qing Dynasty, because he had a very large number of troops, so there would be no development of the Qing Dynasty after surrendering.

History is history, not good, especially in the late Ming and early Qing dynasties, history is more complicated. The Qing Dynasty already existed before Wu Sangui and Li Zicheng came into contact, Nurhachi established the Later Jin in 1616, and Huang Taiji changed the Later Jin to the Manchu Qing in 1636. Wu Sangui really surrendered to Li Zicheng, whether the Qing Dynasty could enter the customs and unify the whole country is not good, if it has to, the possible results are as follows.

Wu Sangui's surrender of Li Zicheng at Shanhaiguan may lead to a scuffle between the Manchu regime, Li Zicheng's Dashun military regime, the Nanming regime, and Zhang Xianzhong's Daxi military regime, and the Manchu Qing may eventually win. After Li Zicheng captured Beijing, Dolgon led the Qing troops to cross the Great Wall to attack Li Zicheng instead of taking the Shanhaiguan Road, but Wu Sangui sent people to lead the Qing army into the pass.

The Manchu Qing Dynasty belonged to the new regime, which was alive and on the rise. The key is that during the reign of Huang Taiji, the Northern Yuan regime was eliminated and the Korean problem was solved. After the fall of the Yuan Dynasty, there was a Northern Yuan regime in the Mongolian steppe, and the Ming Dynasty did not eliminate the Northern Yuan regime.

Huang Taiji defeated Lin Dan Khan, and after Lin Dan Khan's death, his son submitted to Huang Taiji, and the Northern Yuan regime fell, increasing the area and strength of the Manchu Qing administration. The Manchus defeated Korea and solved their worries.

Back then, the Jin Dynasty wiped out the Liao State and the Northern Song Dynasty, and the Manchu Qing Dynasty was stronger than the Jin Dynasty by virtue of the northeast and Mongolian steppe regions, and should be able to defeat Li Zicheng's peasant army. Li Zicheng's peasant army owned Hebei, Henan, Shanxi, Shaanxi, Gansu and other regions, which had little combat effectiveness due to frequent wars and famines.

Li Zicheng and Zhang Xianzhong had a conflict, there was a contradiction between the two people, and it was difficult to unite to resist the Qing Dynasty; Nanming also planned to unite with the Manchus to fight Li Zicheng, so that the Manchus could defeat Li Zicheng's peasant army.

Zhang Xianzhong's establishment of the Daxi regime could not defeat the Qing army. The Southern Ming forces were also no match for the Manchus. The Qing army was expected to win.

Looking at the Qing Dynasty, there was a large-scale army system, and the decades of the Ming and Qing Liaodong campaigns and the later Huang Taiji army reform (the establishment of the Han Army Green Battalion and the reorganization of the Manchu and Mongolian Eight Banners) have enabled the Qing Dynasty to have hundreds of thousands of good war rear. After Yuan Chonghuan beheaded Mao Wenlong, the Ming army on Phi Dao could no longer get supplies from the Ming Dynasty, and it could no longer pose a threat to the rear of the Qing Dynasty. In addition, the Mongol tribes at that time had fallen to the Qing Dynasty.

The Qing Dynasty had a large-scale army formation, stable rear supplies, and the assimilation policy of the Ming Dynasty surrendered civilian officials to the occupied territories!

The long and narrow border between Mongolia and the Ming Dynasty could be used by the Qing Dynasty for attack. Therefore, strategically, the Qing Dynasty has occupied an absolute dominance in the three late Ming and early Qing dynasties of the Ming Dynasty, the Qing Dynasty and the Great Shun Dynasty. Even without Wu Sangui's Shanhaiguan, the Qing Dynasty could use Mongolia's long and narrow border to enter the Ming hinterland to fight.

On the contrary, if Wu Sangui joins Li Zicheng's Dashun, it will only add a living military force to Li Zicheng, not a fundamental strategic change! At that time, the Qing Dynasty had already occupied an absolute advantage in various fields, and it was only a matter of time before it became the ruler of the Central Plains!

I think that even if Wu Sangui really surrenders to Dashun and Li Zicheng in Shanhaiguan, there will still be a dynasty of the Qing Dynasty, but sooner or later the time of establishment will have an impact.

At this time, I think there should be no Qing Dynasty, but some other people will re-establish a dynasty.

Of course not, because Wu Sangui was very strong at that time, and if he really surrendered, there would be no Qing Dynasty.

A grass people have lost the Ming Dynasty alive, and they have not sat firmly, without him, the Qing military exploits occupy the northern Beijing, just look at the door and sigh.

What kind of words did you say, if the three customs were in hand, the Qing army would still not be able to come.