Should Ma Tan be killed? Please from all sides

No, Ma Tan has also made contributions to Shu, and Ma Tan is indeed talented, but he is arrogant, but, after the street pavilion, Ma Tan also knows his shortcomings, and another, the Three Kingdoms are standing, it is the time to employ people, and Ma Tan is indeed a talent

Ma Tan is the younger brother of Ma Liang, known as a talented person, and was appreciated by Zhuge Liang. Before his death, Liu Bei told Zhuge Liang that Ma Jian 'exaggerated and should not be used', but Zhuge Liang did not listen. During the Northern Expedition, Zhuge Liang overrode public opinion and appointed Ma Jian as the vanguard, but the Shu army was defeated by the Wei general Zhang Tai in Jieting, Zhuge Liang retired from Hanzhong, and Ma Jian died after being imprisoned (one said that he was executed by military law) at the age of 39.

Ma Tan - A concise biography.

In the romance, Ma Tan is good at war theory, strategic deployment, and tactical arrangement, but lacks actual combat experience. In the first battle of Jieting, he served as the vanguard, did not listen to the advice of the deputy general Wang Ping, insisted on going his own way, and committed a taboo in the army, resulting in the defeat of the Shu army. Because he made a military order, Zhuge Liang had to put him to death with military justice, and after "tearing and cutting off the horse", Zhuge Liang also asked for a demotion and took responsibility for the failure of the Northern Expedition.

I don't think he should be killed, because a big man is not a little derelict in his duties, if he makes a mistake, he will deny him, a little too much, so he should be given another chance, because if he makes a mistake once, he will know that he has made a mistake, and he will change his ways, so he should not be killed.

The, 1Arrogance, intimidating generals, 2Prevent the recurrence of such incidents with proper military law.

It should not be killed, victory or defeat is a common thing in soldiers. can let him train Shu talents and be a principal. It's a shame to kill!

Cao Cao didn't kill the generals who were burned by Zhuge Liang and Bowangpo. You can be extrajudicial and merciful, otherwise it will chill the hearts of wise people. Ma Tan can make Zhuge Liang less tired.

It's still talented. You can't just kill it once you fail.

Although he is talented, he is known as a talented man in Shu. But he was too proud and conceited, and lost the kiosk in the street, and if he was not killed, it would be difficult to convince the people....Wait.

You should be killed, because you play Ma Yan.

Did Ma Jian kill Zhuge Liang? Yi Zhongtian gives the answer!

In the "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

, Ma Tan has three main endings. The first ending is that Ma Jian was not Zhuge Liang.

Beheaded, but fled, and later renamed Ning Sui. After Zhuge Liang's death, Ma Jian returned to Shu and became Shu Han again.

Effectiveness. The second result was that Ma Tan was indeed sentenced to death by Zhuge Liang, but before the execution, he fell ill and died in prison. The third statement is in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

The same is true for , which is also the most popular way of saying it right now. Ma Tan was killed by Zhuge Liang with tears.

<> some scholars, after studying the history books, believe that although there are three endings in the history of Ma Tan, the most likely is the second ending. Ma Tan made a big mistake in the street pavilion and was ordered to be executed by Zhuge Liang. However, before the execution, Ma Jian died of illness in prison.

In ** "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Ma Jian is the general of Shu Han, after enlisting in the army. Five brothers, talented. He and his brother Ma Liangshi Liu Bei.

went to Shu together. Before dying, Liu Bei said to Prime Minister Zhuge Liang:"Ma Tan is generous. You should proceed with caution"。Zhuge Liang didn't listen, and took Ma Jian as his confidant. In the third year of Jiaxing, Zhuge Liang conquered the south, Ma Tan decided to attack the heart, and Zhuge Liang thought so.

Speaking of Ma Tan's death, in people's traditional impression, Ma Tan was called by Zhuge Liang in front of the camp after the street pavilion was lost. This allusion comes from "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". At that time, the Liang army of Wei Coarse Prefecture was menacing, and the street pavilion was used as the grain route of the Shu army, against Western Shu.

The fate of the people is extremely important. Zhuge Liang ordered Ma Tan and Wang Ping.

Led more than 25,000 elite soldiers to fight the Wei army at Jieting. Set up camp in the mountains. Later, he couldn't resist Wang Ping's bitter words, and gave him 5,000 soldiers to camp at the crossroads.

Do a detailed explanation of the problem for a detailed interpretation of the problem, I hope it will help you, if you have any questions, you can leave me a message in the comment area, you can comment with me a lot, if there is something wrong, you can also interact with me more, if the big rock Yunjia likes the author, you can also follow me, the like is the biggest help to me, thank you.

Not sure, there are three different versions of his final ending, one of which is that he did not surrender in the end, and chose to abscond in fear of crime; The second Li Qingchong theory is that Zhuge Liang ordered Ma Jian to be beheaded; The 3rd theory of Zhengyou is that he died of illness in prison.

Ma Tanjing was killed in the end. Ma Tan was really killed by Zhuge Liang. Because Zhuge Liang felt that he had lost Liang Fu and cleared his territory, killing him was actually to make more princes of Hall Yan obedient.

Ma Tan's ending was killed by Zhuge Liang. There is also a theory that he was executed by Zhuge Liang after making a mistake, and finally died of illness in prison before Yuhui was executed.

Ma Yan's final outcome should be that he died of illness in prison. I don't think the mission was killed by Zhu Leak to Ge Liang, because he was not by Zhu Hui Qingming Ge Liang's side at all when he died.

He shouldn't have been killed. Although Ma Jian is a defeated general, Ma Jian is also a very powerful person. If Ma Jian had not been killed, Ma Jian would definitely have made better achievements to prove that he was a useful person, and he would have made more contributions to the Han Dynasty.

I think I should be killed, so I think if I don't kill it, it will definitely bring a lot of trouble to society.

Should. It will affect the morale of the soldiers, will affect the subsequent results, and will also affect the development of the Han family, and will also give others an opportunity to take advantage of.

Guan Yu also made a military order, but in the end, he was exempted from death and made meritorious service, Zhuge Liang was so stupid.

Dead in prison, the body was taken out and killed again. Waste utilization.

Did Ma Jian kill Zhuge Liang? Let's take a look at Yi Zhongtian's analysis! You get the idea!

Ma Tan (190 228 years), the word is young, a native of Yicheng, Xiangyang (now south of Yicheng, Hubei), the younger brother of Ma Liang, a general of the Shu Han Dynasty during the Three Kingdoms period. At the beginning, he followed Liu Bei into Shu as a Jingzhou worker, and successively served as the Mianzhu County Commander, the Chengdu County Commander, and the Yuewang Taishou.

Zhuge Liang, the prime minister of the Shu Han Dynasty, appointed him to join the army. Ma Tan is talented and good at military strategy. Zhuge Liang has always been very important to him, and every time he meets and talks, from day to night.

In the sixth year of Jianxing (228), when Ma Tan was in Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition, he violated Zhuge Liang's combat instructions, resulting in the loss of Jieting, and was beheaded by Zhuge Liang after withdrawing.

"Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms": "Fighting with the Wei general Zhang He in the street pavilion, he was broken by He, and the soldiers were scattered. Liang Jin had no basis, and the army retreated to Hanzhong. After going to prison, Liang was sobbing for it, and he Chinese New Year's Eve nine. ”

He died in prison and was not beheaded for public display.

When you go back to the Three Kingdoms, let's take a look...

1.Zhuge Liang beheaded.

2.Died in prison.

Ma Tan was killed by Zhuge Liang mainly because he lost the strategically important street pavilion, which belonged to the position that the Shu and Wei kingdoms must fight for, and then Ma Tan lost it, in order to appease the government and the opposition of the Shu State, and gave an explanation to the government and the opposition of the Shu State, he had to kill.

Ma Tan violated military law, he received a military order but did not complete the task; And the main reason is that he does not act according to Zhuge Liang's layout, for the sake of military justice, Zhuge Liang can only kill him.

boasted that Haikou also failed, Ma Jian made a military order, and then because of his own mistakes, the Northern Expedition failed.