The new version of the Three Kingdoms is very different from the original work

I suggest you read it yourself.

The TV series is an interpretation of the director and screenwriter, with a different emphasis, so you actually accept his ideas after watching it. You may have the opinion of being alone.

Middle school students can't watch the new version of the Three Kingdoms instead of reading the original book!!

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is wonderful, and it is said that Nurhachi of the Qing Dynasty asked for subordinate generals"Romance of the Three Kingdoms"Read it as a soldier.

The new Three Kingdoms of the TV series is different from "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", especially the interspersing of some plot backgrounds, it is better to read the original book, if you want to understand the real history of the Three Kingdoms, you should take a look at "Three Kingdoms", the history books are also very different from **.

I pour the new version of the Three Kingdoms is more reasonable than the old version of the Three Kingdoms, the old version of the Three Kingdoms is very loyal to the original, the character building and still show the stage drama style of the performance have the feeling of moving from the original book, and the new Three Kingdoms on the basis of respecting the original work is more biased, in recent years, some well-known scholars on the Three Kingdoms period after the study of the personal views. I didn't dwell too much on the line styling or something, at least the new version of the Three Kingdoms is still very sincere.

In addition, there is still a big difference between reading a book and watching a TV series, words give you more room for imagination, while TV dramas often reflect impressions directly in your mind, and there is less room for thinking.

Watching TV series can't completely replace reading books, but reading books is probably still a little boring, if you are very interested in the Three Kingdoms, it is recommended to read books, if you have too many doubts about watching "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", you can take a look at "Three Kingdoms", but history books are generally boring, make sure you want to watch it, don't regret it after reading half of it.

Of course, it can't be replaced.

You can read the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and take a look at the new Three Kingdoms, which are two completely different concepts, and the content in them is not exactly the same as what is written in the Three Kingdoms.

If Luo Guanzhong is still alive, go to the court and sue Gao Xixi for bankruptcy and sale Upstairs is taken out of context, b Khan, people are talking about Zhao Yun, Changbanpo. You see that Zhao Yun is long...

Of course not. Let's just say that Cao Cao's cowardice, it is not like that at all in the original book. The TV series is just in line with the taste of the public, and if you are interested in the Three Kingdoms, it can be very interesting to read the original book.

I said, Who is Zhao Yunchang in the sixth article above, Zhao Yu???

There are two versions, the Jiajing version and the Mao version, and the Jiajing version is the closest to the original.

It is known that the earliest edition was engraved in the first year of Jiajing (1522), called Jiajingben, with the title "History Biography of Chen Shou, Marquis of Pingyang, Jin, and Later Luo Ben Guanzhong Edition".

After the Jiajing version, a large number of new editions appeared, all of which were mainly based on the Jiajing version, and only did some illustrations, research, comments, additions and deletions of texts, and the collation of the number of volumes and the purpose of the review. During the Kangxi reign of the Qing Dynasty, Mao Lun and Mao Zonggang made some revisions to Jiajing's "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", mainly to sort out the review and revise the wording. There are no major changes to the content, etc., such as changing the poems.

Generally speaking, there are two versions of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

In modern times, the revised version based on the Mao book is a little better.

One is "The Popular Romance of the Three Kingdoms", the original version of Luo Guan, called "Luo Ben", and the earliest edition was engraved during the Jiajing period of the Ming Dynasty.

One is "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", "Mao Ben", which was written during the Kangxi period of the Qing Dynasty. Mao Zonggang and his son added and deleted comments on the basis of "Robben", and when Mao Zonggang made revisions, he corrected many of the original mistakes and polished the sentences. After this book came out, "Robben" disappeared into oblivion.

What is commonly used now is the revised version of the Modern People's Literature Publishing House based on Mao's book, deleting Mao's comments, correcting some of the errors, and adding a small number of notes. This version is the best.

There is also a version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" published by Jiangsu Ancient Books Publishing House for reference. There are a lot of corrections in the book"Technical errors"and in the form of a "List of School Managers", listed in turn"Technical errors", point out the error, put forward correction opinions, and explain the basis for correction; At the same time, annotate the reader's unknown or plausible points, explain in simple terms, and give people new knowledge. This is not suitable for the average reader.

What are you talking about**? ** I know that there are two versions of Jiajingben and Maoben Jiajingben: "Popular Romance of the Three Kingdoms" in the Wunian year of Jiajing Renwu in the Ming Dynasty (1522 AD). Now it is regarded as the closest version to Luo Guanzhong's original work, and is also called "Robben".

Mao Ben: That is, the most widely circulated version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" today. The version re-surveyed by Mao Lun, Mao Zonggang and his son, a beginner in the Qing Dynasty, is called "The First Book of Talents - Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

Its biggest feature is that through the deletion and modification of the original text, it highlights the views that are not in the original text, such as "respecting Liu and degrading Cao", "combining for a long time must be divided, and dividing for a long time must be combined".

Personally, I think that compared with Maoben and Jiaqingben, the sentences are more fluent and the context is clear, but Mao Lun and Mao Zonggang father and son have made unnecessary modifications in many places according to their own understanding, which makes Luo Guanzhong's original ideas misunderstood.

I've seen the old Three Kingdoms and the new Three Kingdoms, the new Three Kingdoms are more exciting, the old Three Kingdoms are very comprehensive, and some of the things in the book are basically performed.

There are two most important versions:

1.Mao Ben: Mao Zonggang father and son in the Qing Dynasty, deleted from the Ming Dynasty version, is the most popular version in modern times. It is commonly known as the Mao Ben, also known as the Passage Book.

2.Jiajingben: The earliest version, the version that best reflects the appearance of Luo Guanyuan's work. Because of the profound thoughts, the real penmanship, and the facial makeup of the characters like Maoben, it failed to become a popular book.

ps: I recommend the Jiajing version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" commented by Kong Rang

The first version, which version of Tang Guoqiang played. The new shot is not good-looking.

I think it's the first version!

Nowadays, the remake of old dramas has become a trend, and many TV series have been remade again, such as "Dream of Red Mansions", "Journey to the West" and "Huanzhu Gege" written by Aunt Qiong Yao, etc., and some will even be remade many times, but they are no longer the original cast, so it will inevitably be compared by the human side. Make a comparative review. Let's take a look at the new version of the Three Kingdoms and the old version of the Three Kingdoms.

Analyze which one is more popular.

Take a look at the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

It is irrefutable that the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" can be said to be the theme of an era, which fully reflects the background of that era at that time, and the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is based on the original work, and there is relatively little tampering with the description in the book. Among them, the literary drama is also more exciting, after all, the classics are not so easy to surpass and break through. Whether it is in terms of plot or actors' acting skills, the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" still has his own characteristics.

The new version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

The new "Three Kingdoms" stands at a considerable historical height, and regards Cao, Liu and Sun as heroes with different personalities, bearings, and styles. It does not simply affirm one side and negate one side, nor does it make one-sided articles about overturning the case. The new edition of "Three Kingdoms" sublimates the pursuit and celebration of ideal morality.

It also more fully embodied the most fundamental pursuit of that era: trying to give full play to one's own wisdom and talents to reunite the country. This is the core part of the ideological value of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and it is also the most important common cultural psychology of the Chinese nation. Beginnings.

Actually, I think the old version and the new version have their own characteristics. Different aesthetic tastes naturally have different preferences.

Personally, I like the New Three Kingdoms, except for the section of Zhao Yun in Changbanpo, Cao Cao said to Cao Ren that Zhao Zilong is really a tiger general, I love him to death... After I was thundered, the other plots were quite good, especially after the death of Guan Erye, who appeared and went to Chengdu and Liu Bei to say brother, I'll go first, take care of yourself... I was so moved.

It's not exactly the same, but the changes don't affect the classic plot, and the changes aren't thunderous.

A lot of changes have been made, and a lot of deletions have been made. The old Three Kingdoms are still relatively detailed.

The old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and the new version of "Three Kingdoms" have their own merits, if you have to make a comparison,That's definitely better for the old version.

In the past eight years, he filmed all the four famous novels, although the economic conditions at that time were not very good, but the actors were very dedicated. It is said that they spend a long time figuring out the characters before filming a TV series. Therefore, everyone actually has some temperament of people of that era, and every person is very imposing.

And at that time, the service was also very good, and most of them were based on history. Unlike now, some of the costumes are worn indiscriminately, and some are not costumes from the Three Kingdoms period at all. In short, the historical dramas filmed at that time were really in line with history, and there would not be too many modern elements in them.

The new "Three Kingdoms" is now relatively good in many costume TV series, but it can be seen that he is an assembly line job. Actors are all about making quick money, and they don't spend a lot of time figuring out the role. Many of them are just similar in appearance, but there is no way to reach the same height as before.

If you just look at this TV series as a costume drama, it's still very good, but if you want to compare it with the old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it's a little inferior. Whether it is the shaping of the characters or the polishing of the costumes, these are all lacking. It's not that you can make a better TV series by spending more money, but the main thing is the efforts of the main creators.

The old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is indeed far superior to the new version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms in terms of plot and actors' acting skills. The old version of the Romance of the Three Ridges has left a very deep impression in the minds of the audience, and the new Romance of the Three Kingdoms is not all without merit.

Romance of the Three Kingdoms (1994).

The old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is indeed far superior to the new version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms in terms of plot and actors' acting skills. The old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms left a very deep impression in the minds of the audience, and the new Romance of the Three Kingdoms is not all without merit. The new Romance of the Three Kingdoms is indeed better than the old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms in terms of martial arts action, this is because the filming conditions of the old version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms at that time were far inferior to the current level of film and television drama shooting.

Many of the actors in the CCTV version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms can be said to be the top level actors in China. Therefore, these actors have their own deep understanding and awareness of the mentality and emotions of these historical figures. It is precisely because of this that the CCTV version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms has become an immortal monument to domestic TV dramas.

And the CCTV version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms was loved and sought after by the audience when it first began to be broadcast, which also set an amazing ratings record for CCTV. The Romance of the New Three Kingdoms was criticized by many viewers when it was first broadcast, this is because there is a big gap between the Romance of the Three Kingdoms and the CCTV version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and this is because when filming the CCTV version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it can almost be said that the best film and television resources in China were gathered at that time, so this is also where the Romance of the New Three Kingdoms cannot be compared. However, we also see that the new Romance of the Three Kingdoms also has its own understanding and understanding.

Because when the new Romance of the Three Kingdoms was filmed, it not only referred to the story told in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, but also the history and events expressed in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Although the New Romance of the Three Kingdoms did not surpass the CCTV version of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the New Romance of the Three Kingdoms also has a very high status in the minds of young audiences today, because the New Romance of the Three Kingdoms also gathered a large number of excellent actors at that time, and these actors also contributed very good acting skills and content.