How credible is the historical record of the loss of 300,000 men by the Qin army in the Battle of Ch

<> claim that the Qin army lost 300,000 men is somewhat exaggerated.

The total number of Zhao troops was 450,000, and 400,000 were killed in the pit in the Battle of Changping.

, Zhao Jun was beheaded by the Qin army by 50,000, and more than half of the Qin army reached 300,000, netizens said that the combat effectiveness of the Zhao army was beyond imagination, and the 300,000 troops could go straight to Xianyang. White up.

The tactics of the Battle of Changping, taking advantage of the terrain, surrounded Zhao Kuo.

sent heavy troops to strengthen the encirclement, with the intention of encircling the Zhao army to death in the encirclement. In the breakout battle, the biggest one is the one that breaks through. In the anti-breakout, in the face of the Zhao army, the ** ratio of the Qin army and the Zhao army is one to one, which is considered to be the Zhao army, not to mention the ratio of six to one?

How did the 300,000 ** come about? From the white rise. Netizens believe that Qin beat Changping, and more than half of them died. The number of Qin troops participating in the battle was 600,000, and more than half of the deaths were 300,000 deaths, so there is a saying that the Qin army lost 300,000 people in the Battle of Changping.

Wu Anjun: Bai Qi. A year after the Battle of Changping, the Qin army took Shangdang.

Divide the army into two roads, Pigao and Taiyuan. In January of the forty-ninth year, he did not fight, and in September of the forty-ninth year, Qin attacked Handan, the capital of Zhao. Shiro got sick and couldn't play.

The Qin army did not defeat it, and the soldiers of the King of Qin were on the front line, losing five colonels, and did not take Handan. King Qin couldn't sit still, Bai Qi was well, let Bai Qi be handsome, Bai Qi said that Handan was not easy to fight, and the princes sent troops to help Handan. What is the situation of us, achieved results in Changping, Qin State.

More than half of the soldiers died, and there was a shortage of food in the country.

Obviously, the statement that Qin was half dead in the Battle of Changping is taken out of context. When Bai Qi said that more than half of the dead defeated Handan, it was not Changping.

The dead were Qin's total troops, not Changping's 600,000. <>

When the army was defeated in Handan, the Qin army did not stop. In order to get Shangdang County, attack Yewang City.

The following year, the Battle of Changping was launched, and Lian Po was peaceful.

Hold each other, fight a decisive battle with Zhao Kuo, bury 400,000 Zhao troops alive, and then spend another year to completely occupy the party. Then fight Taiyuan and Pigao, capture Pigao, and the loss of a siege battle will not be less. The loss of troops will be in Handan, and the first battle loss is very serious.

The second time it lost five schools. At this point, the Qin army fought continuously for five years, and it was reasonable that the high-intensity combat caused the Qin state to lose half.

The claim that the Qin army lost 300,000 in the Battle of Changping comes from Sima Qian's historical records, but this statement is actually not very credible, because at that time, the Qin State sent 550,000 troops and the Zhao State 450,000, and in the battle between the two armies, the Zhao army lost only 50,000 people in the battle, and the rest were all killed, and the battle loss of 50,000 can be exchanged for the battle loss of 300,000 Qin army? I don't think it's possible, because if that's the case, it won't be Zhao Guo who loses.

I don't think it's very credible, because the population of ancient China was originally very small, and the population of 300,000 was almost all the troops of the Zhao State, so this data should be fictitious.

This is a bit exaggerated, the Qin army lost a maximum of 200,000, because the Qin army and the Zhao army were at war at that time, and only about 200,000 people were killed in the battle, and then the Zhao army was killed.

I think this news is very true and reliable, and it was recorded in the history books at that time that the army of Qin was very heavy during the Battle of Changping, reaching more than 300,000 people.

At that time, Bai Qi, the general of the Qin army, besieged the Zhao army with 450,000 troops, and finally annihilated the Zhao army with 400,000 troops. However, the Qin army also lost 250,000 horses, which shows that the figure of 300,000 is not credible.

The credibility is still quite high, because at that time, the Qin soldiers fought more than 600,000 people, and the loss of 300,000 people may be understatement, and the losses may be more than that.

I think there's credibility. Because during the Warring States period, the number of their soldiers was very large, accounting for almost half of the total number of people in the country.

can use the anti-treacherous scheme to drive a wedge between the emperor of Zhao and the generals, so that the king of Zhao will kill Lian Po, and replace a cowardly and greedy person who is stupid as a general to cover the army. After that, this general Hongyuan will be recorded and asked to open the city gates.

The battle of Changzheng and Pingping can be based on local materials, and after burying Jing to capture a city, you can open a warehouse and release grain, which can attract some young and strong laborers to join the army, and can also supplement the military needs.

I think that in the Battle of Changping, the Qin army should give the other party a urn to catch turtles directly, lead them to the territory of the Qin army, and just start fighting.

The Battle of Changping can be said to be the 500-year-long Spring and Autumn Period and the Warring States Period, and then the most tragic battle in ancient Chinese history. The battle, which ended with the Zhao army being killed by 400,000 Qin troops, is still heart-wrenching. Sima Qian said in the "Historical Records" that Zhao Guo fell for Bai Qi's counter-plan, and used Zhao Kuo to replace the famous general Lian Po to bury Zhao Jun as the main general, leaving the idiom of "talking on paper" for future generations.

No matter what time there is a war, there is a natural advantage in numbers, so many generals lie about the number of troops before the war to threaten the enemy.

For example, in the Battle of Weishui, Fu Jian was known as 800,000 foot horseback. The Battle of Chibi, Cao Cao is also known as 800,000. Chen Youliang is called 600,000.

In fact, in addition to the war, there are only one side of the force, and there are hundreds of thousands of troops at every turn, and there are exaggerated factors. But the crux of the matter is, were all of these 400,000 people really killed? And are these 400,000 people professional soldiers?

The answer is clearly no. You must know that after the Battle of Changping, if Zhao still has 400,000 professional soldiers alive, Bai Qi will of course frame them, and whether he can achieve the final victory in this war is a big unknown.

If you want to say why, it is because the Qin State at that time, even if the soldiers of the whole country were gathered, there were only 600,000 people. Because in the era of cold weapons, it was obviously very difficult to easily kill the other 400,000 professional soldiers with 600,000 professional soldiers. When Zhao Kuo launched an attack on the Qin army, no one expected that he would fall for Bai Qi's stupid trick and be surrounded for forty-six days.

At the critical juncture, Zhao Kuo organized four troops to break through. As a result, there was no going out. The Qin army rained arrows.

In the fierce battle, Zhao Kuo was hit by dozens of arrows and finally died.

After Zhao's death, Zhao Jun put down ** and surrendered. In order to escape the troubles, except for the restorers, Bai Qi put all 400,000 people in the cave and killed them, the scene was really cruel. The Battle of Changping, which decided the fate of Qin and Zhao, also ended with the victory of the Qin army.

Of course, in addition to intimidating the enemy, another reason is to eat food. In fact, there were only 10 people, but it was reported to 20 people, and after receiving the salary of 10 more people, it went into the general's own pocket. It is not uncommon for many false declarations to be made, resulting in a large discrepancy between the actual number of troops and the number of people on the books.

It is really necessary to kill more than a million people in a lifetime according to the number of ledger monsters. It was equivalent to killing all the young and middle-aged labor force in seven countries at that time, which was obviously unrealistic.

It should be fake. According to the archaeological findings, there are mass graves dug and buried alive in the Changping area, which fully says that the Qin army killed 400,000 Zhao soldiers in the pit is not true.

Historical records are a chronicle in the history of our country, and many of the historical defeats and poems recorded in it are very true. The Qin army was indeed very tyrannical at that time, killing prisoners in the war.

The total number of participants of the Qin army in the Battle of Changping should be about the same as that of the Zhao army, and it is also four or five hundred thousand people, and the number of losses of the Qin army Bai Qi clearly said after the war that although Qin broke the Changping army, more than half of the Qin soldiers were killed, and the country was empty. In other words, the number of people killed by the Qin army in Changping should be about 250,000.

In the Battle of Changping, Qin sent about 650,000 troops, and one of the reasons why Bai Qi refused to allow King Qin to lead troops to attack Handan was that more than half of the Qin army in the Battle of Changping was analyzed, and according to this, the Qin army in the Battle of Changping was about 300,000.

The Qin army is about 500,000-600,000 people, and it should mainly be encircled by using the terrain.

The terrain was unfavorable, and 400,000 people had been divided and surrounded, so Zhao Kuo surrendered as soon as he died and had no leader.

The Qin army had "more than 100,000 tigers, 1,000 cars, and 10,000 horses" more than half of the Qin army died, and the Zhao army "hundreds of thousands of men with armor, 1,000 cars, and 10,000 horses." More than 400,000 people were buried alive by Bai Qi, Bai Qi's military prestige reached its peak, and his merits were high, and he was given death by King Qin Zhao.

According to the "Historical Records", after this war, more than half of the Qin soldiers died, and the country was empty. It can be seen that in the Battle of Changping, Qin also killed no less than four or five hundred thousand people.

There were 400,000 people who killed and buried the other party, and about half of the Qin State died. It should be more than 200,000.

It is recommended to take a look at "The Great Qin Empire" with a lot of different points of view.

First of all, the Battle of Changping was not a small battle, but a general battle that lasted for three years. The initial strength of the two sides may only be about 100,000, but because it is constantly consumed, it must be replenished at any time, and perhaps the fighting force of each fight is only nearly 10,000 people, but because it is a state of fierce battle, the battlefield has become a meat grinder, and soldiers are constantly dying on the front line, and it is convenient to keep sending troops to the front line.

From the perspective of logistics, many people questioned that the number of combatants on both sides could not be so large, but they ignored the statistical methods of the ancients, because the ancients counted the cumulative number of combatants in three years. Logistics is indeed unable to support a huge number of belligerent troops for a long time, so the Battle of Changping is actually fighting for the logistics support capabilities of both sides, and the strength of the troops is slowly increasing, so that in the later period, Zhao State can no longer carry the supplies needed by the front line, and the King of Zhao finally made the decision to change the commander.

Lian Po is a famous general and can set the heart of the army, so King Zhao replaced him with Zhao Kuo, because King Zhao wanted to play a game, he understood the fate of the Battle of Changping for Zhao, and King Zhao didn't want Lian Po to pay for his gamble. And after Zhao Kuo is a famous general, he is familiar with military books, born in a family, even if the army is defeated, he will bear all the infamy and guilt because of the righteousness of the Spring and Autumn Period, and no one wants to live in the shadow of his ancestors, so Zhao Kuo, the born calf, bet all of his own, and played all in with King Zhao, they must have thought it through.

Zhao Kuo's final result was that Zhao Kuo was defeated, and Zhao was killed 400,000 soldiers, and these 400,000 existed in the history books, so it attracted people's doubts. In fact, on the one hand, these 400,000 have exaggerated elements to deter the six eastern countries, on the other hand, they mainly took the opportunity to kill the soldiers and civilians of Shangdang, after all, the Battle of Changping was a dispute over the belonging of Shangdang. So the 400,000 water is beyond imagination.

Stills related to the Battle of Changping.

Therefore, in the Battle of Changping, in terms of heads, a total of seven or eight hundred thousand existed, and not all of them were soldiers who fought, some of them were people who served logistics, and some of them were ordinary people in Shangdang who were labeled as Zhao Jun, and it was impossible for the main combat force at a certain point in time to exist as seven or eight hundred thousand, because the logistics of the Warring States could not guarantee so many supplies.

It should be only more than 400,000, in essence, in the absence of unified deployment, to lead troops to break through. Checkmate, the chain of command is paralyzed, and no one can replace him as the commander. As a result, more than 400,000 people were taken prisoner. The general also died three times.

The so-called 400,000 Zhao army is obviously not enough. Even if Zhao Guo wanted to mobilize to the limit, three months would not be enough to pile up 400,000 people.

I think this statement is too exaggerated, after all, the maximum number of troops in a battle is two or three hundred thousand, and there are generally tens of thousands of troops, not so many.

There is no specific record of the number of combatants, most of them are false or exaggerated, but there are theories that there are only about 450,000 people.

The actual real strength was not so much, after all, the population at that time was also limited, and the total number of people in the army may not be so many.

The Battle of Changping lasted for 3 years, and the initial strength plus the soldiers and civilians who were constantly replenished later, the logistics services, and some of the civilians who participated should add up. But the actual real strength of the army is not so much.

I don't think it's true, there are so many people in one battle, how can it be possible to find so many troops at one time, and send them all out to fight without knowing how to save money.

There must be a lot of moisture in this data, and many scholars believe that the strength of the Qin army was between 500,000 and 1 million.